Motions of no confidence in the United Kingdom

Motions of no confidence, also called votes of confidence,^[1] votes of no-confidence^[2] or censure motions,^[1] are a feature of the Westminster system of government used in the United Kingdom that requires an executive to retain the confidence of the House of Commons. It is a fundamental principle of the British constitution that the Government must retain the confidence of the legislature as it is not possible for a Government to operate effectively without the support of the majority of the legislature.^[3]

In last resort the principle is based upon the government's dependence upon the House of Commons for "political capital".^[4] It is possible for a vote of no confidence to succeed where there is a minority government, a small majority or where there are internal party splits. Where there is a minority government, the government may seek agreements or pacts with minor parties in order to remain in office. Despite their importance to the British constitution, the rules surrounding motions of no confidence are dictated by convention. A defeat in a vote of no confidence will oblige a government to resign or seek a dissolution of Parliament.^[5] A no confidence vote was last successfully used on 28 March 1979, when the minority government of James Callaghan was defeated in a confidence motion which read "That this House has no confidence in Her Majesty's Government".^[6] A no confidence vote can have the effect of uniting the ruling party; for this reason such motions are rarely used and successful motions are even rarer.^[7] Before 1979 the last successful motion of no confidence occurred in 1924.^[8]

Forms

Since 1945 there have been 23 votes of no confidence and 3 of confidence.^[9]

Government

Motions of no confidence fall into three categories. Motions initiated by the Government, those initiated by the Opposition, and motions which can be regarded as issues of confidence because of particular circumstances.^[6] The first category are effectively threats of dissolution as occurred in 1993 so that John Major could pass the Social Chapter of the Maastricht Treaty.

Opposition

Opposition motions are initiated by the Opposition party and often occur with little chance of a confidence motion succeeding. By convention a no confidence vote will take precedence over normal Parliamentary business for that day and will begin with Speeches from the Prime Minister and the leader of the Opposition rather than the Ministers for the policy area which may be the concern of the motion. Not every no confidence motion will profess no confidence in the Government, some no confidence motions only state no confidence in the particular policies of a government. Probably the most famous no confidence motion was on the night of March 28th 1979 when Jim Callagahan's Labour Government fell from office by one vote, 311-310.^[10]. It was considered the most dramatic night in Westminister's history.

Although there is no commonly accepted and comprehensive definition of a confidence motion it is possible to identify confidence motions from their timing, the speakers and the terms of the motion.^[6] Motions of confidence are supportive of the Government whereas motions of no confidence are unsupportive of the Government. It can be difficult to distinguish an opposition no confidence motion and other opposition motions critical of Government policy. The term censure motion can also refer a category of motion which does not attempt to remove the Government.

A Government can also be forced into resigning or calling an election by a lost vote on the Queen's Speech (The government's legislative programme), losing a Finance Bill or a vote on a major issue on which it fought a General Election campaign.^[3]

Successful no confidence votes

18th century

• 1782 vote of no confidence against the government of Lord North

19th century

• 1841 vote of no confidence against the government of Viscount Melbourne
• 1855 vote of no confidence against the government of the Earl of Aberdeen
• 1866 vote of no confidence against the government of the Earl Russell
• 1885 vote of no confidence against the government of William Gladstone
• 1886 vote of no confidence against the government of William Gladstone
• 1892 vote of no confidence against the government of the Marquess of Salisbury
• 1895 vote of no confidence against the government of the Earl of Rosebery

20th century

• 1924 vote of no confidence against the government of Stanley Baldwin
• 1924 vote of no confidence against the government of Ramsay MacDonald
• 1979 vote of no confidence against the government of James Callaghan

Constitutional practice

If a government win a confidence motion they are able to remain in office. If a confidence motion is lost then the Government is obliged to resign or seek a dissolution of Parliament (and call a General Election). Modern practice shows dissolution rather than resignation to be the result of a defeat. The government is only obliged to resign if it loses a confidence vote although a significant defeat on a major issue may lead to a confidence motion.

During the period 1945-1970 Governments were rarely defeated in the House of Commons and the impression grew that if a Government was defeated it must reverse the decision, seek a vote of confidence or resign.^[11]

Brazier argues: "it used to be the case that a defeat on a major matter had the same effect as if an explicit vote of confidence had carried" but that a development in constitutional practice has occurred since the 1970s. Thatcher's defeat over the Shops Act did not trigger a confidence motion despite being described as ‘a central piece of their legislative programme’. The government simply accepted that they could not pass the bill and gave assurances to Parliament that they would not introduce it.^[5]

After a defeat on a major issue of government policy the Government may resign, dissolve Parliament or seek a vote of confidence from the House. Recent historical practice has been to seek a vote of confidence from the House. John Major did this after defeat over the "Social Protocol" of the Maastricht Treaty.^[5] Defeats on minor issues do not raise any constitutional questions.^[5]

Recent practice

Michael Martin

A proposed motion of no confidence can force a resignation. For example in 2009 the proposed vote of no confidence in the Speaker of the House of Commons forced the resignation of Michael Martin. Several MPs breached a constitutional convention and openly called for the resignation of the Speaker. Those Members of Parliament were:

Liberal Democrat Nick Clegg[12] Norman Baker[13] Danny Alexander[14] John Hemming[15] Chris Huhne[16] Norman Lamb[17] Jo Swinson[18] Stephen Williams[19] Lynne Featherstone[19] Greg Mulholland[20] Adrian Sanders[20]

