Marilyn Musgrave

Marilyn Musgrave
Member of the U.S. House of Representatives from Colorado's 4th district
In office January 3, 2003 – January 3, 2009
Preceded by	Bob Schaffer
Succeeded by	Betsy Markey
Personal details
Born	January 27, 1949 (1949-01-27) (age 62) Greeley, Colorado
Political party	Republican
Spouse(s)	Steven Musgrave
Residence	Fort Morgan, Colorado
Alma mater	Colorado State University
Occupation	High school teacher, small business owner, spokeswoman
Religion	Assemblies of God

Marilyn Neoma Musgrave (born January 27, 1949), American politician, is a former Republican member of the United States House of Representatives who served from 2003 to 2009, representing the 4th District of Colorado.

Musgrave served on the Agriculture and Small Business Committees. In the 110th Congress, she served as Ranking Minority member of the Specialty Crops, Rural Development, and Foreign Agriculture subcommittee. She also served as the Region Two representative for the Republican Steering Committee. She was the first Republican woman elected to Congress from Colorado.

Musgrave lost her seat in 2008 to Democratic challenger Betsy Markey by a 56 to 44 percent margin.^[1]

Musgrave currently works for the Susan B. Anthony List, a non-profit that supports pro-life women in politics.^[2]

Background and early political career

Musgrave was born Marilyn Neoma Shuler in Greeley, Colorado. She graduated from Eaton High School in 1968, and attended Colorado State University (CSU) in Fort Collins, graduating with a B.A. in social studies in 1972. Musgrave married while attending CSU. She and her husband Steve Musgrave settled in Fort Morgan, south of Greeley, where they owned and operated a bale stacking business. Musgrave also taught school. The Musgraves have four children and eight grandchildren.

Musgrave's career in elective office began in 1991, when she served one term on the Fort Morgan School Board, where she focused on changing the local sex education curriculum to abstinence-only. She was also involved in the Fort Morgan Right To Life chapter, at one time serving as its president. Musgrave was then elected to the Colorado State House of Representatives in 1992, and served there until after her successful 1998 campaign for a Colorado State Senate seat. While serving in the state senate, Musgrave was selected the Senate Republican Caucus Chairman. In 2002, Musgrave ran for the Fourth Congressional District seat being vacated by Bob Schaffer.

Musgrave is a devout Pentecostal (she is a member of the Assemblies of God), and was one of three Pentecostals serving in the 110th Congress. The others — Republicans — were Tim Johnson of Illinois and Todd Tiahrt of Kansas.^[3]

Musgrave was one of the most conservative members of the state legislature, often sparring with more socially moderate and liberal legislators. She focused her time on social issues.^[4] She staunchly opposed granting civil unions and marriage for same-sex couples. In another area she was active on small business and agricultural issues, particularly authoring bills to exempt farm equipment dealers from sales tax and lowering taxes on small business.

Election history

2002 election

In 2002, after Congressman Bob Schaffer retired, Musgrave ran for and won the Republican nomination to succeed him. Her opponent was businessman Jeff Bedingfield.^[5] She received a big boost in the primary when she gained the endorsements of Schaffer and former Senator William Armstrong.

In November 2002 Musgrave defeated Democratic State Senate President Stan Matsunaka 55% to 42%. She had been favored most of the way due to her large campaign war chest and the district's traditional Republican lean (it had been in Republican hands since 1973).

2004 re-election

In 2004, Musgrave faced Matsunaka again. Matsunaka attacked Musgrave as a "one-trick pony," referring to her focus on outlawing same-sex marriage (see below). He also claimed that Musgrave neglected the 4th's needs and provided poor constituent services.

In the end, Musgrave held her seat by taking 51% of the vote to Matsunaka's 45%. Musgrave won most of the counties in this large and mostly rural district by margins of 2-to-1 or more. However, 85% of the district's vote is cast in two counties which account for only a third of its land—Larimer (home to Fort Collins) and Weld (home to Greeley). Musgrave lost Larimer County by 4,100 votes. She also lost the district's share of Boulder County, including Longmont. She was only able to hold onto her seat by winning Weld County by 15 points (almost 10,000 votes)—far larger than the overall margin of victory. She was also undoubtedly helped by George W. Bush's 58% win in the district.

