Efforts to impeach George W. Bush

During the presidency of George W. Bush, several American politicians sought to either investigate Bush for allegedly impeachable offenses, or to bring actual impeachment charges on the floor of the United States House of Representatives. The most significant of these efforts occurred on June 10, 2008, when Congressman Dennis Kucinich, along with co-sponsor Robert Wexler, introduced 35 articles of impeachment ^[1] against Bush to the U.S. House of Representatives.^[2] The House voted 251 to 166 to refer the impeachment resolution to the Judiciary Committee on July 25, where no further action was taken on it.^[3] Bush's presidency ended on January 20, 2009 with the completion of his second term in office, rendering impeachment efforts moot.

Kucinich/Wexler impeachment articles

The Kucinich/Wexler impeachment resolution contained 35 articles covering the Iraq war, the Valerie Plame affair, creating a case for war with Iran, capture and treatment of prisoners of war, spying and or wiretapping inside the United States, use of signing statements, failing to Comply with Congressional Subpoenas, the 2004 elections, medicare, Hurricane Katrina, global warming, and 9/11.^[1]

The 2003 invasion of Iraq was the most substantial portion of the articles of impeachment introduced by Kucinich and Wexler. 15 of the 35 articles directly relate to alleged misconduct by Bush in seeking authority for the war, and in the conduct of military action itself. Five other articles address allegations partially or tertiarily relating to the war, including the "outing" of Valerie Plame, treatment of prisoners (both in Iraq and from operations in Afghanistan and other countries), and building a case for Iran being a threat based in part on alleging Iranian actions in Iraq.

Justification for invasion

Further information: Iraq and weapons of mass destruction, Saddam Hussein and al-Qaeda, Downing Street memo, Bush-Blair memo, Legitimacy of the 2003 invasion of Iraq, and Bush-Aznar memo

The first 4 impeachment articles charge the president with illegally creating a case for war with Iraq, including charges of a propaganda campaign, falsely representing Iraq as responsible for 9/11, and falsely representing Iraq as an imminent danger to the United States.^[1]

Legitimacy of invasion

Further information: UN Charter, War of aggression, Jus ad bellum, and Legitimacy of the 2003 invasion of Iraq

Articles 5 - 8 and 12 deal with the invasion of Iraq and include charges that funds were misspent before the war, that the war was in violation of HJRes114, that Iraq was invaded without a war declaration, that the war is a violation of the UN Charter, and that the purpose of the war was to control the country's oil supplies.^[1][4]

Conduct of the Iraq war

Further information: 2003 invasion of Iraq

Articles 9, 10, 11, and 13 deal with conduct of the war, including failing to provide troops with body armor, falsifying US troop deaths and injuries, establishing a permanent military base in Iraq, and creating a secret task force to develop energy and military policies with respect to Iraq and other countries. Articles 15 and 16 cover contractors in Iraq and charges that the president misspent money on contractors and provided them with immunity.

Valerie Plame Wilson

Article 14 is about the outing of Valerie Plame Wilson.

Treatment of detainees

Further information: Abu Ghraib torture and prisoner abuse, Bagram torture and prisoner abuse, United Nations Convention Against Torture, Geneva Conventions, Command responsibility, and Hamdan v. Rumsfeld

Articles 17-20 concern the treatment of detainees, the "kidnapping" and detention of foreign nationals, and the use of torture.

Attempt to overthrow the government of Iran

Article 21 claims that the president misled congress and the American people about threats from Iran, and supported terrorist organizations within Iran, with the goal of overthrowing the Iranian government.

NSA warrantless surveillance controversy

Further information: NSA warrantless surveillance controversy and Separation of powers

Articles 24 and 25 charge the president with illegally spying on American citizens, directing US telecom companies to create databases of citizens, and violating the fourth amendment of the US constitution.

Signing statements

Further information: Signing statement#Controversy over George W. Bush's use of signing statements

Article 26 concerns the presidential use of signing statements.

