Edinburgh town walls

Edinburgh town walls
Edinburgh, Scotland
The Flodden Tower, with the Telfer Wall on the right, and Edinburgh Castle behind
Built	15th to 17th century
Construction materials	Stone
Demolished	Parts demolished from mid 18th century
Current condition	Some sections remain to full height
Map showing the town walls, overlaid on the present-day streets Key: Orange: King's Wall, Red: Flodden Wall, Purple: Telfer Wall A: Edinburgh Castle, B: Flodden Tower, C: Greyfriars Kirkyard; D: site of Netherbow Port, E: Waverley station Blue shading: approximate extent of Nor Loch

There have been several town walls around Edinburgh, Scotland, since the 12th century. Some form of wall probably existed from the foundation of the royal burgh in around 1125, though the first building is recorded in the mid-15th century, when the King's Wall was constructed. In the 16th century the more extensive Flodden Wall was erected, following the Scots' defeat at the Battle of Flodden Field in 1513. This was extended by the Telfer Wall in the early 17th century. The walls had a number of gates, known as ports, the most important being the Netherbow Port, which stood halfway down the Royal Mile. This gave access from the Canongate which was, at that time, a separate burgh.

The walls never proved very successful as defensive structures, and were easily breached on more than one occasion. They served more as a means of controlling trade and taxing goods, and as a deterrent to smugglers. Throughout their history, the town walls of Edinburgh have served better in their role as a trade barrier than as a defensive one.^[1] By the mid 18th century, the walls had outlived both their defensive and trade purposes, and demolition of sections of the wall began. The Netherbow Port was pulled down in 1764, and demolition continued into the 19th century. Today, a number of sections of the three successive walls survive, although none of the ports remain.

Background

Edinburgh was formally established as a royal burgh by King David I of Scotland around 1125. This gave the town the privilege of holding a market, and the ability to raise money by taxing goods coming into the burgh for sale.^[1] It is probable, therefore, that some form of boundary was constructed around this time, although it may have been a timber palisade or ditch, rather than a stone wall.^[2]

To the north of Edinburgh lay the marshy Nor Loch, formed in the early 15th century in the depression where Princes Street Gardens are now laid out.^[3] This natural defence was augmented by the steep slope up to the northern edge of the Old Town.^[4] Edinburgh Castle, on its rocky outcrop, defended the western approach. Walls were therefore needed primarily on the south and east sides of the burgh.

Early records mention a west gate in 1180, a south gate in 1214, and the Netherbow Port in 1369.^[2] In 1362 the Wellhouse Tower was built beneath the north wall of the castle, protecting the castle's water supply, and defending the approach along the south shore of the Nor Loch.^[5]

King's Wall

The King's Wall is first recorded in 1427, in a title deed which refers to the wall as the property boundary.^[6] In 1450, King James II issued a charter permitting the burgesses of Edinburgh to defend their town, as follows:

Foralsmykle as we ar informit be oure well belovettis the Provest and Communite of Edynburgh, yat yai dreid the evil and skath of oure enemies of England, we have in favour of yame, and for the zele and affectioune that we have to the Provest and Communite of oure said Burgh, and for the comoune profit, grauntit to thaim full licence and leiff to fosse, bulwark, wall, toure, turate, and uther wais to strengthen oure foresaid Burgh in quhat maner of wise or degree that beis sene maste spedefule to thame. Given under oure Grete Seale at Strivelyn the last day of Aprile, and of oure regne the thretene yhere, anno 1450.[7]

Forasmuch as we are informed by our well-beloved Provost and Community of Edinburgh, that they dread the evil and injury of our enemies of England, we have in favour of them, and for the zeal and affection that we have for the Provost and Community of our said Burgh, and for the common profit, granted to them full licence and leave to fosse, bulwark, wall, tower, turret, and other ways to strengthen our said Burgh in what manner of ways or degree that be seen most speedful to them. Given under our Great Seal at Stirling the last day of April, and of our reign the thirteenth year, anno 1450.

