Vegetable oil economy

Vegetable oil economy is the potential of vegetable oil to replace fossil fuels in the economy and how it compares to other potential replacements. Vegetable oils are the basis of biodiesel, which can be used like conventional diesel. Some vegetable oil blends are used in unmodified vehicles, but straight vegetable oil needs specially prepared vehicles which have a method of heating the oil to reduce its viscosity and surface tension. Another alternative is vegetable oil refining. The list of vegetable oils is long, and the vegetable oil market is growing. The availability of biodiesel around the world is increasing. There is significant research in algaculture methods with the intent to make biofuel from algae.

Future of energy for world economy

There is a limited amount of fossil fuel inside the Earth. Since the current world energy resources and consumption is mainly fossil fuels, we are very dependent on them for both transportation and electric power generation. The Hubbert peak theory predicts that oil depletion will result in oil production dropping off in the not too distant future. As time goes on our economy will have to transition to some alternative fuels. Fossil fuels have solved two problems which could be separately solved in the future: the problem of a source of primary energy and of energy storage. Along with straight vegetable oil and biodiesel, some energy technologies that could play an important part in the future include :

width="30%" align="{align|left}" valign="{valign|top}" style="border:0"
* hydrogen economy
* methanol economy
* ethanol economy
* lithium economy
* zinc economy
* liquid nitrogen economy
* synthetic fuel

width="30%" align="{align|left}" valign="{valign|top}" style="border:0"
* solar power / photovoltaics
* fission power
* fusion power
* wind power
* compressed air energy storage
* flywheel energy storage
* biofuel

width="30%" align="{align|left}" valign="{valign|top}" style="border:0"

Environmentally friendly fuel

Plants use sunlight and photosynthesis to take carbon dioxide (CO₂) out of the Earth's atmosphere to make vegetable oil. The same CO₂ is then put back after it is burned in an engine. Thus vegetable oil does not increase the CO₂ in the atmosphere, and does not contribute to the problem of greenhouse gas. It is really a way of catching and storing solar energy. It is a true renewable energy.

Burning fossil fuels releases sulfur dioxide (SO₂) and other harmful air pollution. [ [http://www.ucsusa.org/clean_energy/fossil_fuels/the-hidden-cost-of-fossil-fuels.html The Hidden Cost of Fossil Fuels ] ] Because vegetable oil has not been inside the earth for millions of years, it is not contaminated with things like sulfur and burns much cleaner, even than ultra-low sulphur diesel. Burning fossil fuels also contributes to the greenhouse gas problem.

Note that if fossil fuels are used in any aspect of production and distribution (making fertilizer, tractors, fuel trucks, etc.), then there would be some contribution to pollution. For it to be 100% non-polluting all aspects of vegetable oil production would have to be non-polluting as well.

Safety

Vegetable oil is essentially non-toxic relative to other fuels such as gasoline, petroleum-based diesel, ethanol, or methanol, and has a much higher flash point (approximately 275-290 °C) [ [http://www.canola-council.org/Chemical1-6/Chemical1-6_1.html Chemical1-6_1 ] ] . The higher flash point reduces the risk of accidental ignition. Some types of vegetable oil are edible.

Generation and storage

Technologies of hydrogen economy, batteries, compressed air energy storage, and flywheel energy storage address the energy storage problem but not the source of primary energy. Other technologies like fission power, fusion power, and solar power address the problem of a source of primary energy but not energy storage. Vegetable oil addresses both the source of primary energy and of energy storage. The cost and weight to store a given amount of energy as vegetable oil is relatively low compared to many of the potential replacements for fossil fuels.

Type of vegetable oil

The list of vegetable oils article discusses which types of vegetable oil are used for fuel and where different types are grown.

Transportation

For transportation the energy density and cost to store the energy are important. If the density is low or the cost is too high it is not practical to make vehicles with reasonable range. Vegetable oil and biodiesel are close to regular diesel.

