Labour party proxy and undeclared donations (2007)

The Labour party proxy and undeclared donations was a political scandal involving the British Labour Party in November and December 2007, when it was discovered that, contrary to legislation passed during the Blair Government, the Party had been receiving significant financial donations made anonymously via third parties. The careers of Labour Party treasurer Peter Watt and the leader of the Scottish Labour Party, Wendy Alexander, were curtailed as a consequence. In May 2009 the Crown Prosecution Service decided there was insufficient evidence for any prosecution relating to these events.^[1][2][3]

Background

Abrahams donations

On 25 November 2007, The Mail on Sunday carried a front page headline: "How big Labour backer is a jobbing builder who knows NOTHING about his £200,000 donation". It was revealed that Tyneside lawyer David Abrahams had donated at least £548,850 to the Labour Party since 2003 via two work colleagues, his solicitor and the wife of an employee, which broke electoral law forbidding the use of proxy donors. Abrahams had had a colourful political involvement with the Labour party over many years.

After being honoured with a front row seat in Sedgefield at Tony Blair's announcement that he was leaving office, in November 2007 it emerged that, in the time since Prime Minister Gordon Brown had come to power, Abrahams was now Labour's third largest donor behind Lord Sainsbury of Turville (£2 million) and Iranian businessman Mahmoud Khayami (£320,000 in September 2007).^[4] (Mr Khayami's donations subsequently came under some scrutiny in the press, though there was no indication that they were in any way illegal.)^[5] Abrahams has donated at least £548,850 since 2003, via two work colleagues, his solicitor and the wife of an employee.^[6]

Abrahams's secretary Janet Kidd "gave" £80,000, while builder Ray Ruddick – who has "given" a total of £196,000 according to a political donors list – had contributed £104,000 of the £222,000 donated by Abrahams in the five months since Mr Brown became PM.^[7] Mrs Kidd has "donated" £185,000 since 2003,^[8] and is also listed as a £5,000 donor to Harriet Harman's successful Labour deputy leadership bid in 2007;^[4]

The Mail on Sunday, which broke the story, investigated the donations after it emerged that builder Ray Ruddick lived in a former council house he had bought for £12,000, and drove a second-hand blue Ford Transit;^[8] while Mrs Kidd was a secretary living in Whickham near Gateshead.^[9] It also emerged that £167,000 had been given previously through another intermediary, solicitor John McCarthy.^[10]

Another go-between used by Abrahams, Janet Dunn, who is a life-long Conservative Party supporter and a lollipop lady by profession, has subsequently claimed that she never knowingly paid any money to the Labour Party; she had only on one occasion signed a blank cheque for Mr Abrahams for £25,000 after he had paid a similar amount into her own bank account. "I thought it was just a bit of business", her husband has said. However a donation of £25,000 in her name was received by the Labour Party in 2003, although Mrs Dunn says the first she knew of this was on 26 November 2007.^[11][12]

After the news broke of Mrs Kidd's "donation" to her campaign, Harriet Harman made a statement saying she accepted a donation to her campaign for the Labour Party deputy leadership (which she eventually won) on 4 July "in good faith," had registered the monies with the Electoral Commission and the Register of Members Interests, and she "was not aware of any funding arrangements ... between David Abrahams and Janet Kidd".^[13] Baroness Jay of Paddington, who was working on the deputy leadership team of Hilary Benn, questioned and turned down a donation of £5,000 offered by Mrs Kidd; but it was subsequently accepted by Benn's team when made under the name of Mr Abrahams.^[13] Kidd offered a similar "donation" to the leadership campaign of Gordon Brown, but was turned down as she was not a known donor.^[14]

On 3 December 2007 Peter Hain, on BBC Radio, admitted that some donations to his own Labour deputy leadership campaign "were not registered as they should have been".^[15]

At the time of Abrahams's attempted offer of £5,000 towards Hilary Benn's campaign for the office of Deputy Prime Minister, and his successful donation of £5,000 to Harriet Harman who was campaigning for the same position, Abrahams was in the midst of protracted negotiations concerning a development he was proposing close to the A1. After initial proposals had been rejected by the Highways Agency, Abrahams made his donations, and resubmitted plans which were duly accepted the second time round. The Highways Agency was overseen by the Department for Transport which at that time was headed by the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister.

