- Kolchuga passive sensor
The Kolchuga passive sensor is an ESM system developed in
Ukraine. Its detection range is limited by line-of-sight but may be up to 800 km (500 miles) for very high altitude, very powerful emitters. Frequently referred to as "Kolchuga Radar", the system is not really a radar, but an ESM system comprising three or four receivers, deployed tens of kilometres apart, which detect and track aircraft by triangulationand multilaterationof their RF emissions.
This was developed by the Special Radio Device Design Bureau public holding, the Topaz holding, the Donetsk National Technical University, the Ukrspetsexport state company, and the Investment and Technologies Company. It took them eight years (1993 - 2000) to conduct research, develop algorithms, test solutions on experimental specimens, and launch serial production. The new product dramatically changed the balance in the constant competition between offensive and defensive means. The relatively cheap Ukrainian Kolchuga radar station is able to detect and identify practically all known active radio devices mounted on ground, airborne, or marine objects.
Mode of operation
Kolchuga is an
electronic support measuressystem that employs two or more sites to locate emitters by triangulation. The system is vehicle mounted and comprises a large vertical meshed reflector, with two smaller circular parabolic dishes beneath and a pair of VHF-to-microwave log periodic antennas above. The dishes may exploit amplitude monopulsetechniques for improved direction finding, whilst the angled spacing of the log-periodic antenna suggests that they may use phase interferometryto improve angle measurements. Various smaller antennas, presumably for inter-site communications are to the side and rear of the dish.
The detection range is one of the best in its class, but it is highly dependent on the emitted power of the transmitter being tracked, and requires satisfaction of the
line of sightcondition to at least two receiving sites for triangulation(compared with three sites for a multilateration system such as the VERA passive sensor). A Kolchuga complex can detect and locate air and surface targets and trace their movement to a range generally limited only by the "common" line-of-sight of the stations. Assuming no terrain masking, the line-of-sight range of a single Kolchuga station (in km) is approximately (Skolnik 1981):
where "hr(km)" is the height of the radar in km, and "ht(km)" is the height of the target in kilometres, and assuming standard atmospheric radio refraction. Thus, for a Kolchuga at 100 m altitude (above local terrain) and a target at 10 km (30 kft), the range of the system would be approximately 450 km. For targets at altitudes of 20 km (60 kft) the line of sight limitation would be 620 km—but few targets fly at such altitudes. However, being line-of-sight limited, the system is an effective
early warning air defensesystem.
According to the manufacturer's brochure (from AIDEX 1997), the upgraded Kolchuga-M is equipped [corrected for English grammatical mistakes] :
*With four antennas in the VHF, UHF and SHF radio bands with narrow and wide beams
*With parallel receivers allowing the instant discovery and analysis of signals of radio technical equipment (RTE) in the range 100 MHz -18 GHz and continual tracking across the entire band. [Other sources claim from 130MHz to 18GHz, and a 36 channel preset receiver] .
*With sensitivity of approximately -145 dBW
*With equipment for the analysis, processing and continual calculation and tracking of coordinates by triangulation and chronometrical-hyperbolic method.
*With equipment for the identification, operative displaying of information, long term memory and recording of the results of processing.
The brochure also claims that the system provides [corrected for English grammatical mistakes] :
*The detection, analysis of signals with pulsed and continuous waves and resolution of practically all known radio technical equipment (RTE) deployed on ground, sea and air platforms, including radar units of all classes, identification systems, air traffic control system and navigation systems
*The composition, character of operation and flight paths of RTE in a zone 600 km deep with complete exception of blind zones and continual high accuracy
*The detection of take-off of aerial targets and their formation in groups at a distance exceeding that of modern radars.
*The direction of arrival of solitary and group targets and target indication to active facilities of anti-aircraft systems
Special inhibitory sorters omit up to 24 interfering signals, and tracking sorters make it possible to synchronously sort out and track signals from 32 targets;
Kolchuga is able to detect and identify many types of radio devices mounted on ground, airborne, or marine objects. Target detection relies only on an emitter having sufficient power and being within Kolchuga's frequency range. Target identification, however, is more complex and is based on the measurement of different parameters of the transmitted signal—such as its frequency, bandwidth, pulse width, pulse repetition interval, etc. Kolchuga has been reported to use around forty different parameters when identifying a target. These parameters are compared to a database in order to identify both the type of emitter and, in some cases, even the specific piece of equipment (by identifying the unique signature or "fingerprint" that most transmitters have, due to the variations and tolerances in individual components). The database within Kolchuga is said to have the capacity to store around three hundred different types of emitter and up to five hundred specific signatures for each type.
