Operation Totalize

Operation Totalize
Part of Operation Overlord
A Cromwell tank and jeep pass an abandoned German PaK 43/41 anti-tank gun during Operation Totalize, August 8, 1944.
Date August 8–13, 1944 Location Normandy, France Result Partial Allied success
Belligerents
Canada  United Kingdom  Poland	Germany
Commanders and leaders
Guy Simonds	Kurt Meyer
Strength
3 infantry divisions, 2 armoured divisions, 2 armoured brigades	3 infantry divisions, 1 SS Panzer division, 1 heavy tank battalion
Casualties and losses
At least 1,256 casualties[nb 1] 146+ tanks[nb 2]	3,000 casualties[nb 3] At least 45 tanks[3]

Operation Totalize (also referred to as "Operation Totalise" in some more recent British sources^{[nb 4]}) was an offensive launched by Allied troops of the First Canadian Army during the later stages of the Operation Overlord, from August 8 to August 13, 1944. The intention was to break through the German defences south of Caen on the eastern flank of the Allied positions in Normandy and exploit success by driving south to capture the high ground north of the city of Falaise. The overall goal was to precipitate the collapse of the entire German front, and cut off the retreat of German forces fighting American and British armies further west. The battle is considered the inaugural operation of the First Canadian Army, which had been formally activated on July 23.^[4]

In the early hours of August 8, 1944, II Canadian Corps launched the attack using mechanized infantry. They broke through the German front lines and captured vital positions deep in the German defences. It was intended that two fresh armoured divisions would continue the attack, but some hesitancy by these two comparatively inexperienced divisions and German armoured counter-attacks slowed the offensive. Having advanced 9 miles (14 km), the Allies were halted 7 miles (11 km) north of Falaise, and forced to prepare a fresh attack.^[3]

Background

Caen had been an objective of the British forces assaulting Sword Beach on D-Day.^[5] However, the German defences were strongest in this sector, and most of the German reinforcements sent to Normandy were committed to the defence of the city.^[6] Positional warfare ensued for the next six weeks. Several attempts by British and Canadian forces to capture Caen were unsuccessful until July 9, when all of the city, north of the Orne River, was captured during Operation Charnwood. Between July 18 and July 20, British forces launched Operation Goodwood to outflank the city to the east and south, while Canadian forces mounted Operation Atlantic to cross the Orne River and clear the remaining portions of the city. Although Operation Goodwood was halted with heavy tank losses, the two operations ultimately secured a bridgehead 6 miles (9.7 km) wide and 3 miles (4.8 km) deep south of the Orne.^[7]

The Germans still held the commanding terrain of the Verrières Ridge, 5 miles (8.0 km) south of the city. The repeated British and Canadian attacks launched around Caen (in part to distract the Germans from the western part of the front,^[8] where the First United States Army was preparing to break out of the Allied lodgement) had caused the Germans to defend Verrières ridge with some of their strongest and most determined formations, including elements of three SS Panzer divisions of the I SS Panzer Corps.^[8]

Within 48 hours of the end of Operation Goodwood, the 2nd Canadian Infantry Division launched an attack against the "formidable" German defences on Verrières Ridge.^[9] They suffered over 1,300 casualties and territorial gains were minimal. From July 25 to July 27, another attempt was made to take the ridge as part of Operation Spring. Poor execution^[10] resulted in around 1,500 Canadian casualties.^[11] In total, the Battle of Verrières Ridge had claimed upwards of 2,800 Canadian casualties.^[12] While the ridge remained in German hands,^[13] the 2nd Canadian Infantry Division had gained a foothold on the ridge between the village of Verrières to St.Martin-de-Fontenay, which would allow the troops to assemble free of German observation while they prepared to launch Totalize.^[14]

Also on July 25 the Americans launched their breakout offensive, Operation Cobra, which gained immediate success.^[15] By the end of the third day of the operation, American forces had advanced 15 miles (24 km) south of the Cobra start line at several points.^[16] On July 30, American forces captured Avranches, at the base of the Cotentin peninsula. The German left flank was now open and within 24 hours, units of the American Third Army had entered Brittany and began advancing south and west through open country almost without opposition.^[17] Three German Panzer divisions—the 1st SS, 9th SS and 116th—were shifted westward from Verrières Ridge to face this new threat.^[13]