Conservative Richard Bacon[21] David Davis [22] Douglas Carswell [23] Ben Wallace [24] Richard Shepherd[17] Philip Hollobone[19] Philip Davies[19] Anne Main[20] Malcolm Moss[20] Graham Stuart[20] Charles Walker[20] David Davies[20]

Labour Paul Flynn[23] Gordon Prentice[23] Kate Hoey [25] Charles Clarke[19] Dr Ian Gibson[20]

See also

• Motion of no confidence

References

1. ^ ^{a b} "Censure motions". BBC News. 2008-08-13. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/81939.stm. Retrieved 2010-05-13. 
2. ^ http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/Governmentcitizensandrights/UKgovernment/Centralgovernmentandthemonarchy/DG_073438
3. ^ ^{a b} http://www.parliament.uk/documents/upload/M07.pdf
4. ^ Turpin, C (2002) British Government and the Constitution 5th Ed p487
5. ^ ^{a b c d} http://www.revolts.co.uk/And%20what%20if%20they%20lose.pdf
6. ^ ^{a b c} http://www.parliament.uk/commons/lib/research/briefings/snpc-02873.pdf
7. ^ http://www.parliament.uk/parliament/guide/account.htm
8. ^ http://library.thinkquest.org/C0126211/pag/gov/hc.html
9. ^ "Parliamentary progress: HE Bill". BBC News. 2004-01-27. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/bbc_parliament/3434507.stm. Retrieved 2010-05-13. 
10. ^ "1977: Government wins no confidence vote". BBC News. 1977-03-23. http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/low/dates/stories/march/23/newsid_2531000/2531277.stm. Retrieved 2010-05-13. 
11. ^ http://www.election.demon.co.uk/defeats.html
12. ^ "Politics | Clegg calls on Speaker to resign". BBC News. 2009-05-17. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/8054140.stm. Retrieved 2009-05-18. 
13. ^ "Daily Express | UK News :: Pressure grows on Martin to go". Express.co.uk. http://www.express.co.uk/posts/view/101359/Pressure-grows-on-Martin-to-go. Retrieved 2009-05-18. 
14. ^ "Scotland | Scots MPs split over Martin calls". BBC News. 2009-05-17. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/8054410.stm. Retrieved 2009-05-18. 
15. ^ "News - West Midlands News - MP backing calls for Speaker to quit". Birmingham Post. 2009-05-14. http://www.birminghampost.net/news/west-midlands-news/2009/05/14/mp-backing-calls-for-speaker-to-quit-65233-23619092/. Retrieved 2009-05-18. 
16. ^ http://uk.truveo.com/huhne-calls-for-speaker-to-resign/id/3469033141
17. ^ ^{a b} "Now Liberal Democrats join calls for Commons Speaker to resign | Mail Online". Dailymail.co.uk. 2009-05-14. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1181888/Now-Liberal-Democrats-join-calls-Commons-Speaker-resign.html. Retrieved 2009-05-18. 
18. ^ Helm, Toby (2009-05-17). "Downing Street distances itself from Speaker as no confidence vote looms | Politics | The Observer". London: Guardian. http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2009/may/17/michael-martin-mps-expenses. Retrieved 2009-05-18. 
19. ^ ^{a b c d e} Porter, Andrew (2009-05-18). "Gordon Brown leaves Speaker Michael Martin's future in doubt: MPs' expenses". London: The Telegraph. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/mps-expenses/5342942/Gordon-Brown-leaves-Speaker-Michael-Martins-future-in-doubt-MPs-expenses.html. Retrieved 2009-05-19. 
20. ^ ^{a b c d e f g h} Table Office, House of Commons. "Future Business Part C". Publications.parliament.uk. http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm/cmfbusi/90519c01.htm. Retrieved 2009-05-19. ^{[dead link]}
21. ^ "Norfolk MP joins calls on Speaker to quit". EDP24. http://www.edp24.co.uk/content/edp24/news/story.aspx?brand=EDPOnline&category=News&tBrand=EDPOnline&tCategory=xDefault&itemid=NOED15%20May%202009%2021%3A45%3A17%3A383. Retrieved 2009-05-18. 
22. ^ David Davis. "DAVID DAVIS: Only the Speaker can restore faith in Parliament. That is why Mr Martin must go | Mail Online". Mailonsunday.co.uk. http://www.mailonsunday.co.uk/debate/article-1183508/DAVID-DAVIS-Only-Speaker-restore-faith-Parliament-That-Mr-Martin-go.html. Retrieved 2009-05-18. 
23. ^ ^{a b c} Sparrow, Andrew (2009-05-13). "Labour MPs join Tory to call for Speaker to resign". London: "The Guardian". http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2009/may/13/labour-mps-call-michael-martin-resign. Retrieved 2009-05-18. 
24. ^ 8:14pm (2009-05-11). "The campaign to ditch Speaker Martin gathers pace | Coffee House". Spectator.co.uk. http://www.spectator.co.uk/coffeehouse/3608466/the-campaign-to-ditch-speaker-martin-gathers-pace.thtml. Retrieved 2009-05-18. 
25. ^ "Lib Dem Leader Nick Clegg Says Speaker Michael Martin Must Resign | Politics | Sky News". News.sky.com. 2008-06-23. http://news.sky.com/skynews/Home/Politics/Lib-Dem-Leader-Nick-Clegg-Says-Speaker-Michael-Martin-Must-Resign/Article/200905315283269?lpos=Politics_First_UK_News_Article_Teaser_Region_2&lid=ARTICLE_15283269_Lib_Dem_Leader_Nick_Clegg_Says_Speaker_Michael_Martin_Must_Resign. Retrieved 2009-05-18.