The Politically Incorrect Guide to Science

"The Politically Incorrect Guide to Science" is a 2005 book by Tom Bethell, the third book in the "Politically Incorrect Guides" series published by Regnery Publishing, after the Guides to American History and Islam.

In the book, Bethell, a senior editor at "American Spectator", and a former editor of the "Washington Monthly" aims to deal with what conservatives have seen as the politicization of science. It addresses a number of issues, including global warming, nuclear power, DDT, AIDS denialism and control of malaria, cloning, genetic engineering, intelligent design, the trial of Galileo and the relationship between science and Christianity. On all these topics, "The Politically Incorrect Guide to Science" argues that the Left have distorted scientific facts in order to advance their political agenda and to increase the size of government, often through scare campaigns like the risk of runaway climate change. It also states that the Left have tried to censor those scientists who disagree with their viewpoints, regardless of what the best scientific evidence might say.

Some parts of the book were later expanded in the "Politically Incorrect Guides" to Darwinism and global warming.

Praise

The book received positive coverage from LewRockwell.com, [cite web |url=http://www.lewrockwell.com/orig6/setliff2.html |title=Government vs. Science by Ryan Setliff |format= |work= |accessdate=2008-05-13] American Thinker, [cite web |url=http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2006/01/statists_of_fear.html |title=American Thinker Blog: Statists of Fear |format= |work= |accessdate=2008-05-13] and columnist William Rusher. [cite web |url=http://www.metrowestdailynews.com/opinion/x1987843543 |title=Rusher: The problem of junk science - Framingham, MA - The MetroWest Daily News |format= |work= |accessdate=2008-05-13]

Criticism

Critics have argued that the positions advanced in the book are contrary to the mainstream scientific consensus on a wide range of issues, and reflects a political rather than a scientific agenda. In a review for "Skeptical Inquirer", Chris Mooney noted:cite web |url=http://csicop.org/doubtandabout/bethell/ |title=Upping the Anti (Doubt and About) |accessdate=2008-03-18 |format= |work=]

Rather hilariously, if you look closely at the book's cover image on Amazon.com you will see the tagline "Liberals have hijacked science for long enough. Now it's our turn." "Our turn" to "hijack science," presumably.

and concludes

Overall, then, "The Politically Incorrect Guide to Science" is a very saddening and depressing read. While they have undoubtedly made mistakes, and certainly nourish individual biases just like all the rest of us, scientists in universities and in government have generally worked very hard and have--thanks to the scientific process--come up with a great deal of important and relevant knowledge. But along comes someone like Bethell and, in a book that's likely to be read by a lot of people, radically distorts and undermines their conclusions and findings, while whipping up resentment of the scientific community among rank-and-file political conservatives. That Bethell is finding such a ready audience underscores the severe threat to the role of science in modern American life and, most importantly, in political decision-making.

Another review described Bethell as "an ultra-conservative, right-wing religious zealot" that

takes the research actual scientists have worked on for years and either twists the findings to fit his own narrow-minded agenda or he simply announces to the world that the efforts of dedicated, trained men and women in the fields of medicine, chemistry, molecular biology, genetics, etc. are just “junk science.” He produces reams of type about subjects of which he has no clear understanding and makes no effort to educate himself on matters pertaining to actual scientific method and study. [cite web |url=http://www.glasgowdailytimes.com/opinion/local_story_143142955.html |title=Glasgow Daily Times, Glasgow, KY - More research, less ‘junk’ writing |format= |work= |accessdate=2008-05-13]

References

External links

* [http://www.amazon.com/dp/089526031X The Politically Incorrect Guide to Science at] Amazon.com