Syndemic refers to the concentration of two or more
diseasesor other healthconditions in a population in which there is some level of biological interaction among the diseases and health conditions that magnifies the negative health effects of one or more of the co-present diseases or health conditions. The notion that there can be two or more co-occurring diseases is, of course, not new, and is referred to as comorbidity among other terms. The differences between “comorbid” and “syndemic,” however, are not merely semantic. As Mustanski et al. (2008:40) explain: “ comorbidity research tends to focus on the nosological issues of boundaries and overlap of diagnoses, while syndemic research focuses on communities experiencing co-occurring epidemics that additively increase negative health consequences.” Consequently, it is possible for two afflictions to be comorbid, but not represent a syndemic (i.e., the disorders are not epidemic in the studied population or their co-occurrence is not accompanied by increased adverse health consequences). Thus, two (or more) diseases can be comorbid but no interaction occurs between them, while in other cases interaction occurs but it has beneficial rather than deleterious consequences. "Syndemic theory" seeks to draw attention to and provide a framework for the analysis of adverse disease interactions, including their causes and consequences for human life and well-being.
Notably, syndemics tend to develop under conditions of
health disparity, caused by poverty, stress, or structural violence, and contribute to a significant burden of illness in affected populations. The term syndemics is further reserved to label the dual interactions between co-present diseases in a population and between these diseases and the social conditions that contribute to their spread and negative health impact on the population.
The term syndemic was developed and introduced by
Merrill Singerin several articles in the mid-1990s and has since received growing attention and use among epidemiologists and medical anthropologists concerned with community health and the effects of social conditions and social inequality on health. The traditional biomedical approach to disease is characterized by an effort to diagnostically isolate, study, and treat diseases as if they were distinct entities that existed in nature separate from other diseases and independent of the social contexts in which they are found. This approach proved useful historically in focusing medical attention on the immediate causes and biological expressions of disease and contributed, as a result, to the emergence of targeted modern biomedical treatments for specific diseases, some of which have been enormously successful. As the compendium of knowledge on diseases has advanced, however, it has become increasingly clear that diseases do not usually exist in isolation from other diseases and health conditions, that synergistic disease interactions are of considerable importance to disease course and consequence, and that the social conditions of disease sufferers are critical to understanding the clustering and spread of disease, its expression in signs and symptoms, and its health impact at the individual and population levels.
Types of Disease Interaction
Interest in the "syndemics perspective" has been driven by growing evidence of the regularity of interactions among diseases and recognition that this interaction influences disease course, expression, severity, transmission, and diffusion. Several different kinds of interaction among diseases have been described, including both indirect (changes caused by one disease that facilitate another in some way) and direct interface (disease act in direct tandem). In some syndemic interactions—such as the one between
diabetesand SARS--changes in biochemistry or damage to organ systems caused by one disease (in this case, diabetes), such as weakening of the immune system, promotes the progression of another disease (SARS). This is the relationship found as well between HIV infection and a host of “opportunistic” bacterial (e.g., tuberculosis), mycobacterial (e.g., Mycobacterium avium), fungal (e.g., candidiasis), protozoal (e.g., toxoplasmosis), and viral (e.g., Human Papilloma Virus) infections and possibly viral-caused malignancies ( Kaposi's Sarcoma, which may, in fact, be a viral infection rather than a cancer). Similarly, there is evidence that periodontitis, the progressive loss of the soft tissues (the periodontium) that surround and support the teeth (which can lead eventually to tooth loss), may also be the consequence of a syndemic involving the promotion of one type of infection by another. Periodontitis is known to be caused by bacteria of several different species (e.g., "Porphyromonas gingivalis", "Dialister pneumosintes", "Prevotella intermedia") that adhere to and reproduce on tooth surfaces, especially under the gum line. Multiplication of these pathogens may be inhibited by bodily defenses unless these are weakened by a herpesvirusinfection of the periodontium.
Another type of syndemic relationship involves one disease enhancing the virulence of another. There is evidence, for example, that herpesvirus has this effect on HIV infection, with progression to full-blown AIDS being significantly accelerated by co-infection with herpesvirus. Similarly, in gum infection, periodontal bacteria may enhance the virulence of herpesvirus.
Alternately, one disease can assist the physical transmission of another disease. This appears to be the case, for example, with syphilis and HIV coinfection as a result of genital-tract ulceration caused by the former supporting sexual transmission of the latter. Direct interaction of diseases is in the case of gene mixing among different types of pathogenic agents, as has been described thus far in various plant and animal species. Genetic exchange by recombination of genomic segments is an important process in RNA virus evolution, resulting often in important phenotypic changes that allow changes in the spread and strength of viral infection. Gene mixing among completely different types of pathogenic agents has also been described, such as occurs between avian leukosis virus and Markek's disease virus (MDV) in domestic fowl. Both of these cancer-causing viruses are known to infect the same poultry flock, the same chicken, and, even the same anatomic cell. In co-infected cells, the retroviral DNA of the avian leukosis virus can integrate into the MDV genome, producing altered biological properties compared to those of the parental MDV. The frequency of gene reassortment among human pathogens is less clear than is the case among plant or some animal species but of significant potential concern as animal diseases adapt to human hosts—which they have been doing at an increasingly rapid pace--and as new diseases come into contact.
