An ideology is a set of beliefs, aims and
ideas, especially in politics. An ideology can be thought of as a comprehensive vision, as a way of looking at things (compare Weltanschauung), as in common sense (see Ideology in everyday society below) and several philosophicaltendencies (see Political ideologies), or a set of ideas proposed by the dominant class of a society to all members of this society. The main purpose behind an ideology is to offer change in society through a normative thought process. Ideologies are systems of abstract thought (as opposed to mere ideation) applied to public matters and thus make this concept central to politics. Implicitly every political tendency entails an ideology whether or not it is propounded as an explicit system of thought.
(For the Marxist definition of "ideology" see Ideology as an instrument of social reproduction below.)
Ideology and Semiotic Theory
According to Bob Hodge's article in the Semiotic Encyclopedia Online (http://www.semioticon.com/seo/contents.html), Ideology "identifies a unitary object that incorporates complex sets of meanings with the social agents and processes that produced them. No other term captures this object as well as ‘ideology’. Foucault’s ‘episteme’ is too narrow and abstract, not social enough. His ‘discourse’, popular because it covers some of ‘ideology’s’ terrain with less baggage, is too confined to verbal systems. ‘Worldview’ is too metaphysical, ‘propaganda’ too loaded. Despite or because of its contradictions, ‘ideology’ still plays a key role in semiotics oriented to social, political life" (http://www.semioticon.com/seo/I/ideology.html#).
A detailed entry can be found at Semiotic Encyclopedia Online. www.semioticon.com
Ideology in Cognitive Science, Linguistics, Philosophy, Post-Modernism and Critical Theory
Organizations that strive for power will try to influence the ideology of a society to become closer to what they want it to be. Political organizations (
governments included) and other groups (e.g. lobbyists) try to influence people by broadcasting their opinions.
When most people in a society think alike about certain matters, or even forget that there are alternatives to the status quo, we arrive at the concept of
Hegemony, about which the philosopher Antonio Gramsciwrote. Such a state of affairs has been dramatized many times in literature: Nineteen Eighty-Fourby George Orwell; Brave New Worldby Aldous Huxley; and A Wrinkle in Timeby Madeline L'Engle. Noam Chomskyand Edward S. Hermanhave argued that social ideological homogeneity can be achieved by restricting the conceptual metaphors transmitted by mass communication.
History of the concept of ideology
The term was born in the highly controversial philosophical and political debates and fights of the
French Revolutionand acquired several other meanings from the early days of the First French Empireto nowadays. The word "ideology" was coined by Destutt de Tracyin 1796 [Kennedy, Emmet (1979) "Ideology" from Destutt De Tracy to Marx", Journal of the History of Ideas, Vol. 40, No. 3 (Jul. - Sep., 1979), pp. 353-368 (article consists of 16 pages) http://www.jstor.org/pss/2709242] [Hart, David M. (2002) "Destutt de Tracy: Annotated Bibliography" http://www.econlib.org/library/Tracy/DestuttdeTracyBio.html] assembling the parts "idea" (near to the Lockean sense) and " -logy". He used it to refer to one aspect of his "science of ideas". (To the study itself, not the subject of the study.) He separated three aspects, namely: ideology, general grammar and logic, considering respectively the subject, the means and the reason of this science. [de Tracy, Destutt (1801) "Les Éléments d'idéologie", 3rd ed. (1817), p. 4, cited by: Mannheim, Karl (1929) Ideologie und Utopie, 2nd footnote in the chapter "The problem of "false consciousness"] He argues that among these aspects ideology is the most generic term, because the science of ideas also contains the study of their expression and deduction.
Karl Mannheim's historical reconstruction of the meaning-shifts of ideology, the modern meaning of the word ideology was born when Napoleon Bonaparte(as a politician) used it in an abusive way against "the ideologues" (a group which includedFact|date=June 2008 Cabanis, Condorcet, Constant, Daunou, Say, Madame de Staël and Tracy), to express the pettiness of his (liberal republican) political opponents.
Perhaps the most accessible source for the near-original meaning of "ideology" is
Hippolyte Taine's work on the Ancien Regime(first volume of "Origins of Contemporary France"). He describes ideology as rather like teaching philosophy by the Socratic method, but without extending the vocabulary beyond what the general reader already possessed, and without the examples from observation that practical science would require. Taine identifies it not just with Destutt de Tracy, but also with his milieu, and includes Condillacas one of its precursors. (Tracy read the works of Locke and Condillac while he was imprisoned during the Reign of Terror.)
The word "ideology" was coined long before the Russians coined "intelligentsia", or before the adjective "intellectual" referred to a sort of person (see
substantive), i.e. an intellectual. Thus these words were not around when the hard-headed, driven Napoleon Bonapartetook the word "ideologues" to ridicule his intellectual opponents. Gradually, however, the term "ideology" has dropped some of its pejorative sting, and has become a neutral term in the analysis of differing political opinions.Fact|date=February 2007 Ideological references are important to many people throughout the world. Karl Marxused the term in his own context often throughout his works.
