Commonwealth v. Kneeland

Commonwealth v. Kneeland
Commonwealth v. Kneeland
Court Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court
Full case name Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Abner Kneeland
Date decided March, 1838
Citation(s) 37 Mass. 206 (1838)
Case opinions
Majority: Shaw
Dissent: Morton

Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Abner Kneeland was an 1838 Massachusetts state court case, notable for being the last time a court in the United States jailed a defendant for blasphemy.[1]

Contents

Overview

The defendant, Abner Kneeland, was a mercurial preacher who had been a Universalist, but had since converted to a form of pantheism. He published letters in which he expounded on his recently adopted pantheist philosophy, denying any God other than Nature as well as the uniquely particular divinity of Jesus Christ. Already a controversial figure, he was taken to court after he admitted having written these statements. The legal indictment was for "willfully blaspheming the holy name of God" and for his public disavowal of Christ. Though the statements used for the prosecution were written in 1833, delays and restarts of the trial meant that the final case was heard in 1838.

At trial, Kneeland raised three defenses of his actions:

  1. Kneeland claimed he never denied the existence of God, merely the existence of "a" God. Therefore he was not an atheist.
  2. The law itself was invalid and should be overturned, as it was in violation with the Massachusetts Constitution's guarantee of religious freedom.
  3. The law also violated the guarantee of freedom of the press.

The court was unimpressed with Kneeland's claims. It ruled that regardless of his beliefs, he had libeled God's name with malicious intent, rendering Kneeland's first point moot. As for the second, the court examined other state's colonial charters and pointed out that they too had reconciled blasphemy laws with guarantees of religious freedom, and that the law "was passed very soon after the adoption of the constitution, and no doubt, many members of the convention which framed the constitution, were members of the legislature which passed this law." Therefore, they must not conflict. The court dismissed the third claim out of hand, saying that if unlimited freedom of the press was allowed,

the article in question become a general license for scandal, calumny and falsehood against individuals, institutions and governments, in the form of publication ... but all incitation to treason, assassination, and all other crimes however atrocious, if conveyed in printed language, would be dispunishable.

Kneeland was sentenced to sixty days in prison. In his support, a petition was put forward by for his pardon under grounds of free speech by William Ellery Channing, signed by various prominent people including Ralph Waldo Emerson and William Lloyd Garrison. However, a counter-petition was signed with even more signatures; Kneeland stayed in prison and served his entire term.

See also

References

  1. ^ Levy, Leonard. Blasphemy in Massachusetts: Freedom of Conscience and the Abner Kneeland Case. (1973)

External links


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем сделать НИР

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Old Colony Railroad — This article is about the large railroad system in southeastern Massachusetts. For the earlier Old Colony Railroad , see New Bedford and Taunton Railroad. Old Colony Railroad O.C.R.R. s Boston Kneeland Street Depot …   Wikipedia

  • National Register of Historic Places listings in Boston, Massachusetts — Location of Boston in Massachusetts This is a list of the National Register of Historic Places listings in Boston, Massachusetts. This is intended to be a complete list of the properties and districts on the National Register of Historic Places… …   Wikipedia

  • Atlantic Avenue (Boston) — Atlantic Avenue Viaduct redirects here. For the Long Island Rail Road structure in Brooklyn, New York, see Atlantic Branch. Atlantic Avenue at Essex St., Boston, 2010 Atlantic Avenue is a street in downtown Boston, Massachusetts, USA, partly… …   Wikipedia

  • List of United States Supreme Court cases, volume 141 — This is a list of all the United States Supreme Court cases from volume 141:SCOTUSTable | data =SCOTUSRow case name = In re Garnett page = 1 decision date = decision year = 1891SCOTUSRow case name = Pullman s Palace Car Co v. Commonwealth of… …   Wikipedia

  • Thomas P. O'Neill Jr. Tunnel — Thomas P. O Neill, Jr. Tunnel The northbound entrance to the tunnel from I 93 Overview Location Boston, Massachusetts Status Open Route …   Wikipedia

  • South Station — Infobox Station style=Amtrak name= Boston South Station image size= image caption= address=700 Atlantic AvenueBoston, MA 02110 coordinates = coord|42.352035| 71.055182|display = inline,title line=MBTA Subway:rail color… …   Wikipedia

  • Northampton, Massachusetts —   City   Northampton, Massachusetts Main Street …   Wikipedia

  • History of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology — MIT s Building 10 and Great Dome overlooking Killian Court The history of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology can be traced back to the 1861 incorporation of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Boston Society of Natural History… …   Wikipedia

  • Massachusetts Institute of Technology — Motto Mens et Manus Motto in English Mind and Hand[1] …   Wikipedia

  • Washington Street (Boston) — Old South meeting house, Washington St., 1968 …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”