Cubana Flight 455

Cubana Flight 455

Occurrence summary
Date	October 6, 1976
Type	Airline Bombing
Site	8 km west of Seawell Airport, Bridgetown, Barbados
Passengers	73
Crew	5
Injuries	0
Fatalities	78
Survivors	0
Aircraft type	Douglas DC-8
Operator	Cubana de Aviación
Tail number	CU-T1201

Cubana Flight 455 was a Cuban flight from Barbados to Jamaica that was brought down by a terrorist attack on October 6, 1976. All 78 people on board the Douglas DC-8 aircraft were killed in what was then the deadliest terrorist airline attack in the Western hemisphere. Two time bombs were used, variously described as dynamite or C-4.

Evidence implicated several CIA-linked anti-Castro Cuban exiles and members of the Venezuelan secret police DISIP. Political complications quickly arose when Cuba accused the US government of being an accomplice to the attack. CIA documents released in 2005 indicate that the agency "had concrete advance intelligence, as early as June 1976, on plans by Cuban exile terrorist groups to bomb a Cubana airliner." Former CIA operative Posada Carriles denies involvement but provides many details of the incident in his book "Caminos del Guerrero" (Way of the Warrior).^[1][2]

Four men were arrested in connection with the bombing and a trial was held in Venezuela: Freddy Lugo and Hernán Ricardo Lozano were sentenced to 20-year prison terms; Orlando Bosch was acquitted because of technical defects in the prosecution evidence, and lived in Miami, Florida until he died on the 27th of April, 2011; and Luis Posada Carriles was held for eight years while awaiting a final sentence, but eventually fled. He later entered the United States, where he was held on charges of entering the country illegally but released on April 19, 2007.

Background

On 11 June 1976 Coordination of United Revolutionary Organizations (CORU) was founded at a meeting in the Dominican Republic, uniting five anti-Castro Cuban exile groups,^[3] including Alpha 66 and Omega 7. For three months prior to the bombing of Flight 455, CORU waged a campaign of violence against links between several Caribbean countries which had established links with Cuba. In July, the same flight had been targeted by a suitcase bomb in Jamaica, which exploded shortly before being loaded onto the plane.^[4] Other attacks in the summer included bombings of a number of offices of airlines carrying out business with Cubana, including the offices of the BWIA West Indies Airline in Barbados, of Air Panama in Colombia, and of Iberia and Nanaco Line in Costa Rica.^[3] Other attacks included the murder of a Cuban official in Mexico and two in Argentina,^[3] the September assassination of Orlando Letelier in Washington, D.C., and "a mysterious fire in Guyana [which] destroyed a large quantity of Cuban-supplied fishing equipment."^[4]

Preparations

On October 5, 1976, Freddy Lugo and Hernán Ricardo Lozano left Caracas for Trinidad, arriving at 1 am. The following day they sought to board Cubana de Aviación's Flight CU-455, which was scheduled to fly from Guyana to Havana, Cuba via Trinidad, Barbados, and Kingston. They rejected the offer of an earlier flight with British West Indies Airways (BWIA). With a member of the Cuban fencing team waiting for the Cubana flight assisting with interpretation, the pair were able to insist on boarding the later Cubana flight. The pair left the flight at Barbados, and later returned to Trinidad.^[5]

Crash

Eleven minutes after takeoff from Barbados's Seawell airport (now Grantley Adams International Airport) and at an altitude of 18,000 feet, two bombs exploded on board. One was located in the aircraft's rear lavatory, and another in the midsection of the passenger cabin. The former ultimately destroyed the aircraft's control cables, while the latter created a hole in the aircraft and started a fire.^[5]

The plane went into a rapid descent, while the pilots unsuccessfully tried to return the plane to Seawell Airport. The captain, Wilfredo Pérez Pérez, radioed to the control tower: "We have an explosion aboard, we are descending immediately! ... We have fire on board! We are requesting immediate landing! We have a total emergency!" Realizing a successful landing was no longer possible, it appears that the pilot turned the craft away from the beach and towards the Atlantic Ocean, saving the lives of many tourists. This occurred about eight kilometres short of the airport.

