Coal Palace

Coal Palace
Motto: Coal is light, heat, and power.
General information
Architectural style	Byzantine, Gothic
Location	W. Main St. and S. Washington St., Ottumwa, Iowa, United States
Coordinates	41°1′8.51″N 92°24′53.52″W / 41.0190306°N 92.4148667°W / 41.0190306; -92.4148667
Elevation	~650 ft (198 m)
Inaugurated	September 16, 1890
Demolished	1892
Cost	$25,000–$30,000
Height	Central tower: 200 ft (61 m)
Technical details
Diameter	230 ft × 130 ft (70 m × 40 m)
Design and construction
Owner	Ottumwa Coal Palace Company
Architect	Charles P. Brown
References
[1]

The Coal Palace was a temporary exhibition center that stood in Ottumwa, Iowa from 1890 until 1892. It was used most prominently to showcase the local coal mining industry.

During its brief history President Benjamin Harrison and Congressman William McKinley visited the building, but a decline in attendance and nature's toll on the building's exterior ultimately resulted in the building's demolition in 1892.

Background

Although Iowa is most known for its rich soil and subsequent agriculture industry, Iowa had a thriving coal mining industry throughout the last half of the nineteenth century. Bituminous coal deposits, formed during the Pennsylvanian subperiod, are found throughout much of south-central Iowa, and demand for coal in Iowa grew steadily as railroad construction moved westward. By 1870, several railroad lines stretched across the state, each requiring a constant supply of coal.^[2]

The opening of hundreds of coal mines across southern Iowa coincided with industrialization and the popularity of local expositions designed to showcase agriculture, commerce, and industry. An unusual trend emerged from this confluence in Iowa: massive and opulent but temporary exhibition halls were built to house these expositions, and each was a lumber structure featuring walls veneered with the material being celebrated.^[3] Following the Corn Palace in Sioux City, the Blue Grass Palace in Creston, and the Flax Palace in Forest City, the city of Ottumwa attempted to capitalize on its largest industries with a palace of its own—the Coal Palace.

Funding and construction

The brainchild of three prominent citizens—Colonel Peter G. Ballingall, Calvin Manning, and Henry Phillips—the Coal Palace was first conceived in late 1889, at which time the Ottumwa Coal Palace Company was established with stocks available for $5 per share. Initially very few shares were purchased; only when an emergency meeting was called among Ottumwa's business leaders, at which Peter G. Ballingall offered to purchase $700 in shares, was interest seriously revived. Eventually 395 citizens subscribed (the top subscriber was Thomas D. Foster, manager of the Morrell meatpacking plant, with $1,000), and the company had secured more than $30,000.^[4]

Construction began in the summer of 1890 on a lot donated by Ballingall known as the Sunken Park. The park had previously been a bed of the Des Moines River but was essentially made a slough by the constructed embankment of the Chicago, Burlington and Quincy Railroad, and Ballingall had since transformed the area into a park.^[5] Ten area counties—Appanoose, Davis, Jefferson, Keokuk, Lucas, Mahaska, Marion, Monroe, Van Buren, and Wapello—donated coal for the construction, and each county created an exhibit for the exposition.

Approximately 300 piles were used to bring the ground floor to street level and create the structure's foundation.^[6] From there more than 800,000 feet (240,000 m) of lumber in solid sheets was used to form the framing.^[7] Coal was veneered onto the walls and fused with black mortar, effectively giving the building the look of a medieval stone-clad castle. For the second floor, lighter and smaller forms of bituminous coal—nut and pea—were used, and the roof was coated with highly reflective vitric coal and red mortar. Vitric coal was also used to spell "Coal Palace" above the main entrance.^[8][9]

Architecture

Sioux City architect Charles P. Brown was contracted to design the Coal Palace; he had previously designed the first Corn Palace in Sioux City and was at the time planning the second.^[10] Born in Salem, Massachusetts, Brown moved to Sioux City in 1886 and had designed much of its downtown.^[11]

Exterior

The exterior from the east.

Brown recognized the inherent medieval quality of walls covered in uncut coal and capitalized on this theme by adding turrets, crenellated walls, and spired roofs. Ten flags with the names of the ten coal-donating counties adorned the roof, along with two Coal Palace flags and two large American flags.^[8] The primary entrance to the building was through two archways along the northern side, though four semi-circular turrets on the ground floor also contained doors. The Ottumwa Daily Courier remarked on the completed exterior's artistic detailing in 1890:

Aloft in the main tower, a 'hanging garden of Babylon,' with richest contribution of the tropics, with a frieze of classic figures in relief round the entire building, carefully and artistically chiseled out of bituminous blocks which make 'light, heat, and power.' With flagstaffs on the various turrets proudly waving the pennant of the various countries which the palace is to represent, and with the undisputable evidence of Uncle Samuel's higher authority even over the rich feudal baron, King Coal, from the Stars and Stripes waving from the staff of the main tower—a new flag with 44 stars in the field of azure.

