Oxford Round Table

The Oxford Round Table is a series of interdisciplinary conferences organized and run by a California-based educational organization, incorporated until recently as a for-profit^[1] and a not-for-profit corporation in Kentucky,^[2] and currently as a not-for-profit in Illinois^[3] and England and Wales.^[4]

The mission of the Oxford Round Table, according to its website, is "to provide an interdisciplinary forum for the discussion of contemporary issues that affect the public good in all its various forms and ramifications."^[5]

The Oxford Round Table is not affiliated with the University of Oxford, which has stated that events such as the Oxford Round Table are "external to the university" and "not, as such, authorised or endorsed by the university."^[6] The company has been accused of misrepresenting its relationship with the university.^[6][7]

Conferences

The first meeting of the Oxford Round Table was held at St. Peter's College in 1989, sponsored by the Norham Centre for Leadership Studies of the University of Oxford under the direction of Vivian Williams and by Virginia Tech, under the direction of Kern Alexander.^[8] The organisation brings together scholars and others from a variety of backgrounds (new professors and PhD students, college presidents and deans, school administrators, religious leaders) to discuss research on specific topics usually related to public policy. In its early years, the conference was held every other year, and the organization financed the attendance of participants by raising funds itself (more than £80,000 in 1993).^[9]

One of the earliest conferences, in 1993, was on the links between education and the business sector. It brought together education ministers from major developing and transition countries, representatives of major multinationals (such as Apple, Boeing, BP, and Honeywell), U.S. state officials, and the World Bank. A major highlight was a paper by Edward Dneprov, education minister of Russia, on education reform there.^[10] A 1993 article in the Times Higher Education Supplement noted that "the Oxford conferences are going very well" and had gained "international interest."^[9]

In 2008, there were 25 scheduled sessions of the conference—ten in March and fifteen in July/August.^[11]

Publications

The Oxford Round Table publishes a quarterly journal, also available online, titled The Forum on Public Policy: A Journal of the Oxford Round Table. The mission of the journal, according to its website, is "to disseminate knowledge with regard to salient issues in public affairs."^[12] The journal has eleven institutional OCLC subscribers.^[13]

McGill/Queen's University Press published a volume of papers from a 2003 conference, The University: International Expectations, on public administration issues related to higher education.^[14] Another edited volume on primary (precollegiate) school choices in America emerged from, among other sources, a 2003 meeting on "Choice in Education."^[15]

Company history and officers

For most of its history the Oxford Round Table has been an American organization run by members of the Alexander family and variously headquartered in Kentucky, Illinois, Florida, and California. Kern Alexander, Professor of Excellence at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, founded the Oxford International Round Table on Education Policy in 1989.^[16] However, it was not incorporated until 1994, when it was established in Florida as a for-profit corporation, with Alexander as president. It was administratively dissolved in 1996.^[17] Alexander also incorporated the Oxford Round Table, Inc., a Florida for-profit corporation; it was established and dissolved at the same time as the Oxford International Round Table on Education Policy.^[17]

In 1995, the Oxford Round Table, Inc., a for-profit Kentucky corporation, was incorporated by Samual K. Alexander III (son of Kern Alexander^[18]).^[1] It was administratively dissolved in 1998 and reinstated in 2006.^[19] This corporation dissolved itself 22 September 2008.^[20]

In 1998, the Oxford Round Table, Inc., a for-profit corporation, was incorporated in Illinois. It was involuntarily dissolved in 2000.^[3]

In December 2001, the non-profit Oxford Round Table of Godstow Hall, Inc., was incorporated in Kentucky by several members of the Alexander family.^[2] In May 2007, the non-profit Oxford Round Table, Inc., NFP, was established in Illinois. It changed its name to Oxford Round Table, North America, Inc., NFP, in October 2008.^[3] In July 2008, the non-profit Oxford Round Table, Ltd., was established in the United Kingdom.^[4]

In the 2007 annual report of the Kentucky for-profit Oxford Round Table, Inc., Kern Alexander was listed as company president.^[21] As of the 1/2008 annual report, J.C. Buckman is listed as president.^[1]

Criticism and litigation

A 2009 report cited critics who claimed that the Oxford Round Table "does not make its lack of academic connection [to Oxford University] clear." The article noted that pictures of Oxford University are used liberally on the ORT webpage, and quoted a number of ORT attendees who believed they had been invited by Oxford University. One professor expressed "surprise" when she learned that the ORT was not affiliated with Oxford University and concluded that "my conference funds would be best targeted towards a more appropriate venue."^[7]

In 2007, Times Higher Education reported that Oxford Round Table had been criticised on the forums of the Chronicle of Higher Education website by people who said it was trading on the name of Oxford University, and failed to properly inform people invited that it had no formal academic links to the university. Other criticisms were that its selection criteria were poor and that it was a "vanity conference."

