Protection of Military Remains Act 1986

The Protection of Military Remains Act 1986 (1986 c. 35) is an Act of Parliament in the United Kingdom which provides protection for the wreckage of military aircraft and designated military vessels. [ [http://portal.unesco.org/culture/en/files/28636/11279482863Protection_of_Military_Remains_Act_1986.pdf/Protection%2Bof%2BMilitary%2BRemains%2BAct%2B1986.pdf Text of the 'Protection of Military Remains Act 1986" (UK)] ] The Act provides for two types of protection: "protected places" and "controlled sites". Military aircraft are automatically protected but vessels have to be specifically designated.cite web |title=Protected Wrecks in the UK | publisher=Maritime and Coastguard Agency | url=http://www.mcga.gov.uk/c4mca/mcga07-home/emergencyresponse/mcga-receiverofwreck/mcga-protectedwrecks.htm | accessdate=2008-08-08] The primary reason for designation is to protect as a 'war grave' the last resting place of UK servicemen (or other nationals), however, the act does not require the loss of the vessel to have occurred during war.cite web |title=Marine Archaeology Legislation Project page 23| publisher=English Heritage | url=http://www.english-heritage.org.uk/upload/pdf/marine_archaeology_legislation_project.pdf | accessdate=2008-07-21]

There have been three statutory instruments designating wrecks under the Act, in 2002,cite web |title=The Protection of Military Remains Act 1986 (Designation of Vessels and Controlled Sites) Order 2002 | publisher=Office of Public Sector Information | url=http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2008/uksi_20080950_en_1 | accessdate=2008-07-21] 2006,cite web |title=The Protection of Military Remains Act 1986 (Designation of Vessels and Controlled Sites) Order 2006 | publisher=Office of Public Sector Information | url=http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2006/20062616.htm | accessdate=2008-07-21] and 2008.cite web |title=The Protection of Military Remains Act 1986 (Designation of Vessels and Controlled Sites) Order 2008 | publisher=Office of Public Sector Information | url=http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2008/uksi_20080950_en_1 | accessdate=2008-07-21] Twelve wrecks are designated as controlled sites, on which diving is banned. These twelve vessels (including one German submarine), all lost on military service, provide a small representative sample of all such vessels.cite web |title=Warship wrecks gain greater protection | publisher=Royal Navy | url=http://www.navynews.co.uk/articles/2001/0111/0001111201.asp | accessdate=2008-08-08] All other vessels that meet the criteria of the act are subject to a rolling programme of assessment and those that meet the criteria will be designated as protected places. [cite web |title=Lords Hansard text for 14 November 2005 (51114w04) |work=Hansard |publisher=Parliament Publication and Records | url=http://www.parliament.the-stationery-office.co.uk/pa/ld199697/ldhansrd/pdvn/lds05/text/51114w04.htm | accessdate=2008-08-07] The order that is currently in force, since 2008, designates 46 wrecks as protected places. This means that diving is allowed but divers must follow the rule of "look, don't touch".

Protection under the Act

The Act provides for two types of protection: "protected places" and "controlled sites". [cite web |title=Protected Wrecks in the UK | publisher=Maritime and Coastguard Agency | url=http://www.mcga.gov.uk/c4mca/mcga07-home/emergencyresponse/mcga-receiverofwreck/mcga-protectedwrecks/mcga-protectedwrecks-military.htm | accessdate=2008-07-21] The primary reason for designation is to protect the last resting place of UK servicemen (or other nationals). While this is often referred to as protection as a war grave, the protected wrecks are not graves in the sense of falling under the control of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission, nor are they required to have been lost during wartime.

The wreckage of all military aircraft (UK or other nations) that crashed in the United Kingdom, in United Kingdom teritorial waters or in United Kingdom controlled waters are automatically protected irrespective of whether there was loss of life or whether the wrecking occurred during peacetime or in a combat. The wreckage of United Kingdom military aircraft are also protected under the act elsewhere in the world.

