2002 New Hampshire Senate election phone jamming scandal

"Phonegate" redirects here. For other scandals with this name, see List of scandals with "-gate" suffix.

The 2002 New Hampshire Senate election phone jamming scandal involves the use of a telemarketing firm hired by that state's Republican Party (NHGOP) for election tampering. The tampering involved using a call center to jam the phone lines of a Get Out the Vote (GOTV) operation. In the end, 900 calls were made for 45 minutes of disruption to the Democratic-leaning call centers.

During that state's 2002 election for the U.S. Senate seat being vacated by Robert C. Smith, the NHGOP hired GOP Marketplace, based in Northern Virginia, to jam another phone bank being used by the state Democratic Party and the firefighters' union for efforts to turn out voters on behalf of then-governor Jeanne Shaheen on Election Day. John E. Sununu, the Republican candidate, won a narrow victory. In addition to criminal prosecutions, disclosures in the case have come from a civil suit filed by the state's Democratic Party against the state's Republican Party (now settled).

Four men have been convicted of, or pled guilty to, federal crimes and sentenced to prison for their involvement as of 2008^[update]. One conviction has been reversed by an appeals court, a decision prosecutors are appealing. James Tobin, freed on appeal, was later indicted on charges of lying to the FBI during the original investigation.

History

The scandal breaks

Police in Concord, the state capital, were notified by Democratic workers on the day of the election that they were receiving repeated telephone calls, terminating after five seconds, which were interfering with their efforts to reach voters and offer rides to the polls. For at least an hour and a half at midday they were unable to make any outgoing calls. Verizon was later able to stop most of these calls, but whoever had made them had violated state laws against telephone harassment.

State authorities found the calls came from out of state, and so brought in their federal counterparts. They were eventually traced to Mylo Enterprises, a Pocatello, Idaho-based company that ran phone banks.

The New Hampshire Union Leader reported on it February 8, 2003.^[1] The story forced the resignation of state GOP executive director Charles McGee shortly afterward, when he admitted lying to the paper. Later, prosecutors said that he had come up with the idea of disrupting Democratic communications after seeing a flyer put out by the Shaheen campaign with the numbers. Drawing on his military background, he decided to disrupt "enemy communications" and called several telemarketing firms he knew to have Republican sympathies. However, none of them wanted anything to do with the idea.

However, James Tobin, then Northeast field director for the National Republican Senatorial Committee (NRSC), put McGee in touch with GOP Marketplace, a Northern Virginia firm run by Allen Raymond, which had been hired by the New Hampshire party for similar voter-turnout efforts. McGee had lied in claiming to be unaware of this.

Steve Kornacki of politicsnj.com discovered^[2] that Raymond, a New Jersey native, had worked for James Treffinger, a former gubernatorial candidate then under indictment for a phone scandal during that state's 2001 Republican primary for the senatorial nomination in which calls were made smearing two of his opponents. A prominent figure in that indictment, possibly a co-conspirator, was an unnamed Republican consultant believed to be Raymond (during the later trial of James Tobin, the prosecution said that GOP Marketplace had worked for a Senate campaign in New Jersey and that that work had led to a criminal indictment). During the 2002 Super Bowl, Raymond's firm had placed calls to prospective voters that not only attacked one of Treffinger's rivals but purported to be from another.^[3]

New Hampshire Republicans were initially angry and demanded not only an investigation, but a refund of the $15,600 they paid GOP Marketplace. Two weeks later, however, McGee's replacement, Jayne Millerick, dropped the request.^[4]

Guilty pleas

Little was heard about the case until June 30, 2004, when Allen Raymond pled guilty^[5] to several felony charges in federal court in Concord. McGee followed suit the next month. Joshua Micah Marshall's blog^[6] noted that Todd Hinnen, the prosecutor in Raymond's case, indicated to the court that Raymond had been contacted about the phone jamming idea by "a former colleague who was then an official in a national political organization." Later on that month, both he and the Union Leader reported that this unnamed third individual had a significant role in the Bush-Cheney presidential campaign.

