Pacific Electric Railway

Infobox SG rail
railroad_name=Pacific Electric Railway
logo_filename=PE logo.pnglogo_size=108
old_gauge=
marks=PE
locale=Los Angeles, California, and its suburbs
start_year=1901
end_year=1961
hq_city=Los Angeles, CA

The Pacific Electric Railway reporting mark|PE, also known as the Red Car system, was a mass transit system in Southern California using streetcars, light rail, and buses. At its greatest extent, around 1925, the system interconnected cities in Los Angeles and Orange Counties and also connected to Riverside County and San Bernardino County in the Inland Empire.

The system was divided into three districts:
* Northern District: Pasadena, San Gabriel Valley, San Bernardino.
* Southern District: Long Beach, Newport, San Pedro, Santa Ana.
* Western District: Hollywood, Burbank/Glendale, San Fernando Valley, Santa Monica.

Originally, there was an Eastern District, but this was incorporated into the Northern District early in the company's existence.

Origins

The Pasadena and Pacific railroad was an 1895 merger between the Pasadena and Los Angeles Ry and the Los Angeles and Pacific Ry. It boosted tourism by living up to its motto "from the mountains to the sea."

During this time, the Pacific Electric Railway was established by railroad and real estate tycoon Henry Huntington in 1901. Henry's uncle, Collis P. Huntington, was one of the founders of the Southern Pacific Railroad and had bequeathed Henry a huge fortune upon his death. Only a few years after the company's formation, most of Pacific Electric's stock was purchased by the Southern Pacific Railroad, which Henry Huntington had tried and failed to gain control of a decade earlier. In 1911, Southern Pacific bought out Huntington except for the LARy and also purchased several other passenger railways Huntington owned in the Los Angeles area including Pasadena and Pacific, resulting in the "Great Merger" of 1911. At this point the Pacific Electric became the largest operator of interurban electric railway passenger service in the world, with over 1,000 miles of track. The Pacific Electric also ran frequent freight trains under electric power throughout its service area, including one of the few electrically-powered Railway Post Office routes in the country. The PE was also responsible for an innovation in grade crossing safety that was quickly adopted by other railroads, a fully automatic electromechanical grade crossing signal nicknamed the "wigwag."

After the Great Merger, Henry Huntington kept the company which provided local streetcar service in central Los Angeles and nearby communities, the Los Angeles Railway (LARy). These trolleys were known as the "Yellow Cars," and actually carried more passengers than the PE's "Red Cars" since they ran in the most densely populated portion of Los Angeles.

The company generated a good deal of profit from the land developments created by the "Pacific Electric Land Company" and linked by the railway.

Fleet

Interurban cars

* Blimp MU (61 - Pullmans)
** St Louis Car Co Blimp MU 1930-1959
** Pullman Car Co Blimp MU coach 1913-1961
** Pullman Car Co Blimp MU baggage coach 1913-1959
* St Louis Car Co MU coach 1907-1950
* Jewett Car Co. 1000 "Business Car" 1913-1947
* Jewett Car Co. 1000-class MU interurban 1913-1954
* American Car Co trailer coach 1908-1934
* American Car Co trailer coach 1908-1934
* Pullman Car Co officer's car 1912-1958
* J.G. Brill Portland RPO-baggage 1913-1959
* 500-class interurban cars
* American Car Co 800 class interurban
* Standard Steel Car Co. 1100-class interurban car - Hammond, Indiana
* Pressed Steel Car Co. 1200-class Berdoo MU interurban 1915
* Pullman Car Co. 1222-class Long Beach MU interurban 1921
* Pullman Car Co. 1252-class Portland MU interurban 1912
* Pullman Car Co. 1299 "Business Car" 1912, converted from Portland trailer 1929

City and suburban cars

* St Louis Car Co double-truck Birney 1925-1941
* Pullman Car Co Submarine 1912-1928
* J. G. Brill Birney 1918-1941 (69)
* St Louis Car Co baby five MU coach 1901-1934
* St Louis Car Co medium five MU coach 1909-1934
* St Louis Car Co Hollywood car MU 1922-1959 (160)
* St Louis Car Co Hollywood car 1922 (50) numbered 600-649
* St Louis Car Co Hollywood car 1923 (50) numbered 650-699
* J. G. Brill Hollywood car 192x (50) numbered 700-749
* St Louis Car Co Hollywood car 1924 (10) numbered 750-759
* Pullman Standard PCC 1939 (30) numbered 5000–5029. Sold to Argeninat in 1959
* St. Louis Car Co. 500 class DE streetcars

