Stockport by-election, 1920

The Stockport by-election, 1920 was a parliamentary by-election held on 27 March 1920 for the constituency of Stockport, in Cheshire.

It followed the death of Spencer Leigh Hughes and resignation of George Wardle, the two Members of Parliament (MPs) for Stockport. With the departure of both MPs, a single by-election was held for both seats. Always a rare occurrence in Britain, Stockport was the first such by-election since the Oldham by-election, 1899, and proved to be the last such by-election held before the abolition of multi-member constituencies in 1950.

Background

At the 1918 general election, the Lloyd George Coalition Government had won a large majority. The coalition included most of the Conservative and Liberal parties. Both Stockport MPs had been Coalition candidates, Hughes being a Liberal, but Wardle unusually being a Labour Party supporter of the Coalition. With this unusual level of cross-party agreement, they had not faced any opposition.

By 1920, the prospect of a merger of the Conservative and Liberal parties was being seriously considered. The local Conservative group considered that had it run candidates in 1918, it would have won both seats. As a result, when Hughes died, they considered it their turn to nominate a candidate for the constituency. Meanwhile, the Liberal group was determined to run a candidate to replace Hughes. Lloyd George and Andrew Bonar Law, national Liberal and Conservative leaders, had been considering merging their organisations to form a single party, and considered that it would be a disaster to have Conservative and Liberal candidates facing each other. In order to keep their local organisations happy, they convince Wardle to resign, enabling both to stand a candidate. The Liberals chose Henry Fildes, and the Conservatives, William Greenwood.

The majority of the Labour Party were opposed to the Coalition, and determined to stand candidates outside it in an attempt to gain Wardle's seat. After some discussion, they decided to stand economist and former Liberal MP Leo Chiozza Money and to support the candidature of the national organiser of the Co-operative Party, Samuel Perry.

Horatio Bottomley, a prominent right-wing independent politician also assembled a slate of two candidates on an "Anti-Waste" platform, foreshadowing the Anti-Waste League he formed the following year.

The Irish War of Independence had begun in 1919. While the Labour Party had a policy in favour of Irish self-determination, many Irish people considered that it had done little to act on it. A leading Irish trade unionist and secretary of the Irish Labour Party, William X. O'Brien, was interned by Britain for his role in the conflict, and he decided to stand in the by-election as a platform for his cause, and in an attempt to embarrass the British Labour Party into action. On the ballot, he insisted that he was described as the "Irish Republican Workers Party" candidate, even though no such organisation existed.

In Parliament, Joseph Kenworthy called for O'Brien release to contest the by-election, a call supported by Labour candidate Money, citing the example of John Maclean. Home Secretary Edward Shortt rejected this option.

With a total of seven candidates, the Stockport by-election set a new record, not equalled until the South Dorset by-election, 1962 and not beaten until the Walsall North by-election, 1976.

Results

Greenwood and Fildes achieved a clear victory, their similar tally of votes suggesting that most coalition supporters had indeed voted for both candidates. Money's profile enabled him to take third place, some six thousand votes behind, with Perry further back. The difference in their votes was around 1,500, much of this being explained by the 1,000 voters who had supported Money and O'Brien - very few opting for O'Brien and any other candidate. The Anti-Waste candidates attracted little support, but both were able to beat O'Brien.

Labour were disappointed not to take a seat, particularly as O'Brien's intervention had not taken enough votes to explain their defeat. Perhaps in part as a result of the by-election, they moved their position to more actively support the Irish labour movement.

Greenwood and Fildes both held their seats at the 1922 general election, while O'Brien was elected as TD for Dublin South the same year. Perry was eventually elected as MP for Kettering at the 1923 general election.

Votes

Election box candidate with party link
party = Coalition Conservative
candidate = William Greenwood
votes = 22,847
percentage =
change = "N/A"Election box candidate with party link
party = Coalition Liberal
candidate = Henry Fildes
votes = 22,386
percentage =
change = "N/A"Election box candidate with party link
party = Labour Party (UK)
candidate = Leo Chiozza Money
votes = 16,042
percentage =
change = "N/A"Election box candidate
party = Co-operative Party
candidate = Samuel Perry
votes = 14,434
percentage =
change = "N/A"Election box candidate with party link
party = Independent (politician)
candidate = A. G. Kindell
votes = 5,644
percentage =
change = "N/A"Election box candidate with party link
party = Independent (politician)
candidate = J. J. Terrett
votes = 5,543
percentage =
change = "N/A"Election box candidate with party link
party = Independent Republican (Ireland)
candidate = William X. O'Brien
votes = 2,336
percentage =
change = "N/A"Election box majority
votes =
percentage =
change = "N/A"Election box turnout
votes =
percentage =
change = "N/A"Election box gain with party link
winner = Coalition Conservative
loser = Coalition Labour
swing = "N/A"Election box hold with party link
winner = Coalition Liberal
swing = "N/A"

References

*John McHugh, [http://www.mcrh.mmu.ac.uk/pubs/pdf/mrhr_14_j_mchugh.pdf The Stockport by-election of 1920]
*
*Rayment

See also

*Stockport constituency
*Stockport
*Stockport by-election, 1925
*List of United Kingdom by-elections (1918–1931)