The University told the newspaper that such external events were "not, as such, authorised or endorsed by the university." The principal of Harris Manchester College said that although the college provided the company with an office, "we don't run the ORT in any sense," and that as far as he was aware, all ORT participants were satisfied. The company defended its selection criteria, and reported that its disclaimer, which is on its website, uses "the exact wording that was provided to us by the legal office of the University of Oxford several years ago." A spokeswoman dismissed the critics as "a few nameless bloggers."

One Oxford University research fellow had sent an email to a US academic criticising the company's practices. An attempt by the Oxford Round Table, Inc., to sue the individual, who is based in England, for libel in the Kentucky courts failed on jurisdiction grounds,^[22] and the company threatened to take legal action in the UK.^[6] The company dropped the action after the researcher hired her own lawyer.^[7]

The conference has also attracted controversy in at least three states over the cost of school boards’ paying for administrators to attend; in Louisiana, this led to "a successful legislative push to tighten travel rules for school board members statewide."^[23]

References

1. ^ ^{a b c} Annual report for Oxford Round Table, Inc., filed on 15 January 2008 with the Kentucky Secretary of State, Business Services section, accessed 2008-03-16
2. ^ ^{a b} Annual corporate report, filed 18 January 2008 with the Kentucky Secretary of State, accessed 2008-03-16
3. ^ ^{a b c} see search results for "Oxford Round Table" at Illinois Secretary of State, accessed 2008-03-16
4. ^ ^{a b} see search results for "Oxford Round Table at Companies House
5. ^ Oxford Round Table website
6. ^ ^{a b c} Newman, Melanie (21 December 2007). "'Oxford' events firm under fire". Times Higher Education Supplement. http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/story.asp?storyCode=310154&sectioncode=26. Retrieved 2008-02-01. 
7. ^ ^{a b c} Melanie Newman, "Round Table invitees confused by Oxford 'link'", Times Higher Education, 12 March 2009
8. ^ The Journal of Education Finance: Table of Contents Vols 15-33
9. ^ ^{a b} Huw Richards, "All Rhodes lead to reform," Times Higher Education Supplement, 8 October 1993, p. 8.
10. ^ Richard Margrave, "International Partnership," The Times, 1 November 1993.
11. ^ http://www.hmc.ox.ac.uk/latestnews.html
12. ^ Welcome to the Forum on Public Policy
13. ^ http://www.worldcat.org/wcpa/oclc/150892132
14. ^ Reviewed by Anthony Potts, History of Intellectual Culture, Volume 4, No. 1, 2004.
15. ^ Carreiro, Paula J. and Eileen Shields-West, Choosing the Right Educational Path for Your Child: What Are the Options? Rowman & Littlefield Education, 2008; pp. vii, ix.
16. ^ College of Education Faculty Research Profiles: Kern Alexander
17. ^ ^{a b} Corporate report filed with Florida Secretary of State, Division of Corporations, accessed 2008-03-16
18. ^ Sigma Alpha Epsilon Alumni Association, Kentucky Kappa Alumni Association Alumni News 1960-1964, last update 13 September 2001, accessed 5 March 2008
19. ^ Application for reinstatement of corporation, filed with Kentucky Secretary of State, accessed 2008-03-16
20. ^ http://apps.sos.ky.gov/business/obdb/OBDBDisplayImage.aspx?id=3258043, consulted 3 October 2008.
21. ^ Annual corporate report, filed on 10 May 2007 with the Kentucky Secretary of State, accessed 2008-03-16
22. ^ http://www.internetlibrary.com/cases/lib_case570.cfm
23. ^ Mary Swerczek and Matthew Brown, “Trip is a lesson, but not in frugality,” Times-Picayune (New Orleans), 30 August 2003, Metro p. 1; “A new outrage in the Abbotts,” Asbury Park Press (New Jersey), 1 February 2007; Nancy Averett, “School board chief won't seek district's help in paying for trip,” Morning Call (Allentown, PA), 30 July 2003, p. B9.

External links

• Oxford Round Table website
• Discussion of the Oxford Round Table at the Chronicle of Higher Education
• Forum on Public Policy
• Oxford Round Table, Inc. v. Mahone