Work cars

* LAP trolley wire greaser 1898-1957
* PE tower car 1915-1957

Locomotives

* 1600 class electric locomotives

Freight cars

* LA&R flat-top caboose 1896
* PE flat-top caboose PE 1939
* LS&MS caboose 1915
* LV caboose 1926
* RF&P caboose 1905
* SSC box car 1924

Buses

* GM yellow coach

Facilities

* West Hollywood Car Barn and Yard
* Ocean Park Car Barn and Yard
* Torrance Shops
* Main Terminal
* Hollywood Subway

Decline of the Red Cars

Throughout their existence, the Pacific Electric and its predecessor railroads frequently lost money on passenger operations. Fact|date=May 2008 There were few years when the company's income statement showed a profit, most notably during World War II, when gasoline was rationed and automobiles were not manufactured. Huntington's involvement with urban rail was intimately tied to his real estate development operations. In the pre-automobile era, electric interurban rail was the only way to connect outlying suburban and exurban parcels to central cities. Real estate development was so lucrative for Huntington and Southern Pacific that they could use the Red Car as a loss leader. However, most of the company's holdings had been developed by 1920. As the company's major income source began to deplete, profitability required that the least-used Red Car lines be converted to cheaper buses as early as 1925.

Although the railway owned extensive private rights-of-way, usually between urban areas, much of the Pacific Electric trackage in urban areas was in streets shared with automobiles and trucks, and virtually all street crossings were at-grade, and increasing automobile traffic led to decreasing Red Car speeds on much of its trackage. Fact|date=May 2008 At its nadir, the busy Santa Monica Boulevard line, which connected Santa Monica and Hollywood, had an average speed of 13 miles per hour [http://www.straightdope.com/classics/a2_335.html] , similar to the average speed today on Los Angeles area freeways.

Traffic congestion was of such great concern by the late 1930s that the influential Automobile Club of Southern California engineered an elaborate plan to create an elevated freeway-type "Motorway System," a key aspect of which was the dismantling of the streetcar lines, to be replaced with buses that could run on both local streets and on the new express roads. [http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/thedailymirror/2008/06/june-15-1938.html "Motorways Plan Revealed: System of Roads Designed to Cure Traffic Ills," Los Angeles Times, June 15, 1938]

Pacific Electric carried increased passenger loads during World War II, when Los Angeles County's population nearly doubled as war industries concentrated in the region and attracted millions of workers. Aware that most new arrivals planned to stay in the region after the war, local governments agreed that a massive infrastructure improvement program was necessary. At that time the public demanded Fact|date=May 2008, and politicians agreed to construct, a web of freeways across the region. This was seen as a better solution than a new mass transit system or an upgrade of the Pacific Electric, and large-scale destruction of neighborhoods for freeway construction began in 1951. Fact|date=May 2008

Dismantling and rebirth

Major cutbacks in Pacific Electric passenger service began before World War II, and included lines to Whittier and Fullerton (1938), Redondo Beach and Riverside (1940) and San Bernardino (1941). After the war, Pacific Electric compared costs of refurbishing and operating the Northern District lines to Pasadena, Monrovia and Glendora, and Baldwin Park, with the alternative of converting to buses, and found in favor of the latter; the entire District was then closed to passenger service in 1950 and 1951. In the South, passenger service to Santa Ana closed in 1950, and in the West the last line to Venice and Santa Monca also ended in 1950, and service to the San Fernando Valley lasted only to 1952.

