Hippocratic Corpus

Vaticanus graecus 277, 10v-11r: Table of contents in a fourteenth-century Hippocratic Corpus manuscript. Marcus Fabius Calvus owned this manuscript, transcribed it in his own hand, and used it in the preparation of his 1525 Latin translation.

The Hippocratic Corpus (Latin: Corpus Hippocraticum), or Hippocratic Collection, is a collection of around 60 early Ancient Greek medical works strongly associated with the physician Hippocrates and his teachings. They are, however, varied in content, age and style, and are largely of unknown authorship.

Authorship, name, origin

Of the texts in the corpus, none is proven to be by Hippocrates himself.^[1] The works of the corpus range from Hippocrates' time and school to many centuries later and rival points of view. Franz Zacharias Ermerins identifies the hands of at least twenty authors in the Hippocratic Corpus.^[2] However, the varied works of the corpus have gone under Hippocrates' name since antiquity. The corpus may be the remains of a library of Cos, or a collection compiled in the third century B.C. in Alexandria. It was not, however, only the Coan school of Ancient Greek medicine that contributed to it; the Cnidian did, too.^[3][4] Only a fraction of the Hippocratic writings have survived. The lost medical literature is sometimes referred to in the surviving treatises, as at the beginning of Regimen.^[5] Some Hippocratic works are known only in translation. "Hippocratic" texts survive in Arabic, Hebrew, Syriac, and Latin.

Dates and groupings

The majority of the works in the Hippocratic Corpus date from the Classical period, the last decades of the 5th century BC and the first half of the 4th century BC. Among the later works, The Law, On the Heart, On the Physician, and On Sevens are all Hellenistic, while Precepts and On Decorum are from the 1st and 2nd centuries AD.^[5]

Some of the earliest works of the corpus (mid-fifth century) are connected to the Cnidian school: On Diseases II-III and the early layer within On the Diseases of Women I-II and On Sterile Women.^[6] Prorrhetics I is also mid-fifth century.^[6] In the second half of the fifth century, a single author likely produced the treatises On Airs, Waters, Places; Prognostics; Prorrhetics II; and On the Sacred Disease.^[6] Other fifth-century works include On Fleshes, Epidemics I and III (ca. 410 BC), On Ancient Medicine, On Regimen in Acute Diseases, and Polybus' On the Nature of Man/Regimen in Health (410-400 BC).^[6]

At the end of the fifth or the beginning of the fourth century, one author likely wrote Epidemics II-IV-VI and On the Humors. The coherent group of surgical treatises (On Fractures, On Joints, On Injuries of the Head, Surgery, Mochlicon) is of similar date.^[6]

The gynecological treatises On the Nature of the Woman, On the Diseases of Women, Generation, On the Nature of the Child, and On Sterile Women constitute a closely related group. Hermann Grensemann (de) identified five layers of material in this group, from the mid-fifth century to the mid-fourth century.^[7] The oldest stratum is found in On the Nature of the Woman and On the Diseases of Women II.^[7] Generation and On the Nature of the Child constitute a single work by a late-fifth-century author,^[8] who may also be identified as the author of On Diseases IV and of sections of On the Diseases of Women I.^[9] The latest layer is On Sterile Women, which was composed after the other gynecological treatises were in existence.^[7]

A single fourth-century author probably wrote On Fistulae and On Hemorrhoids.^[6]

Content

The Hippocratic Corpus contains textbooks, lectures, research, notes and philosophical essays on various subjects in medicine, in no particular order.^[1][10] These works were written for different audiences, both specialists and laymen, and were sometimes written from opposing view points; significant contradictions can be found between works in the Corpus.^[11]

Case histories

One significant portion of the corpus is made up of case histories. Books I and III of Epidemics contain forty-two case histories, of which 60% (25) ended in the patient's death.^[12] Nearly all of the diseases described in the Corpus are endemic diseases: colds, consumption, pneumonia, etc.^[13]

Theoretical and methodological reflections

In several texts of the corpus, the ancient physicians elaborate theories of illness, sometimes grappling with the methodological difficulties that lie in the way of effective and consistent diagnosis and treatment: "One of the great merits of the physicians of the Hippocratic Corpus is that they are not content to practice medicine and to commit their experience to writing, but that they have reflected on their own activity."^[14]

Reason and experience

While the approaches range from empiricism to a rationalism reminiscent of the physical theories of the Presocratics, these two tendencies can exist side-by-side: "The close association between knowledge and experience is characteristic of the Hippocratics," despite "the Platonic attempt to drive a wedge between the two."^[15]