Analysis of ideology
Meta-ideology is the study of the structure, form, and manifestation of ideologies. Meta-ideology posits that ideology is a "coherent system of ideas", relying upon a few basic assumptions about reality that may or may not have any factual basis, but are subjective choices that serve as the seed around which further thought grows. According to this perspective, ideologies are neither right nor wrong, but only a relativistic intellectual strategy for categorizing the world. The pluses and minuses of ideology range from the vigor and fervor of true believers to ideological infallibility. Excessive need for certitude lurks at fundamentalist levels in politics, religions, and elsewhere.
The works of
George Walfordand Harold Walsby, done under the heading of systematic ideology, are attempts to explore the relationships between ideology and social systems.
David W. Minar describes six different ways in which the word "ideology" has been used:
# As a collection of certain ideas with certain kinds of "content", usually normative;
# As the "form or internal logical structure" that ideas have within a set;
# By the role in which ideas play in "human-social interaction";
# By the role that ideas play in the "structure of an organization";
# As meaning, whose purpose is "persuasion"; and
# As the "locus" of social interaction, possibly.
For Willard A. Mullins, an ideology is composed of four basic characteristics:
#it must have power over cognitions;
#it must be capable of guiding one's evaluations;
#it must provide guidance towards action;
#and, as stated above, must be logically coherent.
Mullins emphasizes that an ideology should be contrasted with the related (but different) issues of "utopia" and "historical myth".
The German philosopher [http://www.ideologieforschung.de/en Christian Duncker] called for a "critical reflection of the ideology concept" (2006). In his work, he strove to bring the concept of ideology into the foreground, as well as the closely connected concerns of
epistemologyand history. In this work, the term ideology is defined in terms of a system of presentations that explicitly or implicitly claim to absolute truth.
Ideology as an instrument of social reproduction
Karl Marxproposed an "economic base/superstructure" model of society. The "base" refers to the means of productionof society. The "superstructure" is formed on top of the base, and comprises that society's ideology, as well as its legal system, political system, and religions. For Marx, the base determines the superstructure. Because the ruling class controls the society's means of production, the superstructure of society, including its ideology, will be determined according to what is in the ruling class's best interests. Therefore the ideology of a society is of enormous importance since it confuses the alienated groups and can create ' false consciousness' such as the fetishism of commodities. Critics of the Marxist approach feel that it attributes too much importance to economic factors in influencing society.
The ideologies of the dominant class of a society (
dominant ideology) are proposed to all members of that society in order to make the ruling class' interests appear to be the interests of all. György Lukácsdescribes this as a projection of the class consciousnessof the ruling class, while Antonio Gramsciadvances the theory of cultural hegemonyto explain why people in the working-classcan have a false conception of their own interests.
The dominant forms of ideology in capitalism are (in chronological order):
and they correspond to the stages of development of capitalism:
contemporary capitalism(or late capitalism, or current crisis)
The Marxist view of ideology as an instrument of social reproduction has been an important touchstone for the
sociology of knowledgeand theorists such as Karl Mannheim, Daniel Bell, and Jürgen Habermas, amongst many others. However, Mannheim attempted to move beyond what he saw as the 'total' but 'special' Marxist conception of ideology to a 'general' and 'total' conception which acknowledged that all ideologies resulted from social life (including Marxism). Pierre Bourdieuextensively developed this idea.
Louis Althusser's "Ideological State Apparatuses"
Louis Althusserproposed a materialistic conception of ideology, which made use of a special type of discourse: the lacunar discourse. A number of propositions, which are never untrue, suggest a number of other propositions, which are, in this way, the essence of the lacunar discourse is what is "not" told (but is suggested).
For example, the statement 'All are equal before the law', which is a theoretical groundwork of current legal systems, suggests that all people may be of equal worth or have equal 'opportunities'. This is not true, for the concept of
private propertyover the means of productionresults in some people being able to own more ("much" more) than others, and their property brings power and influence (the rich can afford better lawyers, among other things, and this puts in question the principle of equality before the law).
Althusser also invented the concept of the Ideological State Apparatus to explain his theory of ideology. His first thesis was "ideology has no history": while ideolog"ies" have histories, interleaved with the general class struggle of society, the general form of ideology is external to history. His second thesis, "Ideas are material", explains his materialistic attitude, which he illustrated with the "scandalous advice" of Pascal toward unbelievers: "kneel and pray, and then you will believe", thus highlighting that beliefs and ideas are a product of social practices, and not the reverse. However, this mustn't be misunderstood as simple
behaviorism, as there may be, as Pierre Machereyput it, a "subjectivity without subject"; in other words, a form of non-personal liberty, as in Deleuze's conception of becoming-other.
Feminism as critique of ideology
Naturalizing socially constructed patterns of behavior has always been an important mechanism in the production and reproduction of ideologies. Feminist theorists have paid close attention to these mechanisms.
Adrienne Riche.g. has shown how to understand motherhoodas a social institution. However, 'feminism' is not a homogenous whole, and some corners of feminist thought criticise the critique of social constructionism, by advocating that it disregards too much of human nature and natural tendencies. The debate, they say, is about the normative/naturalistic fallacy - the idea that just something 'being' natural does not necessarily mean it 'ought' to be the case.
