Montana Supreme Court

Montana Supreme Court
Seal of the Montana Supreme Court
Established	1841
Jurisdiction	Montana , United States
Location	Helena, Montana
Authorized by	Montana Constitution
Decisions are appealed to	Supreme Court of the United States

The Montana Supreme Court is the highest court of the Montana state court system in the U.S. state of Montana. It is established and its powers defined by Article VII of the 1972 Montana Constitution. It is primarily an appellate court which reviews civil and criminal decisions of Montana's trial courts of general jurisdiction and certain specialized legislative courts, only having original jurisdiction in a limited number of actions. The court's Chief Justice and six Associate Justices are elected by non-partisan, popular elections. The Montana Supreme Court meets in the Justice Building in Helena, Montana, the state's capital, an international style building completed in 1982.

History

Montana Territorial Supreme Court

On May 26, 1864, the United States Congress passed the Organic Act,^[1] which formed the Montana Territory and established the Territorial Supreme Court. The court consisted of one Chief Justice and two Associate Justices, all of whom were appointed by the President of the United States and confirmed by the United States Senate; the court's first members were chosen by President Abraham Lincoln in 1864. The Montana Territorial Supreme Court held its first session in Virginia City, Montana on May 17, 1865.

Each justice presided over one of the territory's three judicial districts, which meant that cases the Territorial Supreme Court heard on appeal were usually first tried in the Montana District Court by one of the justices. This arrangement was altered in 1886 when the Congress passed legislation that disqualified any justice who had previously participated in a case from hearing it on appeal; a fourth justice was also added to the court by the same act.

The Territorial Supreme Court rarely issued written opinions until 1872, when the Territorial Legislature established written reporting for the court. The Territorial Supreme Court held its last session on October 5, 1889; Montana became a state on November 8.

Montana Supreme Court

Article VIII of the 1889 Montana Constitution established the Montana Supreme Court, and provided that its three members would be elected to six-year terms. These elections were partisan until 1909, when the Montana Legislature enacted the Nonpartisan Judiciary Act. This prohibited partisan filings by judicial candidates and required that they instead be nominated by citizen petition. The resulting voter turnout in 1910 was minuscule (fewer than half those who voted on the partisan ballot for the Clerk of the Supreme Court voted for the Chief Justice on the non-partisan ballot) and so many considered the experiment to be a failure. The law was furthermore declared unconstitutional by the Montana Supreme Court in 1911 because it failed to provide any means for nominating candidates to newly created judgeships.^[2] Non-partisan elections were reinstated in 1935, when the legislature prohibited political parties from endorsing, contributing to, or making expenditures in support of or opposition to judicial candidates. Impact on voter participation was, by that time, less dramatic.

The membership of the court was increased by legislative act from three to five justices in 1919. The 1972 Montana Constitution, in Article VII, extended the judicial term of office from six to eight years, and allowed for the legislature to increase the number of associate justices by two members. In 1979 the legislature increased the size of the court from five to seven members to assist in handling the overburdened Court calendar.^[3]

Court composition and selection

The Montana Supreme Court presently consists of a Chief Justice and six Associate Justices.^[4] The Montana Constitution provides for only four Associate Justices, but allows the Montana Legislature to increase the number of Associate Justices to six.^[5] Each justice is elected for an eight-year term in a statewide, nonpartisan election. The terms are staggered so that no more than two seats on the court are scheduled for election at the same time. When a sitting justice runs unopposed, voters cast a "yes" or "no" vote as to whether to retain them. If the seat on the court is contested, the top two vote-getters in the primary election are selected as the final candidates.

Appointments

If a vacancy occurs on the court during a term, it will be temporarily filled by an appointment process. The Judicial Nomination Commission submits a list of three to five candidates to the governor of Montana, who then must choose one from that list to appoint. If the governor fails to make a selection within thirty days of receiving the list, the Chief Justice or Acting Chief Justice makes the nomination.

All appointments must be confirmed by the Montana Senate, though recess appointments serve on the court until the next session of the Senate begins. If the Senate fails to confirm the appointee, the seat on the court will remain vacant and the selection and nomination process restarts. If confirmed, the appointee serves only until the next general election, and if then elected, only serves the remainder of the unexpired term to which he was initially appointed.