The author of On Ancient Medicine launches immediately into a critique of opponents who posit a single "cause in all cases" of disease, "having laid down as a hypothesis for their account hot or cold or wet or dry or anything else they want."^[16] The method put forward in this treatise "could certainly be characterized as an empirical one," preferring the effects of diet as observed by the senses to cosmological speculations, and it was seized upon by Hellenistic Empiricist doctors for this reason.^[17] However, "unlike the Empiricists, the author does not claim that the doctor's knowledge is limited to what can be observed by the senses. On the contrary, he requires the doctor to have quite extensive knowledge of aspects of the human constitution that cannot be observed directly, such as the state of the patient's humors and internal organs."^[18]

Epistemology and the scientific status of medicine

The author of The Art is at pains to defend the status of medicine as an art (techne), against opponents who (perhaps following Protagoras' critique of expert knowledge^[19]) claim it produces no better results against disease than chance (an attack served by the fact that doctors refused to treat the serious and difficult cases they judged to be incurable by their art^[20]). The treatise may be considered "the first attempt at general epistemology bequeathed to us by antiquity," although this may only be because we have lost fifth-century rhetorical works that took a similar approach.^[21]

For this writer, as for the author of On the Places in Man, the art of medicine has been wholly discovered. While for the author of On the Places in Man "the principles discovered in it clearly have very little need of good luck," the author of The Art acknowledges the practical limitations that arise in the therapeutic application of these principles.^[22] Likewise for the author of On Regimen, the "knowledge and discernment of the nature of man in general—knowledge of its primary constituents and discernment of the components by which it is controlled" may be completely worked out, and yet in practice it is difficult to determine and apply the correct and proportionate diet and exercise to the individual patient.^[23]

Natural vs. divine causality

Whatever their disagreements, the Hippocratic writers agree in rejecting divine and religious causes and remedies of disease in favor of natural mechanisms. Thus On the Sacred Disease considers that epilepsy (the so-called "sacred" disease) "has a natural cause, and its supposed divine origin is due to men's inexperience and to their wonder at its peculiar character." An exception to this rule is found in Dreams (Regime IV), in which prayers to the gods are prescribed alongside more typically Hippocratic interventions. Though materialistic determinism goes back in Greek thought at least to Leucippus, "One of the greatest virtues of the physicians of the Hippocratic Collection is to have stated, in its most universal form, what was later to be called the principle of determinism. All that occurs has a cause. It is in the treatise of The Art that the most theoretical statement of this principle is to be found: 'Indeed, under a close examination spontaneity disappears; for everything that occurs will be found to do so through something [dia ti].'"^[24] In a famous passage of On Ancient Medicine, the author insists on the importance of knowledge of causal explanations: "It is not sufficient to learn simply that cheese is a bad food, as it gives a pain to one who eats a surfeit of it; we must know what the pain is, the reasons for it [dia ti], and which constituent of man is harmfully affected."^[24]

Medical ethics and manners

The duties of the physician are an object of the Hippocratic writers' attention. A famous maxim (Epidemics I.11) advises: "As to diseases, make a habit of two things—to help, or at least to do no harm."

The most famous work in the Hippocratic Corpus is the Hippocratic Oath, a landmark declaration of medical ethics. The Hippocratic Oath is both philosophical and practical; it not only deals with abstract principles but practical matters such as removing stones and aiding one's teacher financially. It is a complex and probably not the work of one man.^[25][26] It remains in use, though rarely in its original form.^[26]

The preamble of On the Physician offers "a physical and moral portrait of the ideal physician," and the Precepts also concern the physician's conduct.^[27] Treatises such as On Joints and Epidemics VI are concerned with the provision of such "courtesies" as providing a patient with cushions during a procedure,^[28] and Decorum includes advice on good manners to be observed in the doctor's office or when visiting patients.

Style

"Life is short, [the] art long, opportunity fleeting, experiment treacherous, judgment difficult."

Aphorisms i.1.

The writing style of the Corpus has been remarked upon for centuries, being described by some as, "clear, precise, and simple".^[29] It is often praised for its objectivity and concisesness, yet some have criticised it as being "grave and austere".^[30] Francis Adams, a translator of the Corpus, goes further and calls it sometimes “obscure”. Of course, not all of the Corpus is of this “laconic” style, though most of it is. It was Hippocratic practice to write in this style.^[31]

The whole corpus is written in Ionic Greek, though the island of Cos was in a region that spoke Doric Greek.

