Bangorian Controversy

Bangorian Controversy

The Bangorian Controversy was a theological argument within the Church of England in the 18th century. The origins of the controversy lay in the 1716 posthumous publication of George Hickes's "Constitution of the Catholic Church, and the Nature and Consequences of Schism." In it, Hickes, Bishop of Thetford, excommunicated all but the non-juror churchmen. Benjamin Hoadly, the Bishop of Bangor, wrote a reply entitled, "Preservative against the Principles and Practices of Non-Jurors," in which his own Erastian position was sincerely proposed as the only test of truth. However, the controversy commenced most visibly and vocally when Hoadly delivered a sermon on March 31, 1717 to George I of Great Britain on "The Nature of the Kingdom of Christ." His text was John 18:36, "My kingdom is not of this world," and from that Hoadly deduced, supposedly at the request of the king himself, that there is no Biblical justification for "any" church government of any sort. He identified the church with the kingdom of Heaven—it was therefore not of this world, and Christ had not delegated His authority to any representatives.

ermon and aftermath

The sermon was immediately published and instantly drew counter-attacks. William Law ("Three Letters to the Bishop of Bangor") and Thomas Sherlock (dean of Chichester), in particular, gave vigorous defences of church polity. Hoadly himself wrote "A Reply to the Representations of Convocation" to answer Thomas Sherlock, Andrew Snape, provost of Eton, and Francis Hare, then dean of Worcester. These three men, and another opponent, Robert Moss, dean of Ely, were deprived of their royal chaplaincies by the king. Hoadly did not, however, attempt to answer William Law.

In May 1717, the Convocation appointed a committee to study the sermon. When the report was ready for synodal sanction against Hoadly, the king dismissed the convocation, which did not meet again for over 130 years.

Importance

The controversy may seem esoteric to observers nowadays, but the stakes were quite high. Two competing visions of government were in play. On the one hand, there was a vision of God appointing the king and the bishops to be leaders, selecting them from all others and imbuing them with special characters, either through grace or in creation. This view held that the king, as the head of the Established Church, was not merely a secular leader of a state, but also a religious primate. Power and regulation flowed downward from God to the people. This was the aristocratic model that was favoured by the Tory party and which had been used to propose the divine right of kings. The other view was that power flowed up from the people to the leaders, that leaders were no more "intrinsically" better than those led, and that God gives out revelation freely. This Whig view was also the view of the Puritans and the "Independents" (ie, the various Congregational and Baptist churches, Quakers, etc).

George I favoured the Whig party in Parliament and favoured a latitudinarian ecclesiastical policy in general. This was probably not due to any desire to give up royal prerogative, but rather to break the power of the aristocracy and the House of Lords. A significant obstacle to all kings of England had been the presence of bishops in the Lords. While a king could create peers, it was much more difficult for him to move bishops into and out of the Lords.

Further reading

*Cross, F. A., ed. "The Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church." 1964. London: Oxford University Press.
*"Encyclopedia Britannica" 1911 edition, unsigned article.
*"Church of England and the Bangorian controversy, 1716-1721." Andrew Starkie: 2007: Boydell Press.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно сделать НИР?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • BANGORIAN CONTROVERSY —    a controversy in the Church of England provoked by a sermon which Hoadley, bishop of Bangor, preached before George I. in 1717, which offended the sticklers for ecclesiastical authority …   The Nuttall Encyclopaedia

  • 1717 in literature — The year 1717 in literature involved some significant events and new books.Events* Voltaire is sentenced to eleven months in the Bastille and is banished from Paris for criticizing the Duc D Orléans. While in prison he writes his first play,… …   Wikipedia

  • Benjamin Hoadly — Anglican PortalBenjamin Hoadly (14 November 1676–17 April 1761 [cite web|url=http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/13375|title=Stephen Taylor, ‘Hoadly, Benjamin (1676–1761)’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, Sept… …   Wikipedia

  • William Law — (1686 ndash; April 9, 1761), English divine, was born at Kings Cliffe, Northamptonshire.Early lifeIn 1705 he entered as a sizar at Emmanuel College, Cambridge; in 1711 he was elected fellow of his college and was ordained. He resided at Cambridge …   Wikipedia

  • Thomas Pyle — The Reverend Thomas Pyle (born at Stody, Norfolk, 1674, died Swaffham, Norfolk, 31 December 1756) was a Church of England clergyman and religious controversialist.Background and educationThe son of the Reverend John Pyle (died 1709), Rector of… …   Wikipedia

  • Category:Christianity-related controversies — Differing ideas of Christianity. Subcategories This category has the following 23 subcategories, out of 23 total. A [+] …   Wikipedia

  • Augustan literature — is a style of English literature produced during the reigns of Queen Anne, King George I, and George II in the first half of the 18th century, ending in the 1740s with the deaths of Pope and Swift (1744 and 1745, respectively). It is a literary… …   Wikipedia

  • Ofspring Blackall — Right Reverend Dr. Ofspring Blackall Exeter Offspring Blackall (Blackhall) by George Vertue, after Michael Dahl (NPG) Province Province of Canterbury …   Wikipedia

  • Thomas Sherlock — (1678 ndash; 18 July 1761) was an English divine who served as a Church of England bishop for 33 years. He is also noted in church history as an important contributor to Christian apologetics.Early lifeHe was the son of William Sherlock and was… …   Wikipedia

  • John Balguy — (August 12, 1686 mdash; September 21, 1748) was an English divine and philosopher.Early yearsHe was born at Sheffield and educated at the Sheffield grammar school and at St John s College, Cambridge, graduated BA in 1706, was ordained in 1710,… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”