Jon Mendelsohn, Brown's chief fund-raiser, admitted that he had known since September about the arrangement, but claimed that he disapproved. Abrahams contends that Mendelsohn had known since April, and had encouraged the process. Mendelsohn denies this.^[16]

Resignation of Peter Watt

The General Secretary of the Labour Party, Peter Watt, resigned on 26 November, after saying he took full responsibility. In his monthly press conference on 27 November, Prime Minister Gordon Brown said donations to the Labour Party by Abrahams through intermediaries were "completely unacceptable" and would be repaid.^[14] The Electoral Commission is seeking to investigate under the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000 why they were given wrong names and what checks Labour made into its “donors”,^[7] and has since called in the Crown Prosecution Service for briefings and advice.

In December 2007, the Metropolitan Police wrote to the Labour Party saying that "the donated money was no longer an issue for the police". Mr Abrahams and his middlemen were also cleared of any wrongdoing. It was also discovered that the £630,000 donated had not been returned to Mr Abrahams, although Harriet Harman had returned the £5,000 donated to her.^[17]

Resignation of Wendy Alexander

On 28 June 2008, Wendy Alexander announced her resignation as Leader of the Scottish Labour Party, due to pressure on her following the donation scandal. She said it was with "deep regret" that she was resigning following the decision of the Scottish Parliament's standards committee. She had come under pressure after breaking donation rules and faces a one-day ban from parliament. In her resignation statement, she claimed the breach of the rules was made in "good faith" and the decision of the committee was "partisan" but she respected parliamentary process.^[18]

Political repercussions

Donorgate meant that Gordon Brown's administration was involved in an early scandal, and only a few months after the Cash for Peerages imbroglio which had beset Blair. There was heavy criticism from opposition parties, which includes calls for Harman's resignation. Conservative leader David Cameron questioned Brown's integrity during Prime Minister's Question Time and Liberal Democrat leadership contender Chris Huhne asked police to get involved, in particular as regards the planning permissions granted to Mr Abrahams. Two significant Labour Party heads, those of Wendy Alexander and Peter Watt, rolled as a consequence of the affair.

References

1. ^ CPS decides no charges over Labour Party donations. Crown Prosecution Service. 7 May 2009. http://www.cps.gov.uk/news/press_releases/126_09/. Retrieved 2009-05-10. 
2. ^ Alex Barker and Jim Pickard (7 May 2009). "Prosecutors drop Labour donations probe". Financial Times. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/3a392bd2-3b00-11de-ba91-00144feabdc0.html. Retrieved 2009-05-10. 
3. ^ Isabel Oakeshott (10 May 2009). "‘Brutal’ Brown sacrificed party chief". London: Sunday Times. http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/politics/article6256748.ece. Retrieved 2009-05-10. 
4. ^ ^{a b} How big Labour backer is a jobbing builder who knows NOTHING about his £200,000 donation Mail on Sunday - 25 November 2007
5. ^ Independent on Sunday, 2 December 2007
6. ^ Four top ministers embroiled in Labour sleaze crisis as prosecutions loom Daily Mail - 27 November, 2007
7. ^ ^{a b} £400k Labour donor probe The Sun - 26 November, 2007
8. ^ ^{a b} Property developer was Labour donor Metro.co.uk - November 25, 2007
9. ^ Property developer was Labour Donor The Sunday Express - 25 November, 2007
10. ^ Revealed: How Labour tycoon got green light for business park AFTER £200,000 donation Daily Mail - 27 November, 2007
11. ^ Daily Telegraph 28 November 2007, p. 1
12. ^ Gordon Brown says Labour donations 'illegal' The Daily Telegraph 28 November 2007
13. ^ ^{a b} Harman took cash 'in good faith' BBC News - 27 November, 2007
14. ^ ^{a b} Labour donations to be returned BBC News - 27 November, 2007
15. ^ "Hain admits more donations errors". BBC News. 3 December 2007. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7125770.stm. Retrieved 7 May 2010. 
16. ^ "Abrahams makes proxy donor claim". BBC News. 1 December 2007. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7123236.stm. Retrieved 7 May 2010. 
17. ^ Rice, Dennis (2008-05-11). "£600,000 'donorgate' cash still in Labour account .. six months after vow to repay it". Mail on Sunday. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article_id=565432&in_page_id=1770. Retrieved 2008-05-11. 
18. ^ Alexander quits as Labour leader, BBC News Online, 28 June 2008