Domestic of the Schools

The Domestic of the Schools (Greek: δομέστικος τῶν σχολῶν, domestikos tōn scholōn) was a senior Byzantine military office, extant from the 8th century until at least the early 14th century. Originally simply the commander of the Scholai, the senior of the elite tagmata regiments, the Domestic quickly rose in prominence: by the mid-9th century, its holders essentially occupied the position of commander-in-chief of the Byzantine army, next to the Emperor. The office was eclipsed in the 12th century by that of the Grand Domestic, and in the Palaiologan period, it was reduced to a purely honorary, mid-level court dignity.

History

The Domestic of the Schools first appears in the sources (the chronicle of Theophanes the Confessor) for the year 767,^[1] shortly after the creation of the tagmata. These were elite cavalry regiments stationed in or around the capital Constantinople, commanded by officers titled "Domestics" (δομέστικοι, domestikoi) and distinct from the provincial armies of the themes under their respective stratēgoi.^[2] The Schools (Latin: scholae; Greek: σχολαὶ, scholai) were the senior tagma, tracing their origin to the Scholae Palatinae established by Constantine the Great (r. 306–337) and placed under the command of the magister officiorum.^[3] J.B. Bury has traced a reference to a certain Anianos, "Domestic of the magister", in the Chronicon Paschale for the year 624, and considers this official to be the predecessor of the Domestic of the Schools. As the magister was gradually deprived of some of his functions in the 7th and 8th centuries, the Domestic apparently became an independent official.^[1][4][5]

The troops of the Domestic of the Schools Nikephoros Phokas storm Aleppo in 962

In the 9th century, the "Domesticate" (δομεστικάτον, domestikaton) of the Schools rose in importance and its holder was often appointed as the head of the army in the absence of the emperor, although this role was not yet enshrined: it depended on the abilities of the Domestic, and other generals of inferior rank were sometimes entrusted with supreme command instead. The Domestic of the Schools nevertheless rose to such prominence that the sources frequently speak of the office as "the Domestic" without further qualification, and the power and influence of the post saw it frequently occupied by persons closely related to the emperor. From the time of Michael III (r. 842–867) on, the Domestic ranked in the imperial hierarchy above all other military commanders except for the stratēgos of the Anatolic Theme. In practice, he quickly became senior even to the latter, as demonstrated by the promotion of men like Nikephoros Phokas and John Tzimiskes from the generalship of the Anatolics to the Domesticate.^[6][7] In the reign of Romanos II (r. 959–963) the post was split, with a "Domestic of the West" (δομέστικος τῆς δύσεως, domestikos tēs dyseōs) and a "Domestic of the East" (δομέστικος τῆς ἀνατολῆς, domestikos tēs anatolēs) being created for operations in the Balkans and Asia respectively.^[4][8][9] The ceremony for the Domestic's appointment is described in the De Ceremoniis (II.3);^[8][10] the same work describes his duties and role in court ceremonies.^[11]

During the 10th century, the office was dominated by members of the Phokas family, which produced six holders of the office.^[12] At the same time, emperors often preferred to entrust the potentially over-powerful office to non-military court officials, especially—although in theory forbidden—to eunuchs, a practice that became widespread during the 11th century, before the military aristocracy reasserted its authority.^[13][14] With some exceptions, most notably the unparalleled 22-year tenure of John Kourkouas, Domestics were changed on the average every three to four years, although much more rapidly in times of instability .^[15]

Lead seal of Philaretos Brachamios, prōtokouropalatēs and Domestic of the Schools

