1928 college football season

The 1928 college football season had the USC Trojans recognized as champions under the Dickinson system, but the Rose Bowl was contested between the #2 and #3 teams, California and Georgia Tech. The game was decided by a safety scored by Roy "Wrong Way" Riegels, which gave Georgia Tech an 8-7 win. Major conferences that existed in 1928 were the Western Conference(today's Big Ten), the Pacific Coast Conference (now the Pac-10), the Big Six (forerunner of the Big 12), the Southwest Conference, and the Southern Conference (whose members later formed the SEC and the ACC). At season's end, the Rissman Cup was awarded to the team that finished first in the "Dickinson ratings", which considered strength of schedule, in that a win, loss or tie against a "strong" opponent was worth more than one against a lesser team, and the results were averaged.

eptember

September 29
Army beat Boston University 35-0
New York University (NYU) beat Niagara College 21-0.
Pennsylvania def Ursinus 34-0
California beat Santa Clara 22-0 and USC beat Utah State, 40-12.
Texas beat its crosstown neighbor, Austin's St. Edward's College, 32-0

October

October 6
Nebraska opened its season with a 12-0 win at Iowa State.
Army narrowly beat the visiting SMU Mustangs, 14-13
NYU beat West Virginia Wesleyan, 26-7
Pennsylvania def. Franklin & Marshall 46-0. Texas beat Texas Tech 12-0After losing 2 games out of 3 to non-college opponents, Stanford won at Oregon 26-12; USC beat visiting Oregon State 19-0. California beat St. Mary's, 7-0
Wisconsin beat visiting Notre Dame, 22-6. Georgia Tech beat VMI, 13-0. Illinois beat Bradley, 33-6. Iowa played a Sunday game against Monmouth College, winning 26-0

October 13

Stanford beat visiting UCLA 45-7, and California beat Washington State, 13-3. USC defeated St. Mary's, 19-6

In New Orleans, Georgia Tech beat Tulane, 12-0, and in Dallas, Texas narrowly lost to Vanderbilt, 13-12.
Pennsylvania shut out Swarthmore 67-0
NYU defeated Fordham* 34-7
Army shut out Providence 44-0. Nebraska beat Montana State, 26-6.
Iowa won at Chicago, 13-0, while Illinois hosted Iowa's Coe College, winning 31-0
Wisconsin hosted Cornell College of Iowa, and North Dakota State University, with the varsity winning the first game 49-0, and the reserves beating the Dakotans 13-7.

October 20 In Berkeley, California and USC played to a 0-0 tie. With the exception of this game, USC played all of its other contests at home in Los Angeles in 1928.

Georgia Tech shut out Notre Dame at home, 13-0.
Army won at Harvard 15-0
NYU beat Rutgers* 48-0
Pennsylvania recorded its fourth shutout, beating Penn State 14-0In San Francisco, Stanford beat Idaho, 47-0
Wisconsin and Purdue tied 19-19, and Illinois beat Indiana 13-7. Iowa beat Ripon College, 61-6. Nebraska edged visiting Syracuse, 7-6. Texas beat Arkansas, 20-7.After its first two wins over Ashland College (65-0) and Thiel (38-13), Carnegie Tech beat Washington & Jefferson, 19-0.

October 27
Army won at Yale, 18-6
NYU beat Colgate 47-6
Pennsylvania (4-0-0) was upset by (1-3-0) Navy, 6-0. Prior to that, Penn had outscored its opponents 161-0. USC beat Occidental 19-0
Stanford beat Fresno State, 47-0
Wisconsin won at Michigan, 7-0, and Iowa beat Minnesota, 7-6, while Illinois beat Northwestern 6-0
Carnegie Tech beat Pittsburgh, 6-0. Georgia Tech yielded its first points, winning at North Carolina, 20-7. Nebraska shut out Missouri, 24-0, and Texas won at Rice, 13-6. California lost to the Olympic Club of San Francisco, 12-0. Olympic, nominally an amateur team of former college players, had beaten Stanford 12-6 earlier.