Congressional subpoenas

Article 27 is about failing to comply with congressional subpoenas.

2004 elections

Further information: 2004 United States election voting controversies

Articles 28 and 29 charge the president with tampering with the 2004 elections and violating the Voting Rights Act of 1965.

Medicare

Article 30 states "Misleading Congress and the American People in an Attempt to Destroy Medicare."

Katrina

Further information: Criticism of government response to Hurricane Katrina

Article 31 concerns the supposed failure to plan and respond to Hurricane Katrina.

Global warming

Article 32 charges the president with "Systematically Undermining Efforts to Address Global Climate Change."

9/11

Articles 33, 34 and 35 concern 9/11, alleging that the president failed to respond to prior intelligence, obstructed post 9/11 investigations and endangered the health of 9/11 first responders.

Political views and actions

Democrats in Congress

John Conyers, who had previously advocated the impeachment of George W. Bush, called for an investigation of the President in 2005.

On June 16, 2005 Rep. John Conyers (D-MI) assembled an unofficial meeting to discuss the Downing Street memo and to consider grounds for impeachment.

Conyers filed a resolution on December 18, 2005 to create an investigative committee to consider impeachment. His resolution gained 38 co-sponsors before it expired at the end of the 109th Congress. He did not reintroduce a similar resolution for the 110th Congress.^[5]

Keith Ellison was the leading figure behind the resolution to impeach Bush brought to the Minnesota State House of Representatives in May 2006.^[6] Ellison was elected to the United States House of Representatives in November 2006. During the campaign and when he was named to the House Judiciary Committee, Ellison repeatedly called for an investigation into a possible impeachment.^[7] In support of his candidacy, he “received a $1,000 contribution from ImpeachPAC”.^[8] Later, on April 22, 2007, Ellison met with constituents and listed new conditions for his support for impeachment hearings, such as verifiable facts and the backing of a majority of the American people.^[9]

At another unofficial hearing convened by Conyers on January 20, 2006, Rep. Jerrold Nadler (D-NY) called for the committee to explore whether Bush should face impeachment, stemming from his decision to authorize domestic surveillance without court review.

On May 10, 2006, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) indicated she was not interested in pursuing impeachment and had taken it "off the table", reiterating this phrase on November 8, 2006.^[10][11] In July 2007, Pelosi stated that she "would probably advocate" impeaching Bush if she were not in the House nor Speaker of the House.^[12]

On December 8, 2006 (the last day of the 109th Congress), then-Representative Cynthia McKinney (D-GA) submitted a resolution, H. Res. 1106. The bill expired along with the 109th Congress.^[13]

John Conyers brought up the subject of impeachment on the July 8, 2007 broadcast of This Week with George Stephanopoulos,^[14] stating:

We're hoping that as the cries for the removal of both Cheney and Bush now reach 46 percent and 58 percent, respectively, for impeachment, that we could begin to become a little bit more cooperative, if not even amicable, in trying to get to the truth of these matters.

Presidential candidate Dennis Kucinich's major point in the Democratic Presidential Debate on October 30, 2007 was that Bush and Cheney should be impeached for the Iraq war.^[15][16] On November 6, 2007, Kucinich introduced a resolution to impeach Vice President Cheney in the House of Representatives.^[17]

In November 2007, Joe Biden, then a candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination in 2008, stated that he would move to impeach if President Bush were to bomb Iran without first gaining congressional approval.^[18] However, no such bombing occurred during the rest of Bush's term.

On June 9, 2008, Representative Dennis Kucinich (D-Ohio), introduced a resolution, H.Res. 1258, to impeach president George W. Bush, which included 35 counts in the articles of impeachment. At the end of the evening on June 10, Kucinich offered a motion to refer HRes 1258 to the House Judiciary Committee. On June 11, the House voted 251-166 to send the resolution to the Committee.^[19]

On July 14, 2008, Kucinich introduced a new impeachment resolution (H.Res. 1345) limited to a single count.