Qualifications

All justices of the Montana Supreme Court must be citizens of the United States and residents of Montana for at least two years immediately prior to taking office.^[6] They also must have been admitted to practice law in Montana for at least five years prior to the date of election. Justices must reside within the state during their term.

Chief Justice

The Chief Justice is the administrative head of the Supreme Court. He or she presides over oral argument and court conferences, and represents the court at all official state functions.

The position of Chief Justice is filled directly by election, and candidates do not need to have previously served as an Associate Justice. Whenever the Chief Justice is temporarily absent, or permanently leaves the court during his term, the justice who is nearest the expiration of their term on the court presides as Acting Chief Justice.

Current members

Chief Justice	Term began	Term expires	Notes
Mike McGrath	2009	2016	Elected 2008; previously served as Attorney General, 2000–2008;
Associate Justice	Term began	Term expires	Notes
James C. Nelson	1993	2012	Appointed by Governor Racicot; elected 1994; re-elected 1996, 2004
Patricia O'Brien Cotter	2001	2016	Elected 2000; re-elected 2008
James A. Rice	2001	2014	Appointed by Governor Martz; elected 2002; re-elected 2006
Brian Morris	2005	2012	Elected 2004
Mike Wheat	2010	2012	Appointed by Governor Brian Schweitzer, 2009; elected 2010
Beth Baker	2011	2018	Elected 2010

Former members

Chief Justices

Montana Territorial Supreme Court

Chief Justice	Term served	Notes
Hezekiah L. Hosmer	(1864–1868)	Appointed first Chief Justice of Territorial Supreme Court by President Lincoln
Henry L. Warren	(1868–1871)	Appointed by President Johnson
Decius Wade	(1871–1887)	Appointed by President Grant
N. W. McConnell	(1887–1889)	Appointed by President Cleveland; resigned
Henry N. Blake	(1889)	Appointed by President Harrison, 1889; previously Associate Justice of Territorial Supreme Court (1875–1885); elected first Chief Justice of Montana Supreme Court after statehood

Montana Supreme Court

Chief Justice	Term served	Notes
Henry N. Blake	(1889–1893)	First Chief Justice of Montana Supreme Court; previously Associate Justice of Territorial Supreme Court (1875–1885); Chief Justice of Territorial Supreme Court (1889)
William Y. Pemberton	(1893–1899)
Theodore Brantly	(1899–1922)	Died in office; longest serving Chief Justice to date (23 years)
Llewellyn L. Callaway	(1922–1935)	Appointed
Walter B. Sands	(1935–1938)	Died in office
O. P. Goddard	(1938–1939)	Appointed
Howard A. Johnson	(1939–1946)	Resigned
Carl Lindquist	(1946)	Appointed
Hugh R. Adair	(1947–1956)	Also served as Associate Justice 1943-1946, 1957–1968
James T. Harrison	(1957–1977)	Appointed
Paul G. Hatfield	(1977–1978)
Frank I. Haswell	(1978–1985)	Appointed
Jean A. Turnage	(1985–2000)
Karla M. Gray	(2001–2008)	Elected

Associate Justices

Montana Territorial Supreme Court

Associate Justice	Term served	Notes
Ammi Giddings	(1864–1865)	Appointed by President Lincoln, but never served; resigned immediately due to ill health, though commission remained in force until 1865
Lorenzo P. Williston	(1864–1868)	Appointed by President Lincoln
Lymon E. Munson	(1865–1869)	Appointed by President Lincoln
Hiram Knowles	(1868–1879)	Appointed by President Johnson
George G. Symes	(1869–1871)	Appointed by President Grant
Francis G. Servis	(1872–1875)	Appointed by President Grant
Henry N. Blake	(1875–1885)	Appointed by President Grant; subsequently appointed as Chief Justice of Territorial Supreme Court, 1889; elected first Chief Justice of Supreme Court, 1889–1893
William J. Galbraith	(1879–1888)	Appointed to first term by President Hayes, to subsequent term by President Arthur
Everton J. Conger	(1880–1886)	Appointed by President Hayes
John Coburn	(1884–1886)	Appointed by President Hayes
Thomas C. Bach	(1886–1889)	Appointed by President Cleveland
James H. McLeary	(1886–1888)	Appointed by President Cleveland
Stephen DeWolf	(1888–1889)	Appointed by President Cleveland
Moses J. Liddell	(1888–1889)	Appointed by President Cleveland