November

November 3 In Los Angeles, USC (4-0-1) and Stanford (5-2-0) met, with the Trojans winning 10-0
Wisconsin beat visiting Alabama, 15-0, while 4-0-0 Illinois suffered its first loss, at Michigan, 3-0
California beat Oregon, 13-0. Nebraska won at Kansas, 20-0. Texas lost to visiting SMU, 6-2.
Pennsylvania won at Chicago, 20-13
NYU and Georgetown University, both 5-0-0, with the Hoyas winning 7-2
Army beat Indiana's DePauw College, 38-12. Iowa defeated visiting South Dakota, 19-0
Carnegie Tech extended its streak, with a 32-0 win over Westminster College of Pennsylvania, and Georgia Tech beat visiting Oglethorpe College 32-7.

November 10 Army (6-0-0) hosted Notre Dame(4-2-0). A crowd of 90,000 packed the stands while 5,000 others in the Bronx watched from roofs and fire escapes within view of Yankee Stadium. Though the Fighting Irish weren't having a good year, the score was 0-0 when Knute Rockne inspired his team at halftime by relating George Gipp's deathbed wish ("when the team's up against it, when things are wrong and the breaks are beating the boys-- tell them to go in there with all they've got and win just one for the Gipper"). Though Army scored a touchdown in the third quarter, touchdowns by Jack Chevigny and Johnny O'Brien gave the Irish a 12-6 lead. In the final minute, Army drove to within one foot of the goal line, but the whistle sounded before the Cadets could snap the ball [ "Notre Dame Upsets West Point in Sensational Duel," "Syracuse Herald", November 11, 1928, pXX-1 ] .

In the "New York Daily News" the following on Monday, reporter Francis Wallace first related the story in an article entitled, "Gipp's Ghost Beat Army" [ Murray A. Sperber, "Shake Down the Thunder: The Creation of Notre Dame Football" (Indiana U., 2002), p285. ]

The big game in the South was in Atlanta, where Vanderbilt (6-0-0) visited Georgia Tech (5-0-0), and the home team won 19-7. Texas won at Baylor, 6-0.

Wisconsin defeated Chicago, 25-0, and Iowa won at Ohio State, 14-7. In Indianapolis, Illinois beat Butler, 14-0.

Pennsylvania won at Harvard, 7-0 NYU beat Alfred University, 71-0. USC beat Arizona, 78-7,
Stanford beat Santa Clara 31-0, and California won at Washington, 6-0. Carnegie Tech won at Georgetown, 13-7

Nebraska, which had not played Oklahoma during the last two seasons, renewed a rivalry that became one of the most notable in college football. Playing at Oklahoma, the Cornhuskers won 44-6.

November 17

Iowa (6-0-0) hosted Wisconsin (6-0-1) in a meeting of unbeatens, with the visitors handing the Hawkeyes their first loss, 13-0. Illinois won at Chicago, 40-0
Georgia Tech beat Alabama at home, 33-13
Nebraska (6-0-0) hosted the (5-2-0) Pitt Panthers, and were tied, 0-0.
Pennsylvania beat Columbia 34-7 NYU beat Missouri, 27-6. Army beat Carleton, 32-7. Texas beat a strong TCU team, 6-0.
USC won again, defeating Washington State, 27-13, while Stanford beat Washington, 12-0, California rolled over visiting Nevada, 60-0.(6-0-0) Carnegie Tech won at (5-2-0)Notre Dame, 27-7.

November 24 Carnegie Tech (7-0-0) and NYU (7-1-0) met at Pittsburgh. The Violets handed Tech its first defeat, 27-13.
Georgia Tech crushed visiting Auburn, 51-0. Auburn won only 1 of its 9 games, and scored in only two of those contests.

Army (7-1-0) and Nebraska (6-0-1) met at West Point, with the Cadets beating the visiting Cornhuskers, 13-3
Stanford and California tied at Berkeley, 13-13. USC beat Idaho, 28-7.

November 29, at that time Thanksgiving Day, Pennsylvania beat Cornell 49-0. Overall, the Penn Quakers had outscored their opponents 271 to 26, and finished 8-1-0. NYU closed its season with a 25-13 loss to visiting Oregon State, and finished 8-2-0.
Wisconsin hosted Minnesota, and suffered its first loss, a 6-0 defeat, to close at 7-1-1. After starting the season 6-0, Iowa closed with a second loss, at Michigan, 10-7, to finish 6-2-0. Illinois closed at 7-1-0 after beating visiting Ohio State, 8-0. Nebraska closed its season with an 8-0 win over Kansas State, and Texas wrapped with a 19-0 win over Texas A&M.