Walling in Tweeddale Court, thought to be the King's Wall

In a further royal charter of 28 April 1472, King James III ordered the demolition of houses built on or outside the King's Wall, which were hampering efforts to strengthen the defences.^[8] Edinburgh was thus one of only three Scottish towns to have medieval stone walls, the others being Stirling and Perth, though other towns had earth walls or palisades.^[9]

The wall ran along the south side of the Royal Mile, above the Cowgate, from the slope of the Castle Hill in the west, almost as far as the modern St Mary's Street in the east, where it turned to cross the Royal Mile. In all, the King's Wall enclosed a space no larger than 0.8 by 0.4 kilometres (0.50 by 0.25 mi).^[10] The alignment of the wall was irregular, as existing property boundaries or walls were reinforced to form a defence.^[11] The early wall had two ports: the Upper Bow or Over-Bow, in the vicinity of what is now Victoria Street, and the Nether Bow,^[12] on the Royal Mile near Fountain Close, which was located near around 46 metres (151 ft) further west than the later structure. In addition, posterns (side gates) were provided, for example at Gray's Close.^[13]

Flodden Wall

The Flodden Wall in Greyfriars Kirkyard

In 1513, King James IV led an invasion of northern England in support of the French and the Auld Alliance. On 9 September, the Scots met the English at the Battle of Flodden, and were heavily defeated, with King James killed on the field. An English invasion was widely expected, and in Edinburgh it was resolved to build a new town wall. However, the new wall was also an opportunity to control smuggling into the burgh,^[14] and the town council accordingly decided to extend the wall south to take in the Grassmarket and Cowgate areas of the burgh.^[2] Construction began the following year, but was not completed until 1560.^[10] Work started at the western end, and the final section was the stretch from Leith Wynd to the Nor Loch, incorporating the New Port. The cost of this last work was £4/10s Scots per rood (one rood = six ells or 5.6 metres) for the wall, plus 40s per rood for the battlements.^[15]

The Flodden Wall, as it became known, was generally around 1.2 metres (3 ft 11 in) thick and up to 7.3 metres (24 ft) high.^[16] The Flodden Wall began at the south side of the castle, running south across the west end of the Grassmarket, where the West Port was located, and continued uphill along the Vennel. A watch-tower or bastion survives at this, the south-west extent of the wall. It then ran east, wrapping around Greyfriars Kirkyard, to the Bristo Port and the Potterow Port, both located in the vicinity of the National Museum of Scotland. Continuing east, the wall passed the Kirk o' Field, where the Old College now stands, and ran along Drummond Street, turning north at the Pleasance to enclose the former Blackfriars Monastery. The Cowgate Port was located at the foot of the Pleasance, and the wall then ran up the line of St Mary's Street, where it was formed by strengthening existing walls rather than new walling,^[2] to the Netherbow Port, which stood across the Royal Mile. The wall continued north to the Nor Loch, since replaced by Waverley railway station, terminating at the New Port. The Flodden Wall enclosed an area of just under 57 hectares (140 acres), and remained the limit of the burgh until the 18th century.^[17] Contained within this area, in 1560, was a population of around 10,000.^[16]

The Netherbow Port in the 18th century, seen from the Canongate

Model of the Netherbow Port in Edinburgh's Huntly House Museum

There were six ports in the Flodden Wall. Anti-clockwise from the castle they were:

• West Port, built 1514 at the west end of the Grassmarket,^[16] where the modern street of West Port is today, and giving access to Wester Portsburgh;
• Bristo Port (Greyfriars Port, Society Port), built around 1515 on Bristo Street, close to Greyfriars Kirk and the Society of Brewers;^[18]
• Potterrow Port (Kirk o' Field Port), at the head of Horse Wynd near the Kirk o' Field, giving access to Easter Portsburgh;^[18]
• Cowgate Port (Soo-gate, Blackfriars Port), on the Cowgate near the Blackfriars Monastery, the access to the Grassmarket from the east;
• Netherbow Port, on the Royal Mile;
• New Port (St Andrew's Port), at the foot of Halkerston's Wynd beneath the modern North Bridge, giving access north to Leith.