General Bernard Montgomery (commanding the ground forces in Normandy) now wanted an attack on the eastern flank of the front to capture Falaise, intending that such a move would precipitate a general German collapse.^[18] The First Canadian Army, commanded by Lieutenant General Harry Crerar, held this part of the Allied front. It consisted of the British I Corps, responsible for the extreme eastern flank of the Allied lines, and Canadian II Corps south of Caen.^[18] Canadian II Corps, which was to launch Operation Totalize, was commanded by Lieutenant General Guy Simonds and consisted of the 2nd Canadian Division, 3rd Canadian Division, British 51st Division, 4th Canadian (Armoured) Division, 1st Polish Armoured Division, 2nd Canadian Armoured Brigade and the British 33rd Armoured Brigade.^[19]

Offensive plan

The German defensive positions on Verrières Ridge remained very strong.^[20] The forward infantry positions were well dug-in, with wide fields of fire.^[21] The main concentration of one hundred 75 mm and 88 mm anti-tank guns was deployed around the villages of Cramesnil and Saint-Aignan-de-Cramesnil 3 miles (4.8 km) behind the forward positions to halt any breakthrough by tanks along the Caen-Falaise road.^[20] The front line and defences in depth were held by the 89th Infantry Division, 85th Infantry Division (recently arrived from Rouen) and the remnants of the 272nd Grenadier Infantry Division (which had been decimated by the Canadians during Operation Atlantic).^[19] The 12th SS Panzer Division Hitlerjugend with an attached heavy tank battalion, with fifty tanks in total, was in reserve a further 3 miles (4.8 km) back.^[22] Some of the infantry were commanded by the German LXXXVI Korps, but most of the sector (and 12th SS Panzer Division) was under the command of the I SS Panzer Corps, which had arrived in the area during Operation Goodwood.^[22]

Simonds knew that infantry assaults supported by massed artillery had failed to overcome the German forward lines in Operation Atlantic and Operation Spring. During Operation Goodwood, a bombardment by aircraft of RAF Bomber Command had allowed British tanks to break through the German front, but they had then suffered heavy casualties from the intact German defences in depth.^[23] Infantry had been unable to follow up quickly enough to support the leading tanks or to secure ground behind them (so that follow-up units were also slowed).^[23] To solve the tactical problem presented by the terrain and the deep defences, Simonds proposed a radical solution; in effect, the world's first large-scale mechanized infantry attack.^[19]

Some Canadian and British infantry divisions had been temporarily equipped with M7 Priest self-propelled guns for the D-Day landings. These had since been withdrawn and replaced by towed Ordnance QF 25 pounders. Simonds had the Priests converted into Kangaroo Armoured Personnel Carriers, which would allow infantry to follow the tanks closely on any terrain.^[22] Permission was first requested from the Americans, from whom the M7s had been borrowed, to convert them into APCs.^[24]

Simonds made air power an essential component in his plan for breaking through the German tactical zones.^[25] The preliminary aerial bombardment before the ground attack called for RAF Bombers to saturate the German defences on both flanks of a four mile-wide corridor along the axis of the Caen-Falaise road during the night of August 7.^[26] During the early hours of August 8, two attacking forces of tanks and armoured personnel carriers would advance along this corridor. West of the road under the Canadian 2nd Division were the 4th Canadian Infantry Brigade and 2nd Canadian Armoured Brigade.^[26] East of the road, under the British 51st Division were the 154th (Highland) Brigade and British 33rd Armoured Brigade. These two columns would bypass the front-line defenders, and capture the main German anti-tank defences around Cramesnil and Saint-Aignan de Cramesnil at dawn.^[26]

The second phase would follow immediately. While the remaining four infantry brigades of the 2nd Canadian and 51st British divisions cleared up the isolated German forward defences, and 3rd Canadian Division and British 49th Division (from British I Corps) began subsidiary attacks to widen the base of salient captured in the first phase, the 4th Canadian Armoured Division and Polish 1st Armoured Division would move up the corridor to Cramesnil, and prepare to advance further south. To prepare for their attack, bombers of the United States Eighth Air Force would bombard the German reserve positions at Hautmesnil.^[27] The ultimate objective was the high ground north of Falaise, 15 miles (24 km) beyond the start line.^[27]

Anglo-Canadian Assault

Map of Operation Totalize.

