Liberal movements within Islam

This article is part of the series:
Islam
Beliefs Oneness of God Prophets · Revealed books Angels · Predestination Day of Resurrection
Practices Profession of faith · Prayer Fasting · Alms · Pilgrimage
Texts & laws Quran · Sunnah · Hadith Fiqh · Sharia · Kalam
History & leaders Timeline · Muhammad Ahl al-Bayt · Sahaba Sunni · Shia · Sufi · Others Rashidun · Imamate Caliphate · Spread of Islam
Culture & society Academics · Animals · Art Calendar · Children Dawah · Demographics Festivals · Mosques Philosophy · Politics Science · Women
See also Other religions · Glossary Islam portal This box: view · talk · edit

Progressive Muslims have produced a considerable body of liberal thought within Islam^[1][2] or "progressive Islam" (Arabic: الإسلام التقدمي‎); but some consider progressive Islam and liberal Islam as two distinct movements^[3]). The methodology of reform can be classified into two groups, one depending on re-interpreting the traditional texts which constitutes Islamic law (ijtihad);^[4] this varies widely from little deviation from the traditional interpretation, to the more liberal which considers only the meaning of Qur'an as a divine inspiration, while the wording is believed to be from the prophet Muhammad intended by him to suit his time and situation, therefore interpreting the problematic verses in modern times allegorically or even not considering them. The second is questioning the authentic status applied to texts by the Traditional Islamic Scholars, resulting in the most liberal case as of the Qur'an Alone Muslims in rejecting the Islamic narratives of the sayings and practises of Prophet Muhammad, namely the Hadith completely.

The most liberal Muslim intellectuals who focused on religious reform include Sayyid al-Qimni, Nasr Abu Zayd, Abdolkarim Soroush, Mohammed Arkoun, Mohammed Shahrour, Ahmed Subhy Mansour, Edip Yuksel, Gamal al-Banna, Abdullahi Ahmed An-Na'im, Ahmed Al-Gubbanchi, Mahmoud Mohammed Taha, and Faraj Foda, the last two were killed after apostasy claims which most of them have been accused of by traditional Islamic scholars.

Some liberal Muslims claim that they are returning to the principles of the early Ummah and to the ethical and pluralistic intent of their scripture, the Qur'an.^[5] They distance themselves from some traditional and less liberal interpretations of Islamic law, as they consider these to be culturally based and without universal applicability. The reform movement uses monotheism (tawhid) "as an organizing principle for human society and the basis of religious knowledge, history, metaphysics, aesthetics, and ethics, as well as social, economic and world order."^[6]

Reform

These are movements within Islam, rather than an attempt at schism. As such, they believe in the basic tenets of Islam, such as the Six Elements of Belief and the Five Pillars of Islam. They consider their views to be fully compatible with the teachings of Islam. Their main differences with more conservative Islamic opinion are two, the first is, in differences of interpretation of how to apply the core Islamic values to modern life,^[7] the second includes a more reactionary dialectic which criticizes traditional narratives or even rejects them, hence, denying any obligation to follow them while also allowing greater freedoms in interpreting Qur'an regardless of the hadith.^[8]

Muslim liberals focus on individual autonomy in the interpretation of the Qur'an and ethics rather than focusing on the literal interpretation of the Qur'an. This thinking may have a precedent in the traditions of Sufi and Islamic mysticism^[9] although different in many ways, including the purpose of interpretation.

Central tenets

Several generally accepted tenets have emerged:

• The autonomy of the individual in interpreting the Qur'an and Hadith.^[10] More liberal trends include rejecting Hadiths completely (like Qur'an Alone Muslims) or partially (including hadiths considered authentic (Sahih) by traditionalists) like Gamal Al-Banna.
• A more critical and diverse examination of religious texts, as well as traditional Islamic precedents.
• Complete gender equality in all aspects, including ritual prayer and observance.
• A more open view on modern culture in relation to customs, dress, and common practices. Certain rules on modesty amongst men and women are still self-enforced in response to the Qur'an's injunction against immodest dress.
• The individual use of ijtihad (interpretation) and fitrah (natural sense of right and wrong) is advocated.