In the 10th and 11th centuries, the variant "Grand Domestic" (μέγας δομέστικος, megas domestikos) appears sporadically, used in parallel with other variants such as "Grand Domestic of the Schools" or "Grand Domestic of the East/West" for the same person.^[16] The French scholar Rodolphe Guilland considers most of these early references either as anachronistic references by 12th-century writers, or simply cases where "megas" is used as a honorific prefix, as was the norm with other senior offices, like the Drungary of the Watch or the Domestic of the Excubitors. Nevertheless, Guilland argues that from the time of Alexios I Komnenos (r. 1081–1118) on, the "Grand Domestic" became a separate office, senior to the Domestics of the Schools and in effect the new commander-in-chief of the army beside the Emperor. The habitual division of command between East and West seems to have been sometimes applied with the Grand Domestic as well in the 12th century, and the usage of the titles is not consistent, causing some confusion. In the 13th century however the two titles became clearly distinct: the Grand Domestic was the commander-in-chief of the entire army and one of the highest offices of state, while the Domestic of the Schools was relegated to a simple dignity without content, awarded to provincial governors and other mid-ranking officials.^[17][18] In the words of the mid-14th century Book of Offices of Pseudo-Kodinos, "the Domestic of the Schools once had an office similar to that of the Grand Domestic currently, but he now holds none".^[19] In Pseudo-Kodinos' work, the Domestic of the Schools ranks 31st in the imperial hierarchy, between the mystikos and the Grand Drungary of the Fleet.^[20] During the Palaiologan period, the Domestic's distinctive court dress, as reported by Pseudo-Kodinos, consisted of a gold-brocaded hat (skiadion), a plain silk kabbadion tunic and a silver staff (dikanikion) with a knob on top and another in the middle. For ceremonies and festivities, he bore the domed skaranikon, of yellow silk and decorated with gold wire embroidery, and with a portrait of the emperor seated on a throne in front and another with the emperor on horseback on the rear.^[11][21]

List of known holders

Note: the list does not include holders known only through their seals but otherwise unidentified.