Many political parties base their political action and programme on an ideology. In
social studies, a Political Ideology is a certain ethical set of ideals, principles, doctrines, myths or symbols of a social movement, institution, class, or large group that explains how society should work, and offers some political and cultural blueprint for a certain social order. A political ideology largely concerns itself with how to allocate power and to what ends it should be used. Some parties follow a certain ideology very closely, while others may take broad inspiration from a group of related ideologies without specifically embracing any one of them. Political ideologieshave two dimensions:
#Goalages: How society should work (or be arranged).
#Methods: The most appropriate ways to achieve the ideal arrangement.
An ideology is a collection of ideas. Typically, each ideology contains certain ideas on what it considers to be the best
form of government(e.g. democracy, theocracy, etc), and the best economic system(e.g. capitalism, socialism, etc). Sometimes the same word is used to identify both an ideology and one of its main ideas. For instance, "socialism" may refer to an economic system, or it may refer to an ideology which supports that economic system.
Ideologies also identify themselves by their position on the
political spectrum(such as the left, the center or the right), though this is very often controversial. Finally, ideologies can be distinguished from political strategies (e.g. populism) and from single issues that a party may be built around (e.g. opposition to European integration or the legalisation of marijuana).
Studies of the concept of ideology itself (rather than specific ideologies) have been carried out under the name of
Political ideologies are concerned with many different aspects of a society, some of which are: the economy,
education, health care, labor law, criminal law, the justice system, the provision of social securityand social welfare, trade, the environment, minors, immigration, race, use of the military, patriotismand established religion.
There are many proposed methods for the classification of political ideologies. See the
political spectrumarticle for a more in-depth discussion of these different methods (each of whom generates a specific political spectrum).
Even when the challenging of existing beliefs is encouraged, as in
science, the dominant paradigmor mindsetcan prevent certain challenges, theories or experiments from being advanced.
There are critics who view science as an ideology in itself, or being an effective ideology, called
scientism. Some scientists respond that, while the scientific methodis itself an ideology, as it is a collection of ideas, there is nothing particularly wrong or bad about it.
Other critics point out that while science itself is not a misleading ideology, there are some fields of study within science that are misleading. Two examples discussed here are in the fields of ecology and economics.
A special case of science adopted as ideology is that of
ecology, which studies the relationships between living things on Earth. Perceptual psychologist J. J. Gibsonbelieved that human perception of ecological relationships was the basis of self-awarenessand cognitionitself. Linguist George Lakoffhas proposed a cognitive science of mathematicswherein even the most fundamental ideas of arithmetic would be seen as consequences or products of human perception - which is itself necessarily evolved within an ecology. Deep ecologyand the modern ecology movement(and, to a lesser degree, Green parties) appear to have adopted ecological sciences as a positive ideology.
ecological economicsof likewise turning scientific theory into political economy, although theses in that science can often be tested. The modern practice of green economicsfuses both approaches and seems to be part science, part ideology.
This is far from the only theory of economics to be raised to ideology status - some notable economically-based ideologies include
mercantilism, mixed economy, social Darwinism, communism, laissez-faire economics, and free trade. There are also current theories of safe tradeand fair tradewhich can be seen as ideologies.
* Mullins, Willard A. (1972) "On the Concept of Ideology in Political Science." "The American Political Science Review". American Political Science Association.
* Minar, David M. (1961) "Ideology and Political Behavior", "Midwest Journal of Political Science". Midwest Political Science Association.
* Pinker, Steven. (2002) "The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature." New York: Penguin Group, Inc. ISBN 0-670-03151-8
* [http://www.philosophieportal.net/Ideologiekritik.htm Christian Duncker] : "Kritische Reflexionen des Ideologiebegriffes", 2006, ISBN 1-903343-88-7
* Christian Duncker (Hg.): "Ideologiekritik Aktuell – Ideologies Today. Bd. 1. London 2008, [http://www.turnshare.com/wissenschaft/duncker_9781847900159.html] . ISBN 978-1-84790-015-9
* Marx, Karl ( [1845-46] 1932) "The German Ideology" [http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1845/german-ideology/index.htm]
* Lukács, Georg (1919-23) "History and Class Consciousness" [http://www.marxists.org/archive/lukacs/works/history/index.htm]
* Mannheim, Karl (1936) "Ideology and Utopia" Routledge
* Minogue, Kenneth (1985) "Alien Powers: The Pure Theory of Ideology", Palgrave Macmillan, ISBN 0-312-01860-6
* Eagleton, Terry (1991) "Ideology. An introduction", Verso, ISBN 0-86091-319-8
* Hawkes, David (2003) "Ideology" (2nd ed.), Routledge, ISBN 0-415-29012-0
* Althusser, Louis (1971) 'Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses' "Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays" Monthly Review Press ISBN 1583670394
List of ideologies named after people
Socially constructed reality
* [http://www.autodidactproject.org/guidideo.html Ideology Study Guide]
* [http://www.ideologieforschung.de/en/ Ideology Research]
* [http://www.marx2mao.com/Other/LPOE70ii.html#s5 Louis Althusser's "Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses"]
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.