BAE Systems Nimrod MRA4

Nimrod MRA4
Nimrod MRA4 during a test flight
Role	Maritime patrol aircraft
Manufacturer	BAE Systems
First flight	26 August 2004 [1]
Status	Development cancelled
Number built	3 development plus 2 production[2]
Developed from	Hawker Siddeley Nimrod MR2

The BAE Systems Nimrod MRA4 was a maritime patrol and attack aircraft intended to replace the Hawker Siddeley Nimrod MR2. The rebuilt aircraft would have extended the operating life of the Nimrod fleet by several decades and have significantly improved the aircraft by almost doubling the flight range by installing more efficient Rolls-Royce BR700 turbofan jet engines. The conversion of the flight deck to a digital 'glass cockpit' would have simplified control operations and reduced crew requirements. New detection systems were to be installed, as well as additional weapons for anti-submarine warfare.

However the project was subject to significant delays due to cost over-runs and contract re-negotiations. This was partly due to difficulties combining refurbished Nimrod MR2 fuselages, which had not been built to a common standard, with newly built wings. The numbers of aircraft to be procured fell from 21 to nine over a course of years, while costs continued to climb.

The MRA4 was ultimately cancelled in 2010 as a result of the Strategic Defence and Security Review, at which point it was £789 million over-budget and over nine years late. There is no direct replacement under development, its intended roles are to filled by existing assets such as the Type 23 Frigate and the Merlin helicopter.

Development

Background and origins

In 1992, the Royal Air Force started a Replacement Maritime Patrol Aircraft (RMPA) procurement programme to replace the Nimrod MR2 aircraft. To meet the requirement British Aerospace proposed rebuilding each Nimrod MR2 with new engines and electronics which it called Nimrod 2000. The RAF considered bids from Lockheed with its P-3 Orion, Loral Corporation with rebuilt ex-US Navy Orions, and Dassault with the Atlantique 3. In December 1996 the contract was awarded to British Aerospace for the Nimrod 2000, under the designation Nimrod MRA4.^[3] British Aerospace became BAE Systems in 1999 and continued development on the Nimrod MRA4.

The MRA4 was to be essentially a new aircraft. Significant changes included the installation of current-generation Rolls-Royce BR710 turbofan engines, a larger and more efficient wing, and a fully refurbished fuselage. Much larger air intakes were required on the MRA4 because the airflow requirements of the BR710 engine are significantly higher than that of the original Spey 250 powering the original Nimrods. The MRA4 also borrowed heavily from Airbus technology;^{[N 1]} the glass cockpit was derived from the Airbus A340.^[4][5]

According to BAE Systems, the Nimrod MRA4 systems was to enable the crews to gather, process and display up to 20 times more technical and strategic data than the MR2. The Searchwater 2000 radar was stated to have been capable over land as well as water; with the ability to have swept an area the size of the UK every 10 seconds.^[6] The Aircraft Synthetic Training Aids (ASTA) provided by Thales Training & Simulation was an electronic training suite to allow the training of crew members to transfer from active MRA4 aircraft to ground-based training systems; this change was made to increase the availability of the aircraft for operational missions and allow for more intensive training exercises.^[7]

Delays and development issues

The original scheduled date of entry into service for the MRA4 was April 2003, however development proved far more protracted than anticipated.^[8] An independent company, Flight Refuelling Ltd., was contracted to undertake the conversions to MRA4 standard, however BAE discovered that the Nimrod airframes supplied by the RAF were not built to a common standard and this considerably complicated the refurbishment process. The task of converting the existing airframes was transferred in-house to BAE Systems Woodford.^[9] The BAE team at Woodford then found that the new wing was flawed, which resulted in the project being put on hold while another wing design was developed.^[9]

BAE Systems issued a shock profit warning in December 2002 due to cost overruns of the Nimrod MRA4 and the Astute class submarine projects.^[10] On 19 February 2003 BAE took a charge of £500 million against the MRA4 contract.^[11] The company had previously taken a £300 million "loss charge" in 2000, which was expected to cover "all the costs of completion of the current contract".^[12] The contract was renegotiated for the second time in 2002, where the aircraft requirement was reduced from 21 to 18.^[13]

