Bocuse d'Or

Paul Bocuse, president founder of the Bocuse d'Or

The Bocuse d'Or (the Concours mondial de la cuisine, World Cooking Contest) is a biennial world chef championship. Named for the chef Paul Bocuse, the event takes place during two days near the end of January in Lyon, France at the SIRHA International Hotel, Catering and Food Trade Exhibition, and is one of the world's most prestigious cooking competitions.^{[1][2][3][4][5]}

The event is frequently referred to as the culinary equivalent of the Olympic Games,^{[6][7][8][9][10][11]} though the International Exhibition of Culinary Art in Germany, is more officially titled the Culinary Olympics,^[12] and is separated by an olympiad, i.e. a period of four years.

History

Based on an event first arranged in 1983, when the Salon des Métiers de Bouche (Culinary Sector Exhibition and Trade Fair, later renamed Salon international de la restauration de l'hôtellerie et de l'alimentation, SIRHA) took place in Lyon as "an exhibition organised by professionals for professionals". Paul Bocuse, appointed Honorary President of the exhibition, conceived the idea of a culinary competition to take place during the exhibition, with preparation of all dishes taking place live in front of an audience. Several gastronomy contests were already in existence, however none of them presented a "live performance" and consequently one could not actually see the work performed in the kitchens of the chefs' restaurants.^[13]

The initial Bocuse d'Or took place in January 1987.^[14] The SIRHA, having grown to become one of the biggest and most sophisticated food and culinary arts fairs in the world,^[15] also arranges other contests of culinary skill, including the Coupe du Monde de la Pâtisserie (World Pastry Cup) and in recent years Mondial du Pain (World of Bread Contest).

The audience atmosphere of the Bocuse d'Or evolved in 1997 when the support for the Mexican candidate included a mariachi band, foghorns, cowbells, cheering and yelling from the stands, marking the beginning of a tradition of noisy spectator presence.^[16] At first, the reigning champion nation was not permitted to participate in the following contest, but that rule was removed after the 1999 event when France was competing and did not win gold for the first time.^[16]

France, the invariable home team, has won gold on six occasions, while Belgium, Norway and Sweden have consistently finished in one of the top three placements.^[1][11][17] Léa Linster of Luxembourg became the first woman to win in 1989, and Rasmus Kofoed of Denmark became the first multiple medalist with bronze and silver in 2005 and 2007, and the eventual gold medal in 2011.^[18] The U.S. team has to date never placed higher than sixth as in 2003 and 2009,^{[5][7][11][19][20]} while the highest ranking of a North American chef yet is the fourth place result of Canadian Robert Sulatycky in 1999.^[1][21]

The 2007 Bocuse d'Or was featured in the documentary film, El Pollo, el Pez, y el Cangrejo Real.^[5] The U.S. effort leading up to the 2009 Bocuse d'Or is the subject of the book Knives at Dawn.^[22]

Semi-finals

After its 20th anniversary, the format was expanded, with the first Bocuse d'Or Asia contest taking place in May 2008 in Shanghai and Bocuse d'Or Europe in July 2008 in Stavanger. The inaugural winners were Yasuji Sasaki from Japan and Geir Skeie of Norway, respectively.^[23] Skeie went on to win the 2009 world final.^{[17][24][25][26]}

The inaugural Bocuse d'Or USA competition took place at Epcot in September 2008, and an escalated effort followed with Team USA provided with a preparation budget near $500,000 ahead of the 2009 finals, citing that many European nations often have budgets of more than $1 million. Team USA was represented by Timothy Hollingsworth, then sous-chef at French Laundry, coached by Roland Henin.^{[5][7][11][27][28]} Paul Bocuse stated, "I hope [the U.S. team] will win because we'd really like this competition to cross the Atlantic".^[20] Ultimately, Hollingsworth also placed sixth.^[24][26]

The Bocuse d'Or USA 2010 took place at the earlier February 2010 date arranged at The Culinary Institute of America in Hyde Park, New York. The winner was James Kent who represented Team USA in Lyon in 2011, eventually placing tenth.^[29][30][31] The Bocuse d'Or Asia 2010 was again arranged in Shanghai in March 2010, won by the Malaysian all-women team of See Lay Na.^[32][33] The Bocuse d'Or Europe 2010 arranged in Geneva in June 2010 was won by Danish previous Bocuse d'Or bronze and silver medalist Rasmus Kofoed,^[34] who went on to win the 2011 world final.^[18]

Ahead of the Bocuse d'Or 2013, the Bocuse d'Or USA regional final is arranged in late January 2012 again at The Culinary Institute of America,^[35] while Bocuse d'Or Europe is arranged in Brussels in March 2012,^[36] and Bocuse d'Or Asia to be held in in June 2012 once more in Shanghai.