The remaining Pacific Electric passenger service was sold off in 1953 to a company known as Metropolitan Coach Lines, whose intention was to convert all rail service to bus service as quickly as possible. The Hollywood Boulevard line was shut down in 1954, and service to Glendale and Burbank ended in 1955, but the California state government would not allow the other, most popular lines to be discontinued. In 1958, Metropolitan Coach Lines relinquished control of the remaining rail lines to a government agency, the Los Angeles Metropolitan Transit Authority, known as the MTA, which had been formed in 1951 for the purpose of studying the possibility of establishing a publicly-owned monorail line that would have run from Long Beach to Panorama City via Downtown Los Angeles. In 1954, the agency's powers were expanded to allow it to propose a more extensive regional mass transit system. In 1957, its powers were again expanded, this time to allow it to operate transit lines. Using this authority, the MTA purchased Metropolitan Coach Lines and the remaining streetcar lines of the successor of the Los Angeles Railway, the Los Angeles Transit Lines, and began operating all lines as a single system on March 3, 1958. The system continued to operate under the name MTA until the agency was reorganized and relaunched as the Southern California Rapid Transit District in September 1964. [http://www.mta.net/images/HuntingtonLibrary.pdf (2.6MB PDF file)]

Only a handful of electric train lines remained operating at the time the MTA took over the system and the conventional wisdom held that their days were numbered. The last passenger line of the Pacific Electric, the line from Los Angeles to Long Beach, continued until April 9, 1961. With the closure of the Long Beach line, the final link in the system as well as the PE's first line some sixty years prior, was eliminated. The PE's freight service was continued by the Southern Pacific Railroad and operated under the Pacific Electric name through 1964. The few remaining former Los Angeles Railway streetcar lines were removed in 1963. The majority of the surviving Pacific Electric rolling stock can be seen and ridden at the Orange Empire Railway Museum in Perris.

The "General Motors conspiracy"

The end of the Red Cars is related to the replacement of streetcar lines with bus lines in at least 45 other American cities, including Baltimore, St. Louis, Philadelphia, Salt Lake City, and Oakland, CA. National City Lines, a consortium formed and owned by General Motors, Standard Oil of California, and Firestone, bought up private streetcar lines across the country and systematically dismantled them, replacing electric trolley service, at least partially, with buses. The move came to be known as the Great American Streetcar Scandal.

In 1949, nine corporations, including General Motors, Standard Oil of California, Firestone Tire and others, plus seven individuals, constituting officers and directors of certain of the corporate defendants, were acquitted in the Federal District Court of Northern Illinois of conspiring to monopolize the ownership of transportation companies with the intent of monopolizing transportation services. At the same time, they were convicted in a second count of conspiring to monopolize the sale of buses and related products to local transit companies controlled by the defendants. The court considered the violations to be relatively minor, as the corporate defendants were only fined $5,000, and the individual company directors that had been charged only had to pay a symbolic fine of one dollar each. The verdicts were upheld on appeal. [See appeals court ruling: http://www.altlaw.org/v1/cases/770576]

When National City had completed its conversion and provided buses to replace the electric trolleys, it turned the bus service over to the newly-created public Metropolitan Transportation Authority to operate the system at a loss. That the streetcar lines operated so long without any subsidy other than grants of right-of-way is evidence of their relative economic viability.Fact|date=October 2007

Other factors that may have contributed to the decline of electric traction in the United States include rising real estate values, federal regulations that power utilities could not own trolley systems, development spreading away from public transit nodes due to the proliferation of affordable automobiles, and the inability of private traction lines to modernize their aging equipment and rolling stock due to low revenues. Pacific Electric was operating buses as early as the 1920s, and removed some streetcar lines as early as the early 1930s.

The plot of the 1988 movie "Who Framed Roger Rabbit" is loosely modeled on the conspiracy to dismantle the streetcar lines in Los Angeles.

Electric rail revival

Throughout the Pacific Electric's history, a variety of improvements in service or new systems were proposed, including subway trains and monorails. Political and business will transformed the Los Angeles megalopolis to one based primarily on automotive transit, paved with hundreds of miles of superhighways. Few lamented the decline and disappearance of rail-based mass transit in Los Angeles.

Beginning in the 1970s, a variety of factors, including environmental concerns, an increasing population and the price of gasoline led to calls for mass transit other than buses. In 1976 the State of California formed the Los Angeles County Transportation Commission to coordinate the SCRTD's efforts with those of various municipal transit systems in the area and to take over planning of countywide transportation systems. The SCRTD continued planning of the Metrorail Subway (the Red Line), while the LACTC developed plans for the light rail system. After decades, the wheels of government began to move forward, and construction began on the Los Angeles County Metro Rail system in 1985. In 1988, the two agencies formed a third entity under which all rail construction would be consolidated. In 1993, the SCRTD and the LACTC were finally merged into the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority.

