Tuisto

Tuisto (or Tuisco) is the divine ancestor of the Germanic peoples attested in Tacitus' "Germania" (98 CE). The figure remains the subject of some scholarly discussion, largely focused upon etymological connections and comparisons to figures in later (particularly Norse) Germanic mythology.

"Germania"

Tacitus relates that "ancient songs" (Latin "carminibus antiquis") of the Germanic peoples celebrated Tuisto as "a god, born of the earth" ("deum terra editum"). These songs further attributed to him a son, Mannus, who in turn had three sons, the offspring of whom were referred to as Ingaevones, Herminones and Istaevones, living near the Ocean ("proximi Oceano"), in the interior ("medii"), and the remaining parts ("ceteri") of the geographical region of Germania, respectively. [Tacitus (2000:2.13-15).]

Myth of descendency

Tacitus' report falls squarely within the ethnographic tradition of the classical world, which often fused anthropogony, ethnogony, and theogony together into a synthetic whole. [Lindauer (1975:80-81).] The succession of father-son-three sons parallels occurs in both Germanic and non-Germanic Indo-European areas.Simek (2007:336).] The essential characteristics of the myth have been theorized as ultimately originated in Proto-Indo-European society around 2,000 BCE.Simek (2007:224-225).]

According to Rives (1999), the fact that the ancient Germanic peoples claimed descent from an earth-born god was used by Tacitus to support his contention that they were an indigenous population: the Latin word "indigena" was often used in the same sense as the Greek "autochthonos", meaning literally ' [born from] the land itself'. [Rives (1999:111-12).] Lindauer (1975) notes that, although this claim is to be judged as one made out of simple ignorance of the facts on the part of Tacitus, he was not entirely wrong, as he made the judgement based on a comparison with the relatively turbulent Mediterranean region of his day. [Lindauer (1975:80).]

Etymology

The "Germania" manuscript corpus contains two primary variant readings of the name. The most frequently occurring, Tuisto, is commonly connected to the Proto-Germanic root "*tvai"- "two" and its derivative "*tvis"- "twice" or "doubled". Claims of a connection between Tuisto and "Teut" and/or "Teutones", or worse, the former and the Buddha name "Tat" as proposed by Hargrave Jennings in his "Indian Religions" (1890; republished in 1996) are to be rejected as grand examples of pseudoscientific language comparison. This particular conjecture apparently goes back to Rev. George S. Faber, who published his "Origin of Pagan Idolatry" in 1816. He quipped: "I need scarcely observe that Mannus is Menu or Noah, and that Tuisto is the elder Teut or Adam" (pg. 356). Though rejected outright in scholarly journals even before full publication, Faber's ideas apparently gained a wide circulation. Cf. Valpy (1812:227).] This led Jacob Grimm to suggest that Tuisto may have been a hermaphroditic being, which remains the most prevalent opinion among scholars. [ Stallybrass (2004b:1350). Cf. Simek (1995:432).] Further, this interpretation has led to the assumption of a possible connection between the Germanic Tuisto and Ymir of later Norse mythology (see below).

The second variant of the name, occurring originally in manuscript "E", reads Tuisco. One proposed etymology for this variant reconstructs a Proto-Germanic "*tiwisko" and connects this with Proto-Germanic "*Tiwaz", giving the meaning "son of Tiu". This interpretation would thus make Tuisco the son of the sky-god (Proto-Indo-European *"Dyeus") and the earth-goddess. [Lindauer (1975:81). Nearly the same proposal was made by Grimm (Stallybrass 2004a:344) as early as 1875.]

Tuisto and Ymir

Connections have been proposed between the 1st century figure of Tuisto and the hermaphroditic primeval being Ymir in later Norse mythology, attested in 13th century sources, based upon etymological and functional similarity. [Cf. Simek (1995:432). Simek (1995:485) further connects Ymir to PIE "*iemo"- "twin" or "double", whence Sanskrit Yama, Greek Gemini. See also Dioskuri.] Meyer (1907) sees the connection as so strong, that he considers the two to be identical. [Meyer (1907): referenced in North (1997:269).] Lindow (2001), while mindful of the possible etymological connection between Tuisto and Ymir, notes an essential functional difference: while Ymir is portrayed as an "essentially … negative figure" - Tuisto is described as being "celebrated" ("celebrant") by the early Germanic peoples in song, with Tacitus reporting nothing negative about Tuisto. [Lindow (2001:296).]

Jacob (2005) attempts to establish a genealogical relationship between Tuisto and Ymir based on etymology and a comparison with (post-)Vedic Indian mythology: as Tvastr, through his daughter Saranyū and her husband Vivaswān, is said to have been the grandfather of the twins Yama and Yami, so Jacob argues that the Germanic Tuisto (assuming a connection with Tvastr) must originally have been the grandfather of Ymir (cognate to Yama). Incidentally, Indian mythology also places Manu (cognate to Germanic Mannus), the Vedic progenitor of mankind, as a son of Vivaswān, thus making him the brother of Yama/Ymir. [Jacob (2005:232).]

ee also

* Ethnogenesis

Notes

References

* Jacob, Alexander (2005). "Ātman: A Reconstruction of the Solar Cosmology of the Indo-Europeans." Georg Olms Verlag. ISBN: 3-487-12854-3.
* Lindauer, Josef (1975). "Germania: Bericht über Germanien." München: Deutscher Taschenbuch Verlag. ISBN: 3-423-09101-0.
* Lindow, John. (2001) "Norse Mythology: A Guide to the Gods, Heroes, Rituals, and Beliefs". Oxford University Press.
* North, Richard (1997). "Heathen Gods in Old English Literature." Cambridge University Press. ISBN: 0-521-55183-8.
* Rawlinson, George (2000). [http://classics.mit.edu/Herodotus/history.html The History of Herodotus] .
* Rives, J. B. (1999) (Trans.) Tacitus' "Germania." Oxford University Press 1999. ISBN: 0-198-15050-4.
* Simek, Rudolf (1995). "Lexikon der germanischen Mythology." Stuttgart: Kröner ISBN: 3-520-36802-1.
* Simek, Rudolf (2007) translated by Angela Hall. "Dictionary of Northern Mythology". D.S. Brewer. ISBN 0859915131
* Stallybrass, James Steven. (2004a) (Trans.) J. Grimm’s "Teutonic Mythology", volume I. Dover Publications. ISBN: 0-486-43546-6.
* Stallybrass, James Steven. (2004b) (Trans.) J. Grimm’s "Teutonic Mythology", volume IV. Dover Publications ISBN: 0-486-43549-0.
* Stuart, Duane R (1916). "Germania." New York: MacMillan Co. 1916.
* Tacitus (2000). "De origine et situ Germanorum liber." Stuttgart: Reclam 2000. ISBN: 3-15-009391-0.
* Valpy (1812). [http://books.google.com/books?id=Re2qp-Ni0wYC The Classical Journal] . March/June Edition, Vol. V. London: A. J. Valpy. 1812.