Chandler v. Miller

Chandler v. Miller
Chandler v. Miller
Seal of the United States Supreme Court.svg
Supreme Court of the United States
Argued January 14, 1997
Decided April 15, 1997
Full case name Walker L. Chandler v. Zell D. Miller, Governor of Georgia
Citations 520 U.S. 305 (more)
117 S. Ct. 1295; 137 L. Ed. 2d 513; 65 U.S.L.W. 4243; 145 A.L.R. Fed. 657; 12 I.E.R. Cas. (BNA) 1233; 97 Cal. Daily Op. Service 2723; 97 Daily Journal DAR 4831; 10 Fla. L. Weekly Fed. S 393
Prior history 73 F.3d 1543 (reversed)
Holding
The statute requiring drug testing for all candidates for state offices violated the Fourth Amendment.
Court membership
Case opinions
Majority Ginsburg, joined by Stevens, O'Connor, Scalia, Kennedy, Souter, Thomas, and Breyer
Dissent Rehnquist
Laws applied
U.S. Const. amend. IV

Chandler v. Miller, 520 U.S. 305 (1997) was a case before the United States Supreme Court concerning the Constitutionality under the Fourth Amendment of a state statute requiring drug tests of all candidates for certain state offices.

Contents

Background

Statute

In 1990, Georgia enacted a statute[1] which required candidates for designated state office to certify that they had taken a drug test and obtained negative results. The candidate could provide test specimen at a laboratory approved by the state or at the office of the candidate's personal physician. Once a urine sample was obtained, a state-approved laboratory determined whether any of the specified illegal drugs were present and prepared a certificate reporting the test results to the candidate.

Facts

In 1994, three candidates for such state offices statute filed an action in District Court against the governor of Georgia and two other state officials involved in the administration of the statute, requesting declaratory and injunctive relief barring enforcement of the statute. They alleged that the drug tests required by the statute violated their rights under provisions including the Federal Constitution's Fourth Amendment.

District court

The District Court denied the candidates' motion for a preliminary injunction. After the candidates submitted to the drug tests, obtained the required certificates, and appeared on the ballot in the 1994 election, the District Court entered final judgment for the state officials.

Eleventh Circuit

On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, in affirming, expressed the view that with respect to the Fourth Amendment, the state's interests outweighed the privacy intrusion caused by the statute's required certification (73 F.3d 1543).

Opinion of the Court

On certiorari, Ginsburg, joined by Stevens, O'Connor, Scalia, Kennedy, Souter, Thomas, and Breyer reversed.

Reasoning

The Court noted that while the Fourth Amendment generally prohibits officials from conducting search and seizures without individualized suspicion, there does exist a "closely guarded" category of permissible suspicionless searches and seizures.

However, the Court held that the statute's drug-testing requirement did not fit within this category.

  • The Court emphasized that the proffered special need for drug testing must be substantial--important enough to override the individual's acknowledged privacy interest, sufficiently vital to suppress the Fourth Amendment's normal requirement of individualized suspicion.
  • The Court found that Georgia failed to show, in justification of Ga. Code Ann. § 21-2-140, a special need of that kind. Notably lacking in respondent officials' presentation was any indication of a concrete danger that demanded departure from the Fourth Amendment's main rule. The statute was not needed and could not work to ferret out lawbreakers, and officials barely attempted to support the statute on that ground. However well meant, the candidate drug test Georgia devised diminished personal privacy for a symbol's sake; state action that is prohibited by the Fourth Amendment. In addition to Georgia's failure to provide evidence of a drug problem among its state officials, the Court concluded that even if such a problem did exist, the affected officials would likely not perform the kind of high-risk, safety-sensitive tasks which might justify the statute's proposed incursion on their individual privacy rights. Where, as in this case, public safety was not genuinely jeopardized, the Fourth Amendment precluded a suspicionless search, no matter how conveniently arranged.

Dissent

Chief Justice Rehnquist expressed the view that the statute's urinalysis test was a reasonable search under the Fourth Amendment.

See also

References

  1. ^ Ga. Code Ann. § 21-2-140

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем сделать НИР

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Miller and Sons (London, Piccadilly) — This article is about the manufacturer or oil lamps based in Piccidally, London. For The manufacturer of oil lamps based in Meriden, Connecticut, USA, see E. Miller Co. For The manufacturer of bicycle and motorbike lighting based in Birmingham,… …   Wikipedia

  • Miller Beach —   Neighborhood   The Lake Street Beach in eastern …   Wikipedia

  • Chandler State Wayside — Chandler State Wayside …   Wikipedia

  • Chandler family — The Chandler family is a fictional family from the ABC soap opera All My Children. The Chandler family is one of the most powerful and wealthiest families in daytime television history. Rising up from poverty in Pigeon Hollow, the Chandlers now… …   Wikipedia

  • Miller State Park — For other uses, see Miller Park (disambiguation). Coordinates: 42°51′17″N 71°53′05″W / 42.85472°N 71.88472°W / 42.85472; 71.88472 …   Wikipedia

  • Miller Woods — Map of the public trails at Miller Woods Miller Woods is an area in the far western part of the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore, in Gary, Indiana, in and near the neighborhood of Miller Beach, and south and west of the Gary Works steel mill. The …   Wikipedia

  • Damon Miller — Finn Wittrock as Damon Martin (2009) All My Children Portrayed by Finn Wittrock Duration 2009 2011, 2011 F …   Wikipedia

  • Chris Chandler — No. 12, 17      Quarterback Personal information Date of birth: October 12, 1965 (1965 10 12) (age 46) Place of birth: Everett, Washin …   Wikipedia

  • Don Chandler — No. 34      Placekicker, punter Personal information Date of birth: September 5, 1934(1934 09 05) Place of birth: Council Bluffs, Iow …   Wikipedia

  • Colby Chandler (All My Children) — Colby Chandler Natalie Hall as Colby Chandler (2009–2011) All My Children Portrayed by Carson Grace Levine (1999) Briann …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”