Protected places

Wrecks are designated by name and can be designated as protected places even if the location of the site is not known. Thus, the wreckage of a UK military aircraft is automatically a protected place even if the physical remains have not been previously discovered or identified. Shipwrecks need to be specifically designated, and designation as a protected place applies only to vessels that sank after 14 August 1914. The Act makes it an offence to interfere with a protected place, to disturb the site or to remove anything from the site. Divers may visit the site but the rule is "look, don't touch and don't penetrate". The law concerning protected places applies anywhere in the world, but in practice, outside the UK, the sanctions can only be enforced against UK citizens, UK flagged ships, or vessels landing in the UK, unless backed by local legislation. The first and only license granted in respect of a vessel designated a "protected place" was granted to Mike Williams of the Nautical Archaeology Society, for a project to commemorate the 75th anniversary of the loss of the M2 submarine including the placing of a white ensign underwater. [cite web |title=M2 Submarine Disaster Commemorated 75 years on| publisher=Nautical Archaeology Society | url=http://www.nasportsmouth.org.uk/projects/M2_2007.php | accessdate=2008-07-23]

Controlled sites

"Controlled sites" must be specifically designated by location, where the site contains the remains of an aircraft or a vessel that crashed, sank or was stranded within the last two hundred years. The Act makes it illegal to conduct any operations (including any diving or excavation) within the controlled site that might disturb the remains unless licensed to do so by the Ministry of Defence. Licences have been granted for excavation of aircraft, provided that it is not thought that there are human remains present or unexploded ordnance.cite web |title=Aviation Archaeology | publisher=Ministry of Defence|url=http://www.mod.uk/DefenceInternet/AboutDefence/WhatWeDo/Personnel/SPVA/AviationArchaeology.htm | accessdate=2008-07-23] In the case of sunken vessels, any activities necessary, such as the recovery of extant human remains and the sealing of openings into wrecks is generally carried out by Ministry of Defence diving teams. Controlled sites at sea are marked on admiralty charts and their physical location is marked by means of a buoy (sea mark).

Protection of aircraft

During the 1970s there was a rapid growth in excavation of the crash sites of military aircraft. These were sometimes carried out by interested amateur souvenir hunters, and sometimes by more serious prospectors of valuable military artefacts. The rights and wrongs of this activity was confused by conflicting statements from the Ministry of Defence, who, in 1973 stated that they had abandoned all claim to crashed planes and that any of official interest had been recovered. Later on they reversed this position, claiming Crown title of both RAF and German wrecks and stating that any excavation required official permission, issuing guidelines and threatening that excavation without such permission was illegal interference with Crown Property. Excavations continued however, and several incidents involving the discovery of human remains and live ordnance (along with concerns about divers and shipwrecks) led to the passing of the Protection of Military Remains Act in 1986.cite web |title=Corroded in Action:Excavating plane crash sites can bring special rewards, by Saunders, Andy | publisher=British Archaeology | url=http://www.britarch.ac.uk/BA/ba75/feat1a.shtml | accessdate=2008-08-10]

Since the passing of the Act, investigators have been able to obtain licences to excavate subject to a number of conditions. The applicant must have thoroughly researched the crash and be able to identify the aircraft and the fate of the crew. This research becomes the property of the Ministry of Defence. The landowner of the site of the crash must have given permission. Special conditions may be imposed by local councils or heritage agencies. Following excavation all material receovered must be identified to the Ministry of Defence. Personal property of the aircrew is likely to be returned to next of kin, and military artefacts of historical interest are likely to be placed in the care of the Royal Air Force Museum, but the licensee may apply for ownership of other material. Licences cannot be issued for sites where there is likely to be unexploded ordnance, and Ministry of Defence policy is not to issue licences where human remains are likely to be found. The Ministry of Defence reserves the right to witness all excavations.

A large number of aircraft were lost in the sea off the South and East Coasts of England during the Second World War. These areas are commercially important for marine aggregates. Since the aircraft are protected under this Act, the discovery of aircraft remains during aggregate dredging means that dredging must stop and an exclusion zone around the position of the wreck established. The disturbance of wrecks by dredging is also of concern for potential disturbance of human remains and because of damage to an important historical resource. A project undertaken in 2007-2008 by Wessex Archaeology funded under the Aggregates Levy Sustainabilty Fund managed by English Heritage, looked at the potential of the historical resource of such wrecks and also for issuing guidance to the aggregates industry to manage the impact of finding remains.cite web |title=Aircraft Crash Sites at Sea | publisher=Wessex Archaeology | url=http://blogs.wessexarch.co.uk/aircraftcrashsitesatsea/ | accessdate=2008-08-10]