Another potential issue for new fuels is the Catch-22 conundrum: if there needs to be expensive new infrastructure before people will make cars running on a new fuel, and there needs to be new cars before people will build the infrastructure, how can the transition ever be made? With vegetable oil this is not nearly the problem that it is with some other fuels. The transition from petroleum oil based transportation to vegetable oil based transportation could be gradual and relatively easy compared to hydrogen, ethanol, and most other alternatives. Vegetable oil is used for transportation in four different ways:
* Vegetable oil blends - Mixing vegetable oil with diesel lets users get some of the advantages of burning vegetable oil and is often done with no modification to the vehicle. [ [http://www.ravenfamily.org/andyg/vegoil.htm Vegetable Oil as Vehicle Fuel ] ]
* Biodiesel - If vegetable oil is transesterified it becomes biodiesel. Biodiesel burns like normal diesel and works fine in any diesel engine. The name just indicates that the fuel came from vegetable oil.
* Straight vegetable oil - Straight vegetable oil works in diesel engines if it is heated first. [ [http://journeytoforever.org/biodiesel_svo.html Straight vegetable oil as diesel fuel: Journey to Forever ] ] Some diesel engines already heat their fuel, others need a small electric heater on the fuel line. How well it works depends on the heating system, the engine, the type of vegetable oil (thinner is easier), and the climate (warmer is easier). Some data is available on results users are seeing. [ [http://www.vegetableoildiesel.co.uk/fuelsdatabase/database/index.php Using Vegetable oil as a diesel fuel - database ] ] As vegetable oil has become more popular as a fuel, engines are being designed to handle it better. The Elsbett engine is designed to run on straight vegetable oil. [http://www.elsbett.com/engl/index.htm] However, as of the start of 2007, it seems that there are not any production vehicles warrantied for burning straight vegetable oil, although Deutz offer a tractor and John Deere are known to be in late stages of engine development. There is a German rapeseed oil fuel standard DIN 51605. At this point straight vegetable oil is only a niche market although the market segment in Germany is rapidly growing with large haulage vehicle fleets adopting the fuel, largely for economic reasons. A growing number of decentralised oil mills provide a large part of this fuel. [cite journal | last = Stotz | first = Kathrin | coauthors = Remmele, Edgar | title = Oil Processing in Decentralised Oil Mills - Results of a Survey | journal = Landtechnik | volume = 60 | issue = 1 | pages = 16–1 | date= 200 | url = http://ltnet.lv-h.de/en/volltext/Lt20051/LT20051E_016_017.pdf | format = PDF | accessdate = 2007-10-25 ]
* Vegetable oil refining - Vegetable oil can be used as feedstock for an oil refinery. There it can be transformed into fuel by hydrocracking (which breaks big molecules into smaller ones using hydrogen) or hydrogenation (which adds hydrogen to molecules). These methods can produce gasoline, diesel, or propane. Some commercial examples of vegetable oil refining are NExBTL, H-Bio, and the ConocoPhilips process. [ [http://www.greencarcongress.com/2006/12/conocophillips_.html Green Car Congress: ConocoPhillips Begins Production of Renewable Diesel Fuel at Whitegate Refinery ] ] The transition can start with biodiesel, vegetable oil refining, and vegetable oil blends, since these technologies do not require the capital outlay of converting an engine to run on vegetable oils. Because it costs to convert vegetable oil into biodiesel it is expected that vegetable oil will always be cheaper than biodiesel. After there are production cars that can use straight vegetable oil and a standard type available at gas stations, consumers will probably choose straight vegetable oil to save money. So the transition to vegetable oil can happen gradually.

Electricity generation

Vegetable oil is a convenient safe way to store energy for transportation and is similar to the way things have been done. For electricity generation these things are not so important. The most important thing is cost for the electricity produced. The world coal reserves are far larger than the world oil reserves. So replacing the coal used in power plants is not as urgent as replacing the oil used for transportation. The motivation to use vegetable oil for power generation is much less than for transportation. Other methods, like nuclear power, fusion power, wind power and solar power, may provide cheaper electricity, so vegetable oil may only be used in peaking power plants and small power plants, as diesel is limited to today. There is at least one 5 MW power plant that runs on biodiesel. [ [http://news.com.com/Texas+power+plant+runs+on+biodiesel/2100-11392_3-6168606.html Texas power plant runs on biodiesel | CNET News.com ] ] . MAN B&W Diesel, Wartsila and other companies produce engines suitable for power generation that can be fueled with pure plant oils.

