Right to die

Right to die

The right to die is the ethical or institutional entitlement of the individual to commit suicide or to undergo voluntary euthanasia. Possession of this right is often understood to mean that a person with a terminal illness should be allowed to commit suicide or assisted suicide or to decline life-prolonging treatment, where a disease would otherwise prolong their suffering to an identical result. The question of who, if anyone, should be empowered to make these decisions is often central to debate.

The right to die is sometimes associated with the idea that one's body and one's life are one's own, to dispose of as one sees fit. However, a legitimate state interest in preventing irrational suicides is sometimes argued. Pilpel and Amsel write, "Contemporary proponents of ‘rational suicide’ or the ‘right to die’ usually demand by ‘rationality’ that the decision to kill oneself be both the autonomous choice of the agent (i.e., not due to the physician or the family pressuring them to ‘do the right thing’ and suicide) and a ‘best option under the circumstances’ choice desired by the stoics or utilitarians, as well as other natural conditions such as the choice being stable, not an impulsive decision, not due to mental illness, achieved after due deliberation, etc."[1]

Hinduism accepts the right to die for those who are tormented by terminal diseases or those have no desire, ambition or no responsibilities remaining; and allows death through the non-violent practice of fasting to the point of starvation (Prayopavesa).[2] Jainism has a similar practice named Santhara. Other religious views on suicide vary in their tolerance, and include denial of the right as well as condemnation of the act.



A debate exists within bioethics over whether the right to die is universal, or only applies under certain circumstances—such as terminal illness. A court in the American state of Montana, for example, has found that the right to die applies to those with life-threatening medical conditions. Suicide advocate Ludwig Minelli and bioethics professor Jacob M. Appel, in contrast, argue that all competent people have a right to end their own lives. Appel has suggested that the right to die is a useful litmus test for the overall freedom of a given society.[3]

Legal documents

Most often, the idea of the right to die is related to a person's wish that caregivers allow death—for example, by not providing life support or vital medication—under certain conditions when recovery is highly unlikely or impossible. It may also refer to issues regarding physician-assisted suicide. It may be called passive euthanasia in cases where the patient is unable to make decisions about treatment. Living wills and Do Not Resuscitate orders are legal instruments that make a patient's treatment decisions known ahead of time; allowing a patient to die based on such decisions is not considered to be euthanasia. Usually these patients have also made explicit their wish to receive only palliative care to reduce pain and suffering.

Although specialized legal instruments differ from place to place, there are two more that are important in this context. The Five Wishes document allows a person to state in advance the priorities and values they wish to have honored at the end of life. And the Medical Durable Power of Attorney (or MDPOA) designates an agent to make decisions in case of incapacity, and can be used to give written guidance regarding end of life decision making. The MDPOA is generally considered to be the most powerful of all such instruments. All others may require interpretation on the part of health care providers or even court-appointed guardians; the MDPOA takes the job of interpretation out of the hands of strangers and gives it to a person selected and trusted by the individual.

By country

See Voluntary euthanasia#Euthanasia by country


The Netherlands legalized voluntary euthanasia in 2001 and is one of the few countries in the world to have done so.

In February 2010 a citizens' initiative called Uit Vrije Wil (Out of Free Will) further demanded that all Dutch people over 70 who feel tired of life should have the right to professional help in ending it. The organization, initiated by Milly van Stiphout and Yvonne van Baarle, started collecting signatures in support of this proposed change in Dutch legislation. A number of prominent Dutch citizens supported the initiative, including former ministers and artists, legal scholars and physicians. Among them were former politicians Frits Bolkestein, Hedy d'Ancona and Jan Terlouw, as well as television personality Mies Bouwman. Under current Dutch law, euthanasia by doctors is only legal in cases of "hopeless and unbearable" suffering. In practice this means that it is limited to those suffering from serious medical conditions and in considerable pain. Helping somebody to commit suicide without meeting the qualifications of the current Dutch euthanasia law is illegal.[4][5][6]


As of August 2011 a B.C. Supreme Court judge has been requested to speed up a right-to die lawsuit so that Gloria Taylor can have a doctor assist her in committing suicide. She suffers from Lou Gehrig's disease, and her lawyer, Joe Arvay, says her condition is getting worse.[7] A B.C. Civil Liberties lawsuit is representing six plaintiffs and challenges the laws that make it a criminal offence to assist seriously and incurably ill individuals to die with dignity.