Nimrod MRA4 at the Farnborough Airshow

Announcing plans for the future of the British military on 21 July 2004, the Defence Secretary Geoff Hoon detailed plans to reduce the upgrade programme to cover only 16 MRA4 aircraft, and suggested that an eventual fleet of 12 might suffice.^[14] PA02, the second development MRA4, achieved its first flight in December 2004 and was used to test elements of the mission system and the air vehicle.^[15] BAE Systems received a contract worth £1.1 billion for 12 MRA4s on 18 July 2006; three were to be development aircraft and nine more converted to production standard.^[16] The Nimrod MRA4 successfully released the Sting Ray torpedo for the first time on 30 July 2007.^[17][18]

Further disputes over "affordability" meant that the number of MRA4s to be delivered was further reduced to nine by Spring 2008.^[13] The first production aircraft took its maiden flight on 10 September 2009.^[19] At the time of the flight, each MRA4 was to cost at least £400 million.^{[20][N 2]} The Ministry of Defence announced in December 2009 that the introduction of the MRA4 would be delayed until 2012 as part of defence spending cuts.^[21] The first Nimrod MRA4 was delivered in March 2010 to the RAF for acceptance testing, initial operational capability was expected to be reach in October 2012. The MRA4 was to operate out from its main base at RAF Kinloss, Scotland;^[22] all nine aircraft were due to be delivered by 2012.^[23]

Cancellation

"[The] loss of the capability offered by the Nimrod Maritime Reconnaissance and Attack Mk4 would have an adverse effect on the protection of the strategic nuclear deterrent [Trident missiles on Vanguard class submarines], the provision of which is one of the Ministry of Defence's Standing Strategic Tasks. In addition, the maintenance of the integrity of the UK through detection of hostile air and sea craft would be compromised."

National Audit Office^[24]

In the 2010 Strategic Defence and Security Review of the Armed Forces, the UK government announced the cancellation of the MRA4 on 19 October 2010 and consequently that RAF Kinloss, the intended base for the Nimrod fleet, would be closed.^[25] Although late and over-budget the decision to cancel the MRA4 was controversial as the remaining airframes had all been near completion.^[26] It has been reported that following the retirement of the Nimrod MR2, Russian submarines have been able to travel past the UK in international waters, but they could not be tracked because of the unavailability of suitable aircraft.^[26]

The aircraft would also have been used in the civilian search and rescue role, the Nimrod MR2 had often been used in this role. In this respect the Strategic Defence and Security Review stated that the UK "will depend on other maritime assets to contribute to the tasks previously planned for [the Nimrod MRA4]".^[27]

Following the cancellation, the Defence Secretary Liam Fox used the Nimrod MRA4 procurement as an example of the worst of MOD procurement performance: "The idea that we ever allow ourselves into a position where something that was originally Nimrod 2000 - where we ordered [21] was reduced to nine, spent £3.8bn and we still weren't close to getting the capability - is not to happen again."^[28]

In January 2011 it was reported by the Financial Times that when the decision was taken to scrap the aircraft, "[The MRA4] was still riddled with flaws.... Safety tests conducted [in 2010] found there were still 'several hundred design non-compliances' with the aircraft. It was unclear, for example, whether its bomb bay doors functioned properly, whether its landing gear worked and, most worryingly, whether its fuel pipe was safe."^[29] According to Air Forces Monthly magazine, "significant aerodynamic issues and associated flying control concerns in certain regimes of flight meant that it was grounded at the time of cancellation and may not have been signed over as safe by the.. Military Aviation Authority." The magazine also stated that the reason for the cancellation was that the RAF and Navy placed a higher priority on fast jets and frigates than on maritime patrol.^[30]

On 24 November 2010, 382 sub-contract workers previously working on the MRA4 were laid off at BAE Systems Warton and Woodford.^[31] After the airframes were stripped of electronic equipment, the remaining fuselages were scrapped at BAE Systems Woodford beginning on 26 January 2011. Although the process was conducted behind screens intended to hide the process from the media, the BBC flew a helicopter over Woodford and broadcast footage of the scrapping in process.^[32] Six ex-defence chiefs publicly criticised the decision to scrap the Nimrods the following day.^[33]