Market / cost / price / taxes

Availability of biodiesel around the World is increasing. It is estimated that by 2010 the market for biodiesel will be 7.5 billion litres (2 billion USgallons) in the U.S and 9.5 billion litres (2.5 billion USgallons) in Europe. [ [http://news.com.com/Biodiesel+to+drive+up+the+price+of+cooking+oil/2100-11389_3-6114425.html Biodiesel to drive up the price of cooking oil | CNET News.com ] ] Biodiesel currently has 3% of the diesel market in Germany and is the number 1 alternative fuel. [ [http://www.biodiesel.de/index.php3?hid=014&spid=2 ADM Biodiesel: Hamburg, Leer, Mainz ] ] The German government has a Biofuels Roadmap in which they expect to reach 10% biofuels by 2010 with the diesel 10% coming from fuel made from vegetable oil. [ [http://www.checkbiotech.org/green_News_Biofuels.aspx?infoId=16240 Biofuels News (Green Portal) ] ]

From 2005 to 2007 a number of types of vegetable oil have doubled in price. The rise in vegetable oil prices is largely attributed to biofuel demand. [ [http://www.farmersjournal.ie/2007/1117/farmmanagement/crops/index.shtml Farmers Journal: Vegetable oil prices soar - 17 November 2007 ] ]

Much of the fuel price at the pump is due to fuel tax. If you buy vegetable oil at the grocery store it does not have such high taxes. So at times people have bought vegetable oil at the store for their cars because it was cheaper. They did this in spite of the fact that packaging by the gallon adds to the cost and it was illegal to use in a car since no fuel tax had been paid on it. [ [http://www.sovereignty.org.uk/features/footnmouth/biofuel.html Run A Diesel Car On Vegetable Oil ] ] Since vegetable oil (even as biodiesel) does not contribute to greenhouse gas, governments may tax it much less than gasoline as they have done with ethanol. [ [http://www.washingtonwatch.com/bills/show/110_HR_196.html WashingtonWatch.com - H.R. 196, The Renewable Fuels and Energy Independence Promotion Act of 2007 ] ] This would help them reach Kyoto protocol targets.

Production in sufficient quantity

The World production of vegetable oil in 2004/5 was 387.7 million tonnes. Much of this is from Oil Palm, and palm oil production is growing at 5% per year. [ [http://www.fao.org/docrep/008/j6801e/j6801e08.htm Food Outlook - No. 4 December 2005 ] ] At about 7.5 lb/USgal (900 g/L) this is about 110 billion USgallons (430 billion L). Currently vegetable oil is mostly used in food and some industrial uses with a small percentage used as fuel.

In 2004 the US consumed 530 billion litres (140 billion USgal) of gasoline and 150 billion litres (40 billion USgal) of diesel. [ [http://genomicsgtl.energy.gov/biofuels/transportation.shtml Biofuels for Transportation ] ] In biodiesel it says oil palm produces 5940 litres per hectare (635 USgal/acre) of palm oil each year. To make 180 billion US gallons of vegetable oil each year would require 1,150,000 square kilometres (443,000 sq mi) or a square of land 1070 kilometres (666 miles) on a side.

"The gradual move from oil has begun. Over the next 15 to 20 years we may see biofuels providing a full 25 percent of the world's energy needs. While the move is good for reducing greenhouse emissions, soaring oil prices have encouraged most countries to 'go green' by switching to greater use of biofuels." - Alexander Müller, Assistant Director-General of Sustainable Development at the FAO. [ [http://www.irinnews.org/Report.aspx?ReportId=74941 IRIN Africa | East Africa Southern Africa West Africa | Malawi Mozambique Senegal Tanzania South Africa | AFRICA: Food to eat or to run your car ? | Economy Environment Food Security | News Item ] ]

Algaculture could potentially produce far more oil per unit area. [http://www1.eere.energy.gov/biomass/pdfs/biodiesel_from_algae.pdf Look back at the U. S. Department of Energy's Aquatic Species Program: Biodiesel from Algae; Close-Out Report ] ] Results from pilot algaculture projects using sterile CO₂ from powerplant smokestacks look promising.