Contemporary and controversial issues

Over the course of the 19th and 20th centuries, in accordance with their increasingly modern societies and outlooks, liberal Muslims have tended to reinterpret many aspects of the application of their religion in their life in an attempt to reconnect with the original message, untouched by harmful cultural influences. This is particularly true of Muslims who now find themselves living in non-Muslim countries.^[11]

Such people may describe themselves variously as liberal, progressive, or reformist (in application but not in the tenets of the faith); but rather than implying a specific agenda, these terms tend to incorporate a broad spectrum of views which contest conservative, traditional interpretations of Islam in many different ways. Although there is no full consensus amongst liberal Muslims on their views, they tend to agree on some or all of the following beliefs:

Ijtihad

This means that liberal Muslims often drop traditional interpretations of the Qur'an which they find too culturally conservative and relative, preferring instead readings which are more adaptable to modern society (see ijtihad). Most liberal Muslims reject derivation of Islamic laws from literal readings of single Qur'anic verses. They generally claim that a holistic view which takes into account the 7th century Arabian cultural context allows deeper insight into the manner in which the commands of God (Allah) are carried out.

Human rights

Further information: Human rights in Islamic countries

Moderate Islamic political thought contends that the nurturing of the Muslim identity and the propagation of values such as democracy and Human rights are not mutually exclusive, but rather should be promoted together.^[12]

Most liberal Muslims believe that Islam promotes the notion of absolute equality of all humanity, and that it is one of its central concepts. Therefore, a breach of human rights has become a source of great concern to most liberal Muslims.^[13] Though Human Rights is perceived to be of the utmost concern of all devoted adherents to the Islamic faith, liberal Muslims differ with their culturally conservative counterparts in that they believe that all humanity is represented under the umbrella of Human Rights. Many Muslim majority countries have signed international human rights treaties, but the impact of these largely remains to be seen in local legal systems.^[14]

Muslim liberals often reject traditional interpretations of Islamic law, which allows Ma malakat aymanukum and Slavery. They see that Slavery opposed Islamic principles which they believe to be based on justice and equality and verses relating to slavery or "Ma malakat aymanukum" now can not be applied due to the fact that the world has changed.^[15][16]

Within the framework of justice and equality for all, Muslim liberals include gay rights as a human right.

Feminism

Islamic Feminism Symbol

The place of women in Islam, traditional gender roles in Islam and Islamic feminism are likewise major issues.^[17] For this reason, liberal Muslims are often critical of traditional Islamic law interpretations which allow polygyny for men but not polyandry for women, as well as the traditional Islamic law of inheritance under which daughters receive less than sons. Traditional Muslims believe this is balanced by the right of a wife to her husband's money, whereas the husband does not have a right to his wife's money.

It is also accepted by most liberal Muslims that a woman may lead the state, and that women should not be segregated from men in society or in masjids. Some traditional Muslims also accept a woman as a leader of state so long as it does not conflict with her obligation to family. A small minority of liberal Muslims accept that a woman may lead a mixed group in prayers, despite the established custom for women to pray behind or in a separate space. However, this issue remains controversial; see women as imams. Some Muslim feminists are also opposed to the traditional dress requirements for women (commonly called hijab), claiming that any modest clothing is sufficiently Islamic for both men and women.

