Frank Sibley (philosopher)

Frank Sibley (1923-1996) was a British philosopher who worked mainly in the field of aesthetics. He was a professor of philosophy at Lancaster University. Sibley is best know for his 1959 paper "Aesthetic Concepts" ("Philosophical Review", 68), and for "Seeking, Scrutinizing and Seeing" ("Mind", 64, 1954). Both papers, ,and some others, have been anthologized, "Aesthetic Concepts" multiple times.

Sibley has been considered an important contributor to Aesthetics in the analytical tradition. His collected papers, including some posthumous, were published by Oxford University Press in 2001 as "Approach To Aesthetics", together with a companion volume of critical and evaluative essays on his work.

Work in aesthetics

Most of Sibley's work in aesthetics is collected in "Approach to Aesthetics". He is especially well known for his attempts to distinguish the domains of aesthetic and non-aesthetic. His 1959 paper "Aesthetic Concepts" is often referred as one of the landmarks of 20th century aesthetics in the tradition of analytic philosophy. The paper is rich in themes, but the main line of thought suggest that aesthetic concepts cannot be reduced to non-aesthetic concepts, or sufficiently defined in terms of non-aesthetic concepts. This leads Sibley to think that grasping properties of given items requires the capability to exercise taste or aesthetic sensibility.

Topics and problems relating to taste thus became very important to Sibley's approach, and he returned to them through his career. Also, Sibley did not see Aesthetics as remote from philosophy as whole. This is very clear from his brief programmatic note "About Taste", published in 1966 in "British Journal of Aesthetics". Here Sibley states the situation thus:

"The programme that aestheticians must face is thus a large one, the charting of a huge areas neglected by other philosopers working within their customary bonds. Indeed, far from it's being true that aesthetics is peripheral to philosophy, aestheticians encounter ranges of concepts wider than and inevitably including of those studied by most other branches of philosophy."

Work in other fields

Beside aesthetics, Sibley worked on the philosophy of perception and the philosophy of mind. His first published paper was a long review of Gilbert Ryle's Concept of Mind in 1950. Later he contributed another piece on Ryle, "Ryle and Thinking", to "Ryle: Collection of Essays".

He wrote two papers on the theory of perception, and some papers on the borderline of that field and aesthetics, one paper on colours, and a little piece on applied philosophy. One posthumous paper deals extensively with a certain distinction made by Peter Geach. Other than these, his work was in aesthetics.

Works of Sibley

* Frank Sibley (1954) "Seeking, Scrutinizing and Seeing" "Mind", 64. Also in Geoffrey Warnock (ed.) (1967) "The Philosophy of Perception". Oxford.
*Frank Sibley (2001) "Approach To Aesthetics. Collected Papers On Philosophical Aesthetics." Edited by J. Benson & al. Oxford.

Papers on Sibley

* R. David Broiles (1964), "Frank Sibley's "Aesthetic Concepts"". "The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism", 23/2, 219-225.
* Gary Stahl (1971), "Sibley's "Aesthetic Concepts": An Ontological Mistake". "The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism", 29/3, 385-389

On-line references and reading

Nick Zangwill's article "Aesthetic Judgment" [http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aesthetic-judgment/] in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy discusses Sibleys views, and those of his critics.