In some cases, co-infection may open up multiple syndemic pathways. In studies of human populations, a lethal synergism has been identified between influenza virus and pneumococcus, a likely cause of excess mortality from secondary bacterial pneumonia during influenza epidemics. There is a significant level of evidence indicating that the influenza virus alters the lungs in ways that increase the adherence, invasion and induction of disease by pneumococcus. But other consequential changes, such as alteration of the immune response which weakens the body’s ability to clear pneumococcus (or, alternately, by amplifying the inflammatory cascade), are also suggested by existing research. In other cases, syndemic interaction among diseases is apparent but the pathways of linkage are not yet clear. An example is the apparent interaction that occurs between type 2 diabetes mellitus and hepatitis C viral infection. Several factors are known to contribute to the onset of
type 2 diabetes, including diet, obesity and aging. The role of infection, however, is only beginning to be understood. Already it is known that risk for serious infections of various kinds increase significantly with poor diabetes control, but appreciation of more complex relationships between infection and type 2 diabetes is now emerging as well.
Discussion of deleterious disease interactions raises a question about the possibility of an opposite kind of disease interaction, namely: are there counter syndemics, disease interactions that lower the burden of disease in a population below the sum effects of the individual diseases involved? The discovery of counter-syndemics is important because such entities may suggest novel strategies for the prevention and treatment of disease. Recent research findings suggest that counter-syndemics do occur and are part of the complex world of co-morbidity. For example, William Moss and fellow researchers at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health have found that human immunodeficiency virus is transiently suppressed during an acute
measlesinfection. This finding was the product of a study of HIV-infected children living in Zambia. In the study, children who had measles, and reported various typical symptoms, including fever, rash, conjunctivitis, runny nose, and cough, had a significant drop in HIV levels detectable in the blood as compared to HIV-infected children who were not infected with measles. Several potential mechanisms could be responsible for the temporary suppression of HIV replication early in the course of a measles infection. Morbillivirus (measles virus) infection is known to cause lymphopenia, a reduction in the number of CD4+ T lymphocytes circulating in the blood. The low point in lymphocyte levels occurs just prior to the onset of the distinct red circular skin rash (called rubeola) characteristic of a measles infection. Within a month of this nadir, the number of lymphocytes tends to return to normal levels. The drop in HIV may reflect a decrease in target CD4+ T cells needed for replication. Alternately, measles virus infection may stimulate the production of cells that are directly responsible for suppressing HIV replication. Several candidates have been suggested, including the β-chemokines, CD8+ cell antiviral factor, and the cytokines known as IL-10 and IL-16 (biochemicals that inhibit HIV transcription), but none has been confirmed as the source of HIV suppression. Additionally, Moss and co-workers found that median plasma levels of RANTES, a chemokine that attracts immune system components like eosinophils (a kind of white blood cell that destroys parasitic organisms), monocytes (a precursor of macrophages), and lymphocytes, were higher in HIV-infected children with measles than in those without measles. HIV suppression also has been identified in patients suffering tsutsugamushi disease, a mite-borne infection found in Asia and Australia, also known as scrub typhus, although the how this occurs is not clear. Other counter-syndemics are likely to be discovered as a syndemic perspective emphazing paying attention to processes and relationships diffuses among researchers.
iatrogenesismeans "brought forth by a healer" ( iatrois the Greek word for healer) and almost always is used to refer to adverse health conditions caused by medical treatment (such as unwelcome side effects). Can there be iatrogenic syndemics? In principle, this is possible if medical treatment or medical research is involved in creating conditions that increase the likelihood that two or more diseases come together in a population. An example of this scenario would be the use of gene splicingto unite two pathogenic agents and introducing the resulting novel organism into a population. There is a possibility that this precise event occurred, for example, during a randomized, double-blind clinical trial testing the efficacy of the prototype HIV vaccine called V520. On November 6, 2007, the pharmaceutical manufacturer Merck & Co. announced that research on the drug had been stopped because interim findings showed that there appeared to be an increased risk for HIV infection among participants in the vaccine arm of the study compared to those in the placebo group. Specifically, results showed that of the 741 volunteers in the vaccine group, 24 developed HIV infection (3.2%), while among the 762 volunteers in the placebo arm of the trial, 21 developed HIV (2.75%). Notably, investigators in the study reported a higher risk of HIV infection was found among participants who had an existing immunity to the common cold virus (known as adenovirustype 5 or Ad5). The vaccine was created using a mixture of three components, each of which was made in the laboratory with a replication-defective version of Ad5. This was the organism selected to serve as a carrier, or delivery vector, for three synthetically produced HIV genes. Researchers suggested one explanation for the higher rate of HIV infection among individuals in the treatment group was that the vaccine lowered defenses against the human immunodeficiency virus. In other words, novel organisms created through splicing of genes from two naturally occurring pathogens may have increased the rate of disease. While other explanations of the results exist, the study suggests the possibility of the emergence of syndemics with an iatrogenic origin.
Examples of Syndemics
Various syndemics (although not always labeled as such) have been described in the literature already, including: the
SAVAsyndemic (substance abuse, violence and AIDS): the hookworm, malariaand HIV/AIDSsyndemic: the Chagas disease, rheumatic heart diseaseand congestive heart failuresyndemic: the possible asthmaand infectious diseasesyndemic: the malnutritionand depression syndemic: the TB, HIV and violencesyndemic: the whooping cough, influenza, tuberculosissyndemic; the HIV and STDsyndemic; the stress and obesitysyndemic, and the mental healthand HIV/AIDS syndemic. Additional syndemics are being identified around the world as public health officials, researchers, and service providers begin to focus on the connections among diseases and the social context factors that foster disease concentration and interactions. In January 2006, in a speech at the Enhancing the Healing Environment conference hosted by The Prince's Foundation for the Built Environment and The King's Fund, St James's Palace, London, Prince Charles, The Prince of Wales, noted the importance of paying attention to the built environment, physical inactivity and the obsesity/ diabetessyndemic.