While Matsunaka only entered the race in May and raised around $800,000, Musgrave was heavily targeted by a 527 group funded by Colorado activists such as Tim Gill. The ads featured an actress dressed up like Musgrave picking a corpse's pocket and stealing from a soldier in combat.

2006 re-election

Main article: Colorado 4th congressional district election, 2006

In 2006, Musgrave faced Democratic state representative Angie Paccione. Also running was Reform Party candidate Eric Eidsness, who had previously considered a Republican Party primary challenge to Musgrave but later decided to become a Democrat.

The election was even tighter than the last. Musgrave won a third term by only 5,984 votes, taking 45.61% of the vote to Paccione's 43.12% and Eidsness' 11.28%.^[6] She lost Larimer County by an even larger margin than in 2004. However, Musgrave won Weld County by just under 6,700 votes.^[7]

2008 campaign

See also: United States House of Representatives elections in Colorado, 2008#District 4

Musgrave ran for a fourth term in the 2008 election, held on November 4, 2008. Her opponent was Betsy Markey, the regional director for Senator Ken Salazar in the 4th.

Musgrave was soundly defeated, taking only 44 percent of the vote to Markey's 56 percent—the second-worst margin of defeat for a Republican incumbent in the 2008 cycle. In a repeat of 2004 and 2006, she easily won most of the rural counties in her district while losing badly in Larimer County—this time by 32,300 votes. While in the past she'd relied on Weld County to hold onto her seat, she lost it by 5,700 votes, sealing her defeat.^[8]

After her defeat, Musgrave would not comment on the election results with the media, nor would she concede the race or contact Markey to congratulate her.^[9] She later recorded a robocall for Republican Georgia senator Saxby Chambliss, saying that she was defeated by "leftist special interests" who "smothered the truth with vicious attacks and lies."^[9]

Political ideology

The American Conservative Union ranked Musgrave as the most conservative member of the House, with a 99 lifetime rating.^[10] The National Journal ranked her as the 28th most conservative member based on her 2007 votes.^[11] Her original House Website contained the phrase, "Defending our way of life through conservative leadership." She was a member of the conservative Republican Study Committee House caucus and its "Values Action Team." In 2005, Musgrave received the "Distinguished Christian Statesman" award from D. James Kennedy's Center for Christian Statesmanship.^[12]

Other political groups that Musgrave is allied with include the National Right to Life Committee, Focus on the Family, Alliance for Marriage, the Family Research Council, the National Taxpayers Union, the Christian Coalition, and the Traditional Values Coalition. Musgrave has taken trips sponsored by the Heritage Foundation and Club for Growth.^[13] Following her defeat in 2008, Musgrave began working for the Susan B. Anthony List, a pro-life organization.^[2]

Same-sex marriage

Musgrave sponsored of the unsuccessful Federal Marriage Amendment in the 108th and 109th Congresses, originally drafted by the Alliance for Marriage. This proposed constitutional amendment would define marriage as "the union of a man and a woman" and bar any recognition of same-sex marriage or "legal incidents thereof" in the United States.

In a September 2006 speech to the Family Research Council's "Values Voters Summit", Musgrave said, "as we face the issues that we are facing today, I don’t think there's anything more important out there than the marriage issue."^[14] Musgrave later distanced herself from these claims during the 2006 election.^[15]

Abortion

Musgrave (left) receives a pro-life Susan B. Anthony Award from Jane Abraham.

Musgrave identifies as pro-life and staunchly opposes elective abortion.^[16] At the national level, she has supported the Partial Birth Abortion Ban and the Child Custody Protection Act. Musgrave is an original cosponsor of the Child Interstate Abortion Notification Act. She received the support of the Susan B. Anthony List as a candidate and now works for the organization.^[2]

Musgrave also opposes public funding for embryonic stem cell research on abortion-related grounds,^[17] and was a vocal proponent of the 2005 congressional intervention into the Terri Schiavo case:^[18]

When we talk about a permanent vegetative state, I am offended by that. Terri smiles and acknowledges the people that love her when they come to see her. She cries when they leave. How heartless are we to call somebody like Terri Schiavo a vegetable? What are we thinking?

When we think about this case, we need to think about the message that we are sending to our children and our grandchildren. What we do in this Chamber tonight is as important as anything we have done in defending our Nation, in doing the things that we do as Members of Congress.

