William O'Brien

:"William O'Brien (Irish Parliamentary Party) should not be confused with his contemporary William X. O'Brien (ITGWU) or with William Smith O'Brien (Young Irelanders). For other people of the same name, see William O'Brien (disambiguation)."

William O'Brien (2 October 1852 – 25 February 1928) was an Irish nationalist, journalist, agrarian agitator, social revolutionary, politician, party leader, newspaper publisher, author and Member of Parliament (MP.) in the House of Commons of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland . He was particularly associated with the campaigns for land reform in Ireland during the late 19th and early 20th centuries as well as his conciliatory approach to attaining Irish Home Rule.

Family, education

William O'Brien was born at Bank Place in Mallow, County Cork, as second son of James O'Brien, a solicitor's clerk, and his wife Kate, the daughter of James Nagle, a local shopkeeper. On his mother's side he was descended from the distinguished Norman family of Nagles, long settled in the vicinity of Mallow giving their name to the nearby Nagle Mountains. He was also linked through his mother with the statesman Edmund Burke's mother's family, as well as with the poet Edmund Spencer's family. The Nagles however, no longer held the status or prosperity they once had. In the same month thirty-eight years earlier Thomas Davis was born in Mallow. O'Brien's advocacy of the cause of Irish Independence was to be in the same true tradition of his esteemed fellow-townsman.

O'Brien shared his primary education with a townsman with whom he was later to have a close political connection, Canon Sheehan of Doneraile. He enjoyed his secondary education at the Cloyne diocesan college, which resulted in his being brought up in an environment noted for its religious tolerance. He greatly valued having had this experience from an early age, which strongly influenced his later views for the need of such tolerance in Irish national life.

Early journalism

Financial misfortune in 1868 caused the O'Brien family to move to Cork City. A year later his father died, and the illness of his elder and younger brother and his sister resulted in him having to support his mother and siblings. Always a prolific writer, it quickly earned him a job as newspaper reporter, first for the "Cork Daily Herald". This was to be the primary career which first attracted attention to him as a public figure. He had began legal studies at Queen's College, later University College Cork, but although he never graduated, he held a lifelong attachment to the institution, to which he bequeathed his private papers.

Political origins

From an early age O'Brien's political ideas, like most of his contemporaries, were shaped by the Fenian movement and the plight of the Irish tenant farmers, his elder brother having participated in the rebellion of 1867. It resulted in O'Brien himself becoming actively involved with the Fenian brotherhood, resigning in the mid-1870s, because of what he described in 'Evening Memories' (p.443-4) as "the gloom of inevitable failure and horrible punishment inseparable from any attempt at separation by force of arms".

As a journalist his attention was attracted in the first place to the suffering of the tenant farmers. Now on the staff of the "Freeman's Journal", after touring the Galtee Mountains around Christmas 1877 he published articles describing their conditions, which later appeared in pamphlet form. With this action he first displayed his belief that only through parliamentary reform and with the new power of the press that public opinion could be influenced to pursue Irish issues constitutionally through open political activity and the ballot box. Not least of all, responding to the hopes of the new Irish Home Rule movement.

United Ireland Editor

In 1878 he met Charles Stewart Parnell at a Home Rule meeting. Parnell recognised his exceptional talents as a journalist and writer, influencing his rise to becoming a leading politician of the new generation. He subsequently appointed him in 1881 as editor of the Irish National Land League's journal, "The United Irishman". His association with Parnell and the Irish Parliamentary Party (IPP) led to his arrest and imprisonment with Parnell, Dillon, William Redmond and other nationalist leaders in Kilmainham Gaol that October.

During his imprisonment until April 1882 he drafted the famous Land War "No Rent Manifesto" -- a rent-withholding scheme personally led by O'Brien, escalating the conflict between the Land League and Gladstone's government. He was persecuted nine times in the course of years.

Agitator and M.P.