During the evening of August 7, 1944, the attacking forces formed up in six columns, each only four vehicles wide, of tanks, Kangaroo APCs, half tracks, self-propelled anti-tank guns and Mine flail tanks.^[28] At 23:00, the heavy bombers of RAF Bomber Command commenced their bombardment of German positions along the entire Caen front.^[27] At 23:30, the armoured columns began their advance behind a rolling barrage.^[27]

Initially, movement was slow; many APC drivers became disoriented by the amount of dust caused by the vehicles.^[22] Several vehicles became stuck in bomb craters. Simonds had ordered several means for the columns to maintain their direction: some vehicles were fitted with radio direction-finders, the artillery fired target-marking shells, Bofors 40 mm guns fired bursts of tracer in the direction of advance.^[29] In spite of all these measures there was still confusion. Several vehicles collided, or were knocked out.^[29]

However, the attack succeeded in punching significant holes in the German defenses.^[27] By dawn, the attacking columns from the British 51st Division had reached their intended positions. The infantry dismounted from their Kangaroo APCs within 200 yards (180 m) of their objectives, the villages of Cramensnil and Saint-Aignan de Cramesnil, and rapidly overran the defenders.^[28] The columns from the Canadian 2nd Division were delayed by fog and unexpected opposition on their right flank, but by noon on August 8, the Allied forces had captured the entire Verrières Ridge.^[30] The novel methods used by Simonds ensured that the attackers suffered only a fraction of the loss which would have been incurred in a normal "dismounted" attack.^[31]

The Allies were poised to move against the heavily defended town of Cintheaux, 2 miles (3.2 km) south of their furthest penetration, but Simonds ordered a halt to the advance to allow field artillery and the armoured divisions (4th Canadian and 1st Polish) to move into position for the second phase of the operation.^[27]

German countermoves

SS General Kurt Meyer, commander of the 12th SS Panzer Division, had already ordered infantry from various formations shattered by the bombardment by Bomber Command and by the armoured attack to occupy Cintheaux. He also moved forward two battlegroups from his own division, consisting of assault guns, infantry and Tiger tanks, positioning them across the Canadian front.^[22] Shortly after midday, he ordered these two battlegroups to counter-attack the leading Allied troops.^[32]

At this point, the Allied offensive plan called for additional bombardment by the USAAF Eighth Air Force before the 4th Canadian Armoured Division and the Polish 1st Armoured Division pushed south towards Falaise on either side of the Caen-Falaise Road.^[33] While the counter-attack by the 12th SS Panzer Division was unsuccessful, it did place Meyer's tanks north of the target area that the Eighth Air Force bombarded in preparation for the second phase of the Allied attack.^[4] These tanks, spared the effects of the bombing, slowed the advance of the Polish 1st Armoured Division,^[4] preventing a breakthrough east of the road. West of the road, the German infantry at Cintheaux likewise held up Canadian Armoured formations. Neither division (both in combat for the first time) pressed their attacks as hard as Simonds demanded, and "laagered" (went into a defensive formation while vehicles and troops were resupplied and rested) when darkness fell.^[34]

To restore the momentum of the attack, Simonds ordered a column from the Canadian armoured division to seize Hill 195, just to the west of the main road halfway between Cintheaux and Falaise. The column lost direction and was caught at dawn east of the road by German 88 mm anti-aircraft guns. They held their ground during August 9, but suffered heavy casualties, including most of their tanks. The Canadians were forced to withdraw.^[34]

Because the column was so far from its intended objective, other units sent to relieve it could not find it. Eventually, another force captured Hill 195 in a model night attack on August 10, but the Germans had been given time to withdraw and reform a defensive line on the Laison River.^[19] By August 11, the Anglo-Canadian offensive had been halted.^[35]

Aftermath

Canadian troops searching German prisoners during the early stages of Operation Totalize.

Although significant strategic successes had been made during the first phases of the assault, heavy casualties were taken by the two Allied armoured divisions in their attempt to push towards Falaise.^[34] Formations of four Divisions of the First Canadian Army held positions on Hill 195, directly north of Falaise. At the same time, Allied forces managed to inflict upwards of 1,500 casualties on already depleted German forces.^[36]

Major General Rod Keller was removed from his command of the 3rd Canadian Infantry Division after having been badly wounded when his headquarters were hit by misdirected bombs during an American air attack on German positions. Keller's poor performance in Totalize lost him the confidence of General Crerar and he received no further command positions for the remainder of the war.^[34] Simonds and Crerar mounted a follow-up offensive, Operation Tractable, which took place between August 14 and August 21.^[36]

On August 21, the Falaise Pocket was closed when Canadian and Polish units made contact with US troops to the south, effectively ending Commonwealth participation in the Battle of Normandy with a decisive Allied Victory.^{[37][nb 5]}

See also

	Canadian Armed Forces portal
	World War II portal

• Joe Ekins
• Michael Wittmann

Notes

Footnotes

1. ^ Michael Reynolds quoting Stanisław Maczek, places the Polish losses during the operation at 656 men.^[1] Historian Terry Copp states the Canadians losses included more than 600 men dead.^[2]
2. ^ Reynolds claims that the operation cost the Canadians over 80 tanks, while Maczek claims that the Polish Armoured Division lost an additional 66 tanks.^[1]
3. ^ Copp states that German losses are estimated, but did include 1,270 prisoners.^[2]
4. ^ Although contemporary documents, including the official records of the British 21st Army Group held in the British National Archive in Kew, invariably refer to "Totalize". While there was no rule that names of operations had to be real words, the Concise Oxford Dictionary lists the word, meaning to collect into a total, with a "z"
5. ^ American histories define the Battle of Normandy differently, as their forces effectively left Normandy with Operation Cobra on 25 July, passing over into Brittany.

