Saturnian (poetry)

Saturnian meter or verse is an old Latin and Italic poetic form, of which the principles of versification have become obscure. Only 132 complete uncontroversial verses survive. 95 literary verses and partial fragments have been preserved as quotations in later grammatical writings, as well as 37 verses in funerary or dedicatory inscriptions. The majority of literary Saturnians come from the "Odysseia" (more commonly known as the "Odissia" or "Odyssia"), a translation/paraphrase of Homer's "Odyssey" by Livius Andronicus (ca. 3rd century B.C.), and the "Bellum Poenicum", an epic on the First Punic War by Gnaeus Naevius (ca. 3rd century B.C.).

The meter was moribund by the time of the literary verses and forgotten altogether by classical times, falling out of use with the adoption of the hexameter and other Greek verse forms. Quintus Ennius is the poet who is generally credited with introducing the Greek hexameter in Latin, and dramatic meters seem to have been well on their way to domestic adoption in the works of his rough contemporary Plautus. These Greek verse forms were considered more sophisticated than the native tradition; Horace called the Saturnian "horridus". Consequently, the poetry in this meter was not preserved. Cicero regretted the loss in his "Brutus":

:"Atque utinam exstārent illa carmina, quae multīs saeclīs ante suam aetātem in epulīs esse cantitāta ā singulīs conuīuīs dē clārōrum uirōrum laudibus in "Orīginibus" scrīptum relīquit Catō."

::'I heartily wish those venerable Odes were still extant, which Cato informs us in his "Antiquities", used to be sung by every guest in his turn at the homely feasts of our ancestors, many ages before, to commemorate the feats of their heroes.'

However, it has been noted that later poets like Ennius (by extension Virgil, who follows him in both time and technique) preserve something of the Saturnian aesthetic in hexameter verse. Ennius explicitly acknowledges Naevius' poem and skill (lines 206–7 and 208–9 in the edition of Skutsch, with translations by Goldberg):

: [...] "scrīpsēre aliī rem":"uorsibus quōs ōlim Faunei uātesque canēbant"

::' [...] Others have given an account::in rhythms which the Fauns and seers sang.'

:"nam neque Mūsārum scopulōs ēscendit ad altōs":"nec dictī studiōsus fuit Rōmānus homō ante hunc."

::'For no Roman scaled the Muses' lofty crags::or was careful with his speech before this man.'

Ancient grammarians sought to derive the verse from a Greek model, in which syllable weight or the arrangement of light and heavy syllables was the governing principle. Scholars today remain divided between two approaches:

# The meter was quantitative (but not borrowed from Greek).
# The meter was accentual or based on accented and unaccented syllables.

Despite the division, there is some consensus regarding aspects of the verse's structure. A Saturnian line can be divided into two cola or half-lines, separated by a central caesura. The second colon is shorter than or as long as the first. Furthermore, in any half-line with seven or more syllables, the last three or four are preceded by word-end. This is known as Korsch's caesura or the "caesura Korschiana", after its discoverer.

The Saturnian as quantitative

Most—but not all—Saturnians can be captured by the following scheme:

* ∪ = light syllable
* – = heavy syllable
* ∪∪ = two light syllables that occupy the space of one heavy
* || = caesura
* ∪ over – (x at verse-end) = position can be occupied by either light or heavy syllable
* ∪∪ over – over ∪ = position can be occupied by any of the three

Examples

Numeration of literary fragments is according to Warmington's edition; translations are also by Warmington (see bibliography infra).

(1) Livius Andronicus, "Odissia" fragment 1

::"Virum mihī Camēna īnsece uersūtum":::∪ – ∪ – || ∪ – ∪ || – ∪ ∪ – – x:::'Tell me, O Goddess of song, of the clever man'

(2) Naevius, "Bellum Poenicum" fragments 2–4

::"Postquam auem aspexit in templō Anchīsa"::"sacr(ā) in mēnsā Penātium ordine pōnuntur"::"immolābat auream uictimam pulchram"

:::– ∪ ∪ ∪ || – – ∪ || – – – – – x:::∪ – – – || ∪ – (∪) – || – ∪ – – – x:::– ∪ – – || – ∪ – || – ∪ – – x

:::'After Anchises had seen a bird within the range of view,:::hallowed offerings were set in a row on the table of the Household Gods;:::and he busied himself in sacrificing a beautiul golden victim.'

(3) Epitaph of Lucius Cornelius Scipio Barbatus (ca. 270–150 B.C.)