In an op-ed for the Concord Monitor, Smith called the phone-jamming "an outrage" and deplored the lack of Republican anger over "this despicable action by pathetic political hacks." He also implied that the phone jamming may have denied Shaheen victory.^[7]

The third man

In October, an affidavit^[8] filed by the New Hampshire Democratic Party and released to the media contained information that made it possible to identify the third man as Tobin, then serving as the New England regional director for the Bush campaign. He resigned^[9] October 15, and was indicted^[10] December 1, then arraigned^[11] December 13 on two criminal counts each of conspiring to make harassing telephone calls and aiding and abetting telephone harassment.

Sentences

Allen Raymond was sentenced to five months in federal prison on February 8, 2005, for his role. A month later, Charles McGee received seven months. James Tobin refused to cooperate with investigators as his trial approached. During Tobin's trial, questions arose about the source of the money involved in funding the phone jamming and his defense.

In July, the Union Leader reported that one of Tobin's attorneys told the court he was representing the defendant in his capacity as an employee of the Republican National Committee (RNC).^[12] Since the RNC had stated that Tobin was acting on his own in a rogue operation, it was asked, why would they be paying for his defense?

In August, the RNC finally confirmed that it had spent more than $722,000 for Tobin's defense by the Washington firm of Williams & Connolly. "This support is based on his assurance and our belief that Jim has not engaged in any wrongdoing," a spokesperson told the Associated Press.^[13] The Union Leader reported in February 2006 that the RNC had paid $1.7 million to Williams on the day Tobin was sentenced, for a total of $2.5 million, and would neither confirm nor deny that it was still paying his legal expenses.^[14] The RNC's first financial report of 2006 indicated that it by then spent another $330,000.^[15] Later that year, Tobin's wife was hired by the NRSC as a consultant on the unsuccessful re-election campaign of Rhode Island senator Lincoln Chafee, as Northeast Strategies, a company that listed the Tobins' home as its main address. Despite her lack of any previous experience, she was paid at $300,000.^[16]

On August 28, Marshall reported^[12] that two Indian tribes, the Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians and the Mississippi Choctaw, known clients of influential lobbyist Jack Abramoff, himself at the center of a widening scandal, had made $5,000 contributions^[17] (the legal maximum) to the NHGOP the week of the election in 2002. Neither was known to have any interest in New Hampshire. Later, staffers for Judd Gregg, New Hampshire's senior senator and also a Republican, explained that they had passed along the checks without his knowledge.^[18]

Also unusual was over $600,000 contributed to the Sununu campaign over the final week by the National Republican Congressional Committee, which normally focuses on races in the House and had not shown much interest in previous campaigns by Sununu. Texas congressman and former House majority leader Tom DeLay's Americans for a Republican Majority Political Action Committee (ARMPAC) also contributed $5,000.

On November 10, Judge Steven McAuliffe denied^[19] Tobin's last motion to dismiss the conspiracy charges against him, although he said he would consider another motion to dismiss charges that Tobin denied others their right to vote.

Shortly before the trial started, Marshall reported^[20] that the state's witness list included Terry Nelson, former political director for the Bush campaign. Nelson had been linked^[21] to the scandal involving DeLay's illegal fundraising in Texas.

Trial of James Tobin

Tobin's trial began on December 6, 2005. The first day apparently went well for the defense, when key prosecution witness Chuck McGee seemed to back away from testimony he had agreed to make in exchange for plea bargains.^[22]

McGee's testimony suggested that the DCI Group, a powerful public relations firm which publishes the Tech Central Station website and is closely connected to the Republican party, was involved through lawyer and New Hampshire native Brian McCabe. He also said he had talked to Darrell Henry of the American Gas Association, who said that he would keep the phone jamming going after it was officially called off. Henry, McGee said, had offered to keep the operation going with some volunteers from "the chamber".^[16] Since Tobin's superior at the NRSC, Chris LaCivita, worked at the time for the United States Chamber of Commerce,^[23] it is possible that he, too, had foreknowledge of the plan. He currently works for Terry Nelson's consulting firm, Crosslink Strategy Group.