The Art and On Breaths show the influence of Sophistic rhetoric; they "are characterized by long introductions and conclusions, antitheses, anaphoras, and sound effects typical of Gorgianic style." Other works also have rhetorical elements.^[32] In general, it can be said that "the Hippocratic physician was also an orator," with his role including public speeches and "verbal wrestling matches."^[33]

Printed editions

The entire Hippocratic Corpus was first printed as a unit in 1525. This edition was in Latin and was edited by Marcus Fabius Calvus in Rome. The first complete Greek edition followed the next year from the Aldine Press in Venice. A significant edition was that of Émile Littré who spent twenty-two years (1839–1861) working diligently on a complete Greek edition and French translation of the Hippocratic Corpus. This was scholarly, yet sometimes inaccurate and awkward.^[34] Another edition of note was that of Franz Zacharias Ermerins, published in Utrecht between 1859 and 1864.^[34] Kühlewein's Teubner edition (1894-1902) "mark[ed] a distinct advance."^[34]

Beginning in 1967, an important modern edition by Jacques Jouanna and others began to appear (with Greek text, French translation, and commentary) in the Collection Budé. Other important bilingual annotated editions (with translation in German or French) continue to appear in the Corpus medicorum graecorum published by the Berlin-Brandenburgische Akademie der Wissenschaften.

English translations

The first English translation from the Hippocratic Corpus, Peter Lowe's Chirurgerie ("Surgery"), was published in 1597, but a complete English translation of a dozen and a half "genuine" works was not offered in English until Francis Adams' publication of 1849. Other works of the corpus remained untranslated into English until the resumed publication of the Loeb Classical Library edition beginning in 1988.^[35] The first four Loeb volumes were published in 1923-1931, and five further volumes appeared between 1988 and 2010. A tenth volume by Ann Ellis Hanson, containing the gynecological treatises, is expected to complete the series.^[36][37]

List of works of the Corpus

(Ordering from Adams 1891, pp. 40-105; LCL = vols. of the Loeb Classical Library edition)

Possibly genuine works of Hippocrates On Ancient Medicine or Tradition in Medicine (LCL 1) Prognostics (LCL 2) Aphorisms (LCL 4) Epidemics I and III (LCL 1) On Regimen in Acute Diseases (LCL 2, 6) On Airs, Waters, and Places (LCL 1) On the Articulations or On Joints (LCL 3) On Fractures (LCL 3) On the Instruments of Reduction or Mochlicon (LCL 3) On Injuries of the Head (LCL 3) The Hippocratic Oath (LCL 1) The Law or The Canon (LCL 2) The Physician's Establishment or Surgery (LCL 3) Works of Polybus On the Nature of Man (LCL 4) Regimen in Health (LCL 4) Works predating Hippocrates Prorrhetics I (LCL 8) The Coan Praenotions[38] (LCL 9) Works of the age or spirit of Hippocrates Prorrhetics II (LCL 8) On Ulcers (LCL 8) On Fistulae (LCL 8) On Hemorrhoids (LCL 8) On the Sacred Disease (LCL 2) On Airs or Breaths or Of the Pneuma (LCL 2) On the Places in Man (LCL 8) The Art or The Science of Medicine (LCL 2) On Regimen (LCL 4) On Dreams (LCL 4) On Affections (LCL 5) On Internal Affections (LCL 6) On Diseases (LCL 5, 6) On the Seventh Month's Foetus (LCL 9) On the Eighth Month's Foetus (LCL 9) Epidemics II, IV-VII (LCL 7) On the Humors (LCL 4) On the Use of Liquids (LCL 8)

Gynecological works On Semen or Generation or On Intercourse On the Nature of the Child or Pregnancy On the Diseases of Women On Sterile Women On the Diseases of Young Women or Girls (LCL 9) On Superfoetation (LCL 9) On the Nature of the Woman Post-Hippocratic works (age of Aristotle and Praxagoras) On the Heart (LCL 9) On Aliment or Nutriment (LCL 1) On Fleshes (LCL 8) On the Weeks or On Hebdomads or On Sevens (survives completely only in Latin translations: text Roscher 1913) On the Glands (LCL 8) On the Veins (an excerpt from On the Nature of the Bones, LCL 9) Late and dubious works On the Physician (LCL 2, 8) On Decorum or On Honorable Conduct (LCL 2) Precepts (LCL 1) On Anatomy or On Dissection (LCL 9) On Dentition (LCL 2) On the Excision of the Foetus (LCL 9) On Vision (LCL 9) On the Nature of the Bones (LCL 9) On the Crises (LCL 9) On Critical Days (LCL 9) On Purgative Medicines or Remedies (not in Littré or LCL editions: text Schöne 1920-1924) Letters and Speeches (Hippocrates: Pseudepigraphic Writings, Leiden: Brill, 1990)

See also

• Huangdi Neijing a work of comparable importance in Chinese medicine, published during the same time period