Syndemics in History
While the rate at which new syndemics develop has accelerated through human history, as populations became larger and ever wider tracts of land were inhabited, as the speed of transportation increased with new technologies, and as human impact on the earth's climatic and other environmental systems increased, syndemics are not a new phenomenon. An example of a syndemic from the 19th century can be found on the reservations on which Native Americans were confined with the closing of the U.S. frontier.
It is estimated that in 1860 there were well over 10 million
bisonliving on the American Plains. By the early 1880s, the last of the great herds of bison upon which Plains Indianpeoples like the Siouxwere dependent as a food source were gone, victims of economic greed as well as a conscious plan to control Plains Indian populations. White hunting parties scoured the region, sometimes shooting hundreds or even thousands of bison a day. At the same time, after the U.S. military's defeat at the Battle of the Little Bighornin 1876, there was a concerted effort to beat the Sioux into total submission. Thus, in 1872, Secretary of the Interior Columbus Delanostated: “as they become convinced that they can no longer rely upon the supply of game for their support, they will return to the more reliable source of subsistence [i.e., farming] ." As a result, they were forced to give up their struggle for an independent existence on their own lands and take up reservation life at the mercy of government authority. Treaties that were signed with the Sioux in 1868 and 1876 stipulated that they would be provided with government annuities and provisions in payment for sections of their land and with the expectation among federal representatives that the Sioux would become farmers on individually held plots of land. The Sioux found themselves confined on a series of small reservations where they were treated as a conquered people. Moreover, as was typical of treaties with Native peoples, the government reneged on its promises. The food that was provided to the Sioux was insufficient and of low quality. Black Elk, a noted Sioux folk healer, told his biographer: “There was hunger among my people before I went across the big water [to Europe in 1886] , because the Wasichus [whites] did not give us all the food they promised in the Black Hills treaty... But it was worse when I came back  . My people looked pitiful… We could not eat lies and there was nothing we could do.” Under extremely stressful conditions, and with inadequate diets, as well as being the victims of overt racism on the part of the registration agents appointed to oversee Indian reserves, the Sioux confronted exposure to infectious disease transmitted from contact with whites. While knowledge about the epidemiology of the Sioux from this period is limited, James Mooney, an anthropologist and representative of the Bureau of Indian Affairssent to investigate a possible Sioux rebellion, described the health situation on the reservation in 1896: “In 1888 their cattle had been diminished by disease. In 1889, their crops were a failure ... Thus followed epidemics of measles, grippe [influenza] , and whooping cough Pertussis, in rapid succession and with terrible fatal results…” Similarly, the "Handbook of American Indians" notes, “The least hopeful conditions in this respect prevail among the Dakota [Sioux] and other tribes of the colder northern regions, where pulmonary tuberculosis and scrofula are very common… Other more common diseases, are various forms of, bronchitis… pneumonia, pleurisy, and measlesin the young. Whooping cough is also met with.” Indian children who were removed to white boarding schools were diagnosed with a wide range of diseases, including tuberculosis, trachoma, measles, small pox, whooping cough, influenza, and pneumonia.
As these accounts suggest, it is likely that the Sioux were victims of a syndemic that combined a number of interacting infectious diseases, inadequate diet, and stressful and extremely disheartening life conditions, including, with events like the massacre at
Wounded Kneein 1890 and the murder of their leader Sitting Bull, outright brutalization. As a result, while the official mortality rate on the reservation was between one and two percent, the death rate was probably closer to 10 percent, a devastatingly high figure.
The Influenza Syndemics
There were three
influenza pandemicsduring the 20th century that caused widespread illness, mortality, social disruption, and significant economic losses. These occurred in 1918, 1957, and 1968. In each case, mortality rates were determined primarily by five factors: the number of people who became infected, the virulence of the virus causing the pandemic, the speed of global spread, the underlying features and vulnerabilities of the most affected populations, and the effectiveness and timeliness of the prevention and treatment measures that were implemented. These factors unite a range of bio-social causal forces, including production, communication, and transportation technologies; the medical and public health infrastructures; the specific pathogens involved and the nature of their interactions with human hosts; and the pre-existing health status of patients. All of these, in turn, are shaped, to greater or somewhat lesser degree, by overarching political economic structures globally and locally. Epidemics, in short, including their emergence, course, and impact (and whether they become wide spread pandemics that exact a sorrowful toll on life and well-being) are sculpted by the configuration of human social relationships including prevailing patterns of social inequality.
The 1957 pandemic was caused by the Asian influenza virus (known as the H2N2 strain), a novel influenza variety to which humans had not yet developed immunities. The death toll of the 1957 pandemic is estimated to have been around two million globally, with approximately 70,000 deaths in the United States. A little over a decade later, the comparatively mild Hong Kong influenza pandemic erupted due to the spread of a virus strain (H3N2) that genetically was related to the more deadly form seen in 1957. The pandemic was responsible for about one million deaths around the world, almost 34,000 of which were in the United States. In both of these pandemics, death may not have been due only to the primary viral infection, but also to secondary bacterial infections among influenza patients; in short, they were caused by a viral/bacterial syndemic (but see Chatterjee 2007). The worst of the 20 century influenza pandemics was the 1918 outbreak, which epidemiologists estimate was responsible for the deaths of between 40-100 million people worldwide, making it one of the most deadly events in human history. More people died of the so-called
Spanish flu(caused by the H1N1 viral strain) pandemic in the single year of 1918 than during all four-years of the Black Death( Bubonic plague) scourge that lasted from 1347 to 1351 (although a significantly higher percentage of the world’s population died of the plague than of Spanish flu). It is estimated that between 20-40 percent of the world’s population became ill during the 1918 pandemic.