From 1883-1885 O'Brien was elected MP for Mallow. Following the abolition of that constituency he represented Tyrone South from 1885 to 1886, North East Cork from 1887-1892, and Cork City from 1892-1895 and from 1901-1918, in the House of Commons. There were three periods of absence: 1886-7, from 1895-1900, and eight months in 1904. Amid the turmoil of Irish politics in the late 19th century he was frequently arrested and imprisoned for his support for various Land League protests.

In 1887 O'Brien helped to organise a rent strike during the Plan of Campaign at the estate of Lady Kingston near Mitchelstown, County Cork. On 9 September, after an 8,000-strong demonstration led by John Dillon, three estate tenants were shot dead, and others wounded, by police at the town's courthouse where O'Brien had been brought for trial on charges of incitement under a new Coercion Act. This event became known as the Mitchelstown Massacre. Later that year, thousands of demonstrators marched in London to demand his release from prison, and clashed with police at Trafalgar Square on Bloody Sunday (November 10).

Even in prison, O'Brien continued his protests, refusing to wear prison uniform in 1887. Being left without cloths, a Blarney tweed suit was smuggled in. He occasionally wore this much publicised suit in the Commons when confronting his incarcerator, Arthur Balfour. His imprisonment also inspired protests – notably the 1887 'Bloody Sunday' riots in London. In 1889 he escaped from a courtroom but was sentenced "in absentia" for conspiracy. He fled to America accompanied by Dillon who was on bail, then to France where both held negotiations with Parnell at Boulogne over the leadership of the party. When these broke down, both returned to Folkestone giving themselves up, subsequently serving four months in Clonmel and Galway gaols. Here O'Brien began to reconsider his political future, using the time to write an acclaimed novel, a Fenian romance with a land reform theme set in 1860: "When We Were Boys", which was published in 1890.

Marriage, reorientation

In 1890 he married Sophie Raffalovich, sister of poet and socialite Marc André Sebastian Raffalovich and daughter of the Russian Jewish banker, Hermann Raffalowich, domiciled in Paris. It was to mark a major turning point in O'Brien's personal and political life. His wife brought considerable wealth into the marriage, enabling him to act with political independence and providing finances to establish his own newspapers. His wife (1860-1960) who survived him by over 30 years, gave him considerable moral and emotional support for his political pursuits. Their relationship added an abiding love for France and attachment to Europe to his life, where he often retired to recuperate.

By 1891 he had become disillusioned with Parnell's political leadership, although emotionally loyal to him he tried to persuade him to retire after the O'Shea divorce case. On Parnell's death that year and the ensuing IPP split, he remained aloof from aligning himself with either side of the Party, either the rump pro-Parnellite Irish National League (INL) led by John Redmond or with the anti-Parnellite Irish National Federation (INF) group under John Dillon, although he saw the weight of strength in the latter. O'Brien worked hard in the 1893 negotiations leading to Parliament passing Gladstone's Second Home Rule Bill , which the Lords however rejected. ( on the First Home Rule Bill had beseeched parliament not to reject it).

United Irish League

Distancing himself from the party turmoils, he retired from parliament in 1895, settling for a while with his wife near Westport, County Mayo, which enabled him to experience at first hand from his Mayo retreat the distressed hardship of the peasantry in the West of Ireland, trying to eke out an existence in its rocky landscape.

Believing strongly that agitational politics combined with constitutional pressures were the best means of achieving objectives, O'Brien established on the 16. January 1898 the United Irish League (UIL) at Westport, with Michael Davitt as co-founder and John Dillon present. It was to be a new grass-roots organisation with a programme to include agrarian agitation, political reform and Home Rule. It coincided with the passing of the revolutionary Local Government (Ireland) Act 1898 which broke the power of the landlord dominated "Grand Juries", passing for the first time absolute democratic control of local affairs into the hands of the people through elected Local County Councils.

The UIL was explicidly designed to reconcile the various parliamentary fragments existing since the Parnell split, which proved very popular, its branches sweeping over most of the country organised by its general secretary John O'Donnell , dictating to the demoralised Irish party leaders the terms for reconstruction, not only of the party but the nationalist movement in Ireland. The movement was backed by O'Brien's new newspaper "The Irish People" (Sept. 1899 -Nov. 1904 and Sept. 1905 -Mar. 1909).