Criteria for designation of wrecks

As a result of an extensive consultation carried out in 2000-2001, the Ministry of Defence announced that it would carry out a rolling programme of assessment of all British military wrecks known to have been lost on military service. Designation as a "controlled site" is only applicable in waters controlled by the United Kingom. Wrecks considered dangerous will be designated as "controlled sites". Wrecks that met a set of criteria would be designated. Under the act, wrecks to be designated as "controlled sites" must have sunk within the last two hundred years. Wrecks to be designated as "protected places" must have been lost after 14 January 1918. The criteria for designation announced by the Ministry of Defence include: whether the wreck represents the last resting place of servicemen; whether the wreck has suffered sustained disturbance and looting, and whether designation is likely to stop such disturbance; whether diving on the wreck attracts public criticism; whether the wreck is of historical significance. In addition it was announced that if a wreck designated as a "protected place" suffers sustained disturbance it will be designated as a "controlled site".

History of designations under the Act

The Act was passed in 1986, partly in response to concerns over excavation of military aircraft, partly over public disquiet about the fate of sunken military ships and also because in the aftermath of the Falklands War, public opinion supported the idea that a maritime war grave should be sacrosanct. The ships of concern included HMS "Hampshire", where personal possessions of casualties had been looted by divers and salvage of HMS "Edinburgh" which had occurred without respecting the human remains that it contained. [cite book |editor=Bowens, Amanda |title= Underwater Archaeology: The NAS Guide to Principles and Practice |url=http://www.blackwellpublishing.com/book.asp?ref=9781405175913&site=1 |edition=2nd Edition (2008)|date= |year= |month= |publisher=Blackwell Publishing |isbn=978-1-4051-7591-3 |chapter=International and National Laws Relating to Archaeology Under Water] However, although the Act gave immediate protection to wrecked aircraft the wrecks of ships needed to be individually designated to be protected.

First designations

By the year 2000, there was widespread concern amongst survivor associations (such as those of Force Z), [cite web |title=Force Z Survivors | url=http://www.forcez-survivors.org.uk/about.html | accessdate=2008-07-21] and amongst the majority of divers, about the behaviour of a minority of scuba divers who were disturbing wrecks which most thought should be treated with respect. [cite web |title=Friends of War Memorials | url=http://www.axfordsabode.org.uk/fowm/prescuts.htm | accessdate=2008-07-23] [cite web |title=War Graves and Divers, BSAC website, Extract from Hansard 1 November 2000 | url=http://www.bsac.org/page/629/war-graves.htm | accessdate=2008-07-23] In 2000, the diving associations, BSAC, PADI and SAA, with the support of the Maritime and Coastguard Agency, Ministry of Defence, Nautical Archaeology Society, and Joint Nautical Archaeology Policy Committee, launched a code of conduct for divers entitled "Respect our Wrecks", with the central message of "look, don't touch". [cite web |title=Respect our Wrecks | url=http://www.bsac.org/page/628/respect-our-wrecks.htm | accessdate=2008-07-23] It was not until 2002 that the first designations came into force. The announcement stated that there would be sixteen controlled sites (in waters under UK control), and five designated protected places (five UK wrecks in international waters and one German U-boat in UK waters), with four of the Falkland wrecks HMS "Ardent", HMS "Antelope", HMS "Coventry" and HMS "Sheffield" listed as controlled sites.cite web |title=Maritime military graves to receive greater protection | publisher=Ministry of Defence | url=http://www.operations.mod.uk/onthisday/newsItem_id=1111.htm | accessdate=2008-07-21] The order only covered eleven controlled sites, which did not include the Falkland wrecks. HMS "Prince of Wales" and HMS "Repulse" (the ships of Force Z) as well as HMS Hampshire were included in the designations. However, HMS "Ardent" and HMS "Antelope" were already protected (as prohibited sites because they were considered dangerous) by an order passed in 1983 under the Falkland Islands Protection of Wrecks Ordnance 1977.Protection of Wrecks Ordnance 1977 (No. 12) 7 July 1977 (Falkland Islands)] [Protection of Wrecks (Ardent and Antelope Designation) Order 1983 (No. 2) 20 October 1983 (Falkland Islands)] HMS "Coventry" and HMS "Sheffield" had to wait until 2006 to be protected.

