- Bill James
George William “Bill” James (born
October 5, 1949, in Holton, Kansas) is a baseballwriter, historian, and statistician whose work has been widely influential. Since 1977, James has written more than two dozen books devoted to baseball history and statistics. His approach, which he termed sabermetricsin reference to the Society for American Baseball Research(SABR), scientifically analyzes and studies baseball, often through the use of statistical data, in an attempt to determine why teams win and lose. In 2006, "Time" named him in the Time 100as one of the most influential people in the world. [cite web|url=http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1187260,00.html|publisher= Time (magazine)|date= April 30 2006|title=Bill James] He is currently a Senior Advisor on Baseball Operations for the Boston Red Sox.
After four years at the
University of Kansasresiding at Stephenson Scholarship hall, and one course short of graduating, James joined the Army in 1971. James was the last person in Kansas to be drafted for the Vietnam war, although he never saw action there. Instead, he spent two years stationed in South Korea, during which time he wrote to KU about taking his final class. He was told he actually had met all his graduation requirements, so he returned to Lawrence in 1973 with degrees in English and economics. He also finished an Education degree in 1975, likewise from the University of Kansas.
"The Bill James Baseball Abstract"s
An aspiring writer and obsessive fan, James began writing baseball articles after leaving the
United States Armyin his mid-twenties. Many of his first baseball writings came while he was doing night shifts as a security guard at the Stokely Van Camp pork and beans factory. Unlike most writers, his pieces did not recount games in epic terms or offer insights gleaned from interviews with players. A typical James piece posed a question ("e.g.," "Which pitchers and catchers allow runners to steal the most bases?"), and then presented data and analysis written in a lively, insightful, and witty style, that answered the question. Fact|date=July 2007
Editors considered James' pieces so unusual that few believed them suitable for their readers. In an effort to reach a wider audience, James self-published an annual book titled "The Bill James Baseball Abstract" beginning in 1977. The first edition of the book presented 80 pages of in-depth statistics compiled from James' study of
box scores from the preceding season.
Over the next three years James' work won respect, including a very favorable review by
Daniel Okrentin " Sports Illustrated". New annual editions added essays on teams and players. By 1982 sales had increased tenfold, and a media conglomerate agreed to publish and distribute future editions.
While writers had published books about baseball statistics before (most notably
Earnshaw Cook's "Percentage Baseball", in the 1960s), few had ever reached a mass audience. Attempts to imitate James' work spawned a flood of books and articles that continue to this day.
In 1988, James ceased writing the "Abstract", citing workload-related burnout and concern about the volume of statistics on the market. He has continued to publish hardcover books about baseball history, which have sold well and received admiring reviews; these books include two editions of "The Bill James Historical Baseball Abstract".
During the years after the annual "Abstract" ceased publication, James has published several series of new annuals:
*"The Baseball Book" (1990–1992) was a loosely-organized collection of commentary, profiles, historical articles, and occasional pieces of research.
*"The Player Ratings Book" (1993–95) offered statistics and 50-word profiles aimed at the
* [http://actasports.com/detail.html?&id=9780879463403 The Bill James Handbook] (2003-present) provides past-season statistics and next-season projections for Major League players and teams, and career data for all current Major League players.
* [http://actasports.com/detail.html?&id=9780879463205 The Bill James Gold Mine] (2008-present) is a collection of new essays and never-before-seen statistics, as well as profiles of players and teams.
In 2008, James launched [http://www.BillJamesOnline.com Bill James Online] . Subscribers can read James’ new, original writing and interact with one another—as well as with James—in a question-and-answer format. The web site also offers new “profiles” of teams and players full of facts and statistics that hope to one day map what James has termed “the lost island of baseball statistics.”
Among the statistical innovations attributable to James are:
*Runs Created. A statistic intended to quantify a player's contribution to runs scored, as well as a team's expected number of runs scored. Runs created is calculated from other offensive statistics. James' first version of it: Runs Created = (Total Bases * (Hits + Walks))/(Plate Appearances). Applied to an entire team or league, the statistic correlates closely to that team's or league's actual runs scored. Since James first created the statistic, sabermetricians have refined it to make it more accurate, and it is now used in many different variations.