Around 1900 O'Brien, an unbending social reformer and agrarian agitator, was the most influential and powerful figure within the nationalist movement, although not formally its leader. His UIL was by far the largest organisation in the country, comprising 1150 branches and 84,355 members. The result of the rapid growth of his UIL as a national organisation in achieving unity through organised popular opinion, was to effect a quick defensive reunion under John Redmond of the discredited IPP factions of the INL and the INF, largely fearing O’Brien’s return to the political field. This unity disturbed O’Brien as it resulted in most of the ineffective party candidates being re-elected in the 1900 general election, preventing the UIL from using its power in the pre-selection of candidates. Within a few years the IPP was however, to tactically adjunct the UIL under its wing manoeuvering it out of O'Brien's control.

Land Act architect

O'Brien next intensified the UIL agitation for land purchase by tenant farmers, pressurising for compulsory purchase. It resulted in the calling of the December 1902 Land Conference, an initiative by moderate landlords led by Lord Dunraven for a settlement by conciliatory agreement between landlord and tenant. After six sessions all tenant’s demands were conceded, O’Brien having guided the official nationalist movement into endorsement of a new policy of conciliation. He followed this by campaigning vigorously for the greatest piece of social legislation Ireland had yet seen, orchestrating the Wyndham "Land Purchase Act (1903)" through parliament, which effectively ended landlordism, solving the age old Irish Land Question

This masterful strategy of bringing about agreement on land purchase between tenants and landlords under the Act, though supported by Redmond, was condemned by a Dillon led campaign against O’Brien, ferociously attacking him for putting Land Purchase and Conciliation before Home Rule, Michael Davitt on the grounds that the Act did not espouse land nationalisation. Severely in disagreement with all adversaries, O’Brien left the Irish Parliamentary Party in November 1903 for five years, retiring his parliamentary seat. His Cork electorate however, insistently pushed through his re-election eight months later. O’Brien’s intention of shocking the party to its senses, failed.,

He then embarked on advancing full scale implementation of the Act in alliance with D.D. Sheehan M.P.’s Irish Land and Labour Association (ILLA), which by 1904 had become the new organisational base for O’Brien’s political activities. This aggravated the Dillonite section of the IPP further. Determined to destroy both "before they poison the whole country", they published continual denunciations in the party’s newspaper, the "Freeman Journal" , then coupéd the UIL by means of its new sectrtary, Dillon’s chief lieutenant, Joseph Devlin M.P., Grandmaster of the Ancient Order of Hibernians, Devlin eventually gaining organisational control over the entire UIL and IPP organisations.

Housing Acts

Britain had two bills to pay for past wrongs. After financing tenant land purchase, tenant farmers were now proud proprietors largely in control of local government. The next bill to pay was for extensive rural housing of the tens of thousands of migrant farm labourers struggling to survive in stone cabins, barns or mud hovels. A long standing demand by the ILLA branches and D.D. Sheehan.

O'Brien saw its prime importance and negotiated during 1905, which, after the January 1906 general election, was to become the Bryce "Labourers (Ireland) Act (1906)", and during the course of the next five years financed the erection of over 40,000 commodious cottage homes, each on an acre of land. This unique social housing programme unparalleled anywhere in Europe brought about an unprecedented agrarian revolution, changing the face of the Irish countryside,

Renewed publication of O'Brien's newspaper "The Irish People" (1905-1909) exalting the cottage building, its editorials equally countermanding the IPP's Dublin "bosses" attempts to curtail the program, fearing settled rural communities would no longer be dependent on Party and Church. Munster took full advantage, erecting most of the cottages, additional funding following under Birrell's .

In the interest of united, O'Brien rejoined the Parliamenatry Party in 1908. During negotiations that year for additional funding of land purchase under an amending bill, Redmond called a UIL convention for December in Dublin, claiming the bill over-burdened the British Treasury and the rate payers. Over 3000 delegates attended. Devlin had the hall filled in advance with 400 of his "militant Mollies" , so that when O'Brien and his followers tried to speak in favour of the bill, they were battoned into silence. The bill eventually passed as Birrell's "Land Purchase Act (1909)" , falling far short in its financial provisions.