Ottumwa Daily Courier^[12]

Numerous friezes along the exterior walls reflected both neoclassicism, still strong in the late nineteenth century, and local industry. Among the designs either carved into coal or fancifully painted along the outer walls were a head of Ajax, a series of lions' heads festooned with produce, a depiction of the Carboniferous period connected to a modern coal mine by a miner and pickaxe, and several medallions celebrating local trades—blacksmithing, lumbering, plumbing, masonry, farming, machining, and carpentering were all visible. The smallest turrets were adorned with silver and black stripes, while two gables above the second floor depicted the goddess Ceres watching over farmers and Vulcan watching over factories.^[11] After dusk, arc lamps in the towers and colored, electric lights in the windows lit the structure to make "the scene more splendid than any illuminated castle of the rich barons of the middle ages."^[13]

The eastern portion of the sunken park (extending to Washington Street) remained a garden, though several landscaping features (fountains, walking paths, and exotic foliage) were added.^[14]

Interior

All interior decorations were overseen by D. E. Milward and D. S. Clark of Sioux City, two men who had previously designed the Corn Palace.^[11] The interior of the Coal Palace was no less ostentatious then its exterior. The pillars, rafters, railings, and ceilings which supported the upper floor were largely covered by decorations of barley, blue grass, clover, corn, flax, millet, oats, rye, timothy, and wheat—all native and common to Iowa. Along with lavish displays created by the Iowa counties who had donated coal to construct the Coal Palace, several area businesses and organizations also created displays, including the Morrell Meat Packing Company, T. M. Sinclair & Co. of Cedar Rapids, R. T. Davis Mill Company of St. Joseph, Missouri, the Northern Pacific Railway, the P.E.O. Sisterhood of Ottumwa, Pi Beta Phi, and the Blue Grass Region of Iowa (a consortium of 21 counties in southwestern Iowa). Several prominent citizens also donated historical objects and curiosities.^[15]

The exhibits surrounded the central portion of the hall, which contained a large auditorium and stage. Behind the 1,080 square feet (100 m²) stage stood a waterfall lit by 700 lights and which fell 40 feet (12 m). It required approximately 1,600,000 US gallons (6,100,000 l; 1,300,000 imp gal) of water daily.^[6] Half of the water landed in a lake a further 15 feet below, while the other half navigated a series of boulders and escarpments. A suspension bridge and live spruces and firs completed this effect.^[16] The seating capacity of the auditorium was estimated to be as high as 8,000.^[17]

The central tower featured an observation gallery and dance floor, and could be reached from the main gallery floor by two elevators or a flight of stairs.^[18] From the gallery visitors could be lowered into what was perhaps the Coal Palace's most unusual feature: a miniature, working coal mine beneath the main floor. Taking advantage of the sunken park, this coal mine tour was led by a mule and allowed visitors to observe the coal mining process as miners dug into actual coal.^[19]

Expositions

The Coal Palace was opened once yearly for a month-long exposition and festival in September and October. The expositions were enthusiastically promoted by the subscribers of the company, each of whom received a metal medallion for their financial support.^[11]

1890

In 1890 the Coal Palace officially opened on September 16 and closed on October 11.^[11] On opening day, a parade proceeded to the Palace at 1:30 p.m. with Governor Horace Boies, the mayor of Ottumwa, Company G of the Iowa National Guard, and the Iowa State Band leading the way. The governor spoke at length of the thriving coal industry in Iowa, which he lamented was too often overlooked in a state with such a rich agricultural history. The opening of the Coal Palace and the governor's speech were reported in The New York Times.^[20]

The Coal Palace organizers arranged special celebration days to boost attendance—Des Moines Day, Missouri Day, and days for each of the surrounding counties each brought thousands of tourists and visitors.^[11] But the busiest day at the Coal Palace in 1890 was October 9, when President Benjamin Harrison spent the day in Ottumwa. At approximately 10:00 a.m. he toured the Coal Palace privately and spoke at the exposition before an estimated crowd of 40,000^[21][22] people in the afternoon:

If I should attempt to interpret the lesson of this structure, I should say it was an illustration of how much that is artistic and graceful is to be found in the common things of life, and if I should make an application of this lesson, it would be to suggest that we might profitably carry into all our homes and into all neighborly intercourse the same transforming spirit.