All 73 passengers and 5 crew aboard the plane died: the passengers comprised 57 Cubans, 11 Guyanese, and five North Koreans.^[5] Among the dead were all 24 members of the 1975 national Cuban fencing team that had just won all the gold medals in the Central American and Caribbean Championships; many were teenagers. Several officials of the Cuban government were also aboard the plane: Manuel Permuy Hernández, director of the National Institute of Sports (INDER); Jorge de la Nuez Suárez, secretary for the shrimp fleet; Alfonso González, National Commissioner of firearm sports; and Domingo Chacón Coello, an agent from the Interior Ministry [2]. The 11 Guyanese passengers included five travelling to Cuba to study medicine,^[5] and the young wife of a Guyanese diplomat. The five Koreans were government officials and a cameraman.

Judicial proceedings

Arrests

Hours after the explosions, Trinidad authorities arrested Freddy Lugo and Hernan Ricardo Lozano, two Venezuelan men who had boarded the plane in Trinidad and checked their baggage to Cuba but who had exited the plane in Barbados and flown back to Trinidad. Ricardo had been travelling with a false identity under the name of José Vázquez García.

Lugo and Ricardo confessed, and declared to be acting under the orders of Luis Posada Carriles. Their testimony, along with other evidence, implicated Posada and another Venezuelan, Orlando Bosch.

On 14 October 1976, Posada and Bosch were both arrested in Caracas, Venezuela and the offices of Investigaciones Comerciales e Industriales C.A. (ICICA), a private investigator's company owned by Posada, were raided. Weapons, explosives and a radio transmitter were found. Ricardo was an employee of ICICA at the time of the attack, while Lugo worked as a photographer for the Ministry of Mines and Hydrocarbons.

On October 20, authorities of Trinidad, Cuba, Barbados, Guyana and Venezuela held a meeting in Port of Spain, during which the decision was taken to hold the trial in Venezuela, since the four accused were citizens of that country. Shortly after, Lugo and Ricardo were deported to Venezuela.

Military trial

On August 25, 1977, Judge Delia Estava Moreno referred the case to a military tribunal, charging all four co-conspirators with treason.

In September 1980, a Venezuelan military judge acquitted all four men.

The prosecutor appealed, arguing that a military court was the wrong forum to try the case for two reasons: none of the men were military personnel in 1976, and the crime of qualified homicide or aggravated homicide cannot be tried by a military tribunal. The Military Court of Appeals agreed and surrendered jurisdiction, rendering the acquittal moot. The Judge ruled that the accused "are civilians and the crimes imputed to them are governed by the penal (and not the military) code... Civilians and common law crimes are not subject to the dispositions of the Code of Military Justice..."

Civilian trial

The four were then charged with aggravated homicide and treason before a civilian court.

On August 8, 1985, Venezuelan judge Alberto Perez Marcano of the 11th Penal Court convicted Lugo and Ricardo, sentencing them each to 20 years in prison. The judge reduced the penalty to its lowest limit "due to the extenuating circumstance of no prior criminal records." Orlando Bosch was acquitted, because the evidence gathered by the Barbados authorities during the investigation could not be used in the Venezuela trial, as it was presented too late and had not been translated into Spanish.

Posada fled from the San Juan de los Morros penitentiary on the eve of the pronouncement of his sentence. He had been confined in this prison following two previous failed escape attempts. Allegations were made that Venezuelan authorities were bribed to help him escape. No verdict was entered against Posada because, according to the Venezuelan Penal Code, judicial proceedings cannot continue without the presence of the accused. The court issued an arrest warrant against him which is still pending as of November, 2005^[update].

Aftermath

A different judge then ordered the case reviewed by a higher court. The Venezuelan government declined to appeal the case any further, and in November 1987 Bosch was freed. He had spent 11 years in jail despite having been acquitted twice. Lugo and Lozano were released in 1993 and continue to reside in Venezuela.