Raymond said he'd also run the idea past Kenneth Gross, a former associate general counsel at the Federal Elections Commission, currently a partner in the powerful firm of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom.^[24]

On December 8, Tobin's defense presented two witnesses and rested. They persuaded McAuliffe to drop one charge and narrow the scope of another.^[25]

It would be of no avail; a week later the jury convicted him of two counts related to telephone harassment while acquitting him of the more serious charge of conspiracy to violate voters' rights.^[26][27]

In May 2006, prosecutors asked for a two-year prison sentence. They cited three factors: Tobin's abuse of a public and private trust, the making of multiple calls to multiple victims over a prolonged period of time, and the ultimate purpose of interfering with an election. The first two are specifically addressed by the telephone-harassment statute; the latter is not but, the prosecutors said, so egregious an end that it warranted more severe punishment.^[28] On May 17, 2006 Tobin was sentenced to 10 months in prison.^[29]

The trial left the New Hampshire Republican Party nearly bankrupt, with only $733.60 in its bank account.^[30] Later that year, Democratic candidates upset both of the state's incumbent Republican congressmen.

Conviction reversed on appeal

On December 21, Tobin's lawyers filed documents in U.S. District Court in Concord, N.H. seeking to vacate the jury's verdict and demanding a new trial for Tobin. A month later, a more detailed filing laid out three possible errors:^[31]

• McGee and Raymond went ahead with the plan after talking with Tobin, not before, suggesting it was their decision alone.
• Tobin cannot be shown to have assented to the element of the plan that called for repeated hangup calls.
• There was no evidence of an agreement to proceed before McGee consulted the NHGOP chair and Raymond sought an attorney's advice.
• All the trial evidence showed was that Tobin referred McGee to Raymond.

On March 20, 2007, Chief Judge Michael Boudin of the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Boston ruled that the statute under which Tobin was convicted "is not a close fit" for what Tobin did, and questioned whether the government showed that Tobin intended to harass. However, it did not void the conviction entirely as Tobin's lawyers sought, saying that conspiracy jurisprudence did not require the level of proof Tobin claimed it did. It remanded it to district court for retrial, believing that a properly instructed jury could possibly return a conviction on the basis of his actions alone.^[32] Federal prosecutors said they were reviewing the decision to consider whether to appeal it in turn, or retry.^[33]

2008 Tobin indictment

After over a year of no further legal or investigative developments, on October 9, 2008, a federal grand jury in Maine indicted Tobin anew on two counts of making false statements to FBI agents. At that time Shaheen and Sununu were reprising their 2002 race, which Shaheen won.^[34] These subsequent charges were summarily dismissed in 2009 after the federal judge in Maine's District Court found them motivated by 'vindictive prosecution.'^[35]

Other developments

Noel Hillman, who was credited with moving the case to trial as head of the Justice Department's Public Integrity Section, was nominated^[36] for a federal judgeship by President Bush in January 2006.

Also that month, the NHGOP filed a countersuit against the state's Democratic Party, alleging that the Democratic lawsuit against them was merely part of a national effort to advance the party's interests in an election year^[37] and that the Democrats were abusing the court process to hinder NHGOP's efforts to engage in constitutionally protected political activities. On December 1, the two parties settled for a total of $125,000, payable by the Republicans to the Democrats, in $25,000 annual installments over the next five years. The RNC and NRSC will also each make two $5,000 contributions to charities associated with the Manchester fire and police departments.^[38]

Charles McGee served seven months in prison, and now works at campaign school for GOP candidates, run by a Republican political marketing firm.^[39]

White House connections

A Democratic analysis of phone records introduced at Tobin's criminal trial show he made 115 outgoing calls to the White House between September 17 and November 22, 2002.^[40] Two dozen of the calls were made from 9:28 a.m. the day before the election through 2:17 a.m. the night after the voting, a three-day period during which the phone jamming operation was finalized, carried out, and then abruptly shut down.