The pandemic had devastating effects as disease spread along trade and shipping routes and other corridors of human movement until it had circled the globe. In places like India, the mortality rate reached 50 per 1,000 population. Arriving during the closing phase of the World War I, the pandemic had a significant impact on mobilized national armies. Half of U.S. soldiers who died in the “Great War,” for example, were victims of influenza not of enemy bombs and bullets. It is estimated that almost ¾ of a million Americans died during the pandemic. As noted by one alarmed scientific observer at the time, “ [if the pandemic continues] civilization could easily disappear from the face of the earth within a matter of a few more weeks”. In part, the death toll during the pandemic was caused by viral pneumonia characterized by extensive bleeding in the lungs resulting in suffocation. Many victims died within 48 hours of the appearance of the first symptom. In fact, it was not uncommon for people who appeared to be quite healthy in the morning to have died by sunset. Among those who survived the first several days, however, many died of secondary bacterial pneumonia. Moreover, it has been argued that countless numbers of those who expired quickly from the disease were co-infected with tuberculosis, which would explain the notable plummet in TB cases after 1918 (because so many carriers of the disease perished during the influenza pandemic). Again, as seen with the previous two 20th century global influenza outbreaks, disease interaction appears to have been critical, underlining the importance of syndemics more generally in the production of major public health crises.
Syndemics and the Environment
As a result of the floral changes produced by global warming, a significant escalation is occurring in global rates of allergies and asthma. Currently, allergic diseases constitute the sixth leading cause of chronic illness in the United States, impacting the lives of 17 percent of the population.
Asthma, characterized by episodic inflammation and narrowing of small airway passages in the lungs, affects about 8 percent of the U.S. population, but the rate of affected individuals has been steadily climbing in recent years, especially in low income, ethnic minority neighborhoods in cities. Thus, in 1980 asthma was found to affect only about three percent of the U.S. population according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Asthma among children has been increasing at an even faster pace than among adults, with the percentage of children with asthma going up from 3.6 percent in 1980 to 9 percent in 2005. Among ethnic minority populations, Puerto Ricans the rate of asthma is 125 percent higher than non-Hispanic white people and 80 percent higher than non-Hispanic black people. The asthma prevalence among American Indians, Alaska Natives and black people is 25 percent higher than white people. As is so often the case with health, including health conditions directly affected by global warming, the poor and marginalized suffer the gravest consequences.
Increases in rates of asthma have occurred despite improvements in air quality produced by the passage and enforcement of clean air legislation, such as both the Clean Air Act of 1963 and the Clean Air Act of 1990 in the United States. In other words, existing legislation and regulation have not kept pace with changing climatic conditions and their health consequences. Compounding the problem of air quality is the fact that air-borne pollens have been found to attach themselves to diesel particles from truck or other vehicular exhaust floating in the air, resulting in heightened rates of asthma in areas where busy roads bisect densely populated areas, most notably in poorer inner city areas. Research by the American Cancer Society found that a six percent increase in cardiopulmonary deaths occurs for every elevation of 10 μg/m3 in particulate matter concentration in the air. Exhaust from the burning of diesel fuel is a complex mixture of vapors, gases, and fine particles, including over 40 known pollutants like nitrogen oxide and known or suspected carcinogenic substances such as benzene, arsenic, and formaldehyde. Exposure to diesel exhaust irritates the eyes, nose, throat and lungs, causing coughs, headaches, light headedness and nausea, while causing people with allergies to be more susceptible allergy triggers like dust or pollen. Many particles in disease fuel are so tiny they are able to penetrate deep into the lungs when inhaled. Importantly, diesel fuel particles appear to have even greater immunologic effects in the presence of environmental allergens than they do alone. According Robert Pandya and co-workers who are studying the role of diesel fuel in asthma, “This immunologic evidence may help explain the epidemiologic studies indicating that children living along major trucking thoroughfares are at increased risk for asthmatic and allergic symptoms and are more likely to have objective evidence of respiratory dysfunction.”
Importantly, the damaging effects of diesel fuel pollution appears to go significantly beyond playing a synergistic role in the development of asthma. Recent research suggests that exposure to a combination of microscopic diesel fuel particles among people with high blood cholesterol (i.e., low-density lipoprotein, LDL or “bad cholesterol”) increases the risk for both heart attack and stroke significantly above levels found among those exposed to only one of these health risks. According to André Nel, Chief of Nanomedicine at the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA who led the study of duel exposure, “When you add one plus one, it normally totals two… But we found that adding diesel particles to cholesterol fats equals three. Their combination creates a dangerous synergy that wreaks cardiovascular havoc far beyond what's caused by the diesel or cholesterol alone.” The synergy begins when free radical molecules that are attached to diesel exhaust particles enter the body through the lungs and pass into the circulatory system. Another source of free radicals is the fatty acids that comprise LDL cholesterol, which produce free radicals during cell metabolism. Free radical molecules are highly unstable because they have an odd number of electrons in their outer ring. As a result, they react quickly with other compounds in order to “steal” an electron and gain stability. When the "victimized" molecule loses its electron, it, in turn, becomes a free radical and a chain reaction called oxidation is produced that is known to be damaging to living cells and tissues. Of interest to the Los Angeles research team was the consequences of both sources of free radical production coming into contact. Experimentation revealed that the two mechanisms worked in tandem to stimulate genes that promote cell inflammation, a primary risk for hardening and blockage of blood vessels (
atherosclerosis) and, as narrowed arteries collect cholesterol deposits and trigger blood clots, for heart attacksand strokesas well. Atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease is the leading cause of death in developed countries.