Range Factor. A statistic that quantifies the defensive contribution of a player, calculated in its simplest form as RF = (Assists + Put Outs)/(Games Played). The statistic is premised on the notion that the total number of outs that a player participates in is more relevant in evaluating his defensive play than the percentage of cleanly handled chances as calculated by the conventional statistic Fielding Percentage.
Defensive Efficiency Record. A statistic that shows the percentage of balls in play a defense turns into an out. It is used to help determine a team's defensive ability.
*Win Shares. A unifying statistic intended to allow the comparison of players at different positions, as well as players of different eras. Win Shares incorporates a variety of pitching, hitting and fielding statistics. One drawback of Win Shares is the difficulty of computing it.cite web| url = http://www.hardballtimes.com/main/article/bill-james-interview/ |title = Bill James Interview |work =
The Hardball Times|last = Jaffe |first = Chris |date = 2008-02-04|accessdate=2008-16-02 ]
*Pythagorean Winning Percentage. A statistic explaining the relationship of wins and losses to runs scored and runs allowed. In its simplest form: Winning Percentage equals Runs squared divided by the square of Runs plus the square of Runs Allowed. The statistic correlates closely to a team's actual winning percentage.
Game Scoreis a metric to determine the strength of a pitcher in any particular baseball game.
Major League Equivalency. A metric that uses minor league statistics to predict how a player is likely to perform at the major league level.
*The Brock2 System. A system for projecting a player's performance over the remainder of his career based on past performance and the aging process.
Similarity scores. Scoring a player's statistical similarity to other players, providing a frame of reference for players of the distant past. Examples: Lou Gehrigcomparable to Don Mattingly; Joe Jackson to Tony Oliva.
Secondary Average. A statistic that attempts to measure a player's contribution to an offense in ways not reflected in batting average. The formula is (Extra bases on hits+Walks+Stolen Bases)/At bats. Secondary averages tend to be similar to batting averages, but can vary widely, from less than .100 to more than .500 in extreme cases. Extra bases on hits is calculated with the formula (Doubles)+(Triplesx2)+(Homerunsx3) or more easily, (Total Bases)-(Hits).
Power/Speed Number. A statistic that attempts to consolidate the various "clubs" of players with impressive numbers of both home runs and stolen bases (e.g., the "30/30" club (Bobby Bonds was well known for being a member), the "40/40" club (José Canseco was the first to perform this feat), and even the "25/65" club (Joe Morgan in the '70s)). The formula: (2x(Home Runs)x(Stolen Bases))/(Home Runs + Stolen Bases).
Approximate Value. A system of cutoffs designed to estimate the value a player contributed to various category groups (including his team) to study broad questions such as "how do players age over time".
Although James may be best known as an inventor of statistical tools, he has often written on the limitations of statistics and urged humility concerning their place amidst other kinds of information about baseball. To James, context is paramount: he was among the first to emphasize the importance of adjusting traditional statistics for park factors and to stress the role of luck in a pitcher's won-loss record. Many of his statistical innovations are arguably less important than the underlying ideas. When he introduced the notion of
secondary average, it was as a vehicle for the then-counterintuitive concept that batting averagerepresents only a fraction of a player's offensive contribution. (The runs-created statistic plays a similar role vis-à-vis the traditional RBI.) Some of his contributions to the language of baseball, like the idea of the " defensive spectrum," border on being entirely non-statistical.
In an essay published in the 1984 "Abstract", James vented his frustration about
Major League Baseball's refusal to publish play-by-play accounts of every game. James proposed the creation of Project Scoresheet, a network of fans that would work together to collect and distribute this information.