Genetic modifications to soybeans are already being used. Genetic modifications and breeding can increase vegetable oil yields. From 1979 to 2005 the soybean yield in bushels per acre more than doubled. [ [http://www.ers.usda.gov/Briefing/SoybeansOilCrops/2007baseline.htm ERS/USDA Briefing Room - Soybeans and Oilcrops: Market Outlook ] ] A company has developed a variety of camelina sativa that yields 20% more oil than the standard variety. [ [http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/biotech/2004026594_biotechcrops21.html Biotech | Seeding the way to better biofuels | Seattle Times Newspaper ] ]

Environmental effects

According to a study by Cornell University and University of California-Berkeley, turning plants such as corn, soybeans and sunflowers into fuel uses much more energy than the resulting ethanol or biodiesel generates. [ [http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2005/07/050705231841.htm Ethanol And Biodiesel From Crops Not Worth The Energy ] ] There is concern that the current growing demand for vegetable oil is causing deforestation, with old forests being replaced with oil palms. [http://news.mongabay.com/2006/0425-oil_palm.html Why is oil palm replacing tropical rainforests ] ] When land is cleared it is often burned, which releases lots of CO₂. Vegetable oil production would have to increase substantially to replace gasoline and diesel. With current technology such an increase in production would have a substantial environmental impact. [ [http://www.biofuelwatch.org.uk/ biofuelwatch: home ] ]

While not immediately toxic to wildlife, spills are still potentially dangerous due to the physical damage caused to ecosystems. These effects may include contamination of tissues impeding their vital functions (e.g. plant stomata, fish gills, bird feathers, and mammal hair), increased biological oxygen demand and chemical oxygen demand leading to deoxygenation of water, and infiltration into soil sediments and aquifer contamination.

Food vs fuel debate

In some poor countries the rising price of vegetable oil is causing problems. [ [http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2007/07/19/1982450.htm Biofuel demand makes fried food expensive in Indonesia - ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation) ] ] [ [http://www.iht.com/articles/2008/01/19/business/palmoil.php The other oil shock: Vegetable oil prices soar - International Herald Tribune ] ] There are those that say using a food crop for fuel sets up competition between food in poor countries and fuel in rich countries. Some propose that fuel only be made from non-edible vegetable oils like jatropha oil. Others argue that the problem is more fundamental. Farmers can switch from producing food crops to producing biofuel crops to make more money, even if the new crops are not edible. [ [http://www.engineeringnews.co.za/article.php?a_id=119281 Food versus fuel debate escalates ] ] [ [http://www.theglobalist.com/StoryId.aspx?StoryId=5077 How Food and Fuel Compete for Land by Lester Brown - The Globalist > > Global Energy ] ] The law of supply and demand predicts that if less farmers are producing food the price of food will rise. It may take some time, as farmers can take some time to change which things they are growing, but increasing demand for biofuels is likely to result in price increases for many kinds of food. Some have pointed out that there are poor farmers and poor countries making more money because of the higher price of vegetable oil. [cite web |url= http://www.economist.com/research/articlesBySubject/displaystory.cfm?subjectid=7216688&story_id=10252015 | title= The Economist – The End Of Cheap Food]

Urgency of transition to renewable transportation

* Optimist's view: As oil gets more expensive, people will invest in technologies to increase the supply of oil from petroleum and renewable sources. If renewable sources are less expensive than petroleum, or if the environmental effects are preferred, then they will eventually replace petroleum. As the price of oil goes up, more people will be willing to drive efficient vehicles, like hybrids or diesels, even if capital costs remain higher. [ [http://www.consumeraffairs.com/news04/2007/12/hybrid_universe.html Hybrid Universe Expanding Rapidly ] ] The transition will have a diffusion of innovation time on the order of 20 to 50 years. This should be enough time to figure out how to make lots of vegetable oil, assuming resources are put toward research and development. To the extent that a viable source of oil is not found, then electric vehicles will be produced in greater numbers to supplement the oil-based transportation sector, and reduce demand for oil. [ [http://marshallbrain.blogspot.com/2005/06/peak-oil-will-be-non-event.html Marshall Brain's Blog: Peak oil will be a non-event ] ]

* Pessimist's view: The effects of even a small drop in production can be devastating. For instance, during the 1973 oil crisis, world production of oil dropping 5% caused the price of oil to nearly quadruple. [ [http://www.lifeaftertheoilcrash.net/ Peak Oil: Life After the Oil Crash ] ] Current estimates are that oil production will drop by about 10% in the next 10 years. [ [http://www.theoildrum.com/tag/update The Oil Drum | update ] ] If forest land needed to be reclaimed to grow energy crops, then the extent of deforestation could be environmentally disastrous. We need to change our ways so we don't need so much fuel. For example, plug-in hybrid electric vehicles and diesel hybrids use much less fuel. Alternative technologies need to be invested in and brought to market so that they will be available if and when they are needed. To delay is to invite disaster.

