Ivan the Terrible in Russian folklore

The image created of Ivan IV of Russia throughout Russian folklore is a direct contrast to that which is typically painted of him and his rule by historians. As folklorist Jack V. Haney claims, the tales “about Ivan IV, known as the Terrible, are especially interesting in that they portray the first Orthodox Tsar of All Russia in quite a different light than historians do”. [ Haney, Jack V. An Introduction to the Russian Folktale. The Complete Russian Folktale. Armonk, New York: M.E. Sharpe, 1999. pg 9. ] By studying a variety of folktales about Ivan the Terrible, we can see that, in general, the overall image of this tsar is a positive one. Maureen Perrie states that “insofar as he is the friend of the common people, and the enemy of the boyars, he (Ivan IV) is seen as a ‘good tsar’”. [ Perrie, Maureen. The Image of Ivan the Terrible in Russian Folklore. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987. pg 65 ] By creating the tsar to be either a friend of the commoners or an enemy to the boyar, a positive image of Ivan IV is represented through the particular folktale.

Primarily, throughout folktales, the tsar is typically described as an “ally and protector of the ordinary people against their common enemies, and especially the boyars”. [ Perrie, Maureen. The Image of Ivan the Terrible in Russian Folklore. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987. pg 47 ] One example of a folktale in which the tsar befriends the commoner can be found in Samuel Collins’ recording. [ Perrie, Maureen. Folklore as Evidence of Peasant Mentalite: Social Attitudes and Values in Russian Popular Culture. The Russian Review. Vol. 48. 1989. pg 133. ] In this story, a friendship develops between a disguised Ivan and a thief. Eventually the thief asks the tsar if he wants to go robbing with him and the tsar agrees. After they had robbed from a few shops in the marketplace, the tsar wanted to test his new friend’s loyalty and suggests that they rob the treasury. [ Perrie, Maureen. Folklore as Evidence of Peasant Mentalite: Social Attitudes and Values in Russian Popular Culture. The Russian Review. Vol. 48. 1989. pg 133. ] At this suggestion, the thief slaps the tsar saying that ‘I’ve been thieving for ages, but I’ve never dreamt of robbing the tsar!”. [ Perrie, Maureen. Folklore as Evidence of Peasant Mentalite: Social Attitudes and Values in Russian Popular Culture. The Russian Review. Vol. 48. 1989. pg 133. ] The story continues that the thief suggests that instead of robbing the tsar, the two should rob the boyars because “they get their money for nothing”. [ Perrie, Maureen. Folklore as Evidence of Peasant Mentalite: Social Attitudes and Values in Russian Popular Culture. The Russian Review. Vol. 48. 1989. pg 133. ] For his faithfulness and respect for the tsar, Ivan rewards the young man by asking him to become his counselor. [ Perrie, Maureen. Folklore as Evidence of Peasant Mentalite: Social Attitudes and Values in Russian Popular Culture. The Russian Review. Vol. 48. 1989. pg 133. ]

This tale exemplifies a story in which the tsar befriends a common peasant. Collins’ tale also provides us evidence that the folklore regarding Ivan the Terrible often shows him heroically allying with those of the lower classes against the sly and devious middle and upper class citizens. [ Perrie, Maureen. The Image of Ivan the Terrible in Russian Folklore. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987. pg 47 ] By agreeing to help the thief rob the boyar, the tsar is ultimately legitimizing the thief’s actions. [ Perrie, Maureen. Folklore as Evidence of Peasant Mentalite: Social Attitudes and Values in Russian Popular Culture. The Russian Review. Vol. 48. 1989. pg 133. ] Continually, Maureen Perrie justifies the formation of the friendship between the tsar and the thief because “the tsar endorses the values and attitudes of the representative of the people, and demonstrates that he has more in common with them than with the boyars”. [ Perrie, Maureen. The Image of Ivan the Terrible in Russian Folklore. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987. pg 35. ] Consequently, the image depicted of Ivan is not one in which he is a “meaningless, bloodletting” ruler, but rather he is kind and compassionate towards his lower subjects. [ Perrie, Maureen. The Image of Ivan the Terrible in Russian Folklore. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987. pg 7 ]