State-level Democratic party actions

On March 21, 2006 the New Mexico Democratic Party, at a convention in Albuquerque, adopted a plank to their platform saying “the Democratic Party of New Mexico supports the impeachment of George Bush and his lawful removal from office.”^[20]

On March 24, 2007, the Vermont Democratic State Committee voted to support JRH 15, a state legislative resolution supporting impeachment, calling for its passage as "appropriate action."^[21]

On January 2, 2008, Betty Hall (D), an 87-year-old, fourteen-term State Representative, introduced New Hampshire House Resolution 24 in the State-Federal Relations and Veterans Affairs Committee of the New Hampshire House of Representatives.^[22] The resolution was "petitioning Congress to commence impeachment procedures" against Bush and Cheney for "high crimes and misdemeanors", including domestic spying, illegal detentions, signing statements, electioneering, the breaking of international treaties, and war crimes.^[23] The bill further asserted that "section 603 of Jefferson's Manual of Parliamentary Practice states that an impeachment may be set in motion by the United States House of Representatives by charges transmitted from the legislature of a state".^[23]

On February 20, 2008, the bill was ruled "Inexpedient to Legislate" to pass by a 10 to 5 vote within committee, which passed the resolution on to the full House for a vote.^[22] The bill was tabled in the New Hampshire House of Representatives on April 16, 2008.^[22] After three efforts to have the bill removed from the table were unsuccessful, it died on the table on September 24, 2008.^[22]

See also

Impeachment investigations of United States federal officials

References

1. ^ ^{a b c d} H. Res. 1258, 110th Cong. (2008).
2. ^ Man, Anthony (June 10, 2008). "Impeach Bush, Wexler says". South Florida Sun-Sentinel.com. http://weblogs.sun-sentinel.com/news/politics/broward/blog/2008/06/impeach_bush_wexler_says.html. Retrieved 2008-06-10. 
3. ^ http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?d110:HE01258:@@@X
4. ^ The Constitution in Crisis; The Downing Street Minutes and Deception, Manipulation, Torture, Retribution, and Coverups in the Iraq War Investigative Status Report of the House Judiciary Committee Democratic Staff
5. ^ H.RES.635 - Creating a select committee to investigate the Administration's intent to go to war before congressional authorization, manipulation of pre-war intelligence, encouraging and countenancing torture, retaliating against critics, and to make recommendations regarding grounds for possible impeachment Sponsor: Rep Conyers, John, Jr. (introduced December 18, 2005)
6. ^ Wilson, Conrad (2006-12-08). "The Insurgent". http://www.prospect.org/web/page.ww?section=root&name=ViewWeb&articleId=12284. Retrieved January 27, 2007. 
7. ^ Pugmire, Tim (2006-08-09). "Ellison compares Bush to Nixon". Minnesota Public Radio. http://minnesota.publicradio.org/collections/special/columns/polinaut/archive/2006/08/mprs_tim_pugmir.shtml. Retrieved January 27, 2007. 
8. ^ Hotakainen, Rob (2007-01-25). "Will Ellison pursue impeachment? Not for now, he says". Star Tribune. http://www.startribune.com/587/story/960880.html. ^{[dead link]} Retrieved January 27, 2007
9. ^ Rudolph, Mikael (April 23, 2007). ""Impeachment Should Be on the Table": Rep. Keith Ellison (D-MN)". http://www.opednews.com/articles/genera_mikael_r_070422__22impeachment_should_.htm. 
10. ^ Democrats Won't Try to Impeach President by Charles Babington, Washington Post, 12 May 2006
11. ^ Pelosi Says Democrats Are Ready to Lead by NANCY ZUCKERBROD, Associated Press, 8 November 2006
12. ^ Ari Berman:Why Pelosi Opposes Impeachment. The Nation, 07/31/2007
13. ^ Evans, Ben (2006-12-08). "McKinney Introduces Bill to Impeach Bush". Associated Press. http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/n/a/2006/12/08/national/w152917S79.DTL. 
14. ^ clip of Rep. Conyers on This Week with George Stephanopoulos, YouTube
15. ^ Spillius, Alex (2 November 2007). "US presidential candidate insists he saw UFO". Philadelphia: Telegraph. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2007/11/01/wufo101.xml. Retrieved 2008-10-27. 
16. ^ "Poll: Vermont Wants Bush, Cheney Impeached, Nearly Two-Thirds Of State's Likely Voters Want President, VP Removed Before Term Ends - CBS News". Cbsnews.com. November 1, 2007. http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2007/11/01/politics/main3440466.shtml. Retrieved 2008-10-27. 
17. ^ CLAFFEY, JASON. "Dover NH, Rochester NH, Portsmouth NH, Laconia NH, Sanford ME". DURHAM: Fosters.com. http://www.fosters.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20071122/GJNEWS_01/711220060. Retrieved 2008-10-27. 
18. ^ Leech, Adam. "Biden: Impeachment if Bush bombs Iran". Seacoastonline.com. http://www.seacoastonline.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20071129/NEWS/71129018. Retrieved 2008-10-27. 
19. ^ "Impeaching George W. Bush, President of the United States, of high crimes and misdemeanors". Thomas.loc.gov. http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?d110:HE01258:@@@L&summ2=m&. Retrieved 2008-10-27. 
20. ^ Jones, Jeff (2006-03-21). "N.M. Dems Call For Bush's Exit". http://www.abqjournal.com/news/state/443722nm03-21-06.htm. Retrieved 2007-01-27. 
21. ^ Vermont: 36 towns call for impeachment probe of president, by Shay Totten & Christian Avard Vermont Guardian, March 6, 2007.
22. ^ ^{a b c d} Docket of HR24, New Hampshire General Court - Bill Status System.
23. ^ ^{a b} HR 24 – AS INTRODUCED, NH General Court - Bill Status System.