Musgrave has also weighed in on the Emergency Contraception controversy. On July 25, 2005, Musgrave criticized a witness at a congressional subcommittee hearing who had claimed she was "humiliated and discriminated against" at a pharmacist's refusal to fill a prescription for emergency contraception, claiming that it was only an issue of "inconvenience" to be denied emergency contraception.^[19] In 2003, a Musgrave submitted an amendment to the Runaway, Homeless, and Missing Children Protection Act, which would have prevented distribution of contraception to runaway teen. The amendment was not part of the final legislation^[20]

Second Amendment rights

Musgrave strongly opposes gun control and successfully passed an amendment prohibiting the enforcement of a federal requirement to sell trigger locks with all handguns.^[14] She is the founder of the 2nd Amendment Caucus and is working to protect gun manufacturers and dealers from certain types of lawsuits.

Musgrave is a close ally of the Gun Owners of America (GOA) a firearms lobbying group considered to be more strictly opposed to gun control than the National Rifle Association. Another close ally of Musgrave's from her state legislative days is Dudley Brown, who directs the Colorado wing of the GOA, the Rocky Mountain Gun Owners.^[21] On September 25, 2004, Musgrave was a special guest speaker at the 19th annual Gun Rights Policy Conference awards luncheon, where she was named "Gun Rights Legislator of the Year."^[22]

Home schooling

Musgrave advocates changing the laws to lend more support to families who home-school their children. According to her website, she believes that government intrudes too much on family affairs.^[23] Musgrave home schooled one of her children, as well.

Musgrave is closely linked to the Home School Legal Defense Association (HSLDA).[1] Also, members of Generation Joshua, an HSLDA branch that tries to involve youth in politics, were sent to Musgrave's district in the final hours of the 2006 campaign.

Workforce and economy

Musgrave is one of the staunchest proponents of national Right to Work legislation,^[24] and was a cosponsor of The National Right to Work Act.^[25] Musgrave was heavily targeted by labor unions in the 2006 election. National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation president Mark Mix held a fundraiser for Musgrave at New York's Harvard Club in 2006. After Hurricane Katrina in 2005, Musgrave helped lead the effort to urge President Bush to suspend "Davis-Bacon" prevailing wage protection in the Gulf Coast region. (Bush was quickly forced to rescind this suspension.)

Taxes

Musgrave is a strong supporter of income tax cuts, and supports making the 2001 federal tax cuts permanent.^[26] She also supports the elimination of the Estate tax^[27] and has voted to reduce tariffs on imported goods.^[28]

Religion and public law

In June 2006, Musgrave sponsored a resolution in Congress to declare 2007 as "National Year of the Bible".^[29] The resolution text requested that President Bush issue a proclamation calling on all citizens to "rediscover and apply the priceless and timeless message of the Bible" and encourage them to join the U.S. Federal government in celebrating the year with Bible "programs, ceremonies, and activities." The resolution died in committee.

In June 2005, Musgrave cited Coral Ridge Ministries founder D. James Kennedy, one of the leaders of the Dominionist movement, as one of her inspirations to enter politics:^[12]

"When I first started listening to D. James Kennedy on Truths That Transform," she said, "I was so encouraged that there was a minister of the Gospel that said what was right and what was wrong, and what our responsibility was as Christians in this great nation."

"Those kind of things just grew in me through the years, and then, here I am [today] voting on moral issues. I just want to say to the Christian Statesman staff, Dr. Kennedy is a hero for me."

In the 2002 Republican primary debate with opponent Jeff Beddingfield in Greeley, Colorado, Musgrave stated that the First Amendment does not offer "freedom from religion." In a 2003 interview with Today's Pentecostal Evangel, Musgrave explained how her religious beliefs play a key function in her public position:^[30]

The problems in our culture are just symptoms of spiritual problems in our nation. We must return to God and biblical principles for answers. There are limitations to what we can do, but I’m so thankful I have a voice and a vote.