President Benjamin Harrison, October 9, 1890^[23][24]

A few minutes after this portion of the speech the waterfall began, and Harrison's voice was briefly drowned out (Harrison suspected the waterfall was turned on by a political opponent).^[11][25] Harrison remained in the Palace that evening and shook hands with nearly 10,000 visitors.^[16] When the exposition closed two days later, it was deemed an enormous success, and the company voted to keep the palace standing for use next fall.

1891

Peter G. Ballingall departed for a trip to China in late 1890, and word later reached Ottumwa that he had died suddenly near Hong Kong on March 7, 1891. His funeral was held in the Coal Palace on April 14, with Governor Boies among the attendees.^[26] The death of the chief planner and president of the Ottumwa Coal Palace Company created a hitch among the exhibition planners, but the exposition would go on regardless, with Russell A. Alger, John C. Black, and William McKinley slated to give speeches during the celebration.^[27]

The festival opened with a parade on September 15, and the largest attendance came on September 23, when an estimated 30,000^[27] to 50,000^[17] people came to hear William McKinley, who spoke from Ottumwa's Central Park to ensure everyone could see and hear him. And although John C. Black drew nearly as many Democratic visitors on October 7 (which was "Democratic Day" at the Coal Palace), enthusiasm generally declined for the 1891 festival.^[27] The Coal Palace closed on October 10.^[28]

Legacy

Following the 1891 exposition, the Coal Palace was razed in 1892. Its location is now home to Ballingall Park in Ottumwa, a part of the city willed by Ballingall for use as a park "forever."^[11] Coal mining in Iowa is no longer a major industry. Despite this, the Coal Palace remains a legendary part of Ottumwa history, arriving (and departing) at a time when Ottumwa was often referred to as the "Lowell of the West."^[14] Manufacturing remains a major part of Ottumwa's economy.^[29] In 1998, a miniature replica of the Coal Palace was completed by local historian Milly Morris-Amos, and it is visible today in the Wapello County Historical Museum.

Notes

1. ^ The architectural style is described by Kreiner, p. 338. The location ("immediately north and west of the Union Depot"), ownership, inauguration date, and demolition date are in Waterman, p. 94. The dimensions come from the WPA guide to Iowa, p. 296; the architect is given in Gebhard and Mansheim, p. 335. Finally, the higher cost is described in Appleton, p. 140, while the lowest cost figure is quoted in the September 13, 1890, issue of Harper's Weekly (p. 717–8). A figure of $28,000 is reported in the 1891 Annual Report of the Iowa State Agriculture Society, p. 25, in which may also be found the motto.
2. ^ Schwieder, p. xi.
3. ^ "Iowa's Incredible Exposition Palaces". Iowa Public Television. http://www.iptv.org/IowaPathways/mypath.cfm?ounid=ob_000053. Retrieved 2009-07-28. 
4. ^ Waterman, p. 96.
5. ^ Phrenological Journal and Science of Health (New York: Fowler & Wells Co.) XLI (5): 234–5. November 1890. OCLC 1762314. 
6. ^ ^{a b} Appleton, p. 140.
7. ^ Arundale, Joseph C. (author of "Iowa" section) (1977). Mining and Mineral Operations in the North-Central States. Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office. p. 32. OCLC 3069618. 
8. ^ ^{a b} Shaffer, p. 25.
9. ^ Garvin, p. 203.
10. ^ Gebhard and Mansheim, p. 335
11. ^ ^{a b c d e f g h} Beitz, p. 43.
12. ^ This is quoted in Beitz, p. 43. Although she does not list a date or reference the original, we can assume the reference to a "new" 44-star flag places it in 1890, as Wyoming became the 44th state on July 10, 1890.
13. ^ Ottumwa Daily Courier, date and author unknown, qtd. in Beitz, p. 44.
14. ^ ^{a b} Kneedler, p. 717.
15. ^ Rouse gives an extended, romantic description of the interior exhibits of the Coal Palace from pp. 280–344
16. ^ ^{a b} Beitz, p. 44.
17. ^ ^{a b} "The Major Talks in Iowa" (PDF). The New York Times: p. 5. September 24, 1891. http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-free/pdf?_r=1&res=980CE3D8153AE533A25757C2A96F9C94609ED7CF. Retrieved 2009-07-30. 
18. ^ "An Iowa Coal Palace" (PDF). The New York Times: p. 15. June 22, 1890. http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-free/pdf?res=9506E4D6123BE533A25751C2A9609C94619ED7CF. Retrieved 2009-07-30. 
19. ^ Anderson, p. 255.
20. ^ "Iowa's Great Coal Palace". The New York Times: p. 1. September 17, 1890. http://query.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=9C02E2DA103BE533A25754C1A96F9C94619ED7CF. Retrieved 2009-08-02. 
21. ^ Hedges, p. 255.
22. ^ To, Telegraph (October 10, 1890). "The President". The Los Angeles Times: p. 1. http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/latimes/access/318330332.html?dids=318330332:318330332&FMT=CITE&FMTS=CITE:AI&date=Oct+10%2C+1890&author=&pub=Los+Angeles+Times&desc=THE+PRESIDENT.&pqatl=google. Retrieved 2009-08-02. 
23. ^ Qtd. in Kreiner, p. 341
24. ^ The full text of Harrison's brief address is in Hedges, p. 255-7.
25. ^ Garvin, p. 205
26. ^ Gue, Benjamin F.; Benjamin Franklin Shambaugh (1899). Biographies and Portraits of the Progressive Men of Iowa. Des Moines, IA: Conaway & Shaw. p. 153. OCLC 4215486. http://books.google.com/?id=QZ8UAAAAYAAJ. 
27. ^ ^{a b c} Beitz, p. 45
28. ^ The closing date is visible on a commemorative coin produced for the second season.
29. ^ Warren, Wilson J. (2000). Struggling with "Iowa's Pride": Labor Relations, Unionism, and Politics in the Rural Midwest Since 1877. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press. p. 3. ISBN 0877457131. 