The coordinates given for the position of HMS "Hampshire" had to be corrected in a subsequent order in 2003.cite web |title=The Protection of Military Remains Act 1986 (Designation of Vessels and Controlled Sites) (Amendment) Order 2003 | publisher=Office of Public Sector Information | url=http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2003/20030405.htm | accessdate=2008-07-21]

econd tranche including Battle of Jutland wrecks

On 31 May 2006, the 90th anniversary of the Battle of Jutland, it was announced that the remains of the fourteen UK ships lost in that battle were being designated as protected places.cite web |title=New Protection Announced For Jutland Wrecks | work=Defence News website | publisher= Ministry of Defence | url=http://www.mod.uk/DefenceInternet/DefenceNews/HistoryAndHonour/NewProtectionAnnouncedForJutlandWrecksvideo.htm | accessdate=2006-10-06] [cite web |title=Jutland Commemorated 90 years on | publisher=BBC News | url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/5033582.stm | accessdate=2006-10-06] The 'second tranche' came into force on 1 November 2006. This revoked the first tranche, but re-designated the wrecks and added a further 29 protected places and 1 controlled site (the UB-81). HMS "Sheffield" was one of the protected places added. At around the same time, the Falkland Islands issued an order under the Falkland Islands Protection of Wrecks Ordnance 1977 designating HMS "Coventry" as a restricted area. [Protection of Wrecks (Designation) Order 2006 (no. 24) 23 October 2006 (Falkland Islands)]

The "Storaa" judgment and third tranche

The SS "Storaa" was a merchant vessel sunk by a German torpedo on 3 November 1943 while she was part of a military convoy. Those who died included Royal Navy personnel, as well as merchant seamen.cite web |title= THE QUEEN ON THE APPLICATION OF (1) ROSEMARY FOGG (2) VALERIE LEDGARD Claimants and THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR DEFENCE, Case No: CO/132/2005 Neutral Citation Number: 2005 EWHC 2888 (Admin) | work=Richard Buxton.co.uk | url=http://www.richardbuxton.co.uk/reference/view.php?table=transcripts&id=149&
| accessdate=2006-10-12 In the transcript, the Judge, Mr Justice Newman, identifies the uncontested facts of the history of the SS Storaa.]

Rosemary Fogg and Valerie Ledgard (the claimants), the daughters of one of the men who died, Petty Officer James Varndell RN requested that the Ministry of Defence designate the wreck. When the Ministry of Defence refused on the grounds that this was a merchant ship and therefore not eligible for designation, the claimants launched a judicial appeal, supported by Peter Marsden (a local historian and maritime archaeologist) and the Merchant Navy Association. [cite web |title= Legal Fight to Protect Grave of Wartime Seamen | work=The Guardian |date=15 November 2003 | url=http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2003/nov/15/military.arts| accessdate=2008-08-08] The High Court judge, Mr Justice Newmann decided in their favour of the claimants on 13 December 2005. The Ministry of Defence appealed, but on 5 October 2006, the Appeal Court upheld the High Court decision. The court ruled that the act could apply to merchant vessels and that the Secretary of State for Defence was therefore required to reconsider whether or not the "Storaa" should be designated under the act. Note that the judgement did not guarantee that the wreck would be designated, only that it was eligible for consideration. However, the wreck was subsequently designated in 2008.

The third tranche came into force on 1 May 2008, revoking the 2006 order, but re-designating the wrecks and adding 10 more vessels designated as protected places.cite web |title=Ten military shipwrecks protected as final resting places | work=Ministry of Defence - Defence News | publisher=Ministry of Defence|url=http://www.mod.uk/defenceinternet/defencenews/historyandhonour/tenmilitaryshipwrecksprotectedasfinalrestingplaces.htm | accessdate=2008-07-21] These included the first merchant ships to be protected, SS "Storaa" and "Atlantic Conveyor", which had been requisitioned to serve as a transport ship in the Falklands War.

List of designations under the Act

All of the wrecks designated under the act are designated under the 2008 order since this revoked the previous order. Information about the wrecks can be found in the announcement for the year that they designated (2002, 2006, or 2008). HMS "Ardent", HMS "Antelope" and HMS "Coventry" which were sunk in the Falklands War are not protected under this act, but are protected under the Falkland Islands Protection of Wrecks Ordnance 1977.

ee also

* Aviation archaeology
* Maritime archaeology
* Archaeology of shipwrecks
* Wreck diving
* List of shipwrecks
* Protection of Wrecks Act
* Battle of Jutland

References