Replacement

Press reports in February 2011 claimed the Royal Navy's Fleet Air Arm has established a committee to consider the acquisition of maritime patrol aircraft to replace the scrapped Nimrod MRA4 in the anti-submarine role. The budget is expected to be up to £1 billion, contrasting with the MRA4 program's cost of £3.6 billion.^[34]

Specifications (MRA4)

Data from Flight Insight,^[35] armedforces.co.uk^[36]

General characteristics

• Crew: 10
• Length: 38.6 m (126 ft 9 in)
• Wingspan: 38.71 m (127 ft)
• Height: 9.45 m (31 ft)
• Wing area: 235.8 m2 (2,538 sq ft)
• Empty weight: 51,710 kg (114,000 lb)
• Max takeoff weight: 105,376 kg (232,315 lb)
• Powerplant: 4 × Rolls-Royce BR710 turbofans, 68.97 kN (15,500 lbf) each

Performance

• Maximum speed: Mach 0.77, 496 kn (571 mph, 918 km/h)
• Range: 11,119 km (6,910 mi)
• Service ceiling: 10,972 m (36,000 ft)

Armament

• Guns: None
• Hardpoints: 4× under-wing pylon stations and an internal bomb bay with a capacity of 22,000 lb (10,000 kg) and provisions to carry combinations of:
  • Rockets: None
  • Missiles:
    
    • Air-to-air missile: 2× AIM-9 Sidewinder
    • Air-to-surface missile: AGM-65 Maverick, AGM-84 Harpoon, Storm Shadow
  • Bombs:
    
    • Depth charges
  • Other:
    
    • Air-dropped Mk.46 torpedoes, Sting Ray torpedoes
    • Naval mines
    • Sonobuoys

References

Notes

1. ^ British Aerospace held partial ownership of Airbus at one point.
2. ^ This was equated to the cost of three Nimrod MRA4s to one NASA Space Shuttle.^[20]