In March 2007, Musgrave joined the Congressional Prayer Caucus, which is chaired by J. Randy Forbes. Forbes states the organization's purpose is to "build a spiritual wall around America."^[31]

In May 2007, Musgrave participated in a "Bible Reading Marathon" event on the West Front of the US Capitol.^[32]

Other issues

Musgrave is a staunch advocate of a federal prohibition of online poker. In 2006, she cosponsored H.R. 4777, the Internet Gambling Prohibition Act.^[33] In June 2008, Musgrave voted with the House Democrats and a minority of Republicans to save energy though the use of public transportation.^[34]

Interest group ratings

The National Rifle Association Political Victory Fund, the political action committee of the National Rifle Association, gives Musgrave an 'A' for her support of pro-gun issues facing Congress.^[35] The NRA-PVF states than an 'A' for Musgrave indicates that she is solidly 'pro-gun' and that she has "supported NRA positions on key votes."^[36]

The Center for Christian Statesmanship, founded by D. James Kennedy of Coral Ridge Ministries, awarded Musgrave the "Distinguished Christian Statesman Award" in 2005.^[12]

The Christian Coalition has ranked Musgrave's voting record at '100%' in support of the pro-Christian Coalition legislation listed on their scorecard.^[37] The Christian Coalition was founded in 1989 by Pat Robertson and is dedicated to helping give conservative Christians a voice in their government.^[38]

Agriculture Committee

From 2003 through 2005, $14.7 billion in crop subsidies went to the congressional districts of members on the House Committee on Agriculture, an analysis by the non-partisan Environmental Working Group found. That was 42.4% of the total subsidies. Musgrave is reported to have brought $330 million to her district.^[39]

Controversies

2002 fund-raising controversies

In the 2002 election, Musgrave was criticized for her campaign's ties to Larry Pratt, the executive director of Gun Owners of America (GOA). GOA contributed $5,000 to her campaign, and Pratt wrote two separate fund-raising letters for Musgrave. Publicity surrounding Pratt's history of close ties to extremist groups and publications, and appearances at white supremacist and pro-militia events forced him to resign from Pat Buchanan's 1996 presidential campaign. Guy Short, Musgrave's then-campaign manager, denied Musgrave's knowledge of any of Pratt's reported connections to extremist causes, and discounted their significance.^[40]

A complaint was brought against lobbyist Dudley Brown, a long-time Musgrave ally and executive director of the Rocky Mountain Gun Owners, the state-level organization of GOA. The Associated Press reported that Brown wrote a January 21, 2002 letter soliciting donations to Musgrave's congressional campaign. The complaint filed claimed, "As a registered lobbyist, Mr. Brown is clearly prohibited from fundraising while the General Assembly is in session." Brown called the complaint "frivolous."^[41]

Political appearance with U.S. Marines

Musgrave (right) introduces uniformed Marines at political event

On March 3, 2006, Musgrave served as the Master of Ceremonies at the Larimer County Republican Party Lincoln Day Dinner. During the event, two uniformed US Marines attending the dinner were "honored" by being introduced on stage by Musgrave. A photograph of one of the Marines standing next to Musgrave was published in the Fort Collins Coloradoan, and that photograph "touched off a firestorm from national political writers and Web bloggers who say the party is using the military as public relations props."^[42]

According to Department of Defense directives, members on active duty shall not "participate in partisan political management, campaigns, or conventions (except as a spectator when not in uniform), or make public speeches in the course thereof."^[43]

There was disagreement as to whether the Marines attending as honorees violated military regulations. A Pentagon memo read "Members of the armed forces may not attend partisan political events in uniform, even if only as 'honorees.' A sharply limited exception is made to provide armed forces color guards for national-level political conventions." However, a Marine Corps spokesperson said, "The Marines were in attendance because they were asked to attend to be honored for their service and not as attendees at a political event, there is nothing wrong with Marines being asked to appear in public and being honored for their service."^[44]

In late March, the Pentagon re-issued regulations forbidding uniformed personnel from attending partisan political events.^{[citation needed]}