December 1 Army and Stanford met at Yankee Stadium, with Stanford shutting the Cadets out, 26-0. In Los Angeles, USC hosted Notre Dame, winning 27-14, to close its season at 9-0-1. On December 8, Georgia Tech hosted Georgia and won 20-6, closing regular play at 8-0-0, before its trip to the Rose Bowl.

Conference Leaders

Dickinson System

The AP sportswriters' poll would not begin until 1936. Frank G. Dickinson, an economics professor at the University of Illinois, had invented the Dickinson System to rank colleges based upon their records and the strength of their opposition. The system was originally designed to rank teams in the Big Nine (later the Big Ten) conference. Chicago clothing manufacturer Jack Rissman then persuaded Dickinson to rank the nation's teams under the system, and awarded the Rissman Trophy to the winning university [ Herschel Nissenson "Tales From College Football's Sidelines" (Sports Publishing LLC, 2001), p93. ] .

The system awarded 30 points for a win over a "strong team", and 20 for a win over a "weak team". Losses were awarded points (15 for loss to a strong team, 10 for loss to a weak team). Ties were treated as half a win and half a loss (22.5 for a tie with a strong team, 15 for a tie with a weak team). An average was then derived by dividing the points by games played.

[ "The Dickinson system awards 30 points for a victory over a strong team, and 20 for victory over a weak team. Defeats count half as much as victories, and ties are consideredas games half won and half lost. Dividing this total by the number of games played gives the final rating, "ILLINOIS BEST FOOTBALL TEAM OF YEAR," "The Syracuse Herald", Dec. 4, 1927, p23 ] .

Final Dickinson rankings

Professor Dickinson concluded that the University of Southern California Trojans were "the national football champions of America for 1928". Unbeaten and untied Georgia Tech was ranked third because, Dickinson said, "its schedule was easier than the other contenders". The final ratings: [ "Dickinson Rating Gives U.S.C. National Grid Title," "The Salt Lake Tribune", December 9, 1928, p21 ]

On January 4, 1929, the Jack F. Rissman national intercollegiate trophy was presented by Professor Dickinson to the USC football squad, and Coach Howard Jones, at a student rally on the Los Angeles campus. For the benefit of the crowd, Dickinson added "that even had he taken into consideration the victory of Georgia Tech over California on New Year's Day that the University of Southern California would have still be rated at the top," though Georgia Tech would have ranked second instead of third after its Rose Bowl win [ "Trojans Awarded Rissman Trophy For Nation's Best Grid Eleven," "The Helena (Mont.) Independent" Jan. 8, 1929, p8 ]

1929 Rose Bowl

As the lone post-season college football game, the Rose Bowl matched the California Golden Bears, co-champions (with USC) of the Pacific Coast Conference, against the Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets, nicknamed the "Golden Tornado" as well as the "champions of the South". In the second quarter, the Jackets were on their own 25 yard line, when Warner Mizell fumbled the football. Playing linebacker, California center Roy Riegels scooped up the fumble at the 34 and dashed, unimpeded, toward the end zone. Unfortunately, Riegels had gotten turned around and ran downfield toward the California goal. Though Riegels was not tackled in his own end zone, California was forced to punt from there, and Benny Lom's kick was blocked by Tech's Tom Jones, and Cal's Stan Barr fell on the ball for the safety. Georgia's 2-0 lead at halftime was extended to 8-0 after Stumpy Thomason ran for 15 yards for a score, and the conversion failed. Lom's pass to Irv Phillips, and Barr's extra point, made it 8-7 with a minute left. An onside kick attempt failed, and Georgia Tech ran out the clock to win the other mythical national championship. [ "Lone Mistake Costs California Victory," "Oakland Tribune", January 2, 1929, p20 ]

References

* [http://www.shrpsports.com/cf/stand.php?season=1906&conf=Ind&week=Wk%202 shrpsports college football historical records]
* [http://www.jhowell.net/cf/scores/ScoresIndex.htm James Howell Division I-A historical scores]
* [http://waltercamp.org/index.php/teams_and_awards/ Walter Camp Football Foundation list of All-America Teams]