:: GNAIVOD•PATRE::PROGNATVS•FORTIS•VIR•SAPIENSQVE—QVOIVS•FORMA•VIRTVTEI•PARISVMA::FVIT—CONSOL CENSOR•AIDILIS•QVEI•FVIT•APVD•VOS—TAVRASIA•CISAVNA::SAMNIO•CEPIT—SVBIGIT•OMNE•LOVCANA•OPSIDESQVE•ABDOVCIT

:::In regularized orthography (note the punctuation on the stone, viz. — = verse-end):

::::"Gnaeuō patre / prōgnātus, fortis uir sapiēnsque"::::"cuius fōrma uirtūtī parissuma / fuit"::::"cōnsul, cēnsor, aedīlis quī fuit apud uōs"::::"Taurāsiam, Cisaunam, / Samnium cēpit"::::"subigit omnem Lūcānam, opsidēsque abdūcit."

:::– – ∪ ∪ || – – – || – – – || ∪ ∪ – x:::– ∪* – ∪ || – – – || ∪ – ∪ ∪ ∪ x:::– – – ∪† || – – ∪* || – ∪ ∪† ∪ –** x:::– – ∪ – || ∪ – – || – ∪ – – x:::∪∪ ∪ – – || – – ∪ || – ∪ – ∪ || – – x

::::* As in early Latin poetry, if not – as in later.::::** Some early Latin poetry treats this as ∪.::::† This syllable is historically –.

:::'Sprung from Gnaeus his father, a man strong and wise,:::whose appearance was most in keeping with his virtue,:::who was consul, censor, and aedile among you,:::he captured Taurasia, Cisauna, Samnium,:::he subdued all Lucania and led off hostages.'

The Saturnian as accentual

W.M. Lindsay formalizes the accentual scheme of the Saturnian as follows:

* ´ = accented syllable
* ∪ = unaccented

Handbooks otherwise schematize the verse as 3+ || 2+ stresses. This theory assumes Classical Latin accentuation. However, there is reason to believe that the Old Latin accent may have played a role in the verse. It should be noted that Lindsay himself later abandoned his theory.

Examples

Here are the same texts from above, scanned accentually.

(4) Livius Andronicus, "Odissia" fragment 1

::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪ ∪ (Old Latin)::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪ (Classical Latin)

(5) Naevius, "Bellum Poenicum" fragments 2–4

::(Old Latin)

:::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪ ´ ∪ ∪:::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ∪ (∪) ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪ ∪:::´ ∪ ` ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪

::(Classical Latin)

:::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪:::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ∪ ´ (∪) ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪:::` ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪

(6) Epitaph of Lucius Cornelius Scipio Barbatus

::(Old Latin)

:::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ || ´ ∪ ´ || ´ ∪ ` ∪:::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪:::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ || ´ ´ ∪ ´ ∪ ´:::´ ∪ ∪ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪::: ´ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ || ´ ∪ ` ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪

::(Classical Latin)

:::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ∪ ´ || ` ∪ ´ ∪:::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪:::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ´ ∪ ´ ∪ ´:::∪ ´ ∪ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪:::´ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪ || ` ∪ ´ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪

The Saturnian in non-Latin Italic

Despite the obscurity of the principles of Saturnian versification in Latin, scholars have nonetheless attempted to extend analysis to other languages of ancient Italy related to Latin.

(7) Faliscan (two nearly identical inscriptions on cups from Civita Castellana, 4th century B.C.)

::FOIED•VINO•(PI)PAFO•CRA•CAREFO

:::In Latin orthography:

::::"foiiēd uīnom (pi)pafō. crā(s) carēfō."

:::– – – – (||) ∪ (∪) – || – ∪ – x (Quantitative):::´ ∪ ´ ∪ (||) ´ (∪) ∪ || ´ ∪ ´ ∪ (Accentual)

:::'Today, I shall drink wine. Tomorrow, I shall go without.'

(8) Oscan (one of several similar inscriptions in Etruscoid script on vessels from Teano, 3rd century B.C.)

::minis:beriis:anei:upsatuh:sent:tiianei*

::::* Sabellian inscriptional texts in native orthography are conventionally transcribed in bold-face minuscule, and those in the Latin script italicized.

:::In Latin orthography:

::::"Minis Beris ā(n)nei opsātō sent Teānei."

:::(scansion of first three words uncertain) || – – – – || ∪ – x (Quantitative):::´ ∪ ´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ∪ – ∪ – || ∪ – ∪ (Accentual)

:::' (these) were made at Teanum in Minius Berius' (workshop?).' (meaning of anei uncertain)

(9) Umbrian (inscription on a bronze plate from Plestia, 4th century B.C.)

::cupras matres pletinas sacrụ [esu] **

::::** In epigraphy, graphemes transcribed with an underdot are of uncertain reading, and restorations are enclosed in square brackets.

:::In Latin orthography:

::::"Cuprās Mātris Plestīnās sacrum esum."

:::∪ – – – || – – – || ∪ ∪ ∪ x (Quantitative):::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ∪ ´ ∪ (Accentual)

:::'I am a sacred object of Mother Cupra from Plestia.' (Cupra was a Sabine goddess)

(10) Paelignian (final verse in an inscription on a stone from Corfinium, 1st century B.C.)