Besides, there were a number of small posterns.^[13] The heads and limbs of executed criminals were regularly displayed above the ports.^[19] Of the six ports, the Netherbow was the only one which took the form of a large fortified gateway. Repairs to the Netherbow are recorded in 1538,^[20] and a drawing of 1544 shows the Netherbow as a wide arched gate flanked by two round towers. In 1571, the gateway between the towers was rebuilt, and a central clock tower was added above the gateway, topped by an octagonal stone spire. This structure was repaired in the early 17th century.^[21]

Military action

Sketch of Edinburgh made in 1544, showing the Netherbow Port in the High Street

Although the expected English invasion never materialised after Flodden, the 16th century was a turbulent period in Scotland. In 1544 the Earl of Hertford led an English force into Scotland during the War of the Rough Wooing. On 6 May, having captured Leith, Hertford's men blew open the Netherbow Port with their artillery. The town was burned over the following three days, "so that neither within the walls nor in the suburbs was left any one house unburnt".^[22]

Further disturbances took place during the troubled reign of Mary, Queen of Scots (1542–1567), and its aftermath. In 1558 the Protestant Lords of the Congregation marched on Edinburgh against the Catholic French Regent, Mary of Guise, and were able to take control of the town without difficulty, despite the guards posted at the city gate.^[23] Following the forced abdication of Queen Mary, Scotland's nobility was divided between her supporters, and those of the infant King James VI, represented by a series of regents. Edinburgh was held for the Queen by William Kirkcaldy of Grange, and in May 1571 the town was besieged by the Regent's forces under James Douglas, 4th Earl of Morton. Repairs were made to the walls, and the Netherbow was barricaded. Nearby houses were pulled down to improve defences, and the siege gun Mons Meg was employed to batter houses outside the wall which were being used by snipers. Unable to make any headway, the besiegers withdrew on 20 May.^[24]

Again the defences were strengthened in September, in advance of a second siege which began on 16 October. By this stage only ten per cent of Edinburgh's inhabitants remained in the city. The besiegers under Regent Mar had only seven guns, and while they did manage to breach the Flodden Wall, the inner defences were too strong for an assault. By 21 October the siege was once again lifted.^[25] A blockade of the town was continued until July 1572 when a truce was agreed. Grange retreated into the castle and handed over the town to the Regent's party.^[26] The siege of Edinburgh Castle continued until May 1573, when it was finally reduced by a battery of guns shipped from England.^[27]

A section of the Telfer Wall in Lauriston Place

Telfer Wall

In 1618 the town council bought 10 acres (4.0 ha) of land to the west of Greyfriars Kirk, which was enclosed between 1628 and 1636 by the Telfer Wall.^[28] Most of this land was subsequently sold to the charitable George Heriot's Trust, and is now occupied by George Heriot's School. The rubble-built wall ran south from the Flodden Tower in the Vennel to Lauriston Place; it then turned east, running as far as Bristo Street, where it returned north to the Bristo Port in the Flodden Wall. The Telfer Wall was named after its mason, John Taillefer.^[28]

Later history and demolition

James VI tablet from the demolished Netherbow Port

Brass plates mark the outline of the Netherbow Port

By the 17th century the King's Wall had been almost completely absorbed within later buildings, although it is briefly mentioned in the "Extent Roll", a town survey of 1635, and limited sections appear on James Gordon of Rothiemay's map of 1647.^[29] The mason John Mylne and the wright (carpenter) John Scott strengthened the Flodden and Telfer walls and constructed artillery emplacements in 1650.^[2] Further emplacements were built by Captain Theodore Dury in 1715, in response to the Jacobite rising of that year. In 1736, the lynching of Captain John Porteous by an Edinburgh mob led the British Government in London to impose sanctions on the town. Porteous, Captain of the Town Guard, had been convicted of murder following the shooting of spectators at a public hanging, but following a reprieve, a mob broke into the Tolbooth Jail and executed him. The initial demand by the House of Lords was for the demolition of the Netherbow Port, although this was resisted by the town, and commuted to a fine by the House of Commons.^[30] When the town was threatened by the Jacobite rising of 1745, a company of volunteer citizens was raised for the defence of the city, and the mathematics professor Colin Maclaurin advised on improvements to the walls.^[31] However, as Bonnie Prince Charlie's troops approached, the town was undermanned and the walls undefended. On the morning of 17 September, a group of Highlanders under Donald Cameron of Lochiel rushed the Netherbow Port as the gates were opened, and Edinburgh was captured without a fight.^[32]