Name	Tenure	Appointed by	Notes	Refs
Antony	ca. 767 – ca. 780	Constantine V	A patrikios and staunch iconoclast and close aide of Constantine V, he remained in office until the early regency of Irene of Athens	[22]
Bardanios	ca. 795/796	Irene of Athens	A patrikios, probably the same as Bardanes Tourkos.	[23]
Niketas Triphyllios	ca. 797/798 – ca. 802	Irene of Athens	A patrikios, he supported the eunuch Aetios and later the usurpation of Nikephoros I, but was poisoned on the latter's orders.	[23]
Stephen	ca. 811	Nikephoros I	He survived the disastrous Battle of Pliska and managed to enforce the succession of Nikephoros' son Staurakios.	[23]
Peter	unknown	Nikephoros I	Son of a patrikios and a patrikios himself, nothing is known of him except that he was named to the post by Nikephoros I and that he was taken captive at the Battle of Pliska, becoming a monk afterwards.	[23]
Manuel the Armenian	830 – ?	Theophilos	An experienced general, he was given the post along with the title of magistros after returning from a defection to the Arabs. He participated in several campaigns against the Arabs. He may have died in 838 following the Battle of Anzen, but other sources claim that he lived long after that.	[24][25]
Bardas	858–866	Michael III	Uncle of Michael III, he was appointed magistros and Domestic of the Schools after the banishment of the Empress-dowager Theodora. Promoted to kouropalatēs and eventually Caesar, as the virtual regent of the Empire he rarely exercised his military function, which he delegated to his son Antigonos and his brother Petronas.	[26]
Petronas	863–865	Michael III	Uncle of Michael III and an active general. He exercised the high command in place of his brother Bardas and was raised to the Domesticate and the rank of magistros following his victory over the Arabs at the Battle of Lalakaon.	[26]
Antigonos	865–866	Michael III	Son of the Caesar Bardas, he had been conferred the Domesticate as an honorary appointment already at the age of nine or ten years. He succeeded his uncle Petronas as regular Domestic after the latter's death, but was unable to prevent the murder of his father by Basil the Macedonian and was removed from his post after that.	[27]
Marianos	unknown	Basil I the Macedonian	Brother of Basil I, nothing is known of him except that he was buried at the convent of St. Euphemia	[27]
Christopher	870s	Basil I the Macedonian	Son-in-law of Basil I and a magistros, little is known of him except that he led the Byzantine forces to victory over the Paulicians at the Battle of Bathys Ryax.	[27]
Andrew the Scythian	ca. 880 – 883, 883 – ca. 887	Basil I the Macedonian	Of unknown origin, he was named Domestic and patrikios following his exploits against the Arabs. Dismissed following court intrigues, he was reinstated after his successor was routed by the Arabs and retained the post into the early reign of Leo VI the Wise, probably up to his death ca. 887.	[28][29]
Kestas Styppiotes	883	Basil I the Macedonian	Probably hailing from Štip, he was defeated and possibly killed near Tarsus soon after his appointment.	[30]
Nikephoros Phokas the Elder	ca. 887 – 895/896	Leo VI the Wise	Celebrated for his exploits in southern Italy, he was named to the Domesticate after the death of Andrew the Scythian and served, mostly in the East, probably until 895	[30][31]
Leo Katakalon	896 – 900s	Leo VI the Wise	A commander of the palace guard and relative of Patriarch Photios, he fell into disfavour in the early reign of Leo VI, he was soon recalled and restored to imperial favour. He led the Byzantine army in the disastrous Battle of Boulgarophygon, but survived and continued in office until the early 900s	[32][33]
Andronikos Doukas	ca. 904–906	Leo VI the Wise	He was appointed to the Domesticate before or after scoring a victory over the Arabs at Germanikeia in 904, and was dismissed following the court intrigues of Samonas the eunuch. He fled to the Arabs, where he died in captivity ca. 910.	[34][35][36]
Gregoras Iberitzes	ca. 906 – ?	Leo VI the Wise	Iberitzes appears in 906, when he was sent against the fortress held by Andronikos Doukas and his family; a relative of the Doukai, he took part in the attempted usurpation of Constantine Doukas in 913 and was tonsured and exiled.	[35]
Constantine Doukas	? – 913	Leo VI the Wise	The son of Andronikos Doukas, he escaped from Arab captivity and was restored to high military office by Leo. In 913, as Domestic of the Schools, he attempted to usurp the throne from Leo's infant son Constantine VII, but failed and was killed.	[32][34]