Criticism

For the 2005 Bocuse d'Or, the Spanish delegation had chosen innovative presentation inspired by Salvador Dalí motifs, for the fish course a serving vessel in the shape of a one meter high crystal egg, as a part of an ambitious campaign at the cost of near €1 million to achieve a good result in the competition.^[37] However, the Spanish candidate finished in the next to last place, (a cited reason that the warm dish produced such condensation to the inside of the egg that the judges were near unable to see the presentation) producing heated reactions from the Spanish delegation who called the jury old-fashioned and outdated,^[37] and members of the Spanish media who claimed that the chauvinistic jury despised the creativity of Spanish cooking and called the Bocuse d'Or a competition for buffet and catering.^[38][39]

Controversy arose during the 2007 Bocuse d'Or, as allegations of cheating were raised against the winning chef Fabrice Desvignes, due to the late delivery of two metal containers leading to claims that these contained prepared precooked ingredients.^[40] A contest director responded that the containers were delivered to Desvignes two minutes before he started work because snow delayed their overnight arrival, and these contained silverware and foie gras, not prohibited by the rules.^[16] Two days later the German daily newspaper Die Welt published the article "Gourmet-Skandal: Ist der weltbeste Koch wirklich ein Franzose?" (Gourmet Scandal: Is the World's Best Chef Really a Frenchman?), featuring testimony by the German assistant chef Khabbaz Hicham who described four men that brought black crates with prepared and semi-prepared ingredients, an hour and thirty minutes into the competition.^{[41][42][43][44][45]} The controversy lead to amendments to the rules for future Bocuse d'Or contests, with the addition of a Kitchen Supervising Committee to control the candidate products and equipment.

The U.S. effort also was impeded in the 2007 finals, with the unfortunate experience of the candidate Gavin Kaysen. Upon presenting his second platter, a wheel-shaped ballotine of chicken, with chicken liver, foie gras and Louisiana crayfish, it was discovered that a French dishwasher had eaten two of the intended garnishes in the belief the food was rejected. Kaysen finished in fourteenth place.^[5][6][20]

Competition

The qualification format has seen changes over the years, with a restructured scheme ahead of the 2009 Bocuse d'Or. 24 countries compete in the world finals, having achieved entry through different means: The top 12 finalists of the Bocuse d'Or Europe qualify, from a pool of 20 nations; the top 4 finalists of Bocuse d'Or Asia qualify, from a pool of 12 nations; the top 3 finalists of the Copa Azteca Latin American competition qualify, from a pool of 12 nations. Furthermore 3 entrants are selected from national application, as well as 2 wild card selections.

Each team consists of two chefs, one lead chef, and a commis/assistant chef who must be under 22 years of age at the time of the competition.^[2][20] The team has 5 hours and 35 minutes to prepare two elaborate presentations, a meat dish and a fish dish.^{[4][5][20][46][47]} Taking place in an open "culinary theatre", fully equipped kitchens are lined up side by side, facing an area for the jury, members of the press and audiences,^[10] with spectator numbers limited to ca. 1,000 people.^[37] From the 2009 contest, a designated coach located on the outside of the kitchen area is permitted to communicate with the team.^[48] Also as of 2009, inspectors control equipment and products the backstage zone, as no vegetables may be pre-cut, although teams may pre-peel garlic, portion oil, salt, flour and other ingredients, and bring stocks made in advance.^[49]

The jury consists of 24 renowned chef judges who make their evaluations based on the level of perfection in the presentation, in terms of technical skill, cooking sophistication, creativity and visual beauty. The jury is divided into two groups of 12, each half to judge either the fish dish or the meat dish.^[48] The food's quality determines two-thirds of the score, 40 points; presentation determines 20 points. In the event of a tie, another 20 points will be awarded based on factors such as organization, teamwork, cleanliness and lack of waste.^[20] Judges have included Heston Blumenthal, Ferran Adrià, Wolfgang Puck,^[1] Eyvind Hellstrøm, Thomas Keller and past winners such as Fabrice Desvignes, Mathias Dahlgren and Léa Linster.

