SS Alcoa Puritan

The SS "Alcoa Puritan" was a cargo ship in the service of Alcoa Steamship Company that was torpedoed and sunk in the Gulf of Mexico during World War II.

The SS "Alcoa Puritan" provided freight and passenger service between U.S. and Caribbean ports. The ship was typically staffed with 10 officers and 33 crew, and could also accommodate 8-10 passengers.

Torpedoing

On about May 1 1942, the SS "Alcoa Puritan" sailed from Port of Spain, Trinidad, alone and unarmed, to Mobile, Alabama loaded with bauxite. Newly in command of the ship was Capt. Yngvar A. Krantz. (The former master of the ship, Axel B. Axelsen, had just left command after unsuccessfully urging shoreside management that the ship be armed.) Among the ten passengers were six survivors from the torpedoed Standard Oil tanker "T.C. McCobb."

By April 1942, the German submarine campaign was reaching its height. Records made public after the war revealed that 35 American merchant-marine ships were sunk in March; 42 were sunk in April, and May saw 52 more sent to the bottom.

Just before noon on May 6 1942, a torpedo passed astern of the "Puritan" - its wake sighted by one of the "T.C. McCobb" survivors. General alarm was sounded. A submarine surfaced a few moments later, convert|2|nmi|km|0 off, and fired a warning shell that passed overhead and landed in the water ahead of the ship. Krantz ordered the ship to full speed, hoping to outrun the attacker, and steered a zig-zag course. The sub fired a few more shells that missed, but then refined its targeting and barraged the "Puritan" with about 70 hits over the course of about 25 minutes. The shelling laid open the ship's superstructure, perforated the funnel, broke all the windows and instrument faces, set fire to parts of the interior, and finally disabled the steering mechanism at the stern.

At about 12:30 p.m., with the ship turning in circles, Krantz ordered the engines stopped and personnel to abandon ship. Soon after everyone was in the water, the submarine fired a second torpedo which struck the ship in the engine room on the port side. The "Puritan" started to list heavily to port and soon sank below the surface.

The submarine approached the survivors, which had been gathered into lifeboats. The 34 year old captain of the sub shouted across the water that he was sorry and that he hoped the survivors "make it in all right." He then gave a wave, followed his crew down a hatch, submerged, and departed.

In an hour or less, a United States Navy patrol aircraft - summoned by the "Puritan's" radio operator during the shelling - spotted the survivors, and at about 4:05 pm the U.S. Coast Guard cutter "Boutwell" arrived on the scene and rescued all the passengers and crew - some of them badly injured.

Postwar research revealed the attacking sub to be U-boat U-507, commanded by Kapitanleutnant Harro Schacht. Schacht was still in command of the U-Boat when it was bombed and sunk off Brazil on January 13 1943, by U.S. Navy aircraft. There were no survivors.

Crew and passengers

In addition to Krantz, the crew of the ship comprised J.L. Splane (Worcester, MA, chief mate); N.M. Anderson (3206 General Taylor St, New Orleans, second mate); David M. Conwell (Norfolk, VA, third mate); N.J. Schwartzman, Jr. (Palisade, NJ, third mate); A.L. Kowalsky (Shipton, PA, radio man); J.R. Lewis (405 Fourth St, New Orleans, boatswain); B.F. Graham (1505 Cogins St, Mobile AL, able seaman (AB)); T.B. Lindsay (Atlanta, GA, AB), R.W. Thompson (Mobile, AL, AB); J.R. Tarabula (New Orleans, AB); J.E. Grande (Philadelphia, PA, AB); N.G. Webb (Mobile, AL, AB); J.F. Crawford (Mobile, AL, oiler); W.A. Pitman (1126 Calliope St, New Orleans, oiler); T.J. Cimminiski (622 Carondelet St, New Orleans, mm); F.H. Brewster (New Orleans, chief engineer); J.W. Thomas (Portland, OR, first assistant engineer); E.D. Albertson (Lockport, LA, second assistant engineer); F. Connley (third assistant engineer); J.A. Duckworth, Jr. (Waycross, GA); A.O. Semmler (Seymour, CT, cadet); J.C. Carolan (731 Conti St, New Orleans); W.W. Stark (Norfolk, NY); S.G. Cunningham (Prichard, AL, oiler); E.A. Lorman (Nantasket Beach, MA, oiler); C.P. Boland (Jacksonville, FL, oiler); R.B. Boland (Jacksonville, FL, fireman); S.N. Warrant (Mobile, AL, fireman); G.E. Bigham (Birmingham, AL); Joseph Kerrigan (New York city); C.R. Whitehouse (Everett, MA, fireman); N.C. Hart (San Francisco, steward); J.W. Henderson (Mobile, AL, cook); L.R. Goring (1326 Magazine St, New Orleans); J.A. Waith (New York city); H.L. Harris (Mobile, AL, messman); E.W. Gary (Portland, ME, utility); W.N. Palmer (Mobile, AL); J.F. Morris (Mobile, AL); F.W. Martinez (New York city, messman).

The passengers (apparently an incomplete listing) were Augustus J Senna (New Bedford, MA); W.S. Davis (Ridgeland, SC); J.D. Lawton (Ridgeland, SC); Alex Macknowski (Linden, NJ); Genaro Videllon (Houton, TX); and Charles Petesch (Phillip, WI).

Discovery

Six decades later, contractors performing deep-tow marine surveys for Shell International Exploration and Production encountered a large shipwreck about convert|45|nmi|km|0 south-southeast of the entrance to the Mississippi River, in the Mississippi Canyon area. Based on survey data and historical information, marine archaeologists identified the wreck as the "Puritan." C&C Technologies was hired by Shell to conduct further investigations, which began in 2002 and continued for several years. Visual inspections by Sonsub's ROV vessel "HOS Dominator" found the hull mostly intact, with moderate superstructure damage. Video footage from the "Puritan's" resting place at 1,965 meters depth shows the ALCOA PURITAN, NEW YORK legend on the stern of the ship.

The C&C work formed part of a larger project concerning archaeological and biological analysis of World War II shipwrecks in the Gulf of Mexico, and particularly their artificial reef effect in deep water. Other vessels included in the study were the oil tankers "Virginia," "Halo," and "Gulfpenn"; the German U-boat "U-166"; the steamer "Robert E. Lee"; and the "Anona" (a steam yacht, repurposed as a freighter). All were concluded to be eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places, for both their historical and archaeological import.

References

"32 of Survivors of Two Vessels New Orleanians," The Times-Picayune, New Orleans, Sunday, May 10, 1942, page 12, column 4.

Church, Robert, et al, "Archaeological and Biological Analysis of World War II Shipwrecks in the Gulf of Mexico: Artificial Reef Effect in Deep Water, U.S. Dept of the Interior, Minerals Management Service, Gulf of Mexico OCS Region, New Orleans, OA, OCS Study MMS 2007-015, 387 pp.

Church, Robert, et al, "The SS Alcoa Puritan: Deepwater Discovery and Investigation, Proc of the Underwater Intervention Conference, February, 2003.

Conwell, David M., Sea-Going Days, Part Two, privately distributed, Fairhope, Alabama, 1986, 73 pp.

"The Alcoa Puritan," Society for Historical Archaeology Newsletter 35 (1): 24-25.