Montana Supreme Court

Associate Justice	Term served	Notes
William H. DeWitt	(1889–1897)
Edgar N. Harwood	(1889–1895)
William Henry Hunt	(1894–1900)	Resigned
Horace R. Buck	(1897)	Died in office
William Trigg Pigott	(1897–1903)	Appointed
Robert L. Word	(1900–1901)	Appointed
George R. Milburn	(1901–1907)
William L. Holloway	(1903–1926)	Died in office
Henry C. Smith	(1907–1913)
Sidney Sanner	(1913–1918)
William Trigg Pigott	(1918)	Appointed; previously served as Associate Justice, 1897–1903
Charles H. Cooper	(1919–1924)	Resigned
John Hurley	(1919–1921)
George Y. Patten	(1919)	Appointed to newly created seat; resigned
John A. Matthews	(1919–1920)	Appointed; subsequently served as Associate Justice, 1925–1937
Roy E. Ayers	(1922 - )	Appointed to newly created seat
Albert J. Galen	(1921–1933)
Frank B. Reynolds	(1921–1922)	Died in office
George W. Farr	(1922–1923)	Appointed
Albert P. Stark	(1923–1929)
Wellington D. Rankin	(1924–1925)	Appointed
John A. Matthews	(1925–1937)	Previously served as Associate Justice, 1919
Warren Toole	(1926–1927)	Appointed
Henry L. Myers	(1927–1929)	Appointed
Albert H. Angstman	(1929–1934)	Subsequently served as Associate Justice 1937-1942, 1945-1961 for a total of 28 years
Sam C. Ford	(1929–1933)
Ralph J. Anderson	(1933–1939)
Sam V. Stewart	(1933 - )	Died in office
Claude F. Morris	(1935–1947)
Albert H. Angstman	(1937–1942)	Previously served as Associate Justice, 1929–1934; subsequently served 1945-1961
Ralph L. Arnold	(1939–1941)	Appointed
Leif Erickson	(1939–1945)
Albert Anderson	(1941–1945)
Hugh R. Adair	(1943–1946)	Subsequently served as Chief Justice, 1947–1956, and again as Associate Justice 1957 - 1968
Albert H. Angstman	(1945–1961)	Previously served as Associate Justice, 1929–1934, and 1945–1961
Edwin K. Cheadle	(1945–1947)	Resigned
I. W. Choate	(1947–1949)	Appointed
Fred L. Gibson	(1947–1949)	Appointed
Lee Metcalf	(1947–1953)
R. V. Bottomly	(1949–1961)
Harrison J. Freebourn	(1949–1954)
Forrest H. Anderson	(1953–1956)
Horace S. Davis	(1954–1957)	Appointed
Hugh R. Adair	(1957–1968)	Previously served as Associate Justice, 1943–1946 and as Chief Justice, 1947–1956
Wesley Castles	(1957–1977)	Appointed
Stanley M. Doyle	(1961–1967)	Appointed; resigned
John C. Harrison	(1961–1994)	Longest serving justice in history of the court
Frank I. Haswell	(1967–1978)	Appointed; subsequently served as Chief Justice, 1978–1985
John W. Bonner	(1969–1970)	Died in office
Gene B. Daly	(1970–1983)	Appointed
Daniel J. Shea	(1977–1985)
John C. Sheehy	(1978–1991)	Appointed
Frank B. Morrison	(1981–1987)	Resigned
Fred J. Weber	(1981–1995)
J. C. Gulbrandson	(1983–1989)
William E. Hunt	(1985–2000)
R. C. McDonough	(1987–1993)
Diane G. Barz	(1989–1990)	First woman to serve on the court; resigned
Terry N. Trieweiler	(1990–2003)
Karla M. Gray	(1991–2000)	Subsequently served as Chief Justice, 2000 to 2008
Charles E. "Chip" Erdman	(1995–1997)
Jim Regnier	(1997–2004)
John Warner	(2003–2009)
W. William Leaphart	(1995–2010)	Elected 1994; re-elected 2002