The chef with the highest overall score is awarded the Bocuse d'Or trophy, a golden effigy of Paul Bocuse in his chef's outfit,^[20] receiving the grand prize of €20,000. The Silver Bocuse medallist receives €15,000, and the Bronze Bocuse medallist receives €10,000.^[5][47] Additional prizes are awarded for the best fish and meat dishes, best national culinary identity, best apprentice and best posters.^[10]

Medalists

Geir Skeie, winner of the 2008 Bocuse d'Or Europe and 2009 Bocuse d'Or

Year	Bocuse d'Or	Silver Bocuse	Bronze Bocuse
1987	Jacky Freon	Michel Addons	Hans Haas
1989	Léa Linster	Pierre Paulus	William Wai
1991	Michel Roth	Lars Erik Underthun	Gert Jan Raven
1993	Bent Stiansen	Jens Peter Kolbeck	Guy Van Cauteren
1995	Régis Marcon	Melker Andersson	Patrick Jaros
1997	Mathias Dahlgren	Roland Debuyst	Odd Ivar Solvold
1999	Terje Ness	Yannick Alleno	Ferdy Debecker
2001	François Adamski	Henrik Norström	Hákon Már Örvarsson
2003	Charles Tjessem	Frank Putelat	Claus Weitbrecht
2005	Serge Vieira	Tom Victor Gausdal	Rasmus Kofoed
2007	Fabrice Desvignes	Rasmus Kofoed	Frank Giovannini
2009	Geir Skeie	Jonas Lundgren	Philippe Mille
2011	Rasmus Kofoed	Tommy Myllymäki	Gunnar Hvarnes

References

• List of prizewinners; Participating countriesPDF (44.0 KB) ; Bocuse d'Or 2009 press kitPDF (1.07 MB) Bocusedor.com

