Chambers v. Florida

Chambers v. Florida
Chambers v. Florida
Seal of the United States Supreme Court.svg
Supreme Court of the United States
Argued January 4, 1940
Decided February 12, 1940
Full case name Chambers et al. v. State of Florida
Holding
Confessions compelled by police through duress are inadmissible at trial.
Court membership
Case opinions
Majority Black, joined by unanimous court
Murphy took no part in the consideration or decision of the case.

Chambers v. Florida, 309 U.S. 227 (1940),[1] was an important United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the extent that police pressure resulting in a criminal defendant's confession violates the Due Process clause.

Contents

Case

The case was argued on January 6, 1940 in front of the court by Thurgood Marshall, representing four black men convicted for the murder of a white man in Florida.

The defendant Chambers, along with three other co-defendants, were four of up to forty transient black men arrested for the murder of Robert Darcy, an elderly local man, in Pompano Beach, Florida. The murder was greeted with outrage in the community and the Broward County Sheriff's department was apparently under pressure to close the case. Chambers and the other defendants were taken to Miami for questioning, ostensibly to protect them from the mob that had formed, and then to Fort Lauderdale.

It was not contested that the defendants were held without being able to see a lawyer or be arraigned for a period of a week, or that they were subject to questioning on a random basis, often alone in a room with up to ten police officers and other members of the community. In the legal climate before Miranda, they were not informed of their right to remain silent. After a week of questioning, and despite previous denials, the four co-defendants eventually confessed to the crime and were convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death. Their appeals to the Florida Court of Appeals was rejected on the grounds that the jury had ruled the confessions had been given voluntarily.

Decision

On February 13, 1940, the court delivered its ruling. The unanimous opinion of the court was delivered by Justice Hugo Black of Alabama.

This was Marshall's first of many triumphs in front of the nation's highest tribunal; the Court ruled in favor of the defendants, and overturned their convictions. The court found that on the facts admitted by the police and sheriff's officers, the confessions had clearly been compelled and were therefore inadmissible. It marked one of the first times that the court had accepted the contention that treatment short of physical violence should result in the suppression of evidence.

Several of the features of this case, such as not allowing the defendant to contact anyone, holding them without formal charges or arraignment, and denying them counsel during questioning were common tactics in law enforcement at the time and were eventually rejected by the court in Miranda v. Arizona (1966).

See also

  • List of United States Supreme Court cases

References

  1. ^ Full text of the decision courtesy of Findlaw.com

External links


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем решить контрольную работу

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Chambers Estates, Florida — Infobox Settlement official name = Chambers Estates, Florida settlement type = CDP nickname = motto = imagesize = image caption = image mapsize = map caption = mapsize1 = map caption1 = subdivision type = Country subdivision name = flag|United… …   Wikipedia

  • Chambers Estates, Dania Beach, Florida — Chambers Estates, Florida   CDP   Coordinates …   Wikipedia

  • Florida locations by per capita income — Florida has the eighteenth highest per capita income in the United States of America, at $21,557 (2000). Its personal per capita income is $30,446 (2003).Florida Counties Ranked by Per Capita IncomeThere are sixty seven counties located in… …   Wikipedia

  • Chambers Estates — Dieser Artikel wurde aufgrund von inhaltlichen Mängeln auf der Qualitätssicherungsseite des Projektes USA eingetragen. Hilf mit, die Qualität dieses Artikels auf ein akzeptables Niveau zu bringen, und beteilige dich an der Diskussion! …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Florida Minority Supplier Development Council — (FMSDC) has been in existence since 1984. They work with all aspects of minority business development They are one of Florida Minority Supplier Development Council’s 39 Regional Councils (located across the United States.) Their objective has… …   Wikipedia

  • Chambers Estates — Chambers Estates, FL U.S. Census Designated Place in Florida Population (2000): 3556 Housing Units (2000): 1432 Land area (2000): 0.550812 sq. miles (1.426596 sq. km) Water area (2000): 0.000000 sq. miles (0.000000 sq. km) Total area (2000):… …   StarDict's U.S. Gazetteer Places

  • Chambers Estates, FL — U.S. Census Designated Place in Florida Population (2000): 3556 Housing Units (2000): 1432 Land area (2000): 0.550812 sq. miles (1.426596 sq. km) Water area (2000): 0.000000 sq. miles (0.000000 sq. km) Total area (2000): 0.550812 sq. miles… …   StarDict's U.S. Gazetteer Places

  • Chambers Covered Bridge — Chambers Bridge U.S. National Register of Historic Places …   Wikipedia

  • Florida State Seminoles — University Florida State University Conference(s) Atlantic Coast Conference NCAA …   Wikipedia

  • Florida Democratic Party — Chairman Rod Smith Ideology American Liberalism Blue Dog Democrat Progressivism Center left National affiliation Democratic Party …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”