All-for-Ireland League

As an outcome of the "Baton-Convention" O’Brien felt himself again driven from the party. He foresaw that the IPP, undermined by the AOH, was on a fatal radical path which would frustrate any All-Ireland Home Rule settlement. As a counter measure he established a new League, which was to build on the success his combined "doctrine of conciliation" with "conference plus business" achieved during the 1902 Land Conference with landlords and the ensuing 1903 Land Purchase Act, believing all moderate unionists could still be similarly won over to All-Ireland Home Rule. For many nationalists on the other hand, the adoption of a conciliatory approach to the "hereditary enemy" involved too sharp a deviation from traditional thinking.

In March 1909 he inaugurated the All-for-Ireland League (AFIL) in Kanturk with James Gilhooly MP as Chairman and D.D. Sheehan Hon. Secretary. The AFIL’s political objective was the attainment of an All-Ireland parliament with the consent rather than by the compulsion of the Protestant and Unionist community, under the banner of the "Three Cs", for Conference, Conciliation and Consent as applied to Irish politics. The League was supported by many prominent Protestant gentry, leading landlords and Munster business figures. [MacDonagh, Michael: "William O'Brien, the Irish Nationalist" "All for Ireland, and Ireland for All" p.186, Ernst Benn London (1928) ] . The political activist Canon Sheehan of Doneraile was also a founder member.

Ill-health striking O’Brien, he departed for Florence, Italy to recuperate, returning for the January 1910 general election, in which the Cork electorate returned eight "O'Brienite" MPs. Throughout 1910 his AFIL movement was opposed an Irish Party supported by the Catholic clergy. It returned eight independent AFIL MPs in the December 1910 general election to be O'Brien's new political party. From July 1910 until late 1916 O’Brien published the League’s newspaper, the "Cork Free Press". Election results published by it showed Independents throughout Ireland had won 30% of votes cast.

O’Brien saw it opportune for a co-operative understanding with Arthur Griffith's moderate Sinn Féin movement, having in common - attaining objectives through "moral protest" - political resistance and agitation rather than militant physical-force. Neither O’Brien nor Griffith advocated total abstentionism from the Commons, and regarded Dominion Home Rule, modelled on Canada or Australia, as acceptable. Although Griffith favoured co-operation, a special Sinn Feín executive council meeting called to consider co-operation regretted it was not possible because its constitution would not allow it. [O’Brien, Joseph V.: "William O’Brien and the course of Irish Politics, 1881-1918", "The All-for-Ireland League" p.193, University of California Press (1976) ISBN 0-520-02886-4 ] In the following years O’Brien and his party continued to associate themselves with Griffith's movement both in and out of parliament. In June 1918 Griffith asked O’Brien to have the writ moved for his candidacy in the Cavan-east by-election (moved by AFIL MP Eugene Crean) to which Griffith was elected with a sizable majority. Maume, Patrick: "The long Gestation, Irish Nationalist Life 1891-1918" p.207 (note 322), Gill & Macmillan (1999) ISBN 0-7171-2744-3]

In 1911 O'Brien proposed Dominion Home Rule in a letter to Asquith as the only viable solution to the "Irish Question". Home Rule became technically assured after a new Home Rule bill was introduced in 1912 with the IPP holding the balance of power at Westminster. During the 1913-14 parliamentary debates on the Third Home Rule Bill, O'Brien, alarmed by Unionist resistance to the bill, opposed the IPP's coercive "Ulster must follow" policy, and published in January 1914 specific concession which would enable Ulster join a Dublin parliament "any price for an United Ireland, but never partition". The Ulster Volunteers armed to resist likely "Rome Rule" , Redmond's Irish Volunteers armed likewise to ensure enactment of all-Ireland self-government. Rejecting O'Brien's initiatives, the Redmond-Dillon-Devlin hardline alliance remained uncompromising -- "no concessions for Ulster".