Footnotes

1. ^ ^{a b c d} Chavich, Cinda, The Globe and Mail (May 14, 2008). Even chefs dream of statuettes
2. ^ ^{a b} Shore, Randy, The Vancouver Sun (January 9, 2009). David Wong is Canada's next great hope for the Bocuse d'Or
3. ^ Appell, David, Los Angeles Times (July 23, 2008). Paul Bocuse could make French fast food the next nouvelle cuisine
4. ^ ^{a b} Stukin, Stacie, Time (January 18, 2007). To Be the Real Top Chef
5. ^ ^{a b c d e f g} Abend, Lisa, Time (January 25, 2009). An American Underdog Dreams of Kitchen Gold
6. ^ ^{a b} Smillie, Dirk, Forbes.com (June 5, 2007). French Toast
7. ^ ^{a b c} Fabricant, Florence, The New York Times (May 28, 2008). Tilting at the Bocuse d’Or
8. ^ Wasilczyk, Jacqueline, Zagat (November 5, 2008). U.S. Turns Up the Heat for Bocuse d'Or
9. ^ New York Magazine: Grub Street (July 17, 2008). Hung Huynh Is Among U.S. Bocuse d’Or Semifinalists
10. ^ ^{a b c} Lancaster, Deana, North Shore News (November 26, 2008). On the long road to Lyon
11. ^ ^{a b c d} Hallock, Betty, Los Angeles Times (January 26, 2009). American chef preps for cooking fame at France's Bocuse d'Or
12. ^ Dixon, Rachel, The Guardian: Nibbles (October 23, 2008). What are the Culinary Olympics?
13. ^ bocusedorasia.com History of the Bocuse d'Or
14. ^ Warwick, Joe, The Independent (July 20, 2008). Bites: Will it be douze points for Torquay?
15. ^ Sciolino, Elaine, The New York Times: Diner's Journal (January 27, 2009). Beyond the Bocuse d’Or
16. ^ ^{a b c} Hallock, Betty, Los Angeles Times: Daily Dish (January 27, 2009). Tracking the Bocuse d'Or: Meet France's Philippe Mille
17. ^ ^{a b} Criscione, Valeria, The Wall Street Journal (September 4, 2009). A League of Extraordinary Chefs
18. ^ ^{a b} Bloomberg.com (January 26, 2011). Danish Chef Rasmus Wins Bocuse D'or as Gourmets Pick World's Best Cooking
19. ^ Cowin, Diana, Food & Wine (February 2009). Competing at the Bocuse d’Or: Team USA’s Unbeatable Recipes
20. ^ ^{a b c d e f g} Sciolino, Elaine, The New York Times (January 26, 2009). High Hopes for American Team in Bocuse d’Or Cooking Competition
21. ^ Pawsey, Tim, Vancouver Courier (January 23, 2009). Dynamic duo invades France
22. ^ Terrebonne, Jacqueline, Slashfood.com (December 8, 2009). Bocuse d'Or Fever Hits American Culinary World
23. ^ Holt, Morten, Horecanytt (August 15, 2008). Bocuse d'Or-nasjonene er klare (Norwegian)
24. ^ ^{a b} Sciolino, Elaine, The New York Times (January 28, 2009). Norway Wins the Bocuse d’Or Competition
25. ^ Lindeberg, Anne, Dagens Næringsliv (January 28, 2009). Bocuse d’Or til Geir Skeie (Norwegian)
26. ^ ^{a b} Abend, Lisa, Time (January 28, 2009). No Medal for U.S. at Cooking Olympics
27. ^ Wells, Pete, The New York Times (September 28, 2008). French Laundry Sous Chef Will Represent U.S. in Bocuse d’Or
28. ^ Reuters.com (September 28, 2008). Bocuse d'Or USA Announces Winner
29. ^ Gallagher, Aileen, New York Magazine: Grub Street (February 7, 2010). New Yorker Will Represent U.S. at Bocuse d'Or
30. ^ Weiss, Jan, Dine Magazine (February 6, 2010). James Kent Wins Bocuse d’Or USA
31. ^ The Huffington Post (January 26, 2011). Scandinavian Sweep At Bocuse d'Or, Team USA Uses White House Honey
32. ^ The Independent (March 20, 2010). 'Bocuse d'Or' Asia: results
33. ^ Jayaraj, Jayagandi, The Star (September 19, 2009). Sous chef prepares to compete against Asia’s best
34. ^ Politiken (June 8, 2010). Stjernekokke kroner dansk europamester (Danish)
35. ^ Rodbard, Matt, Food Republic (October 17, 2011). The Culinary World Has An Olympics Too
36. ^ horecanytt.no Hvem får Bocuse d'Or Europe 2014? (Norwegian)
37. ^ ^{a b c} Anker, Nils, Dagens Næringsliv: D2 (January 24, 2009). "- Har jobbet mot dette i femten år" (in Norwegian). http://www.dn.no/d2/mat/article1588750.ece. 
38. ^ Portero, Pilar El Mundo (January 28, 2005). El chef Mario Sandoval, relegado al penúltimo puesto del 'Bocuse d'or' (Spanish)
39. ^ Capel, José Carlos, El País (February 5, 2005). Doble decepción en el concurso Bocuse d'Or (Spanish)
40. ^ Bremner, Charles. Tourres, Marie. The Times (January 29, 2007). We were whipped by cheat chef, say the losing cooks
41. ^ de Frumerie, Mattias, Restaurantören (February 22, 2007). Fuskmisstanke i kock-VM (Swedish)
42. ^ Lisinski, Stefan, Dagens Nyheter (February 23, 2007). Fuskanklagelser i kock-VM (Swedish)
43. ^ Fiskå, Borghild, Aftenposten (May 5, 2008). Et fransk narrespill (Norwegian)
44. ^ Winther, Anne, Avisen.dk. (December 12, 2007). Snyd i verdens største kokkekonkurrence (Danish)
45. ^ Lyon Capitale (February 16, 2007). Bocuse d'Or: les Danois contestent les résultats (open letter by Karsten Kroman)
46. ^ Houck, Jeff, The Tampa Tribune (September 24, 2008). A Top Chef Looks Ahead To America's Next Generation
47. ^ ^{a b} La Rose, Lauren, The Canadian Press (May 28, 2008). Canadian chef to battle for culinary honours
48. ^ ^{a b} Sciolino, Elaine, International Herald Tribune (January 28, 2009). "Chefs from around the globe go for gold". http://www.iht.com/articles/2009/01/27/travel/chefs.4-417210.php. 
49. ^ Sciolino, Elaine; Katz, Basil, The New York Times: Diner's Journal (January 27, 2009). Blogging the Bocuse d’Or Competition

External links

• Bocuse d'Or official site (French) (English)
• Bocuse d'Or video feed SIRHA