Nathaniel Isaacs

* Much of this article is based directly or indirectly on Isaac's own accounts, the accuracy of which has been questioned by modern historians.

Nathaniel Isaacs (1808–1872) was an English adventurer who played a part in the history of Natal, South Africa. He wrote a book spread over two volumes (whose accuracy is now disputed) called "Travels and Adventures in Eastern Africa".^[1][2] This book subsequently became one of the principal sources quoted by writers of the History of Natal including Morris (The Washing of the Spears: The Rise and Fall of the Zulu Nation),^[3] Ritter (Shaka Zulu: The Rise of the Zulu Empire)^[4] and Bulpin (Natal and the Zulu Country).^[5]

Early life

Isaac was born in Canterbury, England into a Jewish family. His father was a merchant and resident of Chatham and his mother was Lenie Solomon, daughter of Nathaniel Solomon of Margate and Phoebe Mitz who came from the Netherlands. After his father died in 1822, he joined his maternal uncle, Saul Solomon, a merchant based on the island of St. Helena. In June 1825 he persuaded his uncle to allow him to accompany Lieutenant King, captain of the brig The Mary to South Africa in the capacity of the captain's "companion". After the brig had discharged its cargoes in Cape Town, King sailed for Port Natal to search for the adventurers Francis Farewell, an East India merchant, and Francis Fynn, a physician, from whom nothing had been heard for eighteen months.^[6][7]

Stranded in Natal

Leaving Cape Town on 26 August 1825, The Mary the party made several stops along the Southern African coast, anchoring off Port Natal on 1 October. On entry to the port, The Mary floundered when she struck a sandbank.^[8][9]

On reaching shore, the party found Farewell's camp, but Farewell and his party were on a hunting expedition. Once Farewell returned, Isaacs accompanied King on a courtesy visit to Dingane, brother of the Zulu king Shaka. Once Shaka heard of King's arrival, King and his entire party were summonsed to his kraal.

He records his impressions of the Zulu people and their customs which are particularly interesting as they are an account of the Zulu people before they came under European influence. He lived in daily contact with the powerful King Shaka of the Zulus, at the time the Zulu Empire was at its peak influence in Southern Africa. He was treated on the whole with favour, having rank and honours conferred upon him, as well as a large tract of land. Most of what has been written about Shaka comes from the accounts of Henry Francis Fynn and Isaacs who learned to speak the Zulu language fluently.

Lt Farewell, Fynn and Isaacs established the town of Port Natal, later renamed Durban, which became the second largest city in South Africa in modern times. In 1828 King Shaka made Isaacs "Induna Incoola", or Principal Chief of Natal, and granted him great areas of land.

Subsequent career

Isaacs left Natal in 1831, when Shaka's successor Dingane had prepared to massacre the few whites living there;

In 1844 Isaacs abandoned his claim on the land granted him by Shaka and settled in Sierra Leone where he built up a thriving business. However in 1854 he was accused of slave-trading by the governor, Sir Arthur Kennedy. He got wind of his impending arrest and left for Liverpool where he was to spend the last years of his life. Kennedy was appointed Governor of New South Wales and took the papers relating to the slave-trading charges with him when returning to England before taking up his post in Australia. The papers were lost when the ship in which he was travelling, the Forerunner was wrecked off Maderia in October 1854.^[10] In the absence of the papers, the English courts refused to proceed with the prosecution.^[9]

Isaacs died in 1872.

Historian's Commentary

In recent years many academics have questioned the accuracy of Isaac's writings. Dan Wylie, an academic at Rhodes University has asserted that Isaacs deliberately exaggerated the extent of Shaka's brutality in order to boost the sales of his and of Flynn's books.^[11]

Another historian, Stephen Gray, also questioned the accuracy of Isaac's writings. In his commentary on the writings of Charles Rawden Maclean in The Nautical Magazine, he notes that Maclean made no mention of Isaacs at all. He also conjectures that it was Isaacs who gave Maclean the name "John Ross" because he could not remember Maclean's real name. Gray is scathing of Isaacs to the extent that when comparing the writings of the two men he wrote "The differences between Maclean's and Isaac's accounts [of Shaka's brutality] are so glaring that one is forced to ask which of the two is plain lying."^[12]

References

Nathaniel Isaacs (1836). Travels and Adventures in Eastern Africa - Vol I. Edward Churton. http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=M8VjAAAAMAAJ&printsec=frontcover&dq=nathaniel+isaacs&source=bl&ots=WtmuXN-997&sig=BOAgVZxZQS4lSuicRrnqoibSBWw&hl=en&ei=0H5eTPi-KY_60wSjtOS9Bw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=3&ved=0CCMQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q&f=false.. Retrieved 2010-08-08. 

Nathaniel Isaacs (1836). Travels and Adventures in Eastern Africa - Vol II. Edward Churton. OL6956051M. 

1. ^ Isaacs - Vol 1
2. ^ Isaacs - Vol II
3. ^ Morris, Donald R (1998). The Washing of the Spears: The Rise and Fall of the Zulu Nation. Da Capo Press. ISBN 978-0306808661. 
4. ^ Ritter, A.E. (1955). "The English Return". Shaka Zulu: The Rise of the Zulu Empire. Longmans Green Ltd. 
5. ^ Bulpin, T.V. (1966). Natal and the Zulu Country. Cape Town: T.V.Bulpin Publications Ltd. pp. 56–69. 
6. ^ "Nathaniel Isaacs Biography". J*GRIT - The Internet index of tough Jews. http://www.j-grit.com/adventurers-nathaniel-isaacs.html. Retrieved 2010-08-10. 
7. ^ Isaacs Vol 1, Introduction - pg xv - xx
8. ^ Isaacs Vol 1, Chapter 1 - Shipwreck
9. ^ ^{a b} Louis Herrman (December 1974). "Nathaniel Isaacs". Natalia (Pietermartizburg: The Natal Society Foundation) (4): 19–22. http://www.natalia.org.za/Files/4/Natalia%20v04%20article%20p19-21%20C.pdf. Retrieved 2010-08-10. 
10. ^ Jennifer Harrison (1999). "Old World Famine, New World Plenty; The Career of Sir Arthur Edward Kennedy". Ulster Historical Foundation. http://www.ancestryireland.com/fileadmin/uhf_pdfs/Familia_pdfs/Familia_1999/Old_Wold_Famine_New_World_Plenty.pdf. Retrieved 2010-08-22. 
11. ^ Rory Carroll (22 May 2006). "Shaka Zulu's brutality was exaggerated, says new book". The Guardian. http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2006/may/22/rorycarroll.mainsection. Retrieved 2010-06-25. 
12. ^ MacLean, Charles Rawden (1992). Gary, Stephen. ed. Natal Papers of 'John Ross'. University of Natal Press. ISBN 9 780869 808511. 

• Oxford Dictionary of National Biography

Persondata
Name	Isaacs, Nathaniel
Alternative names
Short description	Adventurer
Date of birth	1808
Place of birth
Date of death	1872
Place of death