Further reading

• John Bonifaz, Warrior King: The Case for Impeaching George Bush, (2003) ISBN 1-56025-606-0
• Dave Lindorff & Barbara Olshansky, The Case for Impeachment: The Legal Argument for Removing President George W. Bush from Office, (2006) ISBN 0-312-36016-9
• Dennis Loo & Peter Phillips, Eds., Impeach the President: the Case Against Bush and Cheney, (2006) ISBN 978-1-58322-743-5
• John Nichols, The Genius of Impeachment: The Founders' Cure for Royalism, (2006) ISBN 978-1595581402
• Elizabeth de la Vega, U.S. v. Bush, (2006) ISBN 978-1-58322-756-5
• Charles Black, Impeachment: A Handbook (Yale Fastback Series), (1998 Reissue) ISBN 0-300-07950-8^{[dubious – discuss]}
• Glenn Greenwald, How Would a Patriot Act? Defending American Values from a President Run Amok, (2006) ISBN 0-9779440-0-X
• Elizabeth Holtzman with Cynthia Cooper, The Impeachment of George W Bush A Practical Guide for Concerned Citizens, (2006) ISBN 156025940X
• Marjorie Cohn , Cowboy Republic: Six Ways the Bush Gang Has Defied the Law, (2007) ISBN 0977825337
• Charlie Savage , Takeover: The Return of the Imperial Presidency and the Subversion of American Democracy, (2007) ISBN 0316118052

External links

• The 35 Articles of Impeachment and the Case for Prosecuting George W. Bush, by Congressman Dennis Kucinich. Free PDF.
• Feingold to Introduce Resolutions Censuring President Bush, Vice President Cheney, and Other Administration Officials (July 22, 2007)
• Bill Moyers Journal of July 13, 2007 "Tough Talk on Impeachment" focusing on the constitutional issues
• The Impeachment of George W. Bush an article in the January 30, 2006 issue of The Nation magazine