Other Muslim feminists embrace hijab, pointing out its tendency to de-sexualize women and therefore assist them in being treated less as an object and more as a person. Furthermore, some Muslim feminists prefer to wear the hijab as an obvious sign that they are indeed Muslim, while also feminists. Most -but not all- schools of Islamic law require women to cover all but the hands and the face, while men are only required to cover from the navel to the knee. Traditional reports of the prophet, called hadith, are used to support the idea of covering everything on a woman except her face and hands. The reported story is told that the prophet saw Asma clothed in a thin garment, at which he proclaimed: "when a woman reaches the age of menstruation, she should cover everything but"- and he then pointed to his face and hands. The Qur'an itself requires men and women to dress modestly (see: Qur'an 24:30-31). The words "bosom/chest" and "modest" are found in 24:31, however the word "hair" is absent. In the same verse woman are advised to not "strike their feet" as to draw attention to their hidden adornment. This leaves "adornment" (sometimes translated as beauty) open to interpretation, as to whether it includes the hair.

Secularism

Main article: Secularism in the Middle East

Some liberal Muslims favor the idea of modern secular democracy with separation of church and state, and thus oppose Islam as a political movement.

The existence or applicability of Islamic law is questioned by many liberals. Their argument often involves variants of the Mu'tazili theory that the Qur'an was created by God for the particular circumstances of the early Muslim community, and reason must be used to apply it to new contexts.

Tolerance and non-violence

Tolerance is another key tenet of Liberal Muslims, who are generally open to interfaith dialogue and conflict resolution with such communities as Jews, Christians, Hindus, and the numerous factions within Islam.

Liberal Muslims are more likely to reflect the idea of jihad in terms of the widely accepted "internal spiritual struggle" rather than an "armed struggle." The ideals of non-violence are prevalent in Liberal Muslim ideology and backed by Qu'ranic text; "permission to fight is given only to those who have been oppressed... who have been driven from their homes for saying, 'God is our Lord'" (22:39)

Reliance on secular scholarship

Liberal Muslims^[who?] tend to be skeptical about the validity of Islamization of knowledge^{[citation needed]} (including Islamic economics, Islamic science, Islamic history and Islamic philosophy) as separate from mainstream fields of inquiry. This is usually due to the often secular outlook of Muslim liberals, which makes them more disposed to trust mainstream secular scholarship. They may also regard the propagation of these fields as merely a propaganda move by Muslim conservatives.^[18]

Anarchism

Main article: Islam and anarchism

Movements

Quranism

Main article: Qur'an alone

Quranists reject the hadith and follow the Quran only.

North America

Main articles: Muslims for Progressive Values, Progressive Muslim Union, Muslim Canadian Congress, and Canadian Muslim Union

Russia and CIS

Main articles: Jadid and Ittifaq al-Muslimin

Europe

Main article: Progressive British Muslims

See also

Divisions of Islam European Islam Islamic feminism Islam Hadhari Criticism of Islam Reform Judaism Reconstructionist Judaism Liberal Christianity Al-Mawrid List of Muslim reformers Thinkers and activists Rashad Khalifa Jamal Khwaja Tarek Heggy Fethullah Gülen Mohammad Khatami Louay M. Safi Shirin Ebadi Muhammad Ali of Egypt Tahir Abbas Khaled Abou El Fadl Alireza Alavitabar Abdul Hadi Palazzi Mohammed Abed al-Jabri Mehdi Bazargan Luthfi Assyaukanie Ahmad Ghabel Ghulam Ahmed Pervez Syed Ahmed Khan Muhammad Ali Jinnah Shabbir Ahmed (writer) Mohsen Kadivar Abul Kalam Azad Irshad Manji Edip Yuksel M. A. Muqtedar Khan Fazlur Rahman Malik Ziauddin Sardar Abdolkarim Soroush Mohammad Mojtahed Shabestari Yousef Saanei Ali Shariati Nasser Suleiman-Gabryel Abdullahi Ahmed An-Na'im Irfan Habib Javed Ahmad Ghamidi Morad El Hattab (France) Pervez Hoodbhoy Mostafa Malekian Raquel Evita Saraswati Mahmoud Taleghani Mahmoud Mohammed Taha Ahmed Al-Gubbanchi Iyad Jamal Al-Din Bassam Tibi Amina Wadud Chekannur Maulavi Hameed Chennamangaloor Sayyid Al-Qemany Khaleel Mohammed Tashbih Sayyed Tawfik Hamid Reza Aslan Khalil Abdel-Karim Zuhdi Jasser Ani Zonneveld