In May 1914 O'Brien and his followers abstained from the final vote passing the Home Rule Act 1914 , denouncing it as a "partition deal", after Sir Edward Carson leader of the Ulster Unionist Party forced through an amendment mandating the partition of Ireland , the Nationalist's confrontation course with Ulster ending in fiasco.

Rallying for Europe

O'Brien saw the outbreak of World War I in August as an opportunity to undertake a last crusade to preserve at any price the unity of Ireland, by uniting the Green and Orange in a common cause, declaring himself on the side of the Allied and Britain's European war effort. O'Brien was the first Nationalist leader to call on Irish Volunteers for the front. Towards the end of August he had an interview with Lord Kitchener, Secretary of State for War, and laid before him a scheme for raising an Irish Army Corps embracing all classes and creeds, South and North. Kitchener favoured the idea [MacDonagh, Michael: "The Life of William O'Brien, the Irish Nationalist", p.200, Ernst Benn London (1928)] . O’Brien immediately summoned a meeting held in the Cork Town Hall under the auspices of the All-for-Ireland League on the 2nd September, the hall packed with an enthusiastic audience of men and women. In a speech that far exceeded Redmond’s in favour of its adherence to England cause, he said:- :cquote|"We are taking to-night – I don’t conceal it from myself – one of the most momentous decisions in our history. If we make up our minds, for heaven’s sake let there be no half-heartedness, let there be no qualifications or reservations. We have got to be honest friends or honest enemies of England. It won’t do merely to say that we are willing to fight for Belgium, or to fight for Ireland, or to fight for France, much though we love those gallant nations (cheers). We have got to go further and to say, without putting a tooth in it, that we are ready to fight for England as well, in England’s way (cheers). And in fighting England’s battle in the particular circumstance of this war, I am convinced to the heart’s core that we are fighting the most effective battle in all the ages for Ireland’s liberty (cheers) as well as to save our towns and our homes and our women and children from the grip of the most appalling horde of brutes in human shape that ever cursed this earth since Atilla met his doom at the hands of eternal justice (cheers)." [ibid pp. 200-201.]

O'Brien later wrote: "Whether Home Rule is to have a future will depend upon the extent to which the Nationalists in combination with Ulster Covenanters, do their part in the firing line on the fields of France" [O'Brien, Joseph V.: "William O'Brien and the course of Irish Politics" p.215, Uni. California Press (1976)] . He stood on recruiting platforms with the other National leaders and spoke out encouragingly in favour of voluntary enlistment in the Royal Munster Fusiliers and other Irish regiments.

Changing tides

O'Brien, alarmed at the increased activity of Sinn Féin in 1915, predicted the danger of a potential republican eruption, culminating in the IRB 1916 Rebellion , in which however Sinn Féin were not involved. He was forced to cease publication of his "Cork Free Press" in 1916 soon after the appointment of Lord Decies as Chief Press Censor for Ireland. Decies warned the press to be careful about what they published. Such warnings had little effect when dealing with such papers as the "Cork Free Press". It was suppressed after its republican editor, Frank Gallagher, accused the British authorities of lying about the conditions and situation of republican prisoners in the Frongoch internment camp [Martin, Peter; "Censorship in the two Irelands 1922-39", Introduction p.9, Irish Academic Press (2008) ISBN 0-7165-2829-0] .

O'Brien accepted the Rising and the ensuing changed political climate in 1917 as the best way of ridding the country of IPP and AOH stagnation. Home Rule had been lost in 1913, an inflexible IPP long out of touch with reality, reflected by Britain's two failed attempts to introduce Home Rule in 1916 and again in 1917. O'Brien refused to participate in the Irish Convention after southern unionist representatives he had proposed were turned down. The Convention ended as he predicted in failure when Britain attempted to link the enactment of Home Rule with conscription.