While the resulting non-profit organization never functioned smoothly, it worked well enough to collect accounts of every game from 1984 through 1991. James' publisher agreed to distribute two annuals of essays and data - the 1987 and 1988 editions of "
Bill James Presents The Great American Baseball Statbook" (though only the first of these featured writing by James).
The organization was eventually disbanded, but many of its members went on to form for-profit companies with similar goals and structure.
STATS, Inc., the company James joined, provided data and analysis to every major media outlet before being acquired by Fox Sports in 2001.
Acceptance in mainstream baseball
For most of his career, James' ideas have either been ignored or rejected by professional baseball teams. James' sabermetrics rejects much of the
conventional wisdomthat has been passed down by players, executives, and writers over decades. Most teams, managers, and players prefer to continue to follow maxims that were developed decades ago, as well as their gut instincts.
In recent years, James' ideas have gained official acceptance with some clubs.
Oakland Athleticsgeneral manager Billy Beanebegan applying sabermetric principles to running his low-budget team in the late 1990s, to notable effect (as chronicled in Michael Lewis' book " Moneyball"), and sabermetricians have penetrated other organizations since then.
In 2003, James was hired by a former reader, John Henry, the new owner of the
Boston Red Sox. The move generated some controversy, but after 25 years James had finally gained an official position within Major League Baseball. Current Red Sox GM Theo Epsteinalso turned out to have a sabermetric bent. And unlike Oakland's built-in handicap of a money shortage, Boston was willing to spend, with history-making results.
One point of controversy was in handling the Red Sox' relief pitching. James had previously published several analyses of the use of the closer in baseball, and had concluded that the traditional use of the closer both overrated the abilities of that individual, and used him in suboptimal circumstances. Reportedly, James influenced a reorganization of the Boston bullpen, with several moderately talented relievers and no clear closer. When Boston lost a number of games due to bullpen failures, they were forced to acquire a traditional closer (
Byung-Hyun Kim) in order to address the issue. Many writers considered this to be a rejection of James' ideas, and the signing of ace reliever Keith Foulkefollowing the season further suggests this. Others, however, argue that the Boston pen was simply not very talented and that the outcome doesn't necessarily undermine James' arguments.
It should be noted that Boston did not implement James' idea of the "relief ace". James did not suggest a "bullpen by committee"; rather, his studies showed that the relief ace should be used in close or tie games as early as the 7th inning, when the outcome of a ballgame is often decided. Boston had no relief ace in 2003. During the 2004 regular season Foulke was used primarily as a closer in the
Tony La Russamodel; however, Foulke's usage in the 2004 postseason was along the lines of a relief ace with multiple inning appearances at pivotal times of the game. Houston Astrosmanager Phil Garneralso employed a relief ace model, perhaps unwittingly, with his use of Brad Lidgein the 2004 postseason, further demonstrating the efficacy of James's relief ace concept.
James is still (2007) employed by the Red Sox, having published several new sabermetric books during his tenure (see Bibliography, below). Indeed, although James is typically tight-lipped about his activities on behalf of the Red Sox, he is credited with advocating some of the moves that led to the team's first
World Serieschampionship in 86 years, including the signing of non-tendered free agent David Ortiz, the trade for Mark Bellhorn, and the team's increased emphasis on on-base percentage. During his time with the Red Sox, Bill James has received two World Series rings for the team's 2004 and 2007 victories.
The Mind of Bill James", a biography-cum-chronicle of James' works was published in the spring of 2006. " How Bill James Changed Our View of the Game of Baseball" was published in February 2007. He was profiled on " 60 Minutes" on March 30, 2008, in his role as a sabermetric pioneer and Red Sox advisor.
Dowd Report controversy
James was a strong critic of the
Dowd Report, which was the most thorough investigation (commissioned by baseball commissioner Bart Giamatti) on the gambling activities of Pete Rose. James, in his "Baseball Book 1990", dismissed Dowd's conclusion that the former Cincinnati Redsmanager bet on baseball games, for lack of evidence. James reproached commissioner Giamatti and his successor, Fay Vincent, for their acceptance of the Dowd Report as the final word on Rose's gambling. [ [http://www.baseballprospectus.com/news/20021031zumsteg.shtml "Evaluating the Dowd Report"] , Derek Zumsteg, "Baseball Prospectus"]
In 2004, Rose admitted he had bet on baseball and confirmed the Dowd Report was correct. James' argument was that the evidence available to Dowd at the time was insufficient to reach the coincidentally correct conclusion.
James is an avid fan of the University of Kansas men's basketball team and has sometimes written about basketball. He has created a formula for what he calls a "safe lead" in the sport. [cite web|url=http://www.slate.com/id/2185975/|publisher=Slate|date=
March 17 2008|title=The Lead is Safe] He is currently working on a true crimebook. [cite web|url=http://joeposnanski.com/JoeBlog/2008/03/15/morley-oj-and-bill-james-beard/|publisher= Joe Posnanski|date= March 15 2008|title=Morley, O.J. and Bill James’ Beard]
He was recently interviewed on the program "60 Minutes".
Bill James Baseball Abstract" (annual editions published 1977-1988)
The Bill James Historical Baseball Abstract" (1985)
This Time Let's Not Eat the Bones" (1989)
The Bill James Baseball Book" (annual editions published 1990-1992)
* "The Politics of Glory" (1994) (revised as "
Whatever Happened to the Hall of Fame?")
The Bill James Player Ratings Book" (annual editions published 1993-1996)
The Bill James Guide to Baseball Managers(1997)
* "The New Bill James Historical Baseball Abstract" (2001)
* "Win Shares" (2002)
* " [http://actasports.com/detail.html?&id=9780879463403 The Bill James Handbook] " (annual editions published 2003-present)
The Neyer/James Guide to Pitchers" (2004, with co-author Rob Neyer)
* [http://actasports.com/detail.html?&id=0879463171 "How Bill James Changed Our View of Baseball: by Colleagues, Critics, Competitors and Just Plain Fans"] (2007)
* [http://www.actasports.com/detail.html?session=82f1727dad3593523e7f2b76a7e260dd&id=9780879463205 "The Bill James Gold Mine"] (annual editions published 2008-present)
*cite book|title= |authorlink=Michael Lewis (author) |first=Michael |last=Lewis |publisher=
W. W. Norton & Company|date= 2003-04-10|id=ISBN 0393057658 |location=New York |pages=45-47
Rain Delay (essay)
Evolution of baseball player evaluation
* [http://www.billjamesonline.com/ Bill James Online] (Interactions with Bill James through statistics, articles, conversations and more)
* [http://members.cox.net/sroneysabr/JamesIndex/ Works of Bill James]
* [http://www.maximumfun.org/blog/2008/04/podcast-bill-james-legendary-baseball.html Audio interview] with James on public radio program
The Sound of Young America
* [http://www2.ljworld.com/news/2004/apr/25/grassroots_guru/ Lawrence Journal-World article]
* [http://www.baseballdigestdaily.com/bullpen/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=20&Itemid=26 Bill James Interview at Baseball Digest Daily - Part I]
* [http://www.baseballdigestdaily.com/bullpen/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=21&Itemid=26 Bill James Interview at Baseball Digest Daily - Part II]
* [http://www.baseballdigestdaily.com/bullpen/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=22&Itemid=26 Bill James Interview at Baseball Digest Daily - Part III]
* [http://www.newyorker.com/fact/content/articles/030714fa_fact1?030714fa_fact1/ New Yorker Article about Bill James]
* [http://www.opinionjournal.com/la/?id=110010232 WSJ profile]
* [http://www.dugoutcentral.com/blog/?p=1498 Does Bill James Belong in the Hall of Fame?]
*cite news | first=Daniel | last=Okrent | coauthors= | title=He Does It By The Numbers | date=
1981-05-25| publisher= | url =http://vault.sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1124493/1/index.htm | work =Sports Illustrated | pages = | accessdate = 2008-07-18 | language =
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.