Demolitions began soon after the withdrawal of the Jacobite threat in 1746.^[33] The bastions of the Telfer Wall along Lauriston Place were demolished in 1762, as they were obstructing traffic. The Netherbow survived until 1764, when it too was removed as an obstruction.^[34] The West Port and the Potterow Port were removed in the 1780s.^[35] By now, the New Town was under construction, and although smuggling of goods through the city walls was still being punished, complaints about the zealousness of the guards were widely circulated.^[33] The Old College of the University of Edinburgh (constructed from 1789), and then the Royal Museum of Scotland (constructed from 1861), were built over sections of the wall around the Potterow Port. Forrest Road was laid out in the 1840s, resulting in the loss of another section of the Telfer Wall.^[36] During construction works around the Advocates' Library and Parliament House in 1832 and 1845, fragments of walling were uncovered, which were attributed to the King's Wall.^[29]

Surviving fragments

Nothing remains of Edinburgh's earliest enclosures, and very little of the King's Wall survives, although parts are probably incorporated in later buildings. A section of walling in Tweeddale Court, on the south side of the Royal Mile, may represent part of the eastern wall. This was exposed during demolition of a cinema structure in 1985 and was recognised by planners as a fortified wall; subsequently it was not demolished as consented. The height (6 metres (20 ft)), and lack of openings suggest a defensive purpose.^[37] Walling in Castle Wynd, north of the Grassmarket, has also been identified with the King's Wall.^[13] In 1973, archaeological excavations on the site now occupied by the Radisson Hotel, south of the Royal Mile, uncovered a fragment of wall, which was thought likely to be the King's Wall. There was also evidence of a house adjacent, which had been demolished sometime in the 15th century, presumably in response to James III's order of 1472.^[38]

The Flodden Wall at the corner of Drummond Street and the Pleasance

Four sections of the Flodden Wall survive: to the north and south of the Grassmarket; in Greyfriars Kirkyard; and along Drummond Street and the Pleasance. North of the Grassmarket the wall runs alongside Granny's Green steps and has been incorporated into later buildings, including the former Greyfriars Mission Kirk.^[39] A line of granite paving across the Grassmarket marks the line of the wall where it was uncovered during construction work in 2008.^[40] In the Vennel the last remaining bastion of the town walls survives. The Flodden Tower, as it is sometimes known, comprises two remaining walls with a total length of 17.2 metres (56 ft),^[41] pierced by crosslet gunloops and a 19th-century window.^[14] Sections of the Flodden Wall can be seen within Greyfriars Kirkyard, adorned with 16th and 17th century tombstones. At the junction of Forrest Road and Bristo Street a line of cobbles and a narrow gap in the later buildings mark the line of the wall.^[42] The longest section is in Drummond Street and the Pleasance, where it originally enclosed the Blackfriars Monastery. At the corner of the wall a blocked archway is probably the entrance to a demolished bastion.^[2] The site of the Netherbow is marked with an outline of brass blocks at the junction of the Royal Mile and St Mary's Street.^[10]

Paving marks the line of the Flodden Wall in the Grassmarket

There are two remaining sections of the Telfer Wall. The first runs along Heriot Place from the Flodden Tower, and forms the west boundary of George Heriot's School. The wall along Lauriston Place was demolished in 1762, as the bastions were obstructing traffic. The only remaining section is that forming the south wall of Greyfriars Kirkyard. An inscription on the building at the corner of Teviot Place and Bristo Street reads "1513 Site of Town Wall", although it was in fact the 17th-century Telfer Wall, not the earlier Flodden Wall, which stood on this spot.^[43]

The majority of the surviving sections are listed buildings, while three sections are further protected as scheduled ancient monuments: the Flodden Wall at Granny's Green;^[44] the Flodden and Telfer Walls at the Vennel and Heriot Place;^[41] and the Flodden Wall at Drummond Place and Pleasance.^[45] The walls also form part of the Edinburgh Old Town World Heritage Site.