In 2002 the
U.S. State Departmentaccused Ukraine of selling Kolchuga to Iraq, based on recordings of the then Ukrainian president Leonid Kuchmasupposedly made by Mykola Mel'nychenko. This was followed by political steps from United Kingdomand the United States. No material confirmation has been found in Iraq. See Cassette Scandalfor further information.
It has been exported to
Russiawhere additional development has been performed and the system is marketed in conjunction with the new S-400 surface to air missile (SAM) system. [http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/2326451.stm]
Unconfirmed reports in September 2006 suggested a sale was made to Iran [http://www.janes.com/defence/news/jdw/jdw060922_1_n.shtml] [http://www.strategypage.com/qnd/iran/articles/20060923.aspx] although this was denied by the Ukrainian government [http://www.irna.ir/en/news/view/line-17/0609298371173728.htm] .
Rumours and speculation of performance
Since becoming publicly known following the
Cassette Scandal, the capabilities of Kolchuga have been the source of many rumours and uninformed speculation in forums such as [http://www.iraq-war.ru/article/103246] . Many observers have a tendency to credit it with magical powers of detection. Many of these do not stand up to detailed engineering analysis, or have not been confirmed, but are recorded in this section for completeness, together with reasons for doubting the claim. Note that the material in this section should not be regarded as accurate. Claims include:
* That Kolchuga has a range of 800 km. It will certainly have the sensitivity to see high power sources at such a range. However, basic line-of-sight arguments outlined in the sections above show that this would require aircraft to be flying at impractically high altitudes and/or for the Kolchuga stations to be deployed on very high mountains. The claim is thus technically possible but operationally very unlikely.
* That Kolchuga can detect US stealth aircraft by their radio and radar emissions. Whilst technically possible, stealth aircraft do not radiate when in battle, so this mode of operation is militarily irrelevant.
* Kolchuga is sufficiently sensitive to detect US stealth aircraft from unconventional sources of RF emissions, including radiation from exhaust trails and
electromagnetic interferencefrom the engine. (Technically the power levels of these sources are likely to be so small, if at all, that there would be insufficient energy for Kolchuga to measure these effects at one site, let alone the two or more required for triangulation. They would also be almost impossible to distinguish for normal background RF noise and would not appear like the conventional emissions types Kolchuga is designed to receive and analyse).
* Kolchuga is sufficiently sensitive to operate as a bistatic radar receiver and hence exploit other transmitters in the environment. (This is likely to be true for the specific case of forward scatter in which the
radar cross sectionof even a stealth aircraft can become very large for a few moments. However, achieving forward scatter simultaneously in two or more receivers is geometrically impossible, so triangulation would not work. Secondly, unless Kolchuga has been specifically designed to work as a bistatic radarreceiver with a certain radar type—and there's no evidence of Kolchuga being deployed in conjunction with specific radar types—then it will lack the essential matched filter required to reliably detect reflected pulses in the presence of noise. Therefore, if this effect works at all, it is likely to be unreliable and fleeting).
* Ukrainian sources often make claims such as "
[Kolchuga]is head and shoulders above all American, Russian, French, Czech, or Brazilian developments in this field" [http://www.iraq-war.ru/article/103246] . Such claims are unsubstantiated and pure speculation, as the performance and even existence of many ESM systems are highly classified and not deducible by ELINT. It may or may not be true, but must be regarded with caution, particularly as those making the claims are often either journalists or those with an interest in exporting the system.
*BORAP – a similar system using triangulation developed in the
Military of Ukraine
Multinational force in Iraq
Ukrainian Ground Forces
*VERA – a similar system using multilateration developed in the
last = Skolnik
first = Merrill
authorlink = Merrill Skolnik
title = Introduction to Radar Systems
date = 1981
id = ISBN 0-07-057909-1
*"In Focus: The Kolchuga ESM System", The Reliant A Strategic Studies Gazette, Sept 25, 2006. [http://thereliant.blogspot.com/2006/09/in-focus-kolchuga-esm-system.html]
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.