Algae for vegetable oil production

The silver bullet for the vegetable oil economy is harvesting vegetable oil from algae. Some species of algae contain as much as 50% vegetable oil. Algae have very high growth rates compared to plants normally used to produce vegetable oil. Potentially algae could produce much more oil per area of land than current farming methods. So producing vegetable oil this way should result in less deforestation and less competition for food production land. One expert wrote: "As demonstrated here, microalgal biodiesel is technically feasible. It is the only renewable biodiesel that can potentially completely displace liquid fuels derived from petroleum. Economics of producing microalgal biodiesel need to improve substantially to make it competitive with petrodiesel, but the level of improvement necessary appears to be attainable." cite journal | last = Chisti | first = Yusuf | title = Biodiesel from microalgae | journal = Biotechnology Advances | date = 2007 | issue = 25 | pages = 294–306 | url =http://dels.nas.edu/banr/gates1/docs/mtg5docs/bgdocs/biodiesel_microalgae.pdf | doi = 10.1016/j.biotechadv.2007.02.001)/S ]

Where there is existing electricity generation using fossil fuels, there is a source of sterile CO₂. This makes algaculture much easier. To grow algae you need lots of CO₂, but if you get it from air you will also get all kinds of other organisms, some of which eat algae. Getting CO₂ from a smokestack works out really well. Governments trying to address the external costs of coal power plants may have a carbon tax or carbon credit that provides additional motivation to use CO₂ from smokestacks. Several commercial pilot plants are under construction. cite journal
last = McKenna
first = Phil
authorlink =
coauthors =
title = From smokestack to gas tank
journal = New Scientist
volume = 192
issue = 2572
pages = 28–29
publisher = Reed Business Information
date = 7 October 2006
url =
doi =
id = ISSN: 1032 1233
accessdate = ] [ [http://www.cnn.com/2008/TECH/science/04/01/algae.oil/index.html Algae: 'The ultimate in renewable energy' - CNN.com ] ]

If all CO₂ emitting powerplants had algaculture farms attached to them that were making biofuel from algae, the total vegetable oil produced would be about equal to world transportation needs.Fact|date=October 2007 One could run a powerplant off the vegetable oil produced by it, in which case the electricity production would be carbon neutral. However, because coal is so abundant and transportation fuel so valuable, the common case would probably be coal coming into the powerplant and carbon going out as vegetable oil to be used in transportation. After the carbon is used the second time for transportation, it would be released into the atmosphere as CO₂. So the combination of powerplant and transportation would then release as much CO₂ as either does alone now. The other benefit is that transportation fuel would last as long as coal, which is expected to be a long time.

There is substantial research and development work in this area but as of 2007 there is no commercial vegetable oil produced from algae and used as biofuel. If and when the commercialization challenges are overcome, vegetable oil production could expand very rapidly.

Net energy gain

To evaluate potential sources of primary energy it is useful to look at the net energy gain or EROEI. This is the ratio of energy out to energy input. These numbers can change as the technology changes.For example, early photovoltaics technology had EROEI numbers of less than 1 but current cells achieve net energy gain numbers of 10 to 30.

* Ethanol economy 1.09 to 1.34 [ [http://i-r-squared.blogspot.com/2006/03/grain-derived-ethanol-emperors-new.html R-Squared Energy Blog: Grain-Derived Ethanol: The Emperor’s New Clothes ] ]
* Biodiesel 3.2 cite paper
author = John Sheehan, Vince Camobreco, James Duffield, Michael Graboski, Housein shapouri
title = Life Cycle Inventory of Biodiesel and Petroleum Diesel for Use in an Urban Bus
version = Final Report |date=May 1998
publisher = United States Department of Agriculture jointly with United States Department of Energy
url = http://www.nrel.gov/docs/legosti/fy98/24089.pdf | format = PDF (1.9 Mb) | accessdate = 2007-01-02]
* Vegetable oil - Better/higher than biodiesel since less processing is required

ee also

* biofuel
* biodiesel
* biodiesel around the World
* environmental technology
* energy conversion
* energy development
* Food price crisis
* Greasestock
* hydrocarbon economy
* list of vegetable oils
* low-carbon economy
* renewable energy
* straight vegetable oil
* Strategic Fuel Reserve
* sustainable development
* vegetable oil blends
* vegetable oil

References

External links

* [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hoy50APLi_w The Truth About Biofuels in America]