Ideologies and institutions Modern Islamic philosophy Islam and modernity Woman imam Al-Fatiha Foundation 99 Precepts Qur'an-Alone Islam Committee for the Defense of Legitimate Rights Progressive British Muslims Jaringan Islam Liberal Tolu-e-Islam LGBT topics and Islam American Islamic Forum for Democracy

References

1. ^ Finally: Muslims Speak Out Against Jihad
2. ^ Safi, O: "Progressive Muslims", One World: Oxford, 2003.
3. ^ Averroes Foundation
4. ^ Aslan, R: "No god but God", Random House, 2005.
5. ^ Muslim Council of Britain
6. ^ From the article on Tawhid in Oxford Islamic Studies Online
7. ^ Islam in the modern world
8. ^ From the article Where We Went Wrong: A Hard Look at Hadith by Jamal Khawaja
9. ^ "Sufis and anti-Sufis"
10. ^ About Liberal Islam
11. ^ Being a Muslim in the U.S.ا
12. ^ The Fundamentalist City?: Religiosity and the Remaking of Urban Space, Nezar Alsayyad (ed.), Chapter 7: "Hamas in Gaza Refugee camps: The Construction of Trapped Spaces for the Survival of Fundamentalism", Francesca Giovannini. Taylor & Francis, 2010. ISBN 9780415779364."
13. ^ Hassan Mahmoud Khalil: "Islam's position on violence and violation of human rights", Dar Al-Shaeb, 1994.
14. ^ The Soft Power for the Islamic Movement
15. ^ Writer and Islamic thinker "Gamal al-Banna": The Muslim Brotherhood is not fit to rule (2-2)
16. ^ Writer and Islamic thinker "Gamal al-Banna": The Muslim Brotherhood is not fit to rule (1-2)
17. ^ A History of Women in Islam, By Jamal Khawaja
18. ^ S. Irfan Habib: "The Viability of Islamic Science", Economic and Political Weekly, June 5, 2004.

Further reading

• Qur'an and Woman by Amina Wadud.
• American Muslims: Bridging Faith and Freedom by M. A. Muqtedar Khan.
• Liberal Islam: A Sourcebook Edited by Charles Kurzman.
• Progressive Muslims: On Justice, Gender, and Pluralism edited by Omid Safi.
• "Debating Moderate Islam" edited by M. A. Muqtedar Khan.
• Qur'an, Liberation and Pluralism by Farid Esack.
• Revival and Reform in Islam by Fazlur Rahman Malik.
• The Unthought in Contemporary Islamic Thought, by Mohammed Arkoun.
• Unveiling Traditions: Postcolonial Islam in a Polycentric World by Anouar Majid.
• Islam and Science: Religious Orthodoxy and the Battle for Rationality by Pervez Hoodbhoy
• The Viability of Islamic Science by S. Irfan Habib, Economic and Political Weekly, June 5, 2004.
• The Reformist Islamic Thinker Muhammad Shahrur:In the Footsteps of Averroes
• A Liberal Muslim Blog

External links

• Charles Kurzman's Liberal Islam links compiled by the author of Liberal Islam: A Sourcebook (published 1998 by Oxford University Press, USA. ISBN 0-19-511622-4).
• "Can Islam change?", Ziauddin Sardar, New Statesman, 13 September 2004
• http://www.interrel.de/m_sing.htm#engl, on the Lebanese thinker Abdallah al-Alayili (1914–1996).
• In the Footsteps of Averroes - The Reformist Islamic Thinker Muhammad Shahrur by Loay Mudhoon - Qantara
• Martha Nussbaum on Islamic liberalism under fire in India, published in the Boston Review