References

• Adams, Francis (1891), The Genuine Works of Hippocrates, New York: William Wood and Company .
• Gillispie, Charles Coulston (1972). Dictionary of Scientific Biography. VI. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. pp. 419–427. 
• Garrison, Fielding H. (1966), History of Medicine, Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders Company .
• Jones, W.H.S. 1923. General Introduction to Hippocrates, Loeb Classical Library, vol. 1, Harvard University Press.
• Jacques Jouanna (de/fr), Hippocrates, trans. M.B. DeBevoise, Baltimore: John Hopkins UP, 1999, ISBN 0801859077
• Margotta, Roberto (1968), The Story of Medicine, New York: Golden Press .
• Martí-Ibáñez, Félix (1961), A Prelude to Medical History, New York: MD Publications, Inc., Library of Congress ID: 61-11617 .
• Rutkow, Ira M. (1993), Surgery: An Illustrated History, London and Southampton: Elsevier Science Health Science div, ISBN 0-801-6-6078-5 .
• Singer, Charles; Underwood, E. Ashworth (1962), Short History of Medicine, New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, Library of Congress ID: 62-21080 .
•  Tuke, John Batty (1911). "Hippocrates". In Chisholm, Hugh. Encyclopædia Britannica. 13 (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press. pp. 517-519. http://encyclopedia.jrank.org/HIG_HOR/HIPPOCRATES.html. 

Notes

1. ^ ^{a b} Singer & Underwood 1962, p. 27
2. ^ Tuke 1911
3. ^ Margotta 1968, p. 64
4. ^ Martí-Ibáñez 1961, pp. 86–87
5. ^ ^{a b} Gillispie 1972, p. 420
6. ^ ^{a b c d e f} Jouanna 1999, pp. 373-416 (Appendix 3: The Treatises of the Hippocratic Collection)
7. ^ ^{a b c} Ann Ellis Hanson, "Continuity and Change: Three Case Studies in Hippocratic Gynecological Therapy and Theory," in Sarah B. Pomeroy (ed.), Women's History and Ancient History, University of North Carolina Press, 1991, p. 77.
8. ^ Iain M. Lonie, The Hippocratic Treatises "On Generation," "On the Nature of the Child," "Diseases IV", Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 1981, p. 71.
9. ^ Lonie 1981.
10. ^ Rutkow, p. 23
11. ^ Singer & Underwood 1962, p. 28
12. ^ Garrison 1966, p. 95
13. ^ Jones 1923, p. lvi
14. ^ Jacques Jouanna, Hippocrate: Ouevres complètes, Collection Budé, vol. 5, p. 83.
15. ^ Mark J. Schiefsky, Hippocrates: On Ancient Medicine, Leiden: Brill, 2005, p. 117.
16. ^ On Ancient Medicine 1, trans. Schiefsky
17. ^ Schiefsky 2005, pp. 65-66.
18. ^ Schiefsky 2005, p. 345
19. ^ Jouanna 1999, p. 244
20. ^ Jouanna 1999, p. 108.
21. ^ Jouanna 1999, pp. 246-248, 255-256.
22. ^ Jouanna 1999, p. 238
23. ^ Regimen 1.2 (Loeb, vol. 4, pp. 227-229)
24. ^ ^{a b} Jouanna 1999, pp. 254-255.
25. ^ W.H.S. Jones, Hippocrates, Loeb Classical Library edition, vol. 1 (1923), p. 291
26. ^ ^{a b} Garrison 1966, p. 96
27. ^ Jouanna 1999, pp. 404-405.
28. ^ Jouanna 1999, p. 133.
29. ^ Garrison 1966, p. 99
30. ^ Jones 1923, p. xv
31. ^ Adams 1891, p. 18
32. ^ Francesca Schironi, "Technical Languages: Science and Medicine," in Egbert J. Bakker (ed.), A Companion to the Ancient Greek Language, Wiley-Blackwell, 2010, p. 350
33. ^ Jouanna 1999, pp. 79-85.
34. ^ ^{a b c} Jones 1923, p. lxviii-lxix
35. ^ Vivian Nutton, review of Loeb vols. 5-6 (1988)
36. ^ Helen King, Hippocrates' woman: reading the female body in ancient Greece, Routledge, 1998, p. xii
37. ^ Bonnie MacLachlan and Judith Fletcher (eds.), Virginity revisited: configurations of the unpossessed body, Toronto, 2007, p. x
38. ^ The Coan Prenotions, once thought by Littré and others to be the ancient source of Prognostics, is now universally agreed to be a compilation derivative of Prognostics and other Hippocratic works (Jouanna 1999, p. 379).

External links

English translations and Greek/English bilingual editions

• Loeb edition (1923-1931): vol. 1, vol. 2, vol. 3, vol. 4
• Hippocrates: Greek texts and English translations from the Perseus Project
• English translations by Francis Adams: HTML anthology; 1891 edition via Harvard; earlier editions

Other Greek texts

• Corpus Medicorum Graecorum edition online (1927-2003)
• Littré edition (1839-1861) via Collection Medic@ (Greek text and French translation): vols. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10
• Kühlewein edition (1894-1902): Hathi Trust c. 1, c. 2; archive.org vol. 1, vol. 2

Bibliography

• Gerhard Fichtner, Hippocratic bibliography (2011) (Berlin Academy)