::"lifar dida uus deti hanustu herentas"

:::In Latin orthography:

::::"Līfar dida(t) uūs deti hanustō herentās."

:::– – ∪ – || – (scansion of "deti" uncertain) || ∪ – – ∪ – x (Quantitative):::´ ∪ ´ ∪ || ´ ´ ∪ || ∪ ´ ∪ ∪ ´ ∪ (Accentual)

:::'May Liber grant you ... (good?) will ....' (meanings of "deti" and "hanustu" unknown)

Prehistory of the Saturnian

A large number of the verses have a 4 || 3 || 3 || 3 syllable count and division, which scholars have been inclined to take as underlying or ideal. This has permitted comparison with meters from related Indo-European poetic traditions outside Italic, such as Celtic, and a few scholars have tried to trace the verse back to Proto-Indo-European. John Vigorita derived the 4 || 3 || 5-6 syllable Saturnian from:

a Proto-Indo-European 7- or 8-syllable line combined with a shorter 5- or 6-syllable line, which is itself derivable from the octosyllable by undoing truncations (noted in metrical schemes by one or more ^'s, wherever in the meter the truncation has occurred).

M.L. West schematized this subset of verses as:

which he then traces to two Proto-Indo-European octosyllables:

one giving the Saturnian's heptasyllabic half-line by acephaly (truncation of line-beginning), the other yielding the hexasyllabic colon both by acephaly and catalexis (truncation of line-end). Ultimately, owing to the difficulties of describing and analyzing the Saturnian without taking its history into account, attempts at reconstruction have not won acceptance.

References

In English, two collections of the texts are available. Warmington's Loeb contains Livius Andronicus and Naevius' Saturnians, among other poetry and poets, and Courtney's anthology with commentary includes the Scipionic epitaphs and other inscriptions. Regarding the meter, the standard quantitative treatment is still Cole. The details of the accentual approach are set out in Lindsay. A new proposal that draws from Generative Linguistics has recently been put forward by Parsons (currently under follow-up investigation by Angelo Mercado, whose analysis is available [http://www.bol.ucla.edu/~maom/research/ on line] ). No recent treatment of non-Latin Italic material is available in English; see Costa, Morelli, and Poccetti. Vigorita and West discuss the Saturnian and its prehistory in connection with the reconstruction of Proto-Indo-European meter. Goldberg's book is an excellent treatment of the development of Roman epic from Livius Andronicus to Ennius to Virgil. The standard edition of Ennius' "Annales" is that of Skutsch. See also Whitman for a comparative study of Old Latin and Old English meter (he argues for alliteration and accent as definitive for both).

* Cole, Thomas. "The Saturnian Verse." "Yale Classical Studies" 21 (1969): 3–73.
* Costa, Gabriele. "Sulla preistoria della tradizione poetica italica" ["On the Prehistory of the Italic Poetic Tradition"] . Florence: Olschki, 1998.
* Courtney, Edward. "MUSA LAPIDARIA: A Selection of Latin Verse Inscriptions". Atlanta, Georgia: Scholars Press, 1995.
* Goldberg, Sander. "Epic in Republican Rome." New York/Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995.
* Lindsay, W.M. "The Saturnian Meter. Second Paper." "American Journal of Philology" 14.3 (1893): 305–334.
* Morelli, Giussepe. "Un antico saturnio popolare falisco" ["An Ancient Popular Faliscan Saturnian"] . "Archeologia Classica" 25–26 (1973–74): 440–52.
* Parsons, Jed. "A New Approach to the Saturnian Verse and Its Relation to Latin Prosody." "Transactions of the American Philological Association" 129 (1999): 117–137.
* Poccetti, Paolo. "Elementi culturali negli epitafi poetici peligni. III: La struttura metrica" ["Cultural Elements in the Paelignian Poetic Epitaphs. III: Metrical Structure"] . "ΑΙΩΝ" ["AIŌN"] 4 (1982): 213–36.
* Poccetti, Paolo. "Eine Spur des saturnisches Verses im Oskischen" ["A Trace of the Saturnian Verse in Oscan"] . "Glotta" 61 (1983): 207–17.
* Skutsch, Otto, ed. "The "Annals" of Quintus Ennius." Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1985.
* Vigorita, John. "Indo-European Comparative Metrics". Ph.D. Dissertation. University of California, Los Angeles, 1973.
* Warmington, E.H. "Remains of Old Latin". Volume 2. Loeb Classical Library 314. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1936.
* West, M.L. "Indo-European Metre." "Glotta" 51 (1973): 161–187.
* Whitman, F.H. "A Comparative Study of Old English Metre" (University of Toronto Press: Toronto, 1993).