The Mathematical Modelling of Syndemics
mathematical modelis a simplified representation using mathematical language to describe patterns of behavior in natural, mechanical or social systems. Beginning early in the 20th century, epidemiologists became increasingly interested in the use of mathematical modelling procedures to project possible patterns in the spread of infectious diseases, including potential outcomes of an epidemic. To achieve these goals, epidemiological modelers unite several types of information and analytic capacity, including: 1) mathematical equations and computational algorithms; 2) computer technology; 3) epidemiological knowledge about infectious disease dynamics, including information about specific pathogens and disease vectors; and 4) research data on social conditions and human behavior. Mathematical modelling in epidemiologyis now being applied to syndemics. Abu-Raddad, Patnaik, and Kublin (2006), for example, used modelling to quantify the syndemic effects of malaria and HIV in sub-Saharan Africa based on research in Kisumu, Kenya. These researchers point out that infection with HIV facilitates disease progression in individuals exposed to malaria. At the same time, immune reaction to malaria doubles the infectious level of HIV infected individual. In short, in typical syndemic fashion, each of these diseases amplifies the effects of the other. Using mathematical modelling, Abu-Raddad and co-workers found that 5% of HIV infections (or 8,500 cases of HIV since 1980) in Kisumu are the result of the higher HIV infectiousness of malaria-infected HIV patients. Additionally, their model attributed 10% of adult malaria episodes (or almost one million excess malaria infections since 1980) to the greater susceptibility of HIV infected individuals to malaria. Their model also suggests that HIV has contributed to the wider geographic spread of malaria in Africa, a process previously thought to be the consequence primarily of global warming. Other researchers (e.g., Herring and Sattenspiel 2007) also have begun to apply mathematical modelling to syndemics. Modelling offers an enormously useful tool for anticipating future syndemics, including eco-syndemic, based on information about the spread of various diseases across the planet and the consequent co-infections and disease interactions that will result.
In this regard, Jeremy Lauer and colleges (2003) have developed PopMod, a longitudinal population tool that models distinct and possibly interacting diseases. Unlike other life-table population models, PopMod is specifically designed to not assume the statistical independence of the diseases of interest. The PopMod has several intended purposes, including describing the time evolution of population health for standard demographic purposes (such as estimating healthy life expectancy in a population), and providing a standard measure of effectiveness for health interventions and cost-effectiveness analysis. PopMod is used as one of the standard tools of the World Health Organization’s (
WHO) CHOICE (Choosing Interventions that are Cost-Effective) program, an initiative designed to provide national health policy makers in the WHO’s 14 epidemiological sub-regions around the world with findings on a range of health intervention costs and effects.
Future Research on Syndemics
Medical anthropologist, epidemiologists, and clinical researchers are just beginning to understand the nature of syndemics. There is a critical need for new research in this area. Important arenas of inquiry include the following: First, there is a need for studies that examine the processes by which syndemics emerge, including the specific sets of health and social conditions that foster the occurrence of multiple epidemics in a population and how syndemics function to produce specific kinds of health outcomes in populations. Second, there is a need to better understand processes of interaction between specific diseases with each other and with health-related factors like malnutrition, structural violence, discrimination, stigmatization, and toxic environmental exposure that reflect oppressive social relationships. Specifically, there is a need to identify all of the ways, directly and indirectly, that diseases can interact and have, as a result, enhanced impact on human health. Third there is a need for the development of an eco-syndemic understanding of the ways in which
global warmingis contributing to the spread of diseases to new areas and to the potential for new disease interactions. Already it is clear that as a result of global warming infectious diseases such as West Nile Virusare spreading to new places. Similarly malaria is now found in new places because it is spread by particular mosquito species that are migrating to new locations as a reult of changing climates. As a consequence, diseases that did not often interact in the past---through co-infection of the same individuals within a population---may begin interacting more regularly. Finally, there is a need for a better understanding of how the public health systems and communities can best respond to and limit the health consequences of syndemics. Systems are needed to monitor the emergence of syndemics and to allow "early-bird" medical and public health responses designed to lessen their impact. Systematic ethno-epidemiological surveillance with populations subject to multiple social stressors must be one component of such a monitoring system. Current efforts by researchers at the CDC to expand the discussion of syndemics in public health discourse is an important step in the development of a funded research agenda that addresses these research needs. Given the nature of syndemics, this research requires a bio-cultural/social approach that attends to both clinical and social processes.
List of Epidemics
References on Syndemics
Abu-Raddad, Laith, Patnaik, P., and Kublin, J2006 Dual Infection with HIV and Malaria Fuels the Spread of Both Diseases in sub-Saharan Africa. "Science" 314:1603-1606.
Acevedo, Gabriel2008 Causal Determinism, Elective Affinities, and Syndemic Networks: An Application of Epidemiological Theory to the Study of non-Medical Phenomenon. "All Academic Research". Available online at: http://www.allacademic.com//meta/p_mla_apa_research_citation/1/8/4/6/3/pages184630/p184630-1.php.
Akksilp, Somsak, Karnkawinpong, Opart, Wattanaamornkiat, Wanpen, Viriyakitja, Daranee, Monkongdee, Patama, Sitti, Walya, Rienthong, Dhanida, Siraprapasiri,Taweesap, Wells, Charles D., Tappero, Jordan W. and Varmaet, Jay K.2007 Antiretroviral Therapy during Tuberculosis Treatment and Marked Reduction in Death Rate of HIV-infected Patients, Thailand. "Emerging Infectious Diseases" 13(7). Available online at: http://www.cdc.gov/EID/content/13/7/1001.htm.
