Electrical characteristics of dynamic loudspeakers

A dynamic loudspeaker driver's chief electrical characteristic is its electrical impedance versus frequency.

Explanation

The most common driver type is an electro-mechanical transducer using a voice coil rigidly connected to a diaphragm (generally a cone). Other types have similar connections, though differing in detail, between their acoustical environment and their electrical properties.

The voice coil in moving coil drivers is suspended in a magnetic field provided by the loudspeaker magnet structure. As electric current flows through voice coil (from an amplifier), the magnetic field created by the coil reacts against the magnet's fixed field and moves the voice coil (and so the cone). Alternating current will move the cone back and forth.

Resonance

The moving system of the loudspeaker (including the cone, cone suspension, spider and the voice coil) has a certain mass and compliance. This is most commonly likened to a simple mass suspended by a spring that has a certain resonant frequency at which the system will vibrate most freely.

This frequency is known as the "free-space resonance" of the speaker and is designated by "F"_s. At this frequency, since the voice coil is vibrating with the maximum peak-to-peak amplitude and velocity, the back-emf generated by coil motion in a magnetic field is also at its maximum. This causes the effective electrical impedance of the speaker to be at its maximum at "F"_s, shown as "Z"_max in the graph. For frequencies just below resonance, the impedance rises rapidly as the frequency approaches "F"_s and is inductive in nature.

At resonance, the impedance is purely resistive and beyond it -- as the impedance drops -- it behaves capacitively. The impedance reaches a minimum value ("Z"_min) at some frequency where the behaviour is fairly (but not perfectly) resistive over some range. A speaker's rated or nominal impedance ("Z"_nom) is derived from this "Z"_min value (see below).

Beyond the "Z"_min point the impedance is again largely inductive and continues to rise gradually. The frequency "F"_s and the frequencies above and below it where the impedance is "Z"_max/√2 are important in determining the loudspeaker's T/S parameters which can be used to design a suitable enclosure for the driver, especially for low frequency drivers. Note that "F"_s is itself one of the T/S parameters of the loudspeaker.

Load impedance and amplifiers

The variation in loudspeaker impedance is a consideration in audio amplifier design. Among other things, amplifiers designed to cope such variations are more reliable. There are two main factors to consider when matching a speaker to an amplifier.

Minimum impedance

This is the minimum value in the impedance vs. frequency relationship, which can sometimes be slightly higher than the DC resistance of the voice coil, ie, as measured by an ohmmeter. Minimum impedance is significant because the lower the impedance, the higher the current must be at the same drive voltage. The output devices of an amplifier are rated for a certain maximum current level, and when this is exceeded the device(s) will, more or less promptly, fail.

Nominal impedance

Due to the reactive nature of a speaker's impedance over the audio band frequencies, giving a speaker a single value for 'impedance' rating is in principle impossible, as one may surmise from the impedance vs. frequency curve above. The nominal impedance of a loudspeaker is a convenient, single number reference that loosely describes the impedance value of the loudspeaker over a majority of the audio band. A speaker's nominal impedance is defined as:

: $Z\_mathrm\{nom\}\; =\; 1.15\; cdot\; Z\_mathrm\{min\}$

The graph above shows the impedance curve of a single loudspeaker driver in free-air (unmounted in any type of enclosure). A home hi-fi loudspeaker system typically consists of two or more drivers, an electrical crossover network to divide the signal by frequency band and route them appropriately to the drivers, and an enclosure that all these components are mounted in. The impedance curve of such a system can be very complex, and the simple formula above does not as easily apply.

The nominal impedance rating of consumer loudspeakers systems can aid in choosing the correct loudspeaker for a given amplifier (or visa versa). If a home hi-fi amplifier specifies 8 ohm or greater loads, care should be taken that loudspeakers with a "lower" impedance are not used, lest the amplifier be required to produce more current than it was designed to handle. Using a 4 ohm loudspeaker system on an amplifier specifying 8 ohms or greater could lead to amplifier failure.

Impedance Phase Angle

Impedance variations of the load with frequency translate into variation in the phase relationship between the amplifier's voltage and current outputs. For a resistive load, usually (but not always) the voltage across the amplifier's output devices is maximum when the load current is minimum (and the voltage is minimum across the load) and vice-versa, and as a result the power dissipation in those devices is least. But due to the complex and variable nature of the driver/crossover load and its effect on the phase relationship between the voltage and current, the current will not necessarily be at its minimum when the voltage across the output devices is maximum - this results in increased power dissipation in the amplifier output stage which manifests as heating in the output devices. The phase angle varies most near resonance in moving coil loudspeakers. If this point is not taken into consideration during the amplifier design, the amplifier may overheat causing it to shut down, or cause failure of the output devices.

Damping issues

Amplifiers present a relatively low impedance to the loudspeaker which acts as a generator when a coil is moving in a magnetic field. This is the so-called "back EMF".

Characteristically, solid state amplifiers have had much lower output impedances than tube amplifiers. So much so that differences in practice between a 16 ohm nominal impedance driver and a 4 ohm nominal impedance driver have not been important enough to adjust for. Damping factor (ratio of output impedance (amplifier) to input impedance (driver voice coil)) are adequate in either case.

Tube amplifiers have sufficiently higher output impedances that they normally included multi-tap output transformers to better match to the driver impedance. Sixteen ohm drivers (or loudspeakers systems) would be connected to the 16-ohm tap, 8 ohm to the 8 ohm tap, etc. This is significant since the ratio between the loudspeaker impedance and the amplifier's impedance at a particular frequency provides damping (ie, energy absorption) for the back EMF generated by a driver. In practice, this is important to prevent "ringing" or "overhang" which is, essentially, a free vibration of the moving structures in a driver when it is excited (ie, driven with a signal) at that frequency. This can be clearly seen in "waterfall" measurement plots.

Many people claim to be able to hear the effects in music and speech reproduction. A properly adjusted damping factor can control this free vibration of the moving structures and improve the sound of the driver.

The characteristic difference between damping conditions for tube amplifiers and solid state amplifiers is claimed by many to be one of the reasons for a perceived difference in sound between tube and solid state electronics, especially in this case power amplifiers.

ee also

* Thiele/Small Parameters

References

*Designing, Building, and Testing Your Own Speaker System with Projects by David B.Weems (McGraw-Hill/TAB Electronics, ISBN 0-07-069429-X)
*Loudspeakers, Dynamic, Magnetic Structures and Impedance EIA RS-299-A standard
* [http://sound.westhost.com/patd.htm Article about effect of speaker impedance on amplifiers]