In 1990, electric rail passenger train service once again returned to Los Angeles with the opening of the Blue Line. This line runs from downtown Los Angeles to Long Beach, using much of the same right of way as the original Pacific Electric line that was discontinued in 1961. Since then, the LACMTA has opened more lines. The subway Red Line opened in three parts, connecting North Hollywood to Union Station in central Los Angeles. In 1995, the Green Line opened, running in the median of Interstate 105. The latest light rail line is the mostly at-grade Gold Line, connecting Pasadena to downtown Los Angeles along former Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railroad (ATSF) trackage, including a historic 1895 railroad bridge across the Arroyo Seco.

On July 19, 2003, a 1.5 mile streetcar line connecting the cruise ship terminal with other attractions along the San Pedro waterfront began operation. This currently functions as a tourist attraction. Two newly constructed Red Car replicas provide service along the line. In addition, a restored 1907-vintage Pacific Electric car is available for special operations. This was financed and constructed by the Port of Los Angeles as part of its waterfront revival effort. There are plans to extend this line approximately two more miles to the Cabrillo Aquarium. Trackage is in place, but funding for additional improvements has not been identified at this time. Some transit advocates have proposed linking this line to the Blue Line in Long Beach, but this would be a much more intensive and expensive project.

More rail lines are in the planning and building stages. In 2009, the Gold Line Eastside Extension will connect East Los Angeles to Downtown. If construction funds are identified, the "Foothill Extension" of the Gold Line will extend the service to Montclair, or possibly all the way to LA/Ontario International Airport by 2015.

There are several proposals for connecting the congested West Los Angeles area with rail service. The LACMTA will construct the Expo Line, a light-rail line. A color has not yet been assigned to this line. The LACMTA has announced that money is available for construction, which has begun, with surveying activities beginning in May 2006, and construction commencing in October 2006. Service is scheduled to begin as far as Culver City in 2010 and continue to Santa Monica by 2014-2015.

Other groups are lobbying to extend the renamed Purple Line to the west on Wilshire Boulevard, the city's most densely populated corridor, as was originally planned in mass transit plans designed as early as the late 1960s. In 2005, Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa made as one of his most publicized campaign promises a pledge to set the wheels in motion for eventual construction of the "Subway to the Sea" as he called it.

It is unlikely that the Metro Rail system (without including the hundreds of miles of Metrolink commuter line track, some of which duplicate former Pacific Electric lines) will ever have as much track as the Pacific Electric, with increasing construction costs and the complexity of environmental regulations. Mass transit advocates have heralded as necessary and successful whatever rail trackage has been rebuilt. If all current proposals are built, by 2015 Los Angeles will have the third highest amount of mass transit track mileage in the United States, after New York City and Chicago.

ee also

* General Motors streetcar conspiracy
* Los Angeles Railway
* National City Lines
* Pacific Electric Building
* Subway Terminal Building
* San Diego Electric Railway
* Who Framed Roger Rabbit

References

Further reading

*
*
*

External links

* [http://www.davesrailpix.com/pe/pev1.htm Bill Volkmer's collection of Red Car Photos and post cards]
* [http://www.redcarproperty.com Corralitas Red Car Property]
* [http://www.erha.org/pe.htm Electric Railway Historical Association of Southern California]
* [http://www.erha.org/pe_system_map.jpgSystem Map of Pacific Electric Railway - Lines of SoCal - Circa 1920s]
* [http://www.oerm.org/ Orange Empire Railway Museum] official website
* [http://www.railwaypreservation.com/page8.html L.A. Port waterfront Red Car line]
* [http://www.stubchaer.com/Pacific_Electric_Ry_Photos_1947_49_by_Jim_Stubchaer/index.htm Pacific Electric Photos by Jim Stubchaer]
* [http://www.westworld.com/~elson/larail/PE/tunnel.html Pacific Electric Subway]
* [http://www.geocities.com/sccosel/Pacific_Electric.htm Pacific Electric System Map 1949]
* [http://www.redcar-la.com/cmp/home.html Proposal to bring the Red Car back to Downtown Los Angeles]
* [http://www.usc.edu/libraries/archives/la/historic/redcars/ The Red Cars of Los Angeles]
* [http://harrymarnell.com/toluca.htm Subway Tunnel Aerial Maps]
* [http://www.uncanny.net/~wetzel/pery.htm Tours in a Bygone Era]