Martin v. Wilks

Martin v. Wilks
Martin v. Wilks
Seal of the United States Supreme Court.svg
Supreme Court of the United States
Argued January 18, 1989
Decided June 12, 1989
Full case name Martin, et al. v. Robert K. Wilks, et al.
Holding
Respondents are not precluded from challenging the employment decisions taken pursuant to the consent decrees.
Court membership
Case opinions
Majority Rehnquist, joined by White, O'Connor, Scalia, Kennedy
Dissent Stevens, joined by Brennan, Marshall, Blackmun

Martin v. Wilks, 490 U.S. 755 (1989)[1], was a U.S. Supreme Court case brought by Robert K. Wilks challenging the validity of race-based hiring practices.

In 1974, the Jefferson County, Alabama Personnel Board signed a consent decree that required them to hire and promote African-American firefighters. Wilks, a white fireman, took issue with the agreement, claiming that he and other white firefighters (who were not parties to the original consent decrees signed in 1974) were more qualified than some of the black firefighters receiving promotions. The Supreme Court of the United States upheld the appeal of the white firefighters in a 5-4 decision on the issue of whether the white firefighters have a constitutional right to challenge the previously established decrees.

Chief Justice William Rehnquist wrote for the majority. They reasoned that a person cannot be denied his rights in a proceeding to which he was not a party. Since the white firefighters did not have valid notice of the original proceeding, they should have their appeal sustained and the decrees overturned.

Justice John Paul Stevens wrote the dissent, and he was joined by Justice William Brennan, Justice Thurgood Marshall, and Justice Harry Blackmun. The dissent reasoned that the white firefighters should have had only limited means to appeal given that they were challenging the validity of the consent decrees but were not original parties to the consent decrees and that the majority overstepped the authority of the court.

It is noteworthy that despite the racial overtones of the case and the sensitive public issues of civil rights and affirmative action, the core dispute of the case is one regarding proper procedure. The Court argued that the white firefighters should have been joined as parties to the original proceeding under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 19(a).

See also

Further reading

  • Fairless, M. J. (1990). "Martin v. Wilks: Playing by the Rules in Employment Discrimination Litigation". Missouri Law Review 55: 703. ISSN 0026-6604. 
  • Issacharoff, Samuel (1991). "When Substance Mandates Procedure: Martin v. Wilks and the Rights of Vested Incumbents in Civil Rights Consent Decrees". Cornell Law Review 77: 189. ISSN 0010-8847. 

External links

Works related to Martin v. K Wilks Personnel Board of Jefferson County Alabama at Wikisource


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно сделать НИР?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Wilks — may refer to:* Alan Wilks * Eileen Wilks * Ella Wilks * Guy Wilks * Henry Wilks * Ivor Wilks * Jim Wilks * John Wilks * Marian Wilks * Mark Wilks * Mark Wilks Collet * Maurice Wilks * Mike Wilks (author) * Mike Wilks (basketball) * Nicholas Wilks …   Wikipedia

  • Martin Brundle — This article is about the racing driver. For the fictional lead character in the film The Fly II, see Martin Brundle (The Fly). Martin Brundle Brundle in 2004 Born 1 June 1959 (1959 06 01) …   Wikipedia

  • David Wilks — MP Member of the 41st Canadian Parliament for Kootenay Columbia Taking office May 30, 2011 Succeeding Jim Abbott Personal details Born …   Wikipedia

  • Pat Martin — Patrick (Pat) Martin (né le 13 décembre 1955 à Winnipeg, au Manitoba) est un homme politique canadien. Il est député à la Chambre des communes du Canada depuis 1997, représentant la circonscription de Winnipeg Centre pour le Nouveau …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Citation signal — Introductory signals are used in legal citations to present authorities and show how the authorities relate to propositions in textual statements. A legal writer uses an introductory signal to tell readers how her citation to legal authority… …   Wikipedia

  • Civil Rights Act of 1991 — Full title Civil Rights Act of 1991 Enacted by the 102nd United States Congress Citations Public Law Pub. L. 102 166 …   Wikipedia

  • List of United States Supreme Court cases, volume 490 — This is a list of all the United States Supreme Court cases from volume 490 of the United States Reports :* United States v. Sokolow , ussc|490|1|1989 * Dallas v. Stanglin , ussc|490|19|1989 * Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians v. Holyfield ,… …   Wikipedia

  • Famille Brontë — Anne, Emily et Charlotte Brontë, par leur frère Branwell (vers 1834). Lui même s était représenté, au milieu de ses sœurs, avant de s effacer, pour ne pas surcharger le tableau. La famille Brontë[N 1] …   Wikipédia en Français

  • The Ultimate Fighter: United States vs. United Kingdom — Genre Reality, Sports Created by Craig Piligian, Frank Fertitta III, Lorenzo Fertitta, Dana White Starring Dana White, Michael Bisping …   Wikipedia

  • List of Neighbours characters (2011) — The following is a list of characters that first appeared or will appear in the Australian soap opera Neighbours in 2011, by order of first appearance. All characters are introduced by the shows executive producer Susan Bower. The 27th season of… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”