- Canadian federal by-elections, 2008
Four federal by-elections were held in
Canada onMarch 17 ,2008 to fill vacancies in theCanadian House of Commons .The vacancies were caused by the resignations of Liberal MPs
Gary Merasty (Desnethé—Missinippi—Churchill River ),Bill Graham (Toronto Centre ),Stephen Owen (Vancouver Quadra ) andJim Peterson (Willowdale).A further three by-elections were scheduled for September 8 due to the resignations of Liberal MPs
Lucienne Robillard (Westmount—Ville-Marie )Brenda Chamberlain (Guelph) andBloc Québécois MPMaka Kotto (Saint-Lambert). An eighth by-election, resulting from the resignation of Liberal MPJohn Godfrey (Don Valley West ), had been called for September 22, 2008. However, the four by-elections scheduled for September were pre-empted by the issuance on September 7 of election writs for the 2008 federal election. [ [http://www.thestar.com/News/Canada/article/484135] ]March 17 by-electionsWith all four by-elections taking place in ridings previously held by the Liberals, media generally treated them as a test of
Stéphane Dion 's leadership. The riding ofDesnethé—Missinippi—Churchill River , which the Liberals had won by a margin of just 68 votes in the 2006 election and in which the by-election campaign was mired in controversy around the process of appointing candidates, was seen as the only riding of the four that the Liberals could afford to lose — the other three were all safe Liberal ridings whose loss would have been seen as precipitating a major crisis for the party. [ [http://www.thestar.com/News/Canada/article/347212 "It's a great day for Liberals"] ,Linda Diebel , "Toronto Star ",March 18 ,2008 .]Desnethé—Missinippi—Churchill River
The riding of
Desnethé—Missinippi—Churchill River became vacant onAugust 31 ,2007 with the resignation of Liberal MPGary Merasty .David Orchard , a former member of theProgressive Conservative Party of Canada and backer ofStéphane Dion during the Liberal leadership contest, had announced that he would seek the Liberal nomination in Desnethé—Missinippi—Churchill River. However, onJanuary 3 ,2008 , Dion used his power of appointment to appointJoan Beatty as the Liberal candidate for that riding. While Dion has stated several times that he would use his power of appointment to ensure more female candidates [http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20060712/dion_women_060712/20060712?hub=QPeriod| Dion offers plan for gender parity in Parliament] ,July 12 ,2006 ] , many felt the appointment was a snub to his erstwhile supporter and media reports suggested thatRalph Goodale , a prominent Saskatchewan MP, opposed Orchard's candidacy.Delacourt, Susan, "Dion accused of snubbing Orchard", "Toronto Star ",January 5 ,2008 .]Beatty, who was a New Democratic Party MLA in the
Saskatchewan legislature until her federal candidacy was announced, also faced some criticism, both for her switch in party affiliations and for resigning to run federally just seven weeks after being reelected in the 2007 provincial election. [http://www.newstalk650.com/incoming/20080104/joan-beatty-explain-yourself "Joan Beatty, Explain Yourself"] , CKOM News/Talk 650,January 4 ,2008 .] Some Liberal Party members in the riding threatened to boycott the by-election entirely, or to vote for another party, if Dion did not rescind the appointment and allow a normal nomination contest to take place. [http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20080126.wsaskliberals0126/BNStory/National/home "Saskatchewan Liberals may boycott by-election"] , "The Globe and Mail ",January 26 ,2008 .]Voter turnout: 10,462 of 41,841 registered electors (25.0%)
-
Rob Clarke
align=right|4,992
align=right|47.66%
align=right|+6.57%
-Joan Beatty
align=right|3,296
align=right|31.47%
align=right|-9.90%
-
Brian Morin
align=right|1,830
align=right|17.47%
align=right|+2.10%
-
Robin Orr
align=right|320
align=right|3.05%
align=right|+0.89%
-
- bgcolor="white"
align="right" colspan=3|Total rejected ballots
align="right"|37
align="right"|0.35%
align="right"|-
-
-
align="left" colspan=2|Conservative gain
align="right"|Swing
align="right"| +8.2
align="right"Toronto Centre
The riding of
Toronto Centre became vacant onJuly 2 ,2007 , with the resignation of Liberal MPBill Graham .The original Conservative candidate, Mark Warner, was dropped by the party's national council on
October 31 ,2007 [http://www.thestar.com/News/Canada/article/272579 Susan Delacourt, "Harper's team dumps city-friendly candidate"] , "Toronto Star ",November 1 ,2007 ] , reportedly for not following party policy. Warner eventually endorsed Rae rather than his successor as Conservative candidate, Don Meredith, after Meredith reportedly told a voter who asked him a question about the ongoingbedbug problem in theSt. Jamestown neighbourhood to improve their personal hygiene. [Weisblott, Marc, [http://www.eyeweekly.com/city/features/article/20539 "What about Bob?"] , "Eye Weekly ",March 12 ,2008 ]Voter turnout: 23,951 of 85,976 registered electors (27.9%).