Alisjahbana, B., van Crevel, R., Sahiratmadja, E., den Heijer, M., and Maya, A. 2006 Diabetes mellitus is strongly associated with tuberculosis in Indonesia. "International Journal Tuberculosis and Lung Disease"' 10: 696–700
Baer, Hans and Singer, Merrill2008 "Global Warming and the Political Ecology of Health: Emerging Crises and Systemic Solutions." Left Coast Press.
Baer, Hans, Singer, Merrill, and Susser, Ida2004 "Medical Anthropology and the World System". Begin & Garvey: Westport, CT.
Bayliss, Elizabeth, Steiner, John, Fernald, Douglas, Crane, Lori, and Main, Deborah2003 Descriptions of Barriers to Self-Care by Persons with Comorbid Chronic Diseases. "Annal of Family Medicine" 1(1): 15-21.
Bastos, Francisco Inacio, Barcellos, Christovam, Lowndes, Catherine, and Friedman, Samuel 1999 Co-infection with malaria and HIV in injecting drug users in Brazil: a new challenge to public health? "Addiction" 94 (8): 1165–1174.
Brunner, E., Chandola, T. and Marmot, M.2007 Prospective Effect of Job Strain on General and Central Obesity in the Whitehall II Study. "American Journal of Epidemiology" 165:828-837.
Candib, Lucy2007 Obesity and Diabetes in Vulnerable Populations: Reflection on Proximal and Distal Causes. "Annals of Family Medicine" 5:547-556.
Cain, K., Kanara, N., Laserson, K., Vannarith, C., Sameourn, K., Samnang, K., Qualls, M., Varma, J. 2007 The Epidemiology of HIV-associated Tuberculosis in Rural Cambodia. "International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease" 11 (9): 1008-1013.
Chatterjee, R.2007 Portrait of a Killer. "ScienceNow" 117(2). Available online at: http://sciencenow.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full2007/1172?rss=1&eaf.
Cohen, Craig, Duerr, Ann, Pruithithada, Niwat, Rugpao, Sungwal, Garcia, Patricia, Nelson, Kenrad and Hillier, Sharon1995 Bacterial Vaginosis and HIV Seroprevalence among Female Commercial Sex Workers in Chiang Mai, Thailand. "AIDS" 9(9):1093-1098.
Easton, Delia2004 The Urban Poor: Health Issues. "Encyclopedia of Medical Anthropology", Volume 1, pp. 207-213. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers.
Engel, Jeffery2007 Pandemic Influenza: The Critical Issues and North Carolina’s Preparedness Plan. "North Carolina Medical Journal" 68(1):32-37.
Freudenberg, N., Fahs, M., Galea, S., & Greenberg, A.2006 The impact of New York City’s 1975 fiscal crisis on the tuberculosis, HIV, and homicide syndemic. "American Journalof Public Health", 96(3): 424–434.
Gerberding, J.2005 Protecting Health — The New Research Imperative. "Journal of the American Medical Association" 294(11): 1403-1406.
Gielen, A., Ghandour, R., Burke, J., Mahoney, P., McDonnell, K., and O’Campo, P.2007 HIV/AIDS and Intimate Partner Violence: Intersecting Women’s Health Issues in the United States. "Trauma, Violence and Abuse" 8(2):179-198.
Gonzalez-Guardia, Rosa2008 The Syndemic Model for Understanding Substance Abuse, Intimate Partner Violence and HIV/AIDS among Hispanics. Presented at the 8th Annual National Hispanic Science Network on Drug Abuse. Bethesda, Maryland.
Hein, Casey and Small, Doreen2007 Combating Diabetes, Obesity, Periodontal Disease and Interrelated Inflammatory Conditions with a Syndemic Approach. Available online at: http://www.healthdecisions.org/Dental/News/default.aspx?doc_id=109688.
Herring, D. Ann and Sattenspiel, Lisa2007 Social Contexts, Syndemics, and Infectious Disease in Northern Aboriginal Populations. "American Journal of Human Biology" 19:190-202.
Johnson, Roger B.2007 Periodontitis as a Component of Hyperinflammation: Treating Periodontitis in Obese Diabetic Patients. "Compendium" 28(9):500-505.
Kant, L. 2003 Diabetes Mellitus-Tuberculosis: The Brewing Double Trouble. "Indian Journal of Tuberculosis" 50(4): 83-84.
Laserson, K. and Wells, C. 2007 Reaching the Targets for Tuberculosis Control: The impact of HIV. "Bulletin of the World Health Organization" 85(5). Available on at: http://www.scielosp.org/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0042-96862007000500016&lng=&nrm=iso.
Lauer, Jeremy, Röhrich, Klaus, Wirth, Harald, Charette, Claude, Gribble, Steve, and Murray, Christopher2003 PopMod: a longitudinal population model with two interacting disease states. Cost Effectiveness and Resource Allocation 2003; 1: 6. Online publication at: http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=156025.
Marshall, Mac2005 Carolina in the Carolines: A Survey of Patterns and Meanings of Smoking on a Micronesian Island. "Medical Anthropology Quarterly" 19(4):354-382.