United States

Euthanasia, where a physician or another third party administers a lethal medication, is illegal in every state. Assisted suicide, where the physician or third party gives the patient the means to end his/her own life, is legal in the states of Oregon, Washington, and Montana. It is required in these states that the patient be of sound mind when requesting assisted suicide, as confirmed by a doctor and other witnesses, and that the patient be diagnosed with a terminal illness.

See also


  1. ^ A Pilpel, L Amsel. "What is Wrong with Rational Suicide". http://www.avitalpilpel.com/uploads/What_is_wrong_with_rational_suicide_April_2010.pdf 
  2. ^ "Hinduism — Euthanasia and Suicide". BBC. 2009-08-25. http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/hinduism/hinduethics/euthanasia.shtml. 
  3. ^ Next: Assisted Suicide for Healthy People
  4. ^ "'Right to die' for elderly back at centre of Dutch debate"
  5. ^ " Citizens group argues 'right to die' — A citizens action group wants to legalise assisted suicide for all people over 70"
  6. ^ (Dutch)"70-plus eist zachte dood"
  7. ^ Article on CBC.ca

Further reading

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать курсовую

Look at other dictionaries:

  • right to die — noun choosing time of one s death, choosing to die, denial of life support, refusal of extraordinary means to prolong life, right to reject medical treatment to prolong life Generally choice to die, prerogative to die associated concepts: living… …   Law dictionary

  • Right to Die? — is a documentary aired on Sky Real Lives in December 2008 (rebroadcast on PBS on 2 March 2010 as The Suicide Tourist ) about the assisted suicide of Craig Colby Ewert (1947–2006), a 59 year old retired university professor who suffered from Lou… …   Wikipedia

  • right-to-die — adj [only before noun] supporting the right of people who are extremely ill, injured, or unconscious to refuse to use machines or methods that would keep them alive →↑euthanasia ▪ the growing right to die lobby within the USA …   Dictionary of contemporary English

  • right-to-die — right′ to die′ adj. cvb asserting or advocating the right to refuse extraordinary medical measures to prolong one s life when one is terminally ill or irreversibly comatose • Etymology: 1975–80 …   From formal English to slang

  • right-to-die — /ruyt teuh duy /, adj. asserting or advocating the right to refuse extraordinary medical measures to prolong one s life when one is terminally ill or irreversibly comatose: right to die laws. [1975 80] * * * right to die «rysmh>tuh DY»,… …   Useful english dictionary

  • right-to-die — /ruyt teuh duy /, adj. asserting or advocating the right to refuse extraordinary medical measures to prolong one s life when one is terminally ill or irreversibly comatose: right to die laws. [1975 80] * * * …   Universalium

  • Right to Die (Masters of Horror episode) — Infobox Television episode Title = The Right to Die Series = Masters of Horror Caption = DVD Cover for Right to Die Season = 2 Episode = 9 Airdate = January 5, 2007 Production = 209 Running Time = 58 mins Writer = John Esposito Director = Rob… …   Wikipedia

  • Right to Die (film) — Infobox Film name = Right to Die caption = director = Paul Wendkos producer = Karen Danaher Dorr writer = narrator = starring = Raquel Welch Michael Gross music = Brad Fiedel cinematography = Bernd Heinl editing = James Galloway distributor =… …   Wikipedia

  • right-to-die — noun A putative right for a person to decide not to be kept alive by heroic means and to die with dignity …   Wiktionary

  • right to die — individual s right to choose to die rather than live with pain and suffering (generally refers to people suffering from terminal illnesses or those who require life support systems to survive) …   English contemporary dictionary

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”