References

1. ^ "Musgrave unseated by Markey", Denver Post, retrieved 11/19/2008.
2. ^ ^{a b c} Former Rep. Musgrave Takes Job With Susan B. Anthony List
3. ^ "Religion of US Congress". Adherents.com. http://www.adherents.com/adh_congress.html#109. Retrieved 2007-07-17. 
4. ^ "A firm voice against gay marriage - The Boston Globe". http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2004/04/11/a_firm_voice_against_gay_marriage?mode=PF. ^{[dead link]}
5. ^ Election 2002 Web Archive Record - Jeff Bedingfield - Republican - US Congress
6. ^ http://www.sos.state.co.us/pubs/electionresults2006G/
7. ^ http://www.sos.state.co.us/pubs/electionresults2006G/CO-RC-913.htm
8. ^ "State Election Results - Election Center 2008 - Elections & Politics from CNN.com". CNN. http://www.cnn.com/ELECTION/2008/results/state/#CO. Retrieved May 12, 2010. 
9. ^ ^{a b} Fender, Jessica (December 3, 2008). "Ga. robo-call breaks Musgrave's silence". denverpost.com (Denver Post). http://www.denverpost.com/popular/ci_11123749. Retrieved May 11, 2009. 
10. ^ 2006 U. S. Congress Ratings
11. ^ NATIONAL JOURNAL: 2007 Vote Ratings
12. ^ ^{a b c} Impact Newsletter - Forgiveness Not Optional for Colorado Congresswoman
13. ^ OpenSecrets: Travel Database
14. ^ ^{a b} Giroux, Greg (September 28, 2006). "Musgrave's Priorities at Issue in Increasingly Close Colo. 4 Race". The New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/cq/2006/09/28/cq_1520.html. Retrieved May 12, 2010. 
15. ^ NPR: Gay Marriage Issue Looms over Colorado Race
16. ^ Congresswoman Marilyn Musgrave
17. ^ Retrieve Pages
18. ^ Retrieve Pages
19. ^ NPR: Pharmacists' Duties Subject of Hearings on Hill
20. ^ http://www.arhp.org/files/june2003.pdf
21. ^ Denver - News - Let Freedom - and Gunshots - Ring
22. ^ Gun Rights Policy Conference 2004
23. ^ Congresswoman Marilyn Musgrave
24. ^ National Right to Work Newsletter May 2004. Retrieved May 11, 2007
25. ^ National Right to Work Committee — House Committee Holds Hearing on National Right to Work Act September 8, 2005. Retrieved May 11, 2007
26. ^ Marilyn Musgrave — Taxes Retrieved May 11, 2007
27. ^ Marilyn Musgrave — Death Tax is a Burden on American Values Retrieved May 11, 2007
28. ^ Musgrave sides with district's ag interests in trade pact vote Retrieved May 11, 2007
29. ^ Search Results - THOMAS (Library of Congress)
30. ^ Conversations
31. ^ The Coloradoan - www.coloradoan.com - Ft. Collins, CO
32. ^ Milbank, Dana. "Dozens of Heads Were Bowed". The Washington Post. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/05/03/AR2007050302170_pf.html. Retrieved May 12, 2010. 
33. ^ Thomas (Library of Congress): HR 4777
34. ^ Votes Database. Washington Post.
35. ^ National Rifle Association | Political Victory Fund
36. ^ What The Grades Mean
37. ^ http://www.cc.org/2004scorecard.pdf
38. ^ Christian Coalition of America
39. ^ Dilanian, Ken, " Billions go to House panel members' districts", USA Today. July 26, 2007.
40. ^ Rocky Mountain News, Gun-rights activist alleges dirty politics; October 15, 2002.
41. ^ Gun lobbyist draws fire over fund-raising letter Rocky Mountain News March 30, 2002.
42. ^ The Coloradoan - www.coloradoan.com - Ft. Collins, CO
43. ^ http://www.dtic.mil/whs/directives/corres/rtf/d134410x.rtf
44. ^ The Coloradoan - www.coloradoan.com - Ft. Collins, CO

External links

• Biography at the Biographical Directory of the United States Congress
• Voting record maintained by The Washington Post
• Biography, voting record, and interest group ratings at Project Vote Smart
• Issue positions and quotes at On The Issues
• Financial information at OpenSecrets.org
• Campaign finance reports and data at the Federal Election Commission
• Profile at SourceWatch Congresspedia
• Follow the Money — Marilyn Musgrave
  • 2002 House 2000 House 1998 House 1998 Senate 1996 House state legislature campaign contributions

United States House of Representatives
Preceded by Bob Schaffer	Member of the U.S. House of Representatives from Colorado's 4th congressional district 2003–2009	Succeeded by Betsy Markey

Persondata
Name	Musgrave, Marilyn
Alternative names
Short description
Date of birth	January 27, 1949
Place of birth	Greeley, Colorado
Date of death
Place of death