Virtually all the calls to the White House went to the same number, which currently rings inside the political affairs office. In 2002, that office was headed by Ken Mehlman, who later became the chair of the Republican National Committee. The White House has declined to say which staffer was assigned that phone number in 2002.

The national Republican Party, which has continued to pay millions in legal bills to defend Tobin, says the phone calls involved routine election business and that it was "preposterous" to suggest the calls involved phone jamming.^[41][42] Mehlman said that the calls were simply part of the many he and his assistant made to field operatives in competitive races all over the country during that time period.^[43]

Later in April, the state Democratic Party asked Phillip Mangones, the judge presiding over its lawsuit against NHGOP, to allow them to question Mehlman. An activist said Mehlman's explanation that it was routine election-day campaign business is hard to reconcile with records showing Tobin continued to call Mehlman's office long after the election was decided in Sununu's favor. Republican consultant Joe Gaylord accused the Democrats of "trying to stir up crap."^[44]

Haley Barbour connection

On April 28, the Associated Press reported that Haley Barbour, the former RNC chair now serving as governor of Mississippi, had provided a $250,000 startup loan to GOP Marketplace through his investment company, HELM Partners, in 2000.^[45] While he claimed that his involvement ended there and that he had no idea at the time that the company would ever engage in criminal activity, its operating agreement^[46] shows that HELM retained a great deal of control over the company through a different class of stock and that Barbour's partner Ed Rogers had, as a result, equal control of the company with Raymond. Further investigations showed that HELM had only been incorporated shortly before GOP Marketplace was started and that the partnership never invested in any other company. Raymond also owned two-thirds of the company despite his initial investment of only $11,700.

Shaun Hansen

On March 27, 2006, Shaun Hansen, the former owner of Mylo, traveled from Idaho to New Hampshire to face one count each of conspiracy to commit telephone harassment and aiding and abetting telephone harassment. Prosecutors allege that he agreed to use his firm to jam six phone numbers with hangup calls on the day of the election for $2,500.^[47]

Unlike Tobin, Hansen's defense has not been paid for by any entities associated with the Republican Party. Instead, he is currently being represented by the federal public defender's office. The listing of possible defenses he might employ, as listed in his first filing, suggests he may have been led to believe, by Tobin and others, that the jamming was perfectly legal.^[48]

He pled guilty and is due to be sentenced in February 2007. Later he withdrew the guilty plea and sentencing was postponed until May 2008.^[49] The charges against Hansen were ultimately dismissed by the government.

Special prosecutor sought

On May 12, 2006, U.S. Rep John Conyers (Dem, Michigan) sent a formal request to U.S. Attorney Alberto Gonzales, asking him to name a special prosecutor to investigate the 2002 phone-jamming. Conyers, the senior Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee, said an independent counsel is necessary to investigate allegations that White House officials may have been involved in the scheme, pointing out that the US Department of Justice "appears not to be reviewing the extensive contacts between the plotters of the phone jamming and high-level Republican officials."^[50]