During the anti-conscription crisis in April 1918 O'Brien and his AFIL left the House of Commons and joined Sinn Féin and other prominentaries in the mass protests in Dublin. Seeing no future for his conciliatory political concepts in a future election, he believed Sinn Féin in its moderate form had earned the right to represent nationalist interests. He and the other members of his All-for-Ireland League party stood aside putting their seats at the disposal of Sinn Féin, its candidates returned unopposed in the December 1918 general elections. In an address to the election he had said:

"We cannot subscribe to a programme of armed resistance in the field, or even of permanent withdrawal from Westminster; but to the spirit of Sinn Féin, as distinct from its abstract programme, the great mass of independent single-minded Irishmen have been won over, and accordingly they ought now to have a full and sympathetic trial for enforcing the Irish nation's right of self-determination." [MacDonagh, Michael: "The Life of William O'Brien, the Irish Nationalist", "The Irish Free State" p.234, Ernst Benn London (1928)]

O'Brien disagreed with the establishment of a southern Irish Free State under the Treaty, still believing that Partition of Ireland was too high a price to pay for partial independence. Retiring from political life, he contented himself with writing and declined De Valera's offer to stand for Fianna Fáil in the 1927 general election. He died suddenly on 25. February 1928 while on a visit to London with his wife at the age of 75. His remains rest in Mallow, and one of the principal streets in the town bears his name to this day. His head-bust overlooks the town Council's Chamber Room and one of his finest portraits hangs in University College Cork.

In 1920 Arthur Griffith said of O'Brien:

" “The task of William O’Brien’s generation was well and bravely done, had it not been so the work we are carrying out in this generation would have been impossible. In that great work none of Parnell’s lieutenants did so much as William O’Brien.” " [MacDonagh, Michael: "The Life of William O'Brien, the Irish Nationalist", "The Irish Free State" p.237, Ernst Benn London (1928)]

Notes

Publications

O'Brien's books, a number of which are collections of his journalistic writings and political speeches, include:

*"Christmas on the Galtees" (1878) [http://www.ballybegvillage.com/irish_christmas.html/"Ballybeg Village Irish Christmas"]
*"When we were boys" (1890)
*"Irish Ideas" (1893) [http://www.libraryireland.com/Irish-Ideas/Contents.php/"Irish Ideas" (1893)]
*"A Queen of Men, Grace O'Malley" (1898)
*"Recolections" (1905)
*"An Olive Branch in Ireland" (1910)
*"The Downfall of Parliamentarianism" (1918)
*"Evening Memories" (1920)
*"The Responsibility for Partition" (1921)
*"The Irish Revolution" (1921)
*"Edmund Burke as an Irishman" (1924)

References

* O'Brien, William: "An Olive Branch in Ireland", Macmillian London (1910)
* O'Brien, William: "The Downfall of Parliamentarianism", Maunsel & Roberts Dublin & London (1918)
* O’Brien, William: "The Responsibility for Partition", Maunsel & Roberts Dublin & London (1921)
* Sheehan, D. D.: "Ireland since Parnell", Daniel O’Connor London (1921)
* MacDonagh, Michael: "The Life of William O'Brien, the Irish Nationalist", Ernst Benn London (1928)
* Schilling, Friedrich K.: "William O'Brien and the All-for-Ireland League", thesis (1956), Trinity College, Dublin
* Miller, David W.: "Church, State and Nation in Ireland 1898-1921", Gill & Macmillan (1973) ISBN 0 7171 0645 4
* O'Brien, Joseph: "William O'Brien and the course of Irish politics", University of California Press (1976) ISBN 0-520-02886-4
* Clifford, Brendan: "Cork Free Press" "An Account of Ireland's only Democratic Anti-Partition Movement", Athol Books, Belfast (1984)
* Warwick-Halle, Sally: "William O'Brien and the Irish land war", Irish Academic Press, Dublin (1990) ISBN 07-1652-458-9
* Callanan, Frank: "T. M Healy", Cork University Press (1996) ISBN 1-85918-172-4
* Maume, Patrick: "The long Gestation, Irish Nationalist Life 1891-1918", Gill & Macmillan (1999) ISBN 0-7171-2744-3