-
Bob Rae
align=right|14,187
align=right|59.23
align=right|+7.03
-El-Farouk Khaki
align=right|3,312
align=right|13.83
align=right|-9.91
-
Chris Tindal
align=right|3,199
align=right|13.36
align=right|+8.15
-
Don Meredith
align=right|2,939
align=right|12.27
align=right|-5.94
-
Animal Alliance
Liz White
align=right|123
align=right|0.51
align=right|+0.39
-
Doug Plumb
align=right|97
align=right|0.40
align=right|-
-
- bgcolor="white"
align="right" colspan=3|Total rejected ballots
align="right"|96
align="right"|0.40
align="right"|-
-
align="left" colspan=2|Liberal hold
align="right"|Swing
align="right"| +8.5
align="right"Vancouver Quadra
The riding of
Vancouver Quadra became vacant onJuly 27 ,2007 with the resignation of Liberal MPStephen Owen .Joyce Murray won the Liberal nomination in the riding and faced a hard-fought campaign against Conservative challenger Deborah Meredith. Murray, originally an MLA and former provincial cabinet minister from New Westminster, grew up in the riding, but recently moved back to run for federal office. Her campaign was focussed on environmental issues. Meredith is a UBC law lecturer and has lived in Vancouver Quadra her whole life, campaigning primarily on a tougher judicial system. NDP candidate and UBC studentRebecca Coad focussed her attacks on Murray, criticizing her record as provincial environment minister in Gordon Campbell's government. Green Party candidate Dan Grice, a technology consultant, ran a campaign based on cutting down on carbon emissions and tax shifting, hoping for an electoral breakthrough for his party.On election day, early results showed Murray and Meredith in a dead heat, see-saw race. Later in the night, Murray was able to capture a more comfortable lead of several hundred votes, and the media declared her the winner. However, as the advanced polls were opened and counted, Meredith started to close the gap. After all 237 polls were counted, Murray remained in the lead, finishing with a narrow 151 (0.53%) vote margin above her Conservative opponent.
Voter turnout: 28,165 of 83,121 registered electors (33.9%).
-
Joyce Murray
align=right| 10,155
align=right| 35.96%
align=right| -12.88%
-
Deborah Meredith
align=right| 10,004
align=right| 35.42%
align=right| +6.33%
-Rebecca Coad
align=right| 4,064
align=right| 14.39%
align=right| -1.71%
-
Dan Grice
align=right| 3,792
align=right| 13.43%
align=right| +8.29%
-
John Turner
align=right| 111
align=right| 0.39%
align=right| -
-
Psamuel Frank
align=right| 40
align=right| 0.14%
align=right| -
-
- bgcolor="white"
align="right" colspan=3|Total rejected ballots
align="right"|77
align="right"|0.27%
align="right"
-
-
align="left" colspan=2|Liberal hold
align="right"|Swing
align="right"| -9.56
align="right"Willowdale
The riding of Willowdale became vacant on
July 12 ,2007 with the resignation of Liberal MPJim Peterson .Martha Hall Findlay , former Liberal leadership contestant, was astar candidate . She faced Conservative lawyer Maureen Harquail, NDP candidate Rini Ghosh, and Green candidate Lou Carcasole. On election night, Hall Findlay garnered nearly 60% of the vote.Voter turnout: 22,797 of 93,413 registered electors (24.4%).