Other court personnel

The Clerk of the Supreme Court is chosen by popular election for six year terms. The Clerk has the following duties by statute:

(a) keep the seal of the supreme court, its records and files, and the roll of attorneys and counselors at law;

(b) adjourn the court from day to day at the beginning of any term in the absence of any justice and until the arrival of a majority of the justices;

(c) file all papers or transcripts required by law to be filed;

(d) issue writs and certificates and approve bonds or undertakings when required;

(e) make out all transcripts to the supreme court of the United States;

(f) make copies of papers or records when demanded by law or the rules of the court; and

(g) perform other duties as may be required by law and the rules and practice of the supreme court.

Mont. Code § 3-2-402.

The Marshall of the Supreme Court is appointed by the court, and is an employee of the judicial branch.^[7] The Marshall generally attends upon the Supreme Court during each term, and acts as a law clerk, executive officer, and court crier. He has the duty of serving all processes from the court within the state, and acts with the powers and duties of a sheriff to the District Courts when necessary.^[8]

Jurisdiction

The Montana Supreme Court hears civil and criminal appeals directly from the Montana District Courts, which are the trial courts of general jurisdiction in the state; Montana is one of ten states in the United States that does not have a distinct intermediate appellate court.^[9] The court also hears appeals from the Montana Water Courts and the Montana Workers' Compensation Court, which are specialized courts established by the legislation rather than part of the judicial branch under the Montana Constitution.

The Montana Supreme Court has original jurisdiction over the so-called extraordinary writs, which include habeas corpus, injunction, review, mandate, quo warranto, and supervisory control. This jurisdiction is concurrent with the Montana District Courts.

The Montana Supreme Court also may exercise original jurisdiction in a case that has not been through a District Court if there are no facts in dispute and the case presents only legal or constitutional questions.

Supervision of the courts and the practice of law

The Montana Constitution grants the Montana Supreme Court broad administrative authority over the state court system to ensure its efficient and effective operation. It has general authority to adopt rules of practice and procedure for the lower courts. It also regulates the admission of attorneys to the state bar, and the conduct of attorneys and judges generally. The Montana Supreme Court appoints the Court Administrator, who performs such duties as preparing and submitting the judicial budget to the legislature, compiling statistics on the business of the courts, and recommending improvements in the judiciary to the Supreme Court.^[10]

Boards and commissions

To fulfill its duties, the Montana Supreme Court manages twenty specialized boards and commissions, to which it appoints members to terms of either indefinite or specified length depending on the specific body. The structure of these commissions vary as well, such that some are composed exclusively of practicing attorneys, while others have a mixture of attorneys, judges, and laypeople.

Advisory Commission on Rules of Civil and Appellate Procedure Board of Bar Examiners Civil Jury Instructions Guidelines Commission Commission of Continuing Legal Education Commission on Character and Fitness Commission on the Code of Judicial Conduct Commission on Courts of Limited Jurisdiction Commission on Practice Commission on Rules of Evidence Commission on Self-Represented Litigants

Commission on Technology Commission on Unauthorized Practice Criminal Jury Instructions Commission District Court Council Equal Justice Task Force Gender Fairness Commission Judicial Nomination Commission Judicial Standards Commission Sentence Review Division Uniform District Court Rules Commission

Procedures

Appeals from inferior courts

Appeals to the Montana Supreme Court are "appeals of right," meaning that the court does not have discretion as to whether it accepts review of the lower court's decision. Appeals are taken from both civil and criminal matters by a party filing a notice of appeal in the District Court that issued the order or judgment from which the appeal is sought.^[11] Contempt orders are not appealable, and so can only be reviewed on application for a writ of review.^[12]

Criminal defendants may appeal only from final judgments of convictions, and other orders after judgment that affect substantive rights.^[13] Indigent defendants are guaranteed representation by counsel at the State's expense. The State does not have the right to appeal from acquittals or convictions, but may appeal from court orders or judgments that dismiss charges, modify verdicts, grant new trials, quash arrests or search warrants, suppress evidence, suppress confessions or admissions, grant or deny a change of venue, or impose a sentence that is contrary to law.^[14]