Leo Phokas	unknown first tenure, ca. 913 – 919	Leo VI the Wise, Constantine VII	Leo served as Domestic for the first time sometime under Leo VI, and again, with the rank of magistros, during most of the regency of Empress Zoe. He led the Byzantine forces in the disastrous Battle of Acheloos in 917, but survived. He was dismissed from the Domesticate by Constantine VII at the urging of Patriarch Nicholas Mystikos and then outmanoeuvred in the struggle for control of the throne by Romanos Lekapenos. After launching an unsuccessful revolt, he was captured and blinded.	[37]
John Garidas	919	Constantine VII	An old officer in the Hetaireia, he replaced Leo Phokas in 919.	[38]
Adralestos	ca. 920	Romanos I Lekapenos	Adralestos was Domestic in the early years of Romanos I's reign	[38]
Pothos Argyros	920/921–922	Romanos I Lekapenos	Pothos Argyros replaced Adralestos after the latter's death. He participated in the Battle of Pegae (922) but escaped. He was still active as a general in 945, when he defeated the Magyars.	[38]
John Kourkouas	922–944	Romanos I Lekapenos	One of the closest associates of Romanos I, Kourkouas held the Domesticate for 22 years and seven months. He led numerous campaigns against the Arabs which resulted in the conquest of Melitene and the recovery of the Mandylion from Edessa. He was dismissed after the sons of Romanos I toppled their father from power in December 944.	[39][40]
Leo Argyros	unknown	Romanos I Lekapenos (?)	Younger brother of Pothos Argyros, he served as military commander already under Leo VI. It is known that he was magistros and held the post of Domestic, but not when. R. Guilland speculates that this was either in the early years of Romanos I's reign or after the latter's fall.	[41]
Pantherios	944–945	Stephen Lekapenos and Constantine Lekapenos	Appointed in place of John Kourkouas by Romanos I's sons, his tenure was short-lived as Constantine VII overthrew them and assumed sole power.	[42]
Bardas Phokas	945–954	Constantine VII	A distinguished general and brother of Leo Phokas, he was sidelined under Romanos I. He supported Constantine VII's coup against the Lekapenoi and was named magistros and Domestic in return. His military record was poor however, suffering several defeats at the hands of Sayf al-Dawla, and he was replaced by his son Nikephoros in 954. When Nikephoros came to the throne he made his father Caesar.	[43]
Nikephoros Phokas	954–963	Constantine VII	He succeeded his father in the Domesticate, and scored several successes against the Arabs: the sack of Adata in 957, the reconquest of Crete in 960–961 and victories against the Hamdanids in 962–963. In 963, following the death of Romanos II, he rose to the throne. He was murdered in 969 by John Tzimiskes.	[44][45]
Leo Phokas	959–963	Romanos II	Younger brother of Nikephoros II, he occupied senior military posts under Constantine VII, while Romanos II named him as the first Domestic of the West. In 960–961 he replaced his brother in the East during the Cretan campaign, and defeated Sayf al-Dawla. When Nikephoros came to the throne he made him kouropalatēs an head minister. Following the murder of Nikephoros, he conspired repeatedly against Tzimiskes and was blinded and exiled.	[46][47]
John Tzimiskes	963 – ?	Nikephoros II Phokas	Nephew and close aide to Nikephoros Phokas, he was promoted to Domestic of the East on the latter's accession, but was later dismissed. He murdered Nikephoros II in December 969 an reigned as emperor until his death in 976.	[48][49]
Melias	ca. 972–973	John I Tzimiskes	A relative of the celebrated early 10th-century stratēgos Melias, he held the post of Domestic of the East. He led a campaign into northern Mesopotamia in 972–973 and was killed during a siege of Amida.	[48][50]
Bardas Phokas	978–987	Basil II	The heir to the Phokas clan's imperial aspirations, he rebelled against Tzimiskes but was defeated by Bardas Skleros and imprisoned. He was released and given the Domesticate of the East in 978 to confront the rebellion of Skleros against Basil II. He defeated Skleros, but in 987 he rebelled against Basil himself, only to die in the middle of a battle against the emperor at Abydos in April 989.	[51]
Stephen Kontostephanos	ca. 986	Basil II	Domestic of the West during the campaign against Bulgaria, and in part responsible for the heavy defeat in the Battle of the Gates of Trajan	[52]
Nikephoros Ouranos	996–999	Basil II	A confidante of Basil II and capable general, he was appointed "master of all the West" to confront the depredations of Tsar Samuel of Bulgaria, whom he decisively defeated at the Battle of Spercheios in 997. In 999 he was sent east as doux of Antioch, where he strenghtened the Syrian frontier and scored successes against the Fatimids.	[52][53]
