- Stock market bubble
A stock market bubble is a type of
economic bubbletaking place in stock markets when price of stocks rise and become overvalued by any measure of stock valuation.
The existence of stock market bubbles is at odds with the assumptions of
efficient market theorywhich assumes rational investor behaviour. Behavioral financetheory attribute stock market bubbles to cognitive biasesthat lead to groupthinkand herd behavior. Bubbles occur not only in real-world markets, with their inherent uncertainty and noise, but also in highly predictable experimental markets.Cite journal |last=Smith |first=Vernon L. |coauthors=Suchanek, Gerry L.; Williams, Arlington W. |year=1988 |title=Bubbles, Crashes, and Endogenous Expectations in Experimental Spot Asset Markets |journal=Econometrica |volume=56 |issue=5 |pages=1119–1151 |url= |issn= |doi=10.2307/1911361 ] In the laboratory, uncertainty is eliminated and calculating the expected returns should be a simple mathematical exercise, because participants are endowed with assets that are defined to have a finite lifespan and a known probability distribution of dividends.Other theoretical explanations of stock market bubbles have suggested that they are rational,Cite journal |last=De Long |first=J. Bradford |coauthors=Shleifer, Andrei; Summers, Lawrence H.; Waldmann, Robert J. |year=1990 |title=Noise Trader Risk in Financial Markets |journal=Journal of Political Economy |volume=98 |issue=4 |pages=703–738 |url= |issn= |doi=10.1086/261703 ] intrinsic,Cite journal |last=Froot |first=Kenneth A. |coauthors=Obstfeld, Maurice |year=1991 |title=Intrinsic Bubbles: The Case of Stock Prices |journal=American Economic Review |volume=81 |issue=5 |pages=1189–1214 |url= |issn= |doi=10.2307/2006913 ] and contagious.Cite journal |last=Topol |first=Richard |year=1991 |title=Bubbles and Volatility of Stock Prices: Effect of Mimetic Contagion |journal=The Economic Journal |volume=101 |issue=407 |pages786–800= |url= |issn= |doi=10.2307/2233855 ]
Two famous early stock market bubbles were the Mississippi Scheme in France and the South Sea bubble in
England. Both bubbles came to an abrupt end in 1720 bankrupting thousands of unfortunate investors. Those stories, and many others, are recounted in Charles Mackay's 1841 popular account, " Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds."
The two most famous bubbles of the twentieth century, the bubble in American stocks in the 1920s and the
Dot-com bubbleof the late 1990s were based on speculative activity surrounding the development of new technologies. The 1920s saw the widespread introduction of an amazing range of technological innovations including radio, automobiles, aviation and the deployment of electrical power grids. The 1990s was the decade when Internet and e-commerce technologies emerged.
Other stock market bubbles of note include the
Nifty Fiftystocks in the early 1970s, Taiwanese stocks in 1987 and Japanese stocks in the late 1980s.
Stock market bubbles frequently produce hot markets in
Initial Public Offerings, since investment bankers and their clients see opportunities to float new stock issues at inflated prices. These hot IPO markets misallocate investment funds to areas dictated by speculative trends, rather than to enterprises generating longstanding economic value.
A rational or irrational phenomenon?
Emotional and cognitive biases (see
behavioral finance) seem to be the causes of bubbles. But, often, when the phenomenon appears, pundits try to find a rationale, so as not to be against the crowd. Thus, sometimes, people will dismiss concerns about overpriced markets by citing a new economywhere the old stock valuation rules may no longer apply. This type of thinking helps to further propagate the bubble whereby everyone is investing with the intent of finding a greater fool. Still, some analysts cite the wisdom of crowds and say that price movements really do reflect rational expectationsof fundamental returns.
To sort out the competing claims between behavioral finance and efficient markets theorists, observers need to find bubbles that occur when a readily-available measure of fundamental value is also observable. The bubble in closed-end country funds in the late 1980s is instructive here, as are the bubbles that occur in experimental asset markets. For closed-end country funds, observers can compare the stock prices to the net asset value per share (the net value of the fund's total holdings divided by the number of shares outstanding). For experimental asset markets, observers can compare the stock prices to the expected returns from holding the stock (which the experimenter determines and communicates to the traders).
In both instances, closed-end country funds and experimental markets, stock prices clearly diverge from fundamental values. Nobel laureate Dr.
Vernon Smithhas illustrated the closed-end country fund phenomenon with a chart showing prices and net asset values of the Spain Fund in 1989 and 1990 in his work on price bubbles. At its peak, the Spain Fund traded near $35, nearly triple its Net Asset Value of about $12 per share. At the same time the Spain Fund and other closed-end country funds were trading at very substantial premiums, the number of closed-end country funds available exploded thanks to many issuers creating new country funds and selling the IPOs at high premiums.
It only took a few months for the premiums in closed-end country funds to fade back to the more typical discounts at which closed-end funds trade. Those who had bought them at premiums had run out of "greater fools". For a while, though, the supply of "greater fools" had been outstanding.
Stock market bubble as an example of
A rising price on any share will attract the attention of investors. Not all of those investors are willing or interested in studying the intrinsics of the share and for such people the rising price itself is reason enough to invest.
In turn, the additional investment will provide buoyancy to the price, thus completing the loop.
Like all dynamical systems, financial markets operate in an ever changing equilibrium, which translates into price
volatility. However instable is this balance, a self-adjustment ( negative feedback) takes place normally: when prices rise more people are encouraged to sell, while fewer are encouraged to buy. This puts a limit on volatility. However, once a positive feedback takes over, the market, like all systems with positive feedback, enter a state of increasing disequilibrium. This can be seen in financial bubbles where asset prices rapidly spike upwards far beyond what could be considered the rational "economic value", only to fall rapidly afterwards.
Modeling and analysis of financial markets
The South Sea Company
Stock market crash
*Accounts of the
South Sea Bubble, John Law and the Mississippi Companycan be found in Charles Mackay's classic Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds(1843) - [http://www.gutenberg.org/browse/authors/m#a516 available from Project Gutenberg] .
* [http://homepage.mac.com/ttsmyf the compelling Real DJIA, 1924-now]
* [http://homepage.mac.com/ttsmyf/3warnsRD.html the 3 Fed Chair warnings, Real DJIA]
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.