Citations

1. ^ ^{a b} Reynolds, p. 246
2. ^ ^{a b} Copp, p. 211
3. ^ ^{a b} Wilmot, p. 414
4. ^ ^{a b c} Bercuson, p. 229
5. ^ Van der Vat, p. 110
6. ^ Bercuson, p. 215
7. ^ Van Der Vat, p. 157
8. ^ ^{a b} Van der Vat, p. 161
9. ^ Bercuson, p. 222
10. ^ Reid, p. 52
11. ^ Stacey, p. 194
12. ^ Zuehlke, pp. 166–168
13. ^ ^{a b} Bercuson, p. 226
14. ^ Reid, p. 57
15. ^ Wilmot, pp.390–392
16. ^ Wilmot, p. 393
17. ^ Wilmot, p. 394
18. ^ ^{a b} Wilmot, p. 410
19. ^ ^{a b c d} Van der Vat, p. 166
20. ^ ^{a b} D'Este, p. 423
21. ^ Bercuson, p. 221
22. ^ ^{a b c d e} Bercuson, p. 228
23. ^ ^{a b} Van der Vat, p. 160
24. ^ Van der Vat, p. 166.
25. ^ Perrun 2003, p. 139.
26. ^ ^{a b c} Van der Vat, p. 165
27. ^ ^{a b c d e f} Zuehlke, p. 168
28. ^ ^{a b} Wilmot, p.412
29. ^ ^{a b} Roy, p. 166
30. ^ Roy, p. 167
31. ^ Wilmot, p. 413
32. ^ D'Este, p. 424
33. ^ D'Este, p. 422
34. ^ ^{a b c d} Bercuson, p. 230
35. ^ Cawthorne, p. 125
36. ^ ^{a b} Bercuson, p. 231
37. ^ Bercuson, p. 232

Sources

• Bercuson, David (2004) [1996]. Maple Leaf Against the Axis. Red Deer Press. ISBN 0-88995-305-8. 
• Cawthorne, Nigel (2005) Victory in World War II. Arcturus Publishing. ISBN 1-84193-351-1
• D'Este, Carlo (2004) [1983]. Decision in Normandy: The Real Story of Montgomery and the Allied Campaign. Penguin Books Ltd. ISBN 0-14101-761-9. 
• Perrun, Jody. 'Best-Laid Plans: Guy Simonds and Operation Totalize, 7–10 August 1944' in The Journal of Military History, Vol. 67, No. 1 (Jan., 2003), pp. 137–173
• Reid, Brian (2005). No Holding Back. Robin Brass Studio. ISBN 1-896941-40-0. 
• Roy, Reginald (1984). 1944 - The Canadians in Normandy. Macmillan of Canada. ISBN 0-7715-9796-7
• Trew, Simon; Badsey, Stephen (2004). Battle for Caen. Battle Zone Normandy. The History Press Ltd. ISBN 0-75093-010-1. 
• Van Der Vat, Dan (2003). D-Day; The Greatest Invasion, A People's History. Madison Press Limited. ISBN 1-55192-586-9.
• Wilmot, Chester; Christopher Daniel McDevitt (1997) [1952]. The Struggle For Europe. Wordsworth Editions Ltd. ISBN 1-85326-677-9. 
• Zuehlke, Mark (2001). The Canadian Military Atlas: Canada's Battlefields from the French and Indian Wars to Kosovo. Stoddart. ISBN 0-77373-289-6. 

External links

• Stacey, Colonel Charles Perry; Bond, Major C.C.J. (1960). "Official History of the Canadian Army in the Second World War: Volume III. The Victory Campaign: The operations in North-West Europe 1944-1945" (PDF). The Queen's Printer and Controller of Stationery Ottawa. http://www.dnd.ca/dhh/collections/books/files/books/Victory_e.pdf. 

Coordinates: 49°11′10″N 0°21′45″W / 49.18611°N 0.3625°W / 49.18611; -0.3625