Nicholas	1025–1028, 1042–1044(?)	Constantine VIII Zoe	One of the eunuch favourites of Constantine VIII, he was named proedros, parakoimōmenos and Domestic of the Schools, although legally barred from the latter office. Dismissed by Romanos III, he was recalled to imperial favour and the Domesticate of the East by Zoe in 1042. In this capacity he led the defence against the Rus' raid of 1043 and campaigned without success in Armenia, whereupon he was relieved of his military command.	[54]
Symeon	1030 – ?	Romanos III Argyros	One of the eunuch favourites of Constantine VIII, he was named proedros and Drungary of the Watch by the emperor. He played a major role in the rise of Romanos III to the throne through his marriage to Zoe, and received the Domesticate of the East in 1030.	[55]
Constantine	1037–1041 1041–1042	Michael IV Michael V	A eunuch brother of Michael IV, he was named doux of Antioch ca. 1034/1035 and was raised to Domestic of the East in 1037. His leadership was not very successful, and in 1040 a failed conspiracy was directed against him. After the death of Michael, Constantine was recalled and exiled by Empress Zoe. He was restored by his nephew Michael V and promoted to nōbelissimos, but was blinded and exiled again when the latter was deposed.	[56][57]
Constantine Kabasilas	1042 – ?	Zoe	One of the leaders of the revolt against Michael V, he was named "doux of the West" by Zoe.	[58]
Constantine Arianites	ca. 1048 – 1050	Constantine XI	A distinguished general, he is recorded as holding the post of "master [of the troops] of the West" in the campaigns against the Pechenegs. He was killed before Adrianople in 1050.	[59]
Theodore	1054–1057	Theodora	A eunuch and confidante of the empress, he was raised to the Domesticate of the East and the rank of proedros and sent east to fight the Turks. He marched against the rebellion of Isaac Komnenos and was defeated at the Battle of Petroe.	[60]
John Komnenos	1057 – ?	Isaac I Komnenos	Younger brother of Isaac I, he was raised to kouropalatēs and "Grand Domestic" by his brother. The usage of "Grand Domestic" is probably an anachronistic usage by later sources, and his real title was probably Domestic of Schools of the West.	[61]
Philaretos Brachamios	ca. 1068 – ca. 1071 1078 – ?	Romanos IV Diogenes Nikephoros III Botaneiates	An Armenian nobleman, he was raised to Domestic of the East by Romanos IV, probably dismissed by Michael VII and reinstated by Nikephoros III.	[61]
Andronikos Doukas	ca. 1072	Michael VII Doukas	Eldest son of the Caesar John Doukas, prōtoproedros and prōtovestiarios, he was appointed Domestic of the East to confront the deposed emperor Romanos IV.	[62]
Isaac Komnenos	ca. 1073	Michael VII Doukas	Son of the kouropalatēs John Komnenos (brother of Isaac I), he was named Domestic and sent against the Turks, but was defeated and captured.	[62]
Alexios Komnenos	1078–1081	Nikephoros III Botaneiates	Nephew of Isaac I, he was appointed to the Domesticate of the West to combat the revolts of Nikephoros Bryennios and Nikephoros Basilakes. In 1081, he deposed Nikephoros III and became emperor, ruling until his death in 1118.	[63]
Gregory Pakourianos	1081–1086	Alexios I Komnenos	Was named "Grand Domestic of the West" after Alexios Komnenos ascended the throne, and was killed in battle in 1086. R. Guilland qualifies him as the "first person to be officially named "Grand Domestic"."	[64]
Adrianos Komnenos	1086 – after 1095	Alexios I Komnenos	A younger brother of Alexios I, he succeeded Pakourianos as "Grand Domestic of the West" in 1086.	[65]
Alexios Gidos	ca. 1185 ca. 1194	Andronikos I Komnenos Isaac II Angelos	Known to have been "Grand Domestic of the East" in 1185, and Domestic of the West in 1194, when he led the Byzantine army in the disastrous Battle of Arcadiopolis.	[66]
Basil Vatatzes	after 1185 – 1194	Isaac II Angelos	Married to a niece of Isaac II, as Domestic of the East and doux of the Thracesians he suppressed the revolt of Theodore Mankaphas in 1189. By 1193 he was Domestic of the West at Adrianople. He was killed in the Battle of Arcadiopolis in 1194.	[67]
Tzamplakon	unknown	John III Vatatzes	Father of Alexios Tzamplakon and first notable member of his family, he is known to have held the title during the reign of John III (1222–1254).	[68]
Theodotos Kalothetos	ca. 1254/1258	unknown	He known to have held the title from a letter addressed to him by Theodore II Laskaris (ruled 1254–1258). In 1259, he was governor of the Thracesian Theme.	[68]
Ferrand d'Aunes	ca. 1304	Andronikos II Palaiologos	A Catalan mercenary, he was raised to the dignity of "Domestic of the Schools" and entered the Byzantine nobility, marrying into the Raoul family	[68]
Manuel Doukas Laskaris	ca. 1320	Andronikos II Palaiologos	He is the last known holder of the title, mentioned in 1320 as "Domestic of the Schools of the West" and governor of Thessalonica	[69]