The supreme court may affirm, reverse, or modify any judgment or order appealed from and may direct the proper judgment or order to be entered or direct a new trial or further proceedings to be had.^[15] When a lower court's judgment is altered on review of civil matters, the court may order restitution for any property or rights that a party lost due to an erroneous order, either by ordering it directly, or by ordering to District Court to itself order it.^[16] On review of criminal matters, the Montana Supreme Court may reverse, affirm, or modify the lower court's judgment; set aside, affirm, or modify any proceedings subsequent to the judgment from which the appeal is taken; reduce the offence of which the defendant was convicted to a lesser included offense; reduce the punishment imposed by the lower court; or order a new trial.^[17]

Applications for original writs

Applications for original writs are filed directly with the Montana Supreme Court. The court may then order that a summary response from opposing parties be filed immediately, or may dismiss the application at its next conference without such an order. If a summary response is ordered, the court considers the filings at its next conference. The court will subsequently dismiss the application, accept jurisdiction, order more extensive briefing on any issue raised in the application or response, order oral argument in extraordinary cases, or issue any other writ or order deemed appropriate in the circumstances. Pending its disposition of the application for the writ, the court may stay a lower court's proceedings, on motion by a party for good cause shown, or sua sponte.

Individual justices may issue writs of habeas corpus on behalf of anyone held in custody for return to themselves, the full Supreme Court, or the District Courts. Individual justices may also issue writs of certiorari to review judgments of contempt.

Conference and argument

The Montana Supreme Court has promulgated Internal Operating Rules for its internal governance. The justices meet in conference twice a week to discuss pending matters. Its Tuesday conferences considers pending petitions for original jurisdiction, and matters that should be considered by the full court. Its Thursday conferences consider proposed opinions, petitions for rehearing, and appeal classifications. A five-justice panel determines how appeals to the Montana Supreme Court are reviewed by the court, such as for full oral argument before the court sitting en banc, or to be decided purely on the briefs submitted to either the court en banc or to a five-justice panel.

The court’s annual calendar was previously divided into four terms, but legislation effective January 6, 2006 changed this to one term, beginning on January 1 of each year. The Chief Justice may also call a special term at any time. Oral arguments are held before the court every month of the year except July and August. Briefs from amicus curiae are accepted only if all parties consent in writing, or the court grants leave on motion stating the interest of the applicant and the reasons why it should participate. A motion of an amicus curiae for leave to participate in oral argument is granted only for "extraordinary reasons."^[18]

A majority of the court is required for quorum, and a majority of the court must concur in all decisions.^[19] If a justice is disqualified or otherwise unable to participate in a case, a District Court judge is substituted, and their opinion is given the same weight in that case as a sitting justice.^[20]

Written decisions

By statute, all decisions of the Montana Supreme Court must be in writing, and must set forth the grounds of the decision.^[21] However, it is up to the court to decide whether an unelaborated order or a full opinion is appropriate.^[22] If a full opinion is to be issued, its drafting is assigned to a justice during conference. The court attempts to hand down its decision within 120 days of when the case is submitted. All justices must indicate their concurrence in the opinion by signing it, and all justices disagreeing with the majority's decision must indicate this in a written dissent.^[21]

Citations and case reporters

Opinions of the Montana Supreme Court are assigned a "public domain" or "neutral-format" case citation, which consists of the year of decision, the state’s postal abbreviation, and finally a sequential number; the court’s sixth decision handed down during 2006, for example, would have the citation 2006 MT 6. The citations of decisions that have been designated as not for publication are followed by an "N" (e.g., 2006 MT 6N), to indicate that those decisions should not be cited for precedential value in any court. All decisions have numbered paragraphs, so that pinpoint citations can be used without reference to print reporters.

The Montana Reports, published by State Reporter Publishing Company, is the official case reporter of Montana Supreme Court opinions. Its opinions are also included in the regional Pacific Reporter published by West Group. When citing to its previous decisions, the Montana Supreme Court cites to both print reporters as well as the neutral-format citation.

