Melbourne by-election, 1904

A by-election was held for the Australian House of Representatives seat of Melbourne in Victoria on 30 March 1904. This was triggered by the Chief Justice of the High Court (sitting as a Court of Disputed Elections) declaring invalid the election of Sir Malcolm McEacharn to the seat in the 1903 federal election. The writ for the by-election was issued by the Speaker of the Australian House of Representatives on 15 March 1904.^[1]

Background

The 1903 federal election took place on 16 December. Sir Malcolm McEacharn had held the seat for the Protectionist Party since the 1901 election, and was re-elected with a slim 77 vote majority. McEacharn's opponent in 1901 and 1903 was Dr. William Maloney, a medical doctor, social worker and reform agitator who had run for the Labour Party.

Following the declaration of McEacharn's election, Maloney petitioned the Court of Disputed Elections, alleging that the applications for 303 ballot papers had been improperly attested by persons unqualified to do so, including police constables, sergeants and other unqualified persons. In addition, 66 postal ballots were examined, and were likewise ruled invalid as having been recorded on material other than ordinary ballot papers. In all, between 240 and 250 "bad votes" were cast for McEacharn, easily negating his 77 vote majority.^[2]

The Chief Justice took the view that if the votes had been informal through any fault of the voters concerned, the votes would have been voided and Maloney elected. However, as the informality had arisen through the fault of Commonwealth electoral officers, he would have to rule the election invalid, thus triggering a by-election.^[2]

Results

Melbourne by-election, 1904[3]
Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±%
	Labour	William Maloney	8,667	52.61	+2.86
	Protectionist	Sir Malcolm McEacharn	7,808	47.39	−2.86
Total formal votes			16,475	98.65	+0.05
Informal votes			225	1.35	−0.05
Turnout			16,700	62.62	+4.11
	Labour gain from Protectionist		Swing	+2.86

Aftermath

A 2.86% swing towards Labour saw Dr. Maloney elected, and the seat of Melbourne was held by the ALP until 2010. Following his defeat, McEacharn abandoned not only politics but Australia, leaving the country in 1905 and moving to Wigtownshire in Scotland, where he purchased the ancestral home of the Earl of Galloway.^[4]

See also

• List of Australian federal by-elections

References

1. ^ "Federal Affairs – The Melbourne Election". The Advertiser. 15 March 1904. http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article4952203. 
2. ^ ^{a b} "Disputed Elections – Judgment on Points of Law – Sir Malcolm McEacharn Unseated". The Advertiser. 11 March 1904. http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article4952203. 
3. ^ "By-Elections 1903-1906". Psephos. http://psephos.adam-carr.net/countries/a/australia/1903/1903repsby.txt. 
4. ^ David Dunstan, 'McEacharn, Sir Malcolm Donald (1852 - 1910)', Australian Dictionary of Biography, Volume 10, Melbourne University Press, 1986, pp 263-264.