Nathan G. Moore House

Nathan G. Moore House
U.S. Historic district Contributing property
Location:	333 Forest Ave. Oak Park, Cook County, Illinois, USA
Coordinates:	41°53′34.6″N 87°48′2.6″W / 41.892944°N 87.800722°W / 41.892944; -87.800722Coordinates: 41°53′34.6″N 87°48′2.6″W / 41.892944°N 87.800722°W / 41.892944; -87.800722
Built:	Construction: 1895 Alteration: 1923
Architect:	Frank Lloyd Wright
Architectural style:	Tudor Revival
Governing body:	Private owner
Part of:	Frank Lloyd Wright-Prairie School of Architecture Historic District (#7300069)
Added to NRHP:	December 4, 1973

The Nathan G. Moore House also known as the Moore-Dugal Residence is a house designed by Frank Lloyd Wright. The house was built one block south of Wright's home and studio at 333 Forest Avenue in the Chicago suburb of Oak Park, Illinois. It was originally completed in 1895 in the Tudor Revival style at the request of client Nathan Moore. Wright obliged his client's wishes, but long after disliked the house for its adherence to historical styles.

A 1922 fire gave Wright the opportunity to redesign the house. The structure was completely rebuilt above the first floor in a manner in keeping with Wright's other works of the late 1910s and early 1920s. While the new design stayed evocative of Tudor architecture, the house was heavily ornamented by details of Sullivanesque, Mayan, and other exotic origins. Wright’s second scheme remains largely intact today and the house continues to be a private residence despite a brief period as a tour home.

History

In 1886, Nathan Grier Moore bought a small, wood-framed house on a 50 feet by 150 feet lot at the southwestern corner of Forest Avenue and Superior Street. Moore had been born in 1853 in Cherry Tree, Pennsylvania and had attended law school in LaCrosse, Wisconsin. He had recently been hired into the office of Chicago attorney John P. Wilson. However, Moore chose to reside in Oak Park with his wife Anna and first daughter Mary (born in 1883) instead of Chicago. The couple’s second daughter, Marjorie, was born in 1889 while they lived in their first Oak Park house.^[1]

First Wright design

Nathan Moore purchased the neighboring lot to the south in 1891 after the previous house on that site had been destroyed by fire.^[2] He soon announced his intention to build a new home on his expanded property. Frank Lloyd Wright accounted in his autobiography that Moore had been approached by many architects, including Norman S. Patton, before Wright himself was asked to design the project in 1894. Mr. and Mrs. Moore reportedly traveled to Wright’s newly opened downtown Chicago studio in the Schindler Building to request his services rather than simply calling at the emerging architect’s house across the street.^[3]

Moore had apparently not come to Wright in admiration of his design style. According to Wright, he proclaimed that “I don’t want you to give us anything like the house you did for Winslow” referring to the recently completed Wright designed Winslow House in River Forest, Illinois. “I don’t want to go down backstreets to my morning train to avoid being laughed at.” Moore then proceeded to show Wright pictures of English half-timber buildings as inspiration for the proposed dwelling. Wright was apprehensive to design a house in a historical style, but he accepted the commission because of his financial obligations to his family (as he said, his “three children were now running around the streets without proper shoes”).^[4]

First Moore House as viewed from Forest Avenue (photograph taken in 1900)

The first plan proposed a remodel of the home Moore had bought in 1886. Plans changed and the existing structure was instead moved three lots west to front Superior Street. This made way for the construction of a three story Tudor Revival house which was completed in 1895.^[5] The three story structure was built tight against the northern lot line which allowed for maximum yard space to the south. Walls on the main floor were faced in golden-tan Roman brick while the upper floors were finished in typical, dark-stained half timbering over light stucco. A steep, gabled roof and two slender, tall, brick chimneys topped off the composition. The main house was symmetrically proportioned with few exceptions – including the chimneys and window openings flanking the Superior Street entrance. A garage connected the residence to a garden house at the northwestern corner of the property. Wright also designed a matching stable building across an alley to the southwest. The interior was paneled in dark wood yet was amply lit by bands of diamond-patterned, leaded casement windows which opened the rooms up to the south garden. Inside also featured eight fireplaces, each with unique custom surrounds.^[6] (See more period images of the first Moore House).

Nathan and Anna Moore “were delighted with the house.”^[7] Unfortunately the same cannot have been said for Wright. He came to regard the design with embarrassment and admitted that his “heart wasn’t it.”^[8] His decision caused further regret after he was asked on more than one occasion to devise similar Tudor inspired houses for other clients.^[9] Like his mentor and former employer, Louis H. Sullivan,^[10] Wright considered the copying of historic styles to be “uncreative” and completely contrary to American freedom.^[11] Even so, Wright managed to work a few interpretive deviations into the design of the Moore House. These included a broad, south-facing porch complete with brick end piers, Sullivanesque details on the balustrades, and his signature bowl-shaped urns.^[12] “It was the first time…an English, half-timbered house ever saw a porch,” Wright stated and further conceded that “the porch was becoming to the house.”^[13]

Property expansion and Edward R. Hills House

Soon after the new house was finished, Moore resumed the expansion of his property. In 1900 he bought the house on a 100 ft wide lot to the south from prior owner William C. Gray. That same year, Wright was rehired to remodel this recent purchase for Moore’s eldest daughter. Actual construction waited until yet another house was acquired south of the former Gray house in 1905. This last house had been owned by a Mr. and Mrs. D.L. McDaniels. With an estate that now measured 250 feet by 150 feet, Moore was able to demolish the McDaniels house and move the Gray house south where it was subsequently refurbished and enlarged. The house, along with 60 ft of Forest Avenue frontage, was deeded to Mary and her husband Edward Rowland Hills in 1910 (see also Edward R. Hills House).^[14][15]

Fire and second Wright design

Nathan G. Moore House viewed from the corner of Superior Street and Forest Avenue.

