Child Labor Amendment

United States of America
This article is part of the series: United States Constitution
Original text of the Constitution
Preamble Articles of the Constitution I · II · III · IV · V · VI · VII
Amendments to the Constitution
Bill of Rights I · II · III · IV · V VI · VII · VIII · IX · X Subsequent Amendments XI · XII · XIII · XIV · XV XVI · XVII · XVIII · XIX · XX XXI · XXII · XXIII · XXIV · XXV XXVI · XXVII Unratified Amendments I(1) · XIII(1) · XIII(2) · XX(1) · XXVII(1) · XXVII(2)
Other countries ·  Law Portal view · talk · edit

The Child Labor Amendment is a proposed and still-pending amendment to the United States Constitution offered by Republican Ohio Congressman Israel Moore Foster on April 26, 1924, during the 68th Congress, in the form of House Joint Resolution No. 184.

Text of the Child Labor Amendment

Section 1. The Congress shall have power to limit, regulate, and prohibit the labor of persons under eighteen years of age. Section 2. The power of the several States is unimpaired by this article except that the operation of State laws shall be suspended to the extent necessary to give effect to legislation enacted by the Congress.^[1]

Congressional history

House Joint Resolution No. 184 was adopted by the United States House of Representatives on April 26, 1924, with a vote of 297 yeas, 69 nays, 2 absent and 64 not voting.^[2] It was then adopted by the Senate on June 2, 1924, with a vote of 61 yeas, 23 nays and 12 not voting.^[3] And with that, the proposed constitutional amendment was submitted to the state legislatures for ratification pursuant to Article V of the Constitution.

Actions in the state legislatures

The Child Labor Amendment has been ratified by the legislatures of the following 28 states:

• Arkansas in 1924
• Arizona in 1925
• California in 1925
• Wisconsin in 1925
• Montana in 1927
• Colorado in 1931
• Illinois in 1933
• Iowa in 1933
• Maine in 1933
• Michigan in 1933
• Minnesota in 1933
• New Hampshire in 1933
• New Jersey in 1933
• North Dakota in 1933
• Ohio in 1933
• Oklahoma in 1933
• Oregon in 1933
• Pennsylvania in 1933
• Washington in 1933
• West Virginia in 1933
• Idaho in 1935
• Indiana in 1935
• Utah in 1935
• Wyoming in 1935
• Kentucky in 1936
• Kansas in 1937
• Nevada in 1937
• New Mexico in 1937.

In 1929, the Nebraska Senate voted to ratify the Child Labor Amendment, but the Legislature's lower house did not (the Nebraska Legislature in those days was still bicameral); the Mississippi Senate voted to ratify the measure in 1934, but the state's House of Representatives did not; and in 1937, the New York Senate voted to ratify it, but the state's Assembly did not.

Although the act, on the part of state legislatures, of "rejecting" a proposed constitutional amendment has no legal recognition, such action does have political ramifications. The Child Labor Amendment was rejected—and not subsequently ratified—by lawmakers in North Carolina in 1924; by those in Florida, Georgia, Massachusetts, Missouri, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas and Vermont all in 1925; by those in Virginia in 1926; and by those in Maryland in 1927. In the specific case of Louisiana, its legislators thrice rejected the Child Labor Amendment, first in 1924, again a decade later in 1934, and a third time in 1936.

Today, with 50 states in the Union, the ratifications of 10 additional states would be required to incorporate the proposed Child Labor Amendment into the Constitution.

Judicial history

If ever ratified by the required number of United States state legislatures, the Child Labor Amendment would repose in the Congress of the United States jurisdiction concurrent with that of the states to legislate on the subject of child labor. The states would have to yield to federal law where the two conflict—which is normal procedure anyway. After several state legislatures initially balked at the proposal during the 1920s, a number of them re-examined their position during the 1930s and decided to ratify. Those delayed actions resulted in much controversy and spawned the 1939 decision of the United States Supreme Court in the landmark case of Coleman v. Miller (307 U.S. 433) in which it was determined that the Child Labor Amendment remains pending business before the state legislatures because the 68th Congress did not specify a deadline within which the state legislatures must act upon the Child Labor Amendment. The Coleman v. Miller ruling formed the basis of the unusual and belated ratification of the 27th Amendment which was proposed by Congress in 1789 and ratified more than two centuries later in 1992 by the legislatures of at least three-fourths of the 50 states.

See also

• List of amendments to the United States Constitution
• List of proposed amendments to the United States Constitution
• Unsuccessful attempts to amend the U.S. Constitution

References

1. ^ "Constitutional Amendments NotRatified". United States House of Representatives. http://www.house.gov/house/Amendnotrat.shtml. Retrieved 2007-09-30. 
2. ^ 65 Congressional Record 7294-7295
3. ^ 65 Congressional Record 10142

External Links

• Bill Kaufmann. The Child Labor Amendment Debate of the 1920s. Ludwig Von Mises Institute. November 1992
• TIME Labor:Children
• TIME Labor: A 20th Amendment? - online article discussing 1920s attempts to ratify the Amendment
• Child Labor Amendment in the 1930s, Documentary Video on Youtube