Formal distinction

Formal distinction

In scholastic metaphysics, a formal distinction is a distinction intermediate between what is merely conceptual, and what is fully real or mind-independent. It was made by some realist philosophers of the scholastic period in the thirteenth century, and particularly by Duns Scotus.


Many realist philosophers of the period (such as Aquinas and Henry of Ghent), recognised the need for an intermediate distinction that was not merely conceptual, but not fully real or mind-dependent either. Aquinas held that the difference between our concepts arise not just in the mind, but have a foundation in the thing ("fundamentum in re"). Henry held that there was an 'intentional' distinction ("distinctio intentionalis") such that 'intentions' (i.e. concepts) that are distinct in the mind, correspond to things which are potentially distinct in reality.

Scotus argued for an formal distinction ("distinctio formalis a parte rei"), which holds between entities which are inseparable and indistinct in reality, but whose definitions are not identical. For example, the personal properties of the Trinity are formally distinct from the Divine essence. Similarly, the distinction between the 'thisness' or "haecceity" of a thing is intermediate between a real and a conceptual distinction [Honderich p. 209] . There is also a formal distinction between the divine attributes and the powers of the soul.

Ockham was opposed to the idea, arguing that whenever there is any distinction or non-identity in reality, then two contradictory statements can be made. But contradictory statements cannot be truly asserted unless the realities they stand for either (1) distinct real things (2) distinct concepts or (3) a thing and a concept. But if they all exist in reality, they are not distinct concepts, nor are they a real thing and a concept. Therefore they are distinct in reality [Ockham, "Ordinatio" I. i. q1.] .



* Gracia, J.E. & Noone, T., "A Companion to Philosophy in the Middle Ages", Blackwell 2003.
* Grenz, Stanley J., "The Named God And The Question Of Being: A Trinitarian Theo-ontology", Blackwell 2005.
* "The Death of Blessed Scotus", according to Canon Joseph Bonello and Eman Bonnici.
* Honderich, T., (ed.) "The Oxford Companion to Philosophy", article "Duns Scotus", Oxford 1995.
*Ingham, M.B., & Mechthild Dreyer, "The Philosophical Vision of John Duns Scotus: An Introduction." Washington DC: Catholic University of America Press 2004.
*Kretzmann,N., A. Kenny, & J. Pinborg, "Cambridge History of Later Medieval Philosophy" Cambridge: 1982.
* Vos., A. "The Philosophy of John Duns Scotus". Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2006.
* Williams, Thomas, (ed.), "The Cambridge Companion to Duns Scotus." Cambridge University Press 2003.

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно решить контрольную?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Formal organization — is a fixed set of rules of intra organization procedures and structures. As such, it is usually set out in writing, with a language of rules that ostensibly leave little discretion for interpretation. In some societies and in some organization,… …   Wikipedia

  • formal logic — the branch of logic concerned exclusively with the principles of deductive reasoning and with the form rather than the content of propositions. [1855 60] * * * Introduction       the abstract study of propositions, statements, or assertively used …   Universalium

  • Formal interpretation — A formal interpretation [ pg=PA74 lpg=PA74 dq=%22Formal+interpretation%22+%22formal+language%22 source=web ots=pLN ms7Wi2 sig=P JqwdzOqLcX4nMpP64qmacnkDU hl=en#PPA74,M1 Cann Ronnie, Formal Semantics:… …   Wikipedia

  • Formal proof — See also: mathematical proof, proof theory, and axiomatic system A formal proof or derivation is a finite sequence of sentences (called well formed formulas in the case of a formal language) each of which is an axiom or follows from the… …   Wikipedia

  • distinction */*/*/ — UK [dɪˈstɪŋkʃ(ə)n] / US noun Word forms distinction : singular distinction plural distinctions 1) [countable] a difference between two things In practice, these distinctions are often blurred (= not made very clear). distinction between: Do other …   English dictionary

  • distinction — dis|tinc|tion [ dı stıŋkʃən ] noun *** 1. ) count a difference between two things: In practice, these distinctions are often blurred (=not made very clear). distinction between: Do other countries have the same distinction between amateur and… …   Usage of the words and phrases in modern English

  • formal/material mode of speech — A distinction that assumed great importance in the work of Carnap, particularly in his Logical Syntax of Language (1934). In the material mode of speech objects and their relations are the topic; in the formal mode, language itself is mentioned.… …   Philosophy dictionary

  • distinction — noun 1 clear difference ADJECTIVE ▪ critical, crucial, important, key, main, major, vital ▪ basic, essential …   Collocations dictionary

  • Formal ontology — A Formal ontology is an ontology with a structure that is guided and defined through axioms. The goal of a formal ontology is to provide an unbiased (domain and application independent) view on reality. Formal ontologies are founded upon a… …   Wikipedia

  • distinction — [[t]dɪstɪ̱ŋkʃ(ə)n[/t]] distinctions 1) N COUNT: usu N between pl n A distinction is a difference between similar things. There are obvious distinctions between the two wine making areas... The distinction between craft and fine art is more… …   English dictionary

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”