References

• Anderson, Wayne I. (1998). Iowa's Geological Past. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press. ISBN 0877456402. http://books.google.com/?id=D2kzQ5RC4JMC. 
• Beitz, Ruth S. (Summer 1962). "Swarthy King of the Palace Age". The Iowan (Shenandoah, IA: The Iowan Inc.) 10: 42–5, 51. ISSN 0021-0722. 
• "Cities, American". Appletons' Annual Cyclopaedia and Register of Important Events (New York: D. Appleton and Co.) 30: 118 50. 1891. OCLC 6514833. http://books.google.com/?id=QqUoAAAAYAAJ. 
• Federal Writers' Project (1938). Iowa: A Guide to the Hawkeye State. New York: Viking Press. ISBN 9781603540148. OCLC 10334548. http://books.google.com/?id=ciAJzN6CqiEC. 
• Garvin, Paul (1998). Iowa's Minerals. Iowa City: University of Iowa Press. ISBN 0877456267. http://books.google.com/?id=3a1XkpBGdAcC. 
• Gebhard, David; Gerald Mansheim (1993). Buildings of Iowa. New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN 0195061489. http://books.google.com/?id=r9hUAAAAMAAJ. 
• Harrison, Benjamin; Charles Hedges, comp. (1892). Speeches of Benjamin Harrison, Twenty-third President of the United States. New York: United States Book Co. OCLC 11098584. http://books.google.com/?id=gcFxAAAAMAAJ. 
• Kneedler, H. S. (September 13, 1890). "A Prairie Coal Palace". Harper's Weekly (New York: Harper & Brothers): 717–8. 
• Kreiner, Carl B. (October 1922). "The Ottumwa Coal Palace". The Palimpsest (Iowa City: The State Historical Society of Iowa) 3 (10): 336–42. ISSN 0031-0360. 
• Rouse, Clara B. (1891). Iowa Leaves: Six Chapters. Chicago: Illinois Printing and Binding Co.. OCLC 3528167. http://books.google.com/?id=QYQUAAAAYAAJ. 
• Schwieder, Dorothy (1983). Black Diamonds: Life and Work in Iowa's Coal Mining Communities, 1895–1925. Ames, IA: Iowa State University Press. ISBN 0813809916. http://books.google.com/?id=EbKwAAAAIAAJ. 
• Shaffer, John R., ed (1891). Annual Report of the Board of Directors of the Iowa State Agricultural Society for the Year 1890. Des Moines, IA: G.H. Ragsdale. pp. 25–6. http://books.google.com/?id=f0bOAAAAMAAJ. 
• Waterman, Harrison L. (supervising editor) (1914). History of Wapello County Iowa. Chicago: S. J. Clarke Publishing. OCLC 6782813. http://books.google.com/?id=SHcUAAAAYAAJ. 

External links

• Wapello County Historical Museum - The Coal Palace