Posada fled to Panama and then to the United States. In April 2005, a new warrant for Posada's arrest in connection with the bombing was issued in Venezuela by the government of Hugo Chávez. However, a U.S. immigration judge ruled that Posada should not be deported to Cuba or Venezuela because he could be subject to torture in those countries. In 2007, Congressman Bill Delahunt and Jose Pertierra, an immigration lawyer representing the government of Venezuela, argued that Posada could be deported on the grounds that the U.S. was making an exception for Posada. Because, they argued, the U.S. practices extraordinary rendition involving the seizure and transportation of suspected terrorists to Syria and Egypt, both of which practice torture, the U.S. could also deport Posada, a terrorist, to Cuba or Venezuela.^[6]

Freed from Venezuelan charges, Bosch went to the United States, assisted by US Ambassador to Venezuela Otto Reich; there, he was ultimately arrested for a parole violation. Bosch was pardoned of all American charges by President George H.W. Bush on July 18, 1990 at the request of his son Jeb Bush, who later became Governor of Florida; this pardon came despite objections by the then President's own defense department that Bosch was one of the most deadly terrorists working "within the hemisphere."^[7] Although many countries sought Bosch's extradition he remained free in the United States. The political pressure to grant Bosch a pardon was begun during the congressional campaign run by Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, herself a Cuban American, and overseen by her campaign manager Jeb Bush.

In 2005, Posada was held by U.S. authorities in Texas on the charge of illegal presence on national territory before the charges were dismissed on May 8, 2007. His release on bail on April 19, 2007, had elicited angry reactions from the Cuban and Venezuelan governments.^[8] The U.S. Justice Department had urged the court to keep him in jail because he was "an admitted mastermind of terrorist plots and attacks", a flight risk and a danger to the community.^[9]

On September 28, 2005, a U.S. immigration judge ruled that Posada cannot be deported because he faced the threat of torture in Venezuela.^[10]

FBI and CIA knowledge

"The U.S. authorities know that international terrorist Orlando Bosch Avila and his organization of which Luis Posada Carriles is a member hatched the plot to blow up this plane. This is not only backed up by investigations undertaken in Cuba. U.S. Associate Attorney General Joe Whitley, who analyzed hundreds of public documents and secret CIA and FBI files, concluded that the Coordination of United Revolutionary Organizations was responsible for the attack and the top leader of this terrorist group is Bosch."

— Jose Luis Mendez, author of several books on anti-Castro militants ^[11]

Declassified FBI report that reads: "Our confidential source ascertained (...) that the bombing of the Cubana Airlines DC-8 was planned, in part, in Caracas, Venezuela, at two meetings attended by Morales Navarrete, Luis Posada Carriles and Frank Castro"^[12]

Luis Posada Carriles, a Cuban-born naturalized Venezuelan, was the Director of Counterintelligence at Venezuela's FBI equivalent, the DISIP, from 1967 to 1974. A U.S. Government document released through FOIA also confirms Posada's status with the CIA: "Luis Posada, in whom CIA has an operational interest - Posada is receiving approximately $300 per month from CIA". Posada was heavily involved with right-wing anti-Castro groups, in particular the Cuban-American National Foundation (CANF) and the Coordinadora de Organizaciones Revolucionarias Unidas (Coordination of United Revolutionary Organizations - CORU), led at the time by Orlando Bosch.

According to documents Posada stopped being a CIA asset in 1974, but that there remained "occasional contact" until June 1976, a few months before the bombing. CIA had concrete advance intelligence, as early as June 1976, on possible plans by Cuban exile terrorist groups to bomb a Cubana airliner, and the FBI's attache in Caracas had multiple contacts with one of the Venezuelans who placed the bomb on the plane, and provided him with a visa to the U.S. five days before the bombing, despite suspicions that he was engaged in terrorist activities at the direction of Luis Posada Carriles.^[2]

A declassified CIA document dated October 12, 1976, a few days after bombing, quotes Posada as saying, a few days after a plate fund-raising meeting for CORU held around September 15, "We are going to hit a Cuban airliner... Orlando has the details" (Source Comment: The identities of "We" and "Orlando" were not known at the time.)^[13]

“	Our hope is that the US government will designate Luis Posada Carriles as a terrorist and hold him accountable for the pain, suffering and loss he has caused to us and so many other families.	”
— Roseanne Nenninger, whose 19-year-old brother, Raymond, was aboard Flight 455 [14]

A declassified FBI document dated October 21, 1976, quotes CORU member Secundino Carrera as stating that CORU "was responsible for the bombing of the Cubana Airlines DC-8 on October 6, 1976... this bombing and the resulting deaths were fully justified because CORU was at war with the Fidel Castro regime." Carrera also expressed his pleasure over the attention paid to the United States over the bombing, as it was taking attention off of himself and his associate. [3]