References

1. ^ [1]^{[dead link]}
2. ^ http://www.politicsnj.com/kornacki021003_Raymond.htm^{[dead link]}
3. ^ [2] Archived November 28, 2010 at the Wayback Machine
4. ^ [3]^{[dead link]}
5. ^ [4]^{[dead link]}
6. ^ "July 4, 2004 - July 10, 2004 Archives". Talking Points Memo. http://www.talkingpointsmemo.com/archives/week_2004_07_04.php#003132. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
7. ^ http://www.concordmonitor.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20041019/REPOSITORY/410190316/1037/NEWS04 Archived April 17, 2008 at the Wayback Machine
8. ^ http://www.talkingpointsmemo.com/docs/phone.jamming.motion.pdf
9. ^ "October 10, 2004 - October 16, 2004 Archives | TPM". Talkingpointsmemo.com. http://www.talkingpointsmemo.com/archives/week_2004_10_10.php#003694. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
10. ^ http://wid.ap.org/documents/tobinindictment.pdf
11. ^ http://www4.fosters.com/December_2004/12.13.04/news/ap_nh1213f.asp Archived April 11, 2008 at the Wayback Machine
12. ^ ^{a b} "July 17, 2005 - July 23, 2005". Talking Points Memo. http://www.talkingpointsmemo.com/archives/week_2005_07_17.php#006144. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
13. ^ [5] Archived March 5, 2006 at the Wayback Machine
14. ^ "Granite Status: Tobin legal defense may total $2.5 million - Thursday, Feb. 9, 2006". Unionleader.com. 2006-02-09. Archived from the original on September 26, 2007. http://web.archive.org/web/20070926235936/http://www.unionleader.com/article.aspx?headline=Granite+Status:+Tobin+legal+defense+may+total+$2.5+million&articleId=3a7de6ef-08b7-4087-94f5-6fb654738e39. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
15. ^ "Columns". Union Leader. 2010-08-12. Archived from the original on December 30, 2009. http://web.archive.org/web/20091230081152/http://www.unionleader.com/columns.aspx/Opinion?channel=139832ce-97eb-4460-bf99-b71df3b7f0cc. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
16. ^ ^{a b} Joe Bergeron (2007-02-19). "NH Phone Jamming Conspiracy Case Widens - Lost Nation.tv - Political news, commentary, satire and cartoons". Lost Nation.tv. Archived from the original on September 19, 2008. http://web.archive.org/web/20080919032218/http://lostnation.tv/html/jamming1.html. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
17. ^ "Schedule A for ALL Line #'s". Query.nictusa.com. http://query.nictusa.com/cgi-bin/dcdev/forms/C00136457/95264/sa/ALL. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
18. ^ "Granite Status: Big names seek state GOP, Dem posts - Thursday, Dec. 21, 2006". Unionleader.com. 2006-12-21. http://www.unionleader.com/article.aspx?headline=Granite+Status%3A+Big+names+seek+state+GOP%2C+Dem+posts&articleId=798a2e12-f4b8-4a91-83cf-201041219272. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
19. ^ [6]^{[dead link]}
20. ^ Talking Points Memo |
21. ^ [7]^{[dead link]}
22. ^ "Phone jamming trial begins". Concord Monitor. 2005-12-07. Archived from the original on April 17, 2008. http://web.archive.org/web/20080417063020/http://concordmonitor.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20051207/REPOSITORY/512070354/1227/NEWS95. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
23. ^ [8] Archived July 10, 2008 at the Wayback Machine
24. ^ "Witnesses describe GOP official's role". Concord Monitor. 2005-12-08. http://concordmonitor.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20051208/REPOSITORY/512080350/1227/NEWS95. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
25. ^ "Testimony wraps in phone-jam case". Concord Monitor. 2005-12-09. http://concordmonitor.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20051209/REPOSITORY/512090341/1227/NEWS95. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
26. ^ "New Hampshire and Manchester news, weather, business and sports - New Hampshire's newspaper". Theunionleader.com. http://www.theunionleader.com/article.aspx?headline=Tobin+convicted+on+phone-jam+charges&articleId=241bdd6c-2742-4f4f-b360-a860191decd0. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
27. ^ "Ex-GOP official guilty on two counts". Concord Monitor. 2005-12-16. http://concordmonitor.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20051216/REPOSITORY/512160355/1001/NEWS01. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