Mavridis, Agapi2008 Tuberculosis and Syndemics: Implications for Winnipeg, Manitoba. In "Multiplying and DividingTuberculosis in Canada and Aotearoa New Zealand," Judith Littleton, Julie Park, Ann Herring and Tracy Farmer, Eds. Research in Anthropology and Linguistics e3: 43-53.
MacQueen, Kate2002 Anthropology and Public Health.
Encyclopedia of Public Health. New York: Macmillan Reference.
McKenney, David, Brown, Kathryn, and Allison, David1995 Influence of Pseudomonas aeruginosa Exoproducts on Virulence Factor Production in Burkholderia cepacia: Evidence of Interspecies Communication. "Journal of Bacteriology" 177(23): 6989-6991.
Mercado, Susan, Kirsten Havemann, Keiko Nakamura, Andrew Kiyu, Mojgan Sami, Roby Alampay, Ira Pedrasa, Divine Salvador, Jeerawat Na Thalang, and Tran Le Thuey2007 Responding to the Health Vulnerabilities of the Urban Poor in the ‘New Urban Settings’ of Asia. Presented at Improving Urban Population Health Systems, sponsored by the Center for Sustainable Urban Development, July.
Millstein, Bobby 2001 Introduction to the Syndemics Prevention Network. Atlanta: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Millstein, Bobby2004 Syndemics. In: "Encyclopedia of Evaluation". Sandra Mathison, Ed. Pp. 404-405. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Mustanski, Brian, Garofalo, Robert, Herrick, Amy and Donenberg, Geri2007 Psychosocial health problems increase risk for HIV among urban young men who have sex with men: Preliminary evidence of a syndemic in need of attention. "Annals of Behavioral Medicine" 34(1):37-45.
Nichter, Mark2003 Harm Reduction, Harm Reduction, Ecosocial Epidemiology, Ecosocial Epidemiology, and Syndemics. Online at: http://www.csiss.org/events/meetings/risk-perception/docs/nichter_presentation.pdf
Noymer, Andrew and Michel Garenne2000 The 1918 Influenza epidemic's effects on sex differentials in mortality in the United States."Population and Development Review" 26(3):565–581. Online at: http://www.demog.berkeley.edu/~andrew/1918/PDR_1918_flu.pdf
Pablos-Mendez, A., Blustein, J. and Knirsch, C.1997 The role of diabetes mellitus in the higher prevalence of tuberculosis among Hispanics. "American Journal of Public Health" 87: 574–579. Perez, A., Brown, H. and Restrepo, B.2006 Association between tuberculosis and diabetes in the Mexican border and non-border regions of Texas. "American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene" 74: 604–611.
Ponce-De-Leon, A., Garcia-Garcia, L., Garcia-Sancho, M., Gomez-Perez, F., and Valdespino-Gomez, J.2004) Tuberculosis and diabetes in southern Mexico. "Diabetes Care" 27: 1584–1590.
Rosenberg, Rhonda and Malow, Robert2006 Hardness of Risk: Poverty, Women and New Targets for HIV/AIDS Prevention. "Psychology & AIDS Exchange"34:3-4, 9, & 12.
Shaikh, M., Singla, R., Khan, N., Sharif, N., and Saigh, M.2003 Does Diabetes Alter the Radiological Presentation of Pulmonary Tuberculosis. "Saudi Medical Journal" 24(3):278-281
Scheiblauer, H., Reinacher, M, Tashiro, M. and Rott, R.1992 Interactions Between Bacteria and Influenza A Virus in the Development of Influenza Pneumonia. "Journal of Infectious Diseases" 166: 783-791.
Sethi, Sanjeev2002 Bacterial Pneumonia. Managing a Deadly Complication of Influenza in Older Adults with Comorbid Disease. "Geriatrics" 57(3):56-61.
Sheretz, R., Reagan, D., Hampton, K., Robertson, K., Streed, S., Hoen, H., Thomas, R., and Gwaltney, J. Jr. 1996 A Cloud Adult: The Staphylococcus aureus-virus Interaction Revisited. "Annals of Internal Medicine" 124(6):539-547.
Singer, Merrill1994 AIDS and the Health Crisis of the US Urban Poor: The Perspective of Critical Medical Anthropology. "Social Science and Medicine" 39(7):931-948.
Singer, Merrill1996 A Dose of Drugs, a Touch of Violence, A Case of AIDS: Conceptualizing the SAVA Syndemic. "Free Inquiry in Creative Sociology " 24(2):99-110.
Singer, Merrill2004 Critical Medical Anthropology. In "Encyclopedia of Medical Anthropology: Health and Illness in the World’s Cultures". Vol. 1:23-30. Carol Ember and Melvin Ember, (eds). New York: Kluwer.
Singer, Merrill2006 Syndemics. "Encyclopedia of Epidemiology". Sarah Boslaugh (ed). Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage Publications, Inc.
Singer, Merrill 2006 A Dose of Drugs, A Touch of Violence, A Case of AIDS, Part 2: Further Conceptualizing the SAVA Syndemic. "Free Inquiry in Creative" 34(1): 39-56.
Singer, Merrill 2008 Desperate Measures: A Syndemic Approach to the Anthropology of Health in a Violent City. In "Global Health in the Time of Violence", Paul Farmer, Barbara Rylko-Bauer, and Linda Whiteford, Editors. Sante Fe, NM: SAR Press (in press.
Singer, Merrill 2008 The Perfect Epidemiological Storm: Food Insecurity, HIV/AIDS and Poverty in Southern Africa. "Anthropology Newsletter"(American Anthropological Association) 49(7): 12 & 15 October.