The second way a positive image of Ivan was created through folklore can be found by looking at examples that show Ivan was “an enemy of the boyar”. [ Perrie, Maureen. The Image of Ivan the Terrible in Russian Folklore. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987. pg 65 ] Through tales such as the “The Potter,” we see how the tsar was often depicted as siding with the commoner against the boyars and other aristocratic individuals. Throughout “The Potter” a friendship develops between Ivan and a common potter. The tsar is attracted to the potter because of his ability to answer riddles. Because the tsar is impressed by his quick wittedness, he vows that, “if you (referring to the potter) stick to me, and I’ll stick to you”. [ Afanas'ev, Aleksandr. "The Potter." Russian Fairy Tales. Trans. Norbert Guterman. New York: Pantheon Books, 1945. pg 208. ] Consequently, the tsar helps this potter create a monopoly against the other boyars over the pottery sales in Russia. When an un- expecting boyar is unable to pay for the merchandise he ordered, the tsar punishes him by making the boyar switch social roles with the potter. [ Afanas'ev, Aleksandr. "The Potter." Russian Fairy Tales. Trans. Norbert Guterman. New York: Pantheon Books, 1945. pg 208. ]

Through this story we see that a friendship between the tsar and the potter develops out of the mutual dislike of the boyars. We are also provided with evidence that the tsar is more willing to help the common potter than he is the boyar. In addition, the tsar is attracted to the potter’s quick wittedness and consequently he was more willing to help the witty man from the lower social classes than he was the “stupid” middle- upper class boyars. [ Perrie, Maureen. The Image of Ivan the Terrible in Russian Folklore. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987. pg 45. ] Finally, this story is an example of Haney’s claim that through many folktales, Ivan is depicted as a “resolute but compassionate and an enlightened ruler, anxious to protect the peasants from the landowners, and he goes to some extraordinary lengths to do so”. [ Haney, Jack V. An Introduction to the Russian Folktale. The Complete Russian Folktale. Armonk, New York: M.E. Sharpe, 1999. pg 9. ]

As the above examples of folklore show, a positive image of Ivan the Terrible can be found whenever a folktale has Ivan either a friend to a common peasant or an enemy to the boyar. There are a few reasons that folklorists provide us with that explain why this positive image of Ivan IV was created throughout Russian folklore. One valid reason is that the common people did not see the Ivan’s actions as negative- he was simply doing his job as the tsar. [ Perrie, Maureen. The Image of Ivan the Terrible in Russian Folklore. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987. pg 10. ] They believed that it was the tsar’s responsibility to protect his country, and he should do whatever it takes to accomplish that obligation. [ Perrie, Maureen. The Image of Ivan the Terrible in Russian Folklore. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987. pg 10. ]

In addition, because the tsar was seen as their only benefactor, the peasants often would not like to ridicule or satirize the tsar because they feared upsetting him. They hoped to create and tell stories about Ivan IV that would be pleasing to him, which would be build a better relationship between the tsar and the “commoners.” In addition, these stories also created the “ideal tsar” that many Russians hoped would run their country someday. Ivan IV was, for many of the peasants, was the only figure of authority they knew and they did not know any other type of ruling. Consequently, the folklore “represents an artistic response to a historical event or character, and, in the case of a historical figure such as Ivan”. [ Perrie, Maureen. The Image of Ivan the Terrible in Russian Folklore. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987. pg 88. ] The stories regarding Ivan the Terrible were subjected to the tellers’ interpretations and opinion regarding him and his practices, and the folklore’s image of Ivan IV describes the ruler that so many Russians had hoped Ivan would become.

References