Citations

1. ^ "Nimrod MRA4 First Flight". Defence Procurement Agency. 20 September 2005. http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/+/http://www.mod.uk/dpa/projects/first_flight.htm. 
2. ^ "BAE jobs fears in Woodford after Nimrod axed". BBC News. 19 October 2010. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-lancashire-11578124. 
3. ^ "Major Projects Report 2005: Project Summary Sheets; Ministry of Defence". National Audit Office, 2005, p. 67.
4. ^ "BR710". Rolls-Royce Germany. http://www.rolls-royce.com/deutschland/en/products/BR710military.htm. Retrieved 3 January 2010. 
5. ^ Davis, N.J. (1998). "Nimrod MRA4: Collaborative Crew Performance Challenges". rta.nato.int. http://ftp.rta.nato.int/public//PubFullText/RTO/MP/RTO-MP-004///$MP-004-$K1.pdf. 
6. ^ "Nimrod MRA4". BAE Systems. http://www.baesystems.com/ProductsServices/nimrod_mra4.html. Retrieved 16 February 2011. 
7. ^ "Milestone achieved in Nimrod MRA4 Synthetic Training Requirement." asd-network.com. Retrieved: 20 October 2010.
8. ^ "Nimrod MRA4 Replacement Maritime Patrol Aircraft (RMPA)." GlobalSecurity.org. Retrieved: 20 October 2010.
9. ^ ^{a b} "Nimrod MRA4 makes debut at last". The Engineer. 26 October 2009. http://www.theengineer.co.uk/in-depth/analysis/nimrod-mra4-makes-debut-at-last/313735.article. 
10. ^ Odell, Mark (12 December). "BAE warning sends share price to 7-year low: News of 'additional issues' on two big defence contracts takes market by surprise". Financial Times. 
11. ^ Odell, Mark (20 February 2003). "Whitehall re-draws key BAE defence contracts". Financial Times. 
12. ^ Done, Kevin (13 December 2002). "Nimrod refit turns into nightmare". Financial Times: p. 24. 
13. ^ ^{a b} "MOD - The Major Projects Report 2010". National Audit Office. 15 October 2010. http://www.nao.org.uk/idoc.ashx?docId=7FF4E48C-44DC-4C61-9614-7F081820D70E&version=-1. 
14. ^ Ripley, Time."RAF 'super-base' plan leaves future of Kinloss in doubt". scotsman.com, 6 September 2004.
15. ^ Gill, Andrew; Alex Bellamy (2005). "Flight Testing the Nimrod MRA4". rta.nato.int. ftp://ftp.rta.nato.int/PubFullText/RTO/MP/RTO-MP-SCI-162/MP-SCI-162-09.pdf. 
16. ^ "Delayed Nimrod deal secures base" BBC News, 18 July 2006.
17. ^ Boulton, Marc and Mike Sweeney. "News release: Nimrod MRA4 Releases Sting Ray for First Time." BAE Systems, 30 July 2007. Retrieved: 20 October 2010.
18. ^ Thisdell, Dan. "Nimrod MRa4 reconnaissance aircraft passes torpedo drop test." flightglobal,com. Retrieved: 20 October 2010.
19. ^ Boulton, Marc and Lindsay Walls. "First production Nimrod MRA4 takes to the skies." defpro.com, 14 September 2009. Retrieved: 14 September 2009.
20. ^ ^{a b} Page, Lewis. "Nimrod MRA4 Product variant first flight." The Register, 14 September 2009.
21. ^ "Defence Budget reprioritised to support Afghanistan operation." Ministry of Defence, via www.mod.uk, 15 December 2009. Retrieved: 17 December 2009.
22. ^ "House of Commons Written Answers for 16 June 2010." Hansard, 16 June 2010. Retrieved: 20 October 2010.
23. ^ "RAF Accepts First Nimrod MRA4 Surveillance Aircraft." Airforce-Technology.Com, 17 March 2010. Retrieved: 20 October 2010.
24. ^ "The Major Projects Report 2010". National Audit Office. 15 October 2010. http://www.nao.org.uk/idoc.ashx?docId=7FF4E48C-44DC-4C61-9614-7F081820D70E&version=-1. 
25. ^ "RAF Kinloss to close as ministers cancel Nimrod order." BBC News, 19 October 2010. Retrieved: 20 October 2010.
26. ^ ^{a b} Maddox, David (20 November 2010). "RAF Kinloss: Scrapped replacement for Nimrod 'largely completed'". news.scotsman.com. http://news.scotsman.com/scotland/RAF-Kinloss-Scrapped-replacement-.6633252.jp. 
27. ^ "Securing Britain in an Age of Uncertainty: The Strategic Defence and Security Review". HM Government. 19 October 2010. http://www.direct.gov.uk/prod_consum_dg/groups/dg_digitalassets/@dg/@en/documents/digitalasset/dg_191634.pdf. Retrieved 19 October 2010. 
28. ^ "Major projects discussed for '57 hours'". defencemanagement.com. 11 November 2010. http://www.defencemanagement.com/news_story.asp?id=14715. 
29. ^ "A failure of UK budget surveillance". Financial Times. 30 January 2011. 
30. ^ Cox, Tim (March 2011). "Whither MPA?". Air Forces Monthly. 
31. ^ "BAE Systems ends contracts of 382 Nimrod workers". BBC News. 24 November 2010. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-11831893. Retrieved 3 March 2011. 
32. ^ Harding, Thomas (20 January 2011). "Chopped up for scrap, Britain's £4 billion fleet of Nimrods". The Telegraph (London). http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/politics/defence/8269676/Chopped-up-for-scrap-Britains-4-billion-fleet-of-Nimrods.html. Retrieved 21 January 2011. 
33. ^ "Scrapping RAF Nimrods 'perverse' say military chiefs". BBC News. 27 January 2011. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-12294766. 
34. ^ "Navy to buy new aircraft". portsmouth.co.uk, 22 February 2011.
35. ^ "ISR Special Report." Flight Insight, 2009. p. 19.
36. ^ "RAF Aircraft: Nimrod MR2/R1" armedforces.co.uk, Retrieved: 19 February 2011.