Notable decisions

• State v. 1993 Chevrolet Pickup, 116 P.3d 800 (Mont. 2005). The court ruled 6-2 that a warrantless search and seizure of a man's trash did not violate his constitutional rights. Justice James C. Nelson's reluctant concurrence, which he based purely on existing court precedent, received significant attention for his dire warnings about the erosion of civil liberties. His opinion described the amount of personal information contained in trash, such as DNA, and the invasions of privacy he saw becoming more common in other areas of life. "I don't like living in Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four; but I do." He warned that "eventually, we are all going to become collateral damage in the war on drugs, or terrorism, or whatever war is in vogue at the moment."

• Columbia Falls Elem. Sch. Dist. No. 6 v. State, 109 P.3d 257 (Mont. 2005). The court unanimously ruled that the state's public school system violated the Montana Constitution's requirement for the Legislature to fund and establish free schooling so as to provide students with a "quality" education.

• Big Spring v. Jore, 109 P.3d 219 (Mont. 2005). The court ruled 6-1 that seven double-punched ballots in an extremely close election for a seat in the Montana House of Representatives should not have been counted, because ballots were only valid under state law if the voter's intent could be clearly determined. The invalidation of those seven votes gave the election to Democrat Jeanne Windham, whose win gave the Democrats the one seat they needed to have a majority in the Montana House. Had the trial court's counting of those votes been upheld, her opponent, Rick Jore, would have been the first Constitution Party candidate to have won an election at the state level.

• Snetsinger v. Mont. Univ. Sys., 104 P.3d 445 (Mont. 2004). The court ruled 5-3 that the ineligibility of gay and lesbian employees of the University of Montana for domestic partner benefits violated their right to equal protection under the Montana Constitution.

Notes

1. ^ The act was formally titled "An Act to provide a temporary government for the Territory of Montana." See full text (.pdf).
2. ^ State v. O'Leary, 115 P. 204 (Mont. 1911).
3. ^ "Brief History of the Montana Judicial Branch" State of Montana. Accessed May 18, 2010
4. ^ Mont. Code § 3-2-101.
5. ^ Mont. Const. art. VII § 3(1).
6. ^ Mont. Code, § 3-2-102.
7. ^ Mont. Code § 3-2-501.
8. ^ Mont. Code § 3-2-502.
9. ^ The Montana District Courts hear appeals from the lower courts of limited jurisdiction, such as the justice and city courts, and so function as appellate courts in those cases; appeals from the District Court resolution of those cases may then be taken to the Montana Supreme Court.
10. ^ Mont. Code § 3-1-702.
11. ^ Mont. Code Ch. 21, Rule 4.
12. ^ Mont. Code § 3-1-523.
13. ^ Mont. Code § 46-20-104.
14. ^ Mont. Code § 46-20-103.
15. ^ Mont. Code § 3-2-204(1).
16. ^ Mont. Code Ch. 21, Rule 15.
17. ^ Mont. Code § 46-20-703.
18. ^ Mont. Code Ch. 21, Rule 24.
19. ^ Mont. Code § 3-2-302.
20. ^ Mont. Const. Art. VII § 3(2).
21. ^ ^{a b} Mont. Code § 3-2-601.
22. ^ Chief Justice Gray has expressed her preference for unelaborated orders: "In the face of our increasing workload, and the fact that we are primarily an ‘appeal of right’ Court, it strikes me as inherently very unfair to our appellate litigants when we unnecessarily divert our efforts from their appeals to the extent we do here or in other similar matters by issuing a full opinion." Inter-Fluve v. Mont. Eighteenth Judicial Dist. Court, 112 P.3d 258, 265 (Mont. 2005) (Gray, C.J., concurring in part and dissenting in part).

References

• History of the Montana Judicial Branch
• 1989-2005 Annual Reports of the Montana Judicial System; these include statistics for the caseload of the Montana Supreme Court as well as the District Courts, as well as the address of the Chief Justice to the joint session of the Montana Legislature, a history of the court and overview of its functions and procedures, and lists and profiles of the justices.
• Chief Justices of Montana
• Montana Supreme Court order regarding citation formats

External links

• Official site of the Montana Supreme Court
• Decisions of the Montana Supreme Court since 1997 at

Coordinates: 46°35′10″N 112°00′50″W / 46.586146°N 112.014021°W / 46.586146; -112.014021 FindLaw