Documents released by the National Security Archive on May 3, 2007 reveal the links Posada had to the 1976 Cubana airline bombing and other terrorist attacks and plots, including a British West Indian Airways office in Barbados and the Guyanese Embassy in Trinidad. [4] These provide additional proof of Posada's involvement in violent efforts to undermine Castro's socialist government, said Peter Kornbluh, director of the National Security Archive's Cuba Documentation Project. The Archive is an independent research organization located at George Washington University.

Memorials

This memorial was erected in recognition of the 78 people who were killed in the crash of Cubana Flight 455 just off the coast of Bridgetown, Barbados in early October, 1976.

A monument was erected at Payne's Bay, Saint James, Barbados to the memory of the people killed in the bombing, and it was visited several times by Fidel Castro and other Cuban^[15] and Venezuelan officials, including a visit during the CARICOM meeting in December 2005 during which Cuban officials called for Posada "to be brought to justice so as to bring closure to this egregious incident that caused so much pain to the people of the region." In 2008 an additional monument to the tragedy is also under construction in Georgetown, Guyana. It is located at the junction of Camp and Lamaha streets.^[16]

See also

Cuba portal

• Lists of accidents and incidents on commercial airliners
• Air safety
• Cuba-United States relations

References

1. ^ Posada Carriles, Luis 1994 (accessed 4-13-07) Los Caminos del Guerrero. Latin American Studies [1]
2. ^ ^{a b} CIA and FBI Documents Detail Career in International Terrorism; Connection to U.S.
3. ^ ^{a b c} Jean-Guy Allard, Granma, 26 December 2005, The U.S. ignored Costa Rican proposal to extradite Bosch
4. ^ ^{a b} The Guardian, 8 October 1976, Cuban exiles 'bombed jet'
5. ^ ^{a b c d} Phillips, Dion E.(1991), "Terrorism and security in the Caribbean: The 1976 Cubana disaster off Barbados", Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, 14:4, 209 — 219, p211
6. ^ http://www.abc.net.au/26 June 2007
7. ^ 638 Ways to Kill Castro, Channel 4 Television, 28 November 2006: TV documentary covering the many attempts by the CIA to eliminate Cuban leader Fidel Castro, a segment of which focused upon the Flight 455 bombing.
8. ^ Push to free convicted Cuban spies reaches D.C., Miami Herald, September 22, 2006 (English)
9. ^ U.S. criticized as Cuban exile is freed
10. ^ No deportation for Cuban militant (BBC)
11. ^ Author: Anti-Cuba Group Planned 14 Crashes United Press International, October 7, 2009
12. ^ Declassified FBI report on bombing of Cubana Flight 455, dated 5 November 1976
13. ^ Declassified CIA document dated October 14, 1976
14. ^ Former CIA Asset Luis Posada Goes to Trial by Peter Kornbluh, The Nation, January 5, 2011
15. ^ "Cuba a ‘true friend’ to Barbados". Nation Newspaper. November 5, 2010. http://www.nationnews.com/index.php/articles/view/cuba-a-true-friend-to-barbados/. Retrieved October 16, 2011. 
16. ^ Singh, Rickey (September 30, 2010). "OUR CARIBBEAN: Remembering Cubana tragedy 35 years after". Nation Newspaper. http://www.nationnews.com/index.php/articles/view/our-caribbean-remembering-cubana-tragedy-35-years-after/. Retrieved October 16, 2011. 

External links

• Criminal Occurrence description at the Aviation Safety Network
• PDF Report on the Judicial Proceedings (in Spanish)
• 1998 Barbados Monument located in the parish of Saint James, dedicated to the victims of the aircraft bombing.
• Picture of the airplane
• Terrorist Network Operating Openly In The United States by Jane Franklin, ZNET, April 30, 2005
• The Coddled "Terrorists" of South Florida by Tristram Korten and Kirk Nielsen, Salon Magazine, January 14, 2008
• Twilight of the Assassins: The 1976 Bombing of Cubana Airlines Flight 455 - video report by Democracy Now!