Singer, Merrill2008 Drug-related Syndemics and the Risk Environment: Assessing Street risk among Hispanics in Hartford. Presented at the 8th Annual National Hispanic Science Network on Drug Abuse. Bethesda, Maryland.
Singer, Merrill and Baer, Hans2007 "Introducing Medical Anthropology: A Discipline in Action." AltaMira/ Roman Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
Singer, Merrill and Clair, Scott2003 Syndemics and Public Health: Reconceptualizing Disease in Bio-Social Context. "Medical Anthropology Quarterly" 17(4): 423-441.
Singer, Merrill, Erickson, Pamela, Badiane, Louise, Diaz, Rosemary,Ortiz, Dueidy, Traci Abraham, and Nicolaysen, Anne Marie2006 Syndemics, Sex and the City: Understanding Sexually Transmitted Disease in Social and Cultural Context. "Social Science and Medicine" 63(8):2010-2021.
Singer, Merrill and Snipes, Charlene 1992 Generations of Suffering: Experiences of a Pregnancy and Substance Abuse Treatment Program. "Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved" 3(1): 325-239.
Singer, Merrill and Weeks, Margaret 2005 The Hartford Model of AIDS Practice/Research. In "Community Interventions and AIDS" edited by Edison Trickett and Willo Pequegnat, pp. 153-175. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Southgate, Erica, Weatherall, Anne Marr, Day, Carolyn, Dolan, Kate2005 What's in a Virus? Folk Understandings of Hepatitis C Infection and Infectiousness among Injecting Drug users in Kings Cross, Sydney. "International Journal for Equity in Health" 4:5.
Specter, Michael2005 Higher Risk: Crystal Meth, the Internet, and dangerous Choices about AIDS. "The New Yorker", May 23, pp. 39-45.
Stall, Ron 2007 An Update on Syndemic Theory Among Urban Gay Men. Presented at the American Public Health Association meetings, Washington, D.C. Abstract #155854. Abstract available online at: http://apha.confex.com/apha/135am/techprogram/paper_155854.htm.
Stall, Ron, Friedman, M.S., and Catania, J. 2007 Interacting Epidemics and Gay Men’s Health: A theory of Syndemic Production among Urban Gay Men. In "Unequal Opportunity: Health Disparities Affecting Gay and Bisexual Men in the United States", Richard J. Wolitski, Ron Stall, and Ronald O. Valdiserri (Eds). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Stall, Ron, Mills, Thomas, Williamson, J., and Hart, T.2003 Association of Co-occurring Psychosocial Health Problems and Increased Vulnerability to HIV/AIDS Among Urban men who have Sex with Men. "American Journal of Public Health". 93(6): 939-942.
Stall, Ron and Mills, Thomas2006 Health Disparities, Syndemics and Gay Men’s Health. Presented at the Center for Health Intervention and Prevention. University of Connecticut. Available online at: http://www.chip.uconn.edu/lec/Stall%20-%20Connecticut%20Talk.pdf.
Stall, Ron and van Griensven, Frits2005 New Directions in Research Regarding Prevention for Positive Individuals: Questions Raised by the Seropositive Urban Men's Intervention Trial. "AIDS" 19 Supplement 1: S123-S127.
Stephens, Christianne V.2008 “She was Weakly for a Long time and the Consumption Set In”: Using Parish Records to Explore Disease Patterns and Causes of Death In a First Nations Community. "Multiplying and DividingTuberculosis in Canada and Aotearoa New Zealand," Judith Littleton, Julie Park, Ann Herring and Tracy Farmer, Eds. Research in Anthropology and Linguistics e3: 134-148.
Thuy,T., Shah, N, Hoang Anh, M.H, Nghia, D.T., Thom, D., Linh, T., Sy, D.N., Duong, B.D., Chau, L.T.M., Mai, P.T.P., Wells, C., Laserson, K. and Varma, J.K.2007 HIV-Associated TB in An Giang Province, Vietnam, 2001–2004: Epidemiology and TB Treatment Outcomes. "PLoS ONE" 2(6: e507. Online at: http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0000507.
van Lettow, M., Fawzi, W., and Semba, R.2003 Triple Trouble: The Role of Malnutrition in Tuberculosisand Human Immunodeficiency Virus Co-infection. "Nutrition Reviews" 61(3): 81-90.
Ventura, H. and Mehra, M.2004 The Growing Burden of Health Failure: The “Syndemic” is Reaching Latin America. "American Heart Journal" 147(3): 412-417.
Wallace R. A 1988 Synergism of Plagues. "Environment Research" 47:1-33.
Wang, C., Yang, C., Chen, H., Chuang, S., Chong, I., Hwang, J., and Huang, M.2008 Impact of type 2 diabetes on manifestations and treatment outcome of pulmonary tuberculosis. "Epidemiology and Infection" Jun 18:1-8. [Epub ahead of print] .
Wasserheit, J. 1992 Epidemiological synergy. Interrelationships between human immunodeficiency virus infection and other sexually transmitted diseases. "Sexually Transmitted Disease" 19:61-77.
Walkup, James, Blank, Michael, Gonzalez, Jeffrey, Safren, Steven, Schwartz, Rebecca, Brown, Larry, Wilson, Ira, Knowlton, Amy, Lombard, Frank, Grossman, Cynthia, Lyda, Karen, and Schumacher, Joseph2008 The Impact of Mental Health and Substance Abuse Factors on HIV Prevention and Treatment. "JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes" 47 Supplement 1:S15-S19.
Young, C., Ann 2004 A Syndemic Perspective on Whooping Cough Epidemics at York Factory. Presented at the Canadian Association for Physical Anthropology, London, Ontario, Canada.
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.