28. ^ "The TPM DOCUMENT COLLECTION - James Tobin Government Sentencing Memo". Talkingpointsmemo.com. Archived from the original on April 05, 2009. http://web.archive.org/web/20090405233739/http://www.talkingpointsmemo.com/docs/tobin-sentencing-memo/. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
29. ^ [9] Archived March 21, 2007 at the Wayback Machine
30. ^ Post Store (2006-05-17). "GOP Official Faces Sentence in Phone-Jamming". washingtonpost.com. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/05/16/AR2006051601712.html. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
31. ^ [10] Archived April 11, 2008 at the Wayback Machine
32. ^ http://betsydevine.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2007/03/20070321opinion.rtf Archived 24 June 2007 at WebCite
33. ^ "Item Not Found — SFGate". Sfgate.com. Archived from the original on October 16, 2008. http://web.archive.org/web/20081016064940/http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/n/a/2007/03/21/national/a151832D16.DTL. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
34. ^ Sharp, David (2008-10-14). "2002 GOP phone jamming in NH leads to new charges". Associated Press. http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5gpziglTzKEL0hFAxQf4ShPDRCz6QD93QGI300. Retrieved 2008-10-15. 
35. ^ Harrison, Judy (18 February 2009). "District judge clears Tobin". Bangor Daily News. http://www.bangordailynews.com/detail/99819.html. Retrieved 2010-10-02. 
36. ^ Shenon, Philip; Bumiller, Elisabeth (2006-01-27). "Prosecutor Will Step Down From Lobbyist Case". The New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2006/01/27/politics/27judge.html?_r=2. 
37. ^ "Phone jamming: GOP fires back - Sunday, Jan. 8, 2006". Unionleader.com. 2006-01-08. http://www.unionleader.com/article.aspx?headline=Phone+jamming:+GOP+fires+back&articleId=c2ca1af0-f665-435f-92bc-ea12dafb1d56. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
38. ^ "State GOP to pay Democrats $125,000 in phone-jam suit - Sunday, Dec. 3, 2006". Unionleader.com. 2006-12-03. http://unionleader.com/article.aspx?headline=State+GOP+to+pay+Democrats+%24125%2c000+in+phone-jam+suit&articleId=2320c548-2803-401e-81c8-926238b329ec. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
39. ^ Fahrenthold, David A. (2006-05-29). "Lead figure in phone jam to advise GOP contenders". Concord Monitor. http://www.concordmonitor.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060529/REPOSITORY/605290320. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
40. ^ http://www.senatemajority.com/files/EXHIBITA.pdf Archived January 1, 2007 at the Wayback Machine
41. ^ "Granite Status: Meridian to guide Coburn race for governor - Thursday, Mar. 23, 2006". Unionleader.com. 2006-03-23. http://www.unionleader.com/article.aspx?headline=Granite+Status:+Meridian+to+guide+Coburn+race+for+governor&articleId=1a0f8a86-a086-40a6-8963-65395f7767fc. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
42. ^ [11]^{[dead link]}
43. ^ Jeremy Kenney. "Barack's Birthday Cards". Gop.com. http://www.gop.com/News/Read.aspx?ID=6237. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
44. ^ Przybyla, Heidi (2006-04-24). "Senate Vote Inquiry Widens as Democrats Probe White House Link". Bloomberg. http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=10000103&sid=aQGLEwqlIdHo&refer=us. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
45. ^ [12]^{[dead link]}
46. ^ http://www.senatemajority.com/files/GOPMKTPLACEOPERATINGAGREEMENTFULL.pdf Archived August 29, 2006 at the Wayback Machine
47. ^ "Issue Experts. Unique Connections. Maximum Impact". Releases.usnewswire.com. http://releases.usnewswire.com/GetRelease.asp?id=62974. Retrieved 2010-08-29. 
48. ^ http://www.senatemajority.com/node/425 Archived November 11, 2006 at the Wayback Machine
49. ^ McCormack, Kathy (21 February 2008). "Ex-GOP Official Acquitted in Call Scheme". Fox News. http://www.foxnews.com/wires/2008Feb21/0,4670,PhoneJamming,00.html. 
50. ^ [13]^{[dead link]}

External links

• 2002 Election NH "Phone Jamming" Case on SourceWatch
• How High Did It Go?
• Did White House help jam phone calls in election?
• Liberal group files Abramoff complaint in New Hampshire
• Phonegate: Jamming Democrats' Campaign Efforts
• Phone-jamming civil suit is settled