Oxford v Moss

Oxford v Moss
Oxford v Moss
Divisional Court, Queens Bench Division
Date decided 1979
Full case name Oxford versus Moss
Citations (1979) 68 Cr App Rep 183
[1979] Crim LR 119
Judges sitting Smith & Wein, JJ.
Cases cited Peter Pan Manufacturing Corporation v. Corsets Silhouette ltd. [1963] 3 All E.R. 402
Seager v. Copydex Ltd. [1967] 2 All E.R. 415
Argyll v. Argyll [1965] 2 W.L.R. 790
Fraser v. Evans [1968] 3 W.L.R. 1172
Legislation cited Theft Act 1968, Section 4
Case history
Prior actions Police v Oxford, Liverpool Magistrates Court
Subsequent actions None
Keywords
Theft; information; intangible property
v · d · e

Oxford v Moss (1979) 68 Cr App Rep 183 is an English criminal law case, dealing with theft, intangible property and information. The court ruled that information could not be deemed to be intangible property and therefore was incapable of being stolen within the Theft Act 1968.

Facts

The defendant, Moss, was a University student and managed to obtain a proof copy of his forthcoming exam paper. It was accepted that he always intended to return the proof itself, and therefore could not be convicted of theft of the proof itself, however he was charged with stealing information belonging to the Senate of the University.

The case was heard by the Liverpool Stipendiary Magistrate, and it was argued by the prosecution that the information itself was property capable of being stolen because it had attached to it a proprietary right of confidence, and once this was breached, the information itself had been stolen. It was argued by the defence that Section 4 of the Theft Act 1968 did not define a class of intangible property beyond a chose in action, and therefore information per se was not protected by the Theft Act 1968.

The magistrate ruled that confidential information was not a form of property as defined by Section 4, and that confidence consisted in the right to control the publication of the proof and was a right over property rather than property in itself.

Judgment

The Divisional Court considered whether confidential information falls within the definition contained in s4(1) of the Theft Act, and were referred to a number of authorities dealing with trade secrets and matrimonial secrets. It was said that although those cases dealt with confidentiality, the appropriate remedies for breach had been injunction or damages rather than criminal penalties. The conclusion was drawn that the definition of "intangible property" was not broad enough to include confidential information, and the prosecutor's appeal was dismissed.

External links


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем решить контрольную работу

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Oxford v. Moss — (1979) 68 Cr. App. Rep. 183 is an English criminal law case, dealing with theft, intangible property and information. The court ruled that information could not be deemed to be intangible property.First instance hearingThe defendant, Moss, was a… …   Wikipedia

  • MOSS (R.) — Rosalind L. B. MOSS 1890 1990 Fille du révérend H. W. Moss, directeur de l’école de Shrewsburg (sur le Severn, Angleterre), miss Rosalind Moss, née en septembre 1890, a achevé à Oxford, presque centenaire, une exceptionnelle carrière de… …   Encyclopédie Universelle

  • Moss Point, Mississippi —   City   L …   Wikipedia

  • Moss Force — seen from the slopes of Knott Rigg, one km to the north …   Wikipedia

  • Moss Rose — Stadium The Moss Der Silk FM Main Stand Daten Ort England …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Oxford, Mississippi —   City   University of Mississippi, a.k.a. Ole Miss …   Wikipedia

  • Oxford UCCE and Oxford University in 2005 — Oxford UCCE started their 2005 first class season with a weak draw against a Gloucestershire side that opted to use the game as batting practice. Their second first class game, against Derbyshire, Oxford UCCE did well in the first innings,… …   Wikipedia

  • Moss Side — For other uses, see Moss Side (disambiguation). Coordinates: 53°27′22″N 2°14′24″W / 53.456°N 2.240°W / 53.456; 2.240 …   Wikipedia

  • Moss Empires — The Empire Theatre, Leicester Square Moss Empires was a British company formed in Edinburgh from the merger of the theatre companies owned by Sir Edward Moss and Sir Oswald Stoll in 1898. This created the largest British chain of music halls. The …   Wikipedia

  • Moss, Thomas — (1740 1808)    Not much is known of this poet but that he graduated B.A. in 1761 from Emmanuel College, Cambridge, and after taking holy orders he was a minister in several parishes in Staffordshire and Worcestershire. In 1769 he published Poems… …   British and Irish poets

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”