-
Martha Hall Findlay
align=right| 13,507
align=right| 59.15%
align=right| +6.92%
-
Maureen Harquail
align=right| 6,841
align=right| 29.96%
align=right| +0.65%
-
Lou Carcasole
align=right| 1,314
align=right| 5.75%
align=right| +1.66%
-
Rini Ghosh
align=right| 1,082
align=right| 4.74%
align=right| -6.61%
-
- bgcolor="white"
align="right" colspan=3|Total rejected ballots
align="right"|93
align="right"|0.41%
align="right"|-
-
-
align="left" colspan=2|Liberal hold
align="right"|Swing
align="right"| +3.1
align="right"Cancelled by-elections
Four by-elections scheduled for September 2008 were pre-empted by the issuance on September 7 of election writs for the 2008 federal election.
Westmount—Ville-Marie
The riding of
Westmount—Ville-Marie had been vacant sinceJanuary 25 ,2008 due to the resignation of Liberal MPLucienne Robillard . The nominated candidates wereMarc Garneau (Liberal),Charles Larivée (Bloc Québécois ),Guy Dufort (Conservative),Anne Lagacé Dowson (New Democrat),Claude William Genest (Green) and independentsRégent Millette ,David Sommer Rovins ,Ronald Andrew Wattie .The by-election was scheduled for September 8.
aint-Lambert
The riding of Saint-Lambert had been vacant since
March 13 ,2008 due toBloc Québécois MPMaka Kotto 's resignation in order to run for a seat in theQuebec National Assembly . Kotto was elected to the National Assembly in aMay 12 2008 provincial by-election. The new BQ candidate wasJosée Beaudin . The NDP nominated Richard Marois, president of the Conseil régional de l’environnement de la Montérégie, the Liberals ran lawyer and Crown attorney Roxane Stanners, the Conservative candidate was Patrick Clune, and the Greens nominated occupational therapist Diane Joubert.The by-election was scheduled for September 8.
Guelph
The riding of Guelph was held by Liberal
Brenda Chamberlain , until she resigned her seat effectiveApril 7 ,2008 . The Conservative candidate was originally businessmanBrent Barr , but his candidacy was rejected by the party in October without specific reasons for the move being made public. Municipal councillorGloria Kovach was subsequently nominated as the Conservative candidate and faced lawyerFrank Valeriote for the Liberals, author and broadcaster Tom King for the NDP, business managerMike Nagy for the Greens, Philip Bender ran for the Libertarians, Kornelis Klevering ran for the Marijuana Party, Karen Levenson ran for the Animal Alliance Environment Voters Party, andJohn C. Turmel ran as an independent.The by-election was scheduled for September 8.
Don Valley West
The riding of
Don Valley West was held by LiberalJohn Godfrey who initially said he would resign from the House of Commons onJuly 1 ,2008 in order to accept a position asheadmaster ofToronto French School but delayed his resignation untilAugust 1 . The delay was reportedly at the request of the Liberal Party which, the "National Post " claims, would prefer not to fight four by-elections simultaneously for financial reasons. [Ivison, John, " [http://www.nationalpost.com/news/canada/story.html?id=640924 Liberal war chest on credit] ", "National Post", July 9, 2008] Godfrey's office stated the delay was due to a private members bill Godfrey had worked on not being givenroyal assent until June 26. [http://www.thehilltimes.ca/html/cover_index.php?display=story&full_path=/2008/july/14/byelection_calls/&c=1 "Candidates girding for byelection calls"] , "Hill Times", July 14, 2008]This by-election was scheduled for September 22. Due to the timing of Godfrey's retirement, the Don Valley West by-election could not have been added to the September 8 trio. Under current Canadian election law, a by-election cannot occur any earlier than 47 working days (an 11-day period to ensure that
Elections Canada has been notified of the vacancy, plus a minimum 36-day campaign) after a vacancy occurs in the House.Rob Oliphant was nominated as the Liberal Party's standard-bearer onMarch 2 , 2008 after defeating formerParkdale—High Park MPSarmite Bulte for the nomination on the fourth ballot. Constitutional lawyerDeborah Coyne had also contested the nomination but withdrew in February and backed Oliphant. [Queen, Lisa, [http://www.insidetoronto.com/news/News/EastYork/article/42852 "Oliphant wins tough federal Liberal race"] , "The (East York-Rivedale) Mirror",March 3 ,2008 , accessedMarch 4 ,2008 ] TheConservative Party of Canada re-nominated 2006 candidate John Carmichael, theNew Democratic Party nominated actorDavid Sparrow , while the Green Party nominatedGeorgina Wilcock , a medical doctor with specialist training in obstetrics and gynecology.References
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.