References

1. ^ ^{a b} Bury (1911), p. 50
2. ^ Bury (1911), pp. 47–48
3. ^ Kazhdan (1991), pp. 1851–1852
4. ^ ^{a b} Oikonomides (1972), p. 329
5. ^ Guilland (1967), p. 428
6. ^ Bury (1911), pp. 50–51
7. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 428–429, 434, 445–446
8. ^ ^{a b} Bury (1911), p. 51
9. ^ On the various variants of the titles used by the Byzantine writers, cf. Guilland (1967), pp. 429–430
10. ^ cf. Guilland (1967), p. 431
11. ^ ^{a b} Guilland (1967), p. 435
12. ^ Guilland (1967), p. 430
13. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 430–431
14. ^ Kazhdan (1991), p. 648
15. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 431–432
16. ^ cf. Guilland (1967), pp. 405ff.
17. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 414–415, 454–455
18. ^ Kazhdan (1991), pp. 648, 1329–1220
19. ^ Verpeaux (1966), p. 179
20. ^ Verpeaux (1966), p. 138
21. ^ Verpeaux (1966), p. 160
22. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 435–436
23. ^ ^{a b c d} Guilland (1967), p. 436
24. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 436–437
25. ^ Kazhdan (1991), p. 1289
26. ^ ^{a b} Guilland (1967), p. 437
27. ^ ^{a b c} Guilland (1967), p. 438
28. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 438–439
29. ^ Tougher (1997), pp. 58, 204
30. ^ ^{a b} Guilland (1967), p. 439
31. ^ Tougher (1997), pp. 204–205
32. ^ ^{a b} Guilland (1967), p. 440
33. ^ Tougher (1997), pp. 80–81, 85–86, 205
34. ^ ^{a b} Kazhdan (1991), pp. 655–657
35. ^ ^{a b} Guilland (1967), pp. 439–440
36. ^ Tougher (1997), pp. 208–210
37. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 440–441
38. ^ ^{a b c} Guilland (1967), p. 441
39. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 442–443
40. ^ Kazhdan (1991), p. 1157
41. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 441–442
42. ^ Guilland (1967), p. 443
43. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 443–444
44. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 444–445
45. ^ Kazhdan (1991), pp. 1478–1479
46. ^ Guilland (1967), p. 445
47. ^ Kazhdan (1991), p. 1667
48. ^ ^{a b} Guilland (1967), p. 446
49. ^ Kazhdan (1991), p. 1045
50. ^ Kazhdan (1991), p. 1334
51. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 447–448
52. ^ ^{a b} Guilland (1967), p. 448
53. ^ Kazhdan (1991), pp. 1544–1545
54. ^ Guilland (1967), p. 449
55. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 449–450
56. ^ Guilland (1967), p. 450
57. ^ Ringrose (2003), pp. 191–192
58. ^ Garland (1999), pp. 143, 145
59. ^ Guilland (1967), p. 451
60. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 452–453
61. ^ ^{a b} Guilland (1967), p. 453
62. ^ ^{a b} Guilland (1967), p. 454
63. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 406, 454
64. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 407, 454
65. ^ Guilland (1967), p. 407
66. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 408–409, 455
67. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 408, 455
68. ^ ^{a b c} Guilland (1967), p. 455
69. ^ Guilland (1967), pp. 455–456

Sources

• Bury, John B. (1911). The Imperial Administrative System of the Ninth Century. With a Revised Text of the Kletorologion of Philotheos. Oxford University Publishing. 
• Garland, Lynda (1999). Byzantine empresses: women and power in Byzantium, AD 527-1204. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-415146883. http://books.google.com/books?id=6JY2fpMTkKwC. 
• Guilland, Rodolphe (1967) (in French). Recherches sur les institutions byzantines, Tome I. Berlin: Akademie-Verlag. 
• Kazhdan, Alexander, ed (1991). Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-504652-6. 
• Lounghis, Tilemachos C. (1996). "The Decline of the Opsikian Domesticates and the Rise of the Domesticate of the Scholae". Byzantine Symmeikta (10): 27–36. ISSN 1105-1639. http://www.byzsym.org/index.php/bz/article/view/804/701. 
• Oikonomides, Nicolas (1972). Les listes de préséance byzantines des IXe et Xe siècles. Paris: Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique. http://books.google.com/books?id=RFdmAAAAMAAJ. 
• Ringrose, Kathryn M. (2003). The Perfect Servant: Eunuchs and the Social Construction of Gender in Byzantium. University of Chicago Press. ISBN 978-0226720159. 
• Tougher, Shaun (1997). The Reign of Leo VI (886-912): Politics and People. BRILL. ISBN 978-9004097775. http://books.google.com/books?id=iPquae5A4zIC. 
• Verpeaux, Jean, ed (1966) (in French). Pseudo-Kodinos, Traité des Offices. Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique.