Merkle's Puzzles

In cryptography, Merkle's Puzzles is an early construction for a public-key cryptosystem, a protocol devised by Ralph Merkle in 1974 and published in 1978. It allows two parties to agree on a shared secret by exchanging messages, even if they have no secrets in common beforehand.

Description

Suppose Alice and Bob wish to communicate. Bob can send a message to Alice as follows: first he creates a large number of puzzles, each of a moderate amount of difficulty — it must be possible for Alice to solve the puzzle with a moderate amount of computing effort. The puzzles are in the form of an encrypted message with an unknown key; the key must be short enough to allow a brute force attack. Bob sends all of the puzzles to Alice, who chooses one randomly, and solves it. The encrypted solution contains an identifier, as well as a session key, so Alice can communicate back to Bob which puzzle she has solved. Both parties now have a common key; Alice, because she solved a puzzle, and Bob, because he set the puzzle. Any eavesdropper (Eve, say) has a harder task — she does not know which puzzle was solved by Alice. Her best strategy is to solve all the puzzles, but since there are so many, this is more computationally expensive for Eve than it is for Alice.

Complexity

Suppose that the number of puzzles sent by Bob is m, and it takes both Bob and Alice n steps of computation to solve one puzzle. Then both can deduce a common session key within a time complexity of O(m+n). Eve, in contrast, is required to solve all puzzles, which takes her O(m*n) of time. If m ≈ n, the effort for Eve has roughly quadratic complexity compared to Alice and Bob. n should thus be selected such that computation is still feasible for Alice and Bob while it surmounts the capabilities of Eve.

References

• Merkle, R. C. (April 1978). "Secure Communications over Insecure Channels". Communications of the ACM 21 (4): 294–299. doi:10.1145/359460.359473. 

External links

• Ralph Merkle, Secure Communications over Insecure Channels (1974): A history of the idea and its publication

• Ralph Merkle, 1974 project proposal for CS 244 at U.C. Berkeley.