Location

Map of all coordinates from Google Map of all coordinates from Bing
Export all coordinates as KML
Export all coordinates as GeoRSS
Map of all microformatted coordinates
Place data as RDF

Point	Coordinates (links to map & photo sources)	Notes
King's Wall in Tweeddale Court	55°57′01″N 3°11′04″W / 55.95021°N 3.18455°W / 55.95021; -3.18455
Flodden Wall at Granny's Green	55°56′51″N 3°11′53″W / 55.9475°N 3.19798°W / 55.9475; -3.19798
Flodden Tower	55°56′46″N 3°11′49″W / 55.94622°N 3.19698°W / 55.94622; -3.19698Coordinates: 55°56′46″N 3°11′49″W / 55.94622°N 3.19698°W / 55.94622; -3.19698
Flodden Wall in Greyfriars Kirkyard	55°56′48″N 3°11′36″W / 55.9466°N 3.19332°W / 55.9466; -3.19332
Flodden Wall markers in Forrest Road	55°56′47″N 3°11′28″W / 55.94643°N 3.19111°W / 55.94643; -3.19111
Flodden Wall at Drummond Street/Pleasance	55°56′54″N 3°10′56″W / 55.94841°N 3.18236°W / 55.94841; -3.18236
Netherbow Port	55°57′02″N 3°11′03″W / 55.95065°N 3.1843°W / 55.95065; -3.1843
Telfer Wall at Heriot Place	55°56′45″N 3°11′46″W / 55.94571°N 3.19602°W / 55.94571; -3.19602
Telfer Wall at Greyfriars Kirkyard	55°56′43″N 3°11′31″W / 55.94531°N 3.19191°W / 55.94531; -3.19191

References

1. ^ ^{a b} Bell, p.7
2. ^ ^{a b c d e f} Gifford pp.84–85
3. ^ Fife, p.4
4. ^ See Miller
5. ^ Fife, pp.180–181
6. ^ Miller (1887)
7. ^ Marwick, pp.70–71
8. ^ Marwick, pp.134–135
9. ^ McWilliam, p.36
10. ^ ^{a b c} Catford, p.18
11. ^ Schofield, p.181
12. ^ From the Scots language nether, meaning "lower", and bow, meaning "arch". Dictionary of the Scottish Language
13. ^ ^{a b c} Cullen, p.1
14. ^ ^{a b} "Bastion of Flodden Wall, and Telfer Wall (section), Listed Building Report". Historic Scotland. http://hsewsf.sedsh.gov.uk/hslive/hsstart?P_HBNUM=28006. Retrieved 2009-10-09. 
15. ^ New Statistical Account of Scotland, p.627
16. ^ ^{a b c} Potter, p.22
17. ^ Catford, p.20
18. ^ ^{a b} Coghill, p.13
19. ^ Coghill, p.10
20. ^ Kerr, p.303
21. ^ Kerr, p.304
22. ^ The Earl of Hertford's expedition against Scotland, pp.10–12
23. ^ New Statistical Account of Scotland, p.626
24. ^ Potter, pp.60–65
25. ^ Potter, pp.85–86
26. ^ Potter, pp.105–106
27. ^ Potter, p.135
28. ^ ^{a b} "Greyfriars Churchyard, Listed Building Report". Historic Scotland. http://hsewsf.sedsh.gov.uk/hslive/portal.hsstart?P_HBNUM=27029. Retrieved 2009-10-09. 
29. ^ ^{a b} Schofield, p.155–156
30. ^ Roughhead, pp.126, 129
31. ^ Gibson, p.9
32. ^ Gibson, p.16
33. ^ ^{a b} Coghill, p.14
34. ^ The clock from the Netherbow was later incorporated into the Dean Gallery. Coghill, pp.14,17
35. ^ Cullen, p.4
36. ^ Cullen, p.17
37. ^ "Tweeddale Court, walling to west of court and to south of Tweeddale House, Listed Building Report". Historic Scotland. http://hsewsf.sedsh.gov.uk/hslive/hsstart?P_HBNUM=29058. Retrieved 2009-10-09. 
38. ^ Schofield, p.160
39. ^ "4-10 (even nos) Grassmarket, including former church and fragment of Flodden Wall, Listed Building Report". Historic Scotland. http://hsewsf.sedsh.gov.uk/hslive/portal.hsstart?P_HBNUM=28936. Retrieved 22009-11-09. 
40. ^ "Grassmarket gives up a forgotten piece of Flodden Wall". The Scotsman. 7 July 2008. http://heritage.scotsman.com/news/Grassmarket-gives-up-a-forgotten.4261923.jp. Retrieved 2009-10-09. 
41. ^ ^{a b} Historic Scotland (2003). "The Monument known as Edinburgh Town Wall, Flodden Wall and Telfer Wall, Heriot Place: Entry in the Schedule of Monuments". http://hsewsf.sedsh.gov.uk/eschedule/show?id=2901&OK=Y. Retrieved 2009-10-19. 
42. ^ "Secret of the setts revealed by group's detective work". The Scotsman. 30 December 2008. http://business.scotsman.com/edinburgh/Secret-of-the-setts-revealed.4829951.jp. Retrieved 2009-10-09. 
43. ^ Cullen, p.13
44. ^ Historic Scotland (2003). "The Monument known as Edinburgh Town Wall, Flodden Wall, Johnston Terrace to Grassmarket: Entry in the Schedule of Monuments". http://hsewsf.sedsh.gov.uk/eschedule/show?id=3012&OK=Y. Retrieved 2009-10-19. 
45. ^ Historic Scotland (2003). "The Monument known as Edinburgh Town Wall, Flodden Wall, Drummond Street to Pleasance: Entry in the Schedule of Monuments". http://hsewsf.sedsh.gov.uk/eschedule/show?id=3013&OK=Y. Retrieved 2009-10-19. 

