- Cleveland v. United States
-
Cleveland v. United States
Supreme Court of the United StatesArgued October 10, 1945
Reargued October 17, 1946
Decided November 18, 1946Full case name Cleveland et. al. v. United States Citations 329 U.S. 14 (more)
67 S.Ct. 13, 91 L.Ed. 12Prior history 146 F.2d 73 (10th Cir. 1945) Holding Affirmed, notwithstanding the fact that polygamy is a person's religious belief, the Mann Act prohibits the transportation of women across state lines to participate in polygamy. Court membership Associate Justices
Hugo Black · Stanley F. Reed
Felix Frankfurter · William O. Douglas
Frank Murphy · Robert H. Jackson
Wiley B. Rutledge · Harold H. BurtonCase opinions Majority J. Douglas Concurrence W. B. Rutledge Dissent J. Murphy Laws applied 18 U.S.C. 398 Cleveland v. United States, 329 U.S. 14 (1946), was a case in which the Supreme Court of the United States held that notwithstanding the fact that polygamy is a person's religious belief, the Mann Act prohibits the transportation of women across state lines to participate in polygamy.
Contents
Background
Individuals were members of a fundamentalist Mormon sect that practiced polygamy. The individuals were indicted for transporting women across state lines to enter into plural marriages. Following a bench trial, all of the individuals were convicted for violations of the Mann Act. They then appealed their convictions to the U.S. Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals, which affirmed the convictions. The U.S. Supreme Court then granted certiorari to hear the case.
Opinion of the court
Affirmed. Justice William O. Douglas delivered the opinion of the court.
The Court held that transporting a woman or girl across state lines for the purpose of making her a plural wife in a polygamous marriage is a violation of the Mann Act[1] because it is for "an immoral purpose." In explaining its reasoning, the court opined that although the Mann Act was primarily intended to target commercialized white sex slave trade, the phrase "for any other immoral purpose" makes plain that the Act is not so narrowly limited. In noting the historical unlawfulness of polygamy in the United States, the Court found polygamy to be an immoral act of the type contemplated by the Mann Act's prohibitions.
Finally, the Court found that there is no viable defense to the Mann Act by virtue of the religious beliefs that motivate the practice of polygamy.
Concurring opinion
Justice Wiley Blount Rutledge delivered a concurring opinion. Justice Rutledge agreed with the majority's decision insofar as the majority opinion followed the precedent set in Caminetti v. United States, 242 U.S. 470 (1917), However, Rutledge diverged from the majority view in expressing his opinion that the Caminetti case was wrongly decided, as it improperly expanded the application of the Mann Act beyond the legislators' intent.
Dissenting opinion
Justice Frank Murphy delivered a dissenting opinion, stating that polygamy is not of the same genus as "prostitution and debauchery" as contemplated by the Mann Act.
References
- ^ Mann Act, 36 Stat. 825, 18 U.S.C. § 398
External links
Cleveland v. United States, 329 U.S. 14 (1946).
Caminetti v. United States, 242 U.S. 470 (1917).
Lists of United States Supreme Court cases Lists of cases by Court List of cases from all Courts (1789–present; large article) Jay, Rutledge, and Ellsworth Courts (1789–1800) · Marshall Court (1801–1835) · Taney Court (1836–1864) · Chase Court (1864–1873) · Waite Court (1874–1888) · Fuller Court (1888–1910) · White Court (1910–1921) · Taft Court (1921–1930) · Hughes Court (1930–1941) · Stone Court (1941–1946) · Vinson Court (1946–1953) · Warren Court (1953–1969) · Burger Court (1969–1986) · Rehnquist Court (1986–2005) · Roberts Court (2005–present) Complete list Lists of United States Supreme Court cases by volume (United States Reports) By recent term Other lists Landmark decisions · First Amendment cases · Indian Tribe cases Categories:- 1946 in United States case law
- United States Supreme Court cases
- Mormonism and polygamy
- Mann Act
- 1946 in religion
- Law related to Mormonism
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.