In the early morning of December 23, 1922, an electrical fire destroyed the third floor and caused significant damage to the lower floors of the Nathan G. Moore House. At the time, Wright was engaged in the construction of several projects in California, but he accepted Moore’s request to design the reconstruction and appointed Charles E. White, Jr. as local coordinator.^[16][17] Within a year the house was again ready to be occupied.

While Wright took this opportunity to completely redesign the house, he retained the essence of the Tudor style. The foundations as well as most of the first floor walls and south porch were retained. A slate roof and masonry chimneys were rebuilt in almost identical form to the originals, but Wright chose to leave out the second floor walls. The new roof sat directly on the first floor, thus making the entire structure significantly shorter. The pitched roof of the previous porch was traded for a second floor terrace with two open lightwells to the porch below.^[18][19]

This second house was more imbued with integral ornament than the first. A simple, first floor bay window in the east elevation was exchanged for one with a Gothic motif. Each side featured paired lancet windows and a facing of intricately adorned terracotta. While half-timbering was limited to the peaks of three gables, the remaining surfaces were replaced by banding of terracotta and heavily carved, geometrically patterned wood. In these details, Wright not only drew inspiration from English Tudor, but also from Mayan architecture and the elaborate, organic style of Louis Sullivan.^[20][21] The result showed similarities to other Wright designs of the period, including Midway Gardens (1913), the Imperial Hotel (1915–23), the Hollyhock House (1917–1921), and the four textile block houses (1923).^[22] The stables and garden house, which both survived the fire and retained original detailing, serve as a comparison between the styles of the earlier and later designs.^[23]

1946 to present

On August 16, 1946, Nathan Moore died; his house and property were left to Mary Hills. The Hills did not keep the estate, but instead sold it the following June to Milton G. and Mary Summerville. During the transaction, the Hills retained the southern 40 feet of land to expand their own narrow lot.^[24] The home is currently owned by Bob Dugal who opened the house for seasonal public tours. However, these tours ceased operation in 2001 due to the progression of Dugal's Friedreich’s ataxia disease.^[25]

Notes

1. ^ Oak Park HPC 2002, p. 11^†
2. ^ Oak Park HPC 2002, p. 11
3. ^ Wright 2005, p. 116
4. ^ Wright 2005, p. 116
5. ^ Gunning 2002b
6. ^ Lind 1996, p. 46
7. ^ Wright 2005, p. 117
8. ^ Tafel 1979, p. 59
9. ^ Wright 2005, p. 117
10. ^ Sullivan 1976, pp. 227–230; Sullivan saw historical architecture as a result of culture, rather than a series of styles. He thus believed that modern architecture should represent the ideas of the current era rather than replicate the past.
11. ^ Wright 2005, pp. 114,117
12. ^ Lind 1996, p. 46
13. ^ Wright 2005, p. 117
14. ^ Gunning 2002a
15. ^ Oak Park HPC 2002, p. 12
16. ^ Gunning 2002b
17. ^ Thomson 2000, pp. 232–233
18. ^ O'Gorman 2004, pp. 74–75
19. ^ Thomson 200, pp. 379–380
20. ^ O'Gorman 2004, pp. 74–75
21. ^ Tafel 1979, p. 59
22. ^ Lind 1996, p. 46
23. ^ Tafel 1979, p. 59
24. ^ Gunning 2002a
25. ^ Trainor 2009

†	Given nonconsecutive page numbering, any given page numbers refer to the page within the PDF instead of the number displayed on that page.

References

• Gunning, Don (2002a). "313 Forest". Frank Lloyd Wright's Forest Ave. / dgunning.org. http://www.dgunning.org/architecture/ForestAve/313forest.htm. Retrieved 18 April 2010. 
• Gunning, Don (2002b). "333 Forest". Frank Lloyd Wright's Forest Ave. / dgunning.org. http://www.dgunning.org/architecture/ForestAve/333forest.htm. Retrieved 18 April 2010. 
• Lind, Carla (1996). Lost Wright: Frank Lloyd Wright's Vanished Masterpieces. New York: Simon & Schuster, Inc.. ISBN 0-684-81306-8. 
• Oak Park Historic Preservation Commission (2002). "Oak Park Landmark Nomination Form (Hills-DeCaro House)". HAARGIS Database. http://gis.hpa.state.il.us/hargis/PDFs/209223.pdf. Retrieved 18 April 2010. 
• O'Gorman, Thomas J. (2004). Frank Lloyd Wright's Chicago. Thunder Bay Press. ISBN 1592231276. 
• Sullivan, Louis H. (1979). "What is Architecture: A Study in the American People of Today". Kindergarten Chats and Other Writings. San Francisco: Wittenborn Art Books. ISBN 0815000316. 
• Tafel, Edgar (1985). Years With Frank lloyd Wright: Apprentice to Genius. Mineola, N.Y.: Dover Publications. ISBN 0-486-24801-1. 
• Thomson, Iain (2000). Frank Lloyd Wright: A Visual Encyclopedia. London: PRC Publishing, LTD. ISBN 1-85648-533-1. 
• Trainor, Ken (13 October 2009). "The Wright Delta". Wednesday Journal Homes. http://www.wednesdayjournalhomes.com/homes.php?article=90. Retrieved 24 March 2010. 
• Wright, Frank Lloyd (2005). Frank Lloyd Wright: An Autobiography. Petaluma, CA: Pomegranate Communications. ISBN 0764932438. 

External links

• Historic photographs of Moore House prior to 1922 fire (on dgunning.org – Virtual Tour of Forest Avenue); the maturity of the landscape indicates that the top photo was taken several years before the bottom image.