Bibliography

• "Edinburgh". New Statistical Account of Scotland. I. Edinburgh: Blackwood. (1845). 
• Anon. (1886). The Earl of Hertford's expedition against Scotland, 1544. E. & G. Goldsmid. OCLC 4240031. http://www.archive.org/details/earlhertfordsex00unkngoog. 
• Bell, D. (2008). Edinburgh Old Town: The Forgotten Nature of an Urban Form. Tholis. ISBN 9780955948503. 
• Catford, E. F. (1975). Edinburgh: the story of a city. Hutchinson. ISBN 0091238501. 
• Coghill, Hamish (2004). Lost Edinburgh. Birlinn. ISBN 978-1841583099. 
• Cullen, W. Douglas (1988). The Walls of Edinburgh. Cockburn Association. ISBN 0950515914. 
• Fife, Malcolm (2001). The Nor Loch: Scotland's Lost Loch. Pentland Press. ISBN 978-1858218069. 
• Gibson, John Sibbald (1995). Edinburgh in the '45. Saltire Society. ISBN 0854110674. 
• Gifford, John; McWilliam, Colin; Walker, David (1984). Edinburgh. The Buildings of Scotland. Penguin. ISBN 014071068. 
• Kerr, Henry F. (1933). "Notes on the Nether Bow Port". Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 67: 297–307. http://ads.ahds.ac.uk/catalogue/adsdata/PSAS_2002/pdf/vol_067/67_297_307.pdf. 
• McWilliam, Colin (1975). Scottish Townscape. Collins. ISBN 0002167433. 
• Marwick, James David, ed (1871). Charters and other documents relating to the city of Edinburgh. A. D. 1143-1540. Scottish Burgh Records Society. LCCN 03014481. http://www.archive.org/details/chartersotherdoc00edin. 
• Miller, Peter (1887). "Was the town of Edinburgh an open and defenceless one before 1450?". Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 21: 251–265. http://ads.ahds.ac.uk/catalogue/adsdata/PSAS_2002/pdf/vol_021/21_251_265.pdf. 
• Neill, Patrick (1829). Notes Relative to the Fortified Walls of Edinburgh. 
• Potter, Harry (2003). Edinburgh Under Siege: 1571–1573. Tempus. ISBN 0752423320. 
• Roughhead, William, ed (1909). The Trial of Captain Porteous. William Hodge & Co. http://www.archive.org/details/trialofcaptainpo00port. 
• Schofield, John et al. (1976). "Excavations south of Edinburgh High Street 1973-4". Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland 107: 155–204. http://ads.ahds.ac.uk/catalogue/adsdata/PSAS_2002/pdf/vol_107/107_155_241.pdf. 

External links