Summers v. Tice

Summers v. Tice

"Summers v. Tice", [http://online.ceb.com/calcases/C2/33C2d80.htm 33 Cal.2d 80, 199 P.2d 1] (1948), is a seminal California Supreme Court tort law decision relating to the issue of liability where a plaintiff cannot specifically identify which among multiple defendants caused his harm. The case has had its greatest influence in the area of product liability, especially with regard to pharmaceutical products.

Background

In "Summers" the plaintiff, Charles A. Summers, accompanied defendants Tice and Simonson on a quail hunt. Plaintiff advanced ahead of the defendants up a hill, creating a triangle among the three men, with plaintiff front and center. The view of both defendants with respect to Summers was unobstructed, and both defendants knew his location, 75 yards from each of them. A quail flew to a 10 foot elevation above the plaintiff's head (approximately four feet higher than the plaintiff's head), both defendants shot at the quail, and bird shot struck plaintiff in his right eye and another in his upper lip. Plaintiff sued both defendants for personal injuries. At trial it was established that each of two (2) pellets had caused the injuries to plaintiff's lip and eye, respectively, and both might have been discharged from one weapon (defendant) or each defendant contributed one of the injuring pellets. The trial court found that the defendants were negligent (i.e., that when they discharged their weapons they did not do so with ordinary prudence), and that the plaintiff was not contributorily negligent. The defendants appealed.

California Supreme Court ruling

On appeal the defendants argued that they were not joint tortfeasors because they were not acting in concert, and there was no evidence to show which of them discharged one or both pellets that harmed plaintiff. Accordingly, in their view, neither was liable, and they could not be held jointly and severally liable (i.e., each defendant was liable for the full amount of damages).

The court affirmed the lower court ruling that that each defendant’s behavior fell below the standard of care (i.e., they were both negligent) and that the plaintiff's conduct did not contribute to his injury. Having determined that both defendants had been negligent the court then decided that justice required that the burden of proving which of the defendants had caused either or both of plaintiff’s injuries be shifted to the defendants, so either could absolve himself, if possible, because it would be impossible for the plaintiff to show which of the two negligent actors had caused his harm.

Significance of Summers v. Tice

"Summers v. Tice" has had enormous precedential impact in the area of product liability, most notably pharmaceutical (e.g., the drug diethylstilbestrol, known as ‘DES’). See "Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories".


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать курсовую

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Proximate cause — For the notion of proximate cause in other disciplines, see Proximate and ultimate causation. For causation in English law, see Causation in English law …   Wikipedia

  • Supreme Court of California — Seal of the Supreme Court of California Established 1849 Jurisdiction …   Wikipedia

  • Illegal agreement — An illegal agreement, under the common law of contract, is one that the courts will not enforce because the purpose of the agreement is to achieve an illegal end. The illegal end must result from performance of the contract itself, however. A… …   Wikipedia

  • Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories — Sindell v. Abbott Laboratories, [http://online.ceb.com/calcases/C3/26C3d588.htm 26 Cal. 3d 588] (1980), was a landmark products liability decision of the Supreme Court of California which pioneered the doctrine of market share liability.… …   Wikipedia

  • Руби, Джек — В Википедии есть статьи о других людях с такой фамилией, см. Руби. Джек Руби Jack Leon Ruby …   Википедия

  • National Register of Historic Places listings in Berkeley County, West Virginia — Location of Berkeley County in West Virginia This is a list of the National Register of Historic Places listings in Berkeley County, West Virginia. This is intended to be a complete list of the properties and districts on the National Register of …   Wikipedia

  • \@Vampire Mythology: Bibliography —   [↑] @Vampire Mythology   Abbott, George Frederick. Macedonian Folklore. Cambridge, MA: University Press, 1903. Abrahams, Roger D. The ManofWords in the West Indies: Performance and the Emergence of Creole Culture. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins… …   Encyclopedia of vampire mythology

  • Bob Jones University — Infobox University name = Bob Jones University native name = latin name = image size = 230px motto = Petimus Credimus (Latin) mottoeng = We seek, we trust established = 1927 type = Private, Fundamentalist Christian endowment = staff = 1,450… …   Wikipedia

  • Cape Coral, Florida — City of Cape Coral, Florida   City   Cape Coral and Fort Myers from space, July 1997 …   Wikipedia

  • Fort Myers, Florida — City